Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No contact after interview

30 replies

KatherineofGaunt · 09/04/2022 09:58

Is it just me who thinks it's rude that if you interview 2 or 3 people for a job, you could make the effort and call all of them, successful or not?

My DH went for a "chat" about a job on Tuesday last week (local retail job). The manager mentioned one other person they were talking to later (not sure Tues or Thurs). My DH has heard nothing, so we're assuming he hasn't got it. This is a blow to us, as it would have been perfect hours-wise and the money is much-needed.

I can understand not responding to every applicant, but surely it's just good manners to contact everyone after an interview, if there are only a few people? Or is that how it's done in most places, just go quiet?

We are both suffering mentally and I just want to contact this guy and ask him what his deal is. I won't, of course, but it's like kicking us when we're down.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SoggyPaper · 18/04/2022 10:08

@KatherineofGaunt

Thanks for all your similar tales. He didn't email but got an email himself two weeks after the interview saying he hadn't been successful. I think we figured that out a while ago!
Oh well. Not to worry. At least they did email - eventually!
KatherineofGaunt · 18/04/2022 10:02

Thanks for all your similar tales. He didn't email but got an email himself two weeks after the interview saying he hadn't been successful. I think we figured that out a while ago!

OP posts:
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 09/04/2022 15:46

@Grasshole

As someone who interviews and hires people, I think you're being a little premature. We sometimes don't get back to people until early the following week depending on other people we're interviewing.

Also, judging by a lot of the copy and paste applications that we get that have no effort put into them, I don't see why anyone would expect an employer to get back to every applicant.

We generally get back to people who have actually put effort into their application, and we always get back to people we have interviewed.

Also, judging by a lot of the copy and paste applications that we get that have no effort put into them, I don't see why anyone would expect an employer to get back to every applicant.

Unless your job is really special, why would you expect me to devote acres of time to an application? A lot of us just need a job to eat - I don't dream of doing most of the jobs I've done; why do you think I should grovel?

Tlollj · 09/04/2022 15:34

Early days yet I think.

Apple40 · 09/04/2022 15:08

Yep I have had this interviewed over a year ago for a job with an charity, I was only one of 3 being interviewed and to this day never heard a thing. I find it incredibly rude and will never donate to this charity now. I have a feeling I did not get the job as I started talking about couple of new local schemes from LA I knew about from my then current job which they never nothing about and should have due to the charity they were.

litlealligator · 09/04/2022 15:07

You're right that you should get feedback but if you chase for goodness sake do it politely or you could really shoot yourself in the foot. We were recruiting recently at work and took the longlist down to a shortlist for final interviews. There was a candidate we liked but who didn't quite make the cut for the shortlist. However we often have people from the shortlist drop out before interview, so we kept the guy as a 'reserve' thinking if anyone dropped out we'd invite him to the final interviews. As such we didn't get in touch with him to give a yes or a no straightaway. He then sent an incredibly passive aggressive email complaining about how rude it was we hadn't told him he wasn't successful - after literally just a few days. Obviously we dropped him from our reserves list .. it was such a daft thing to do.

IcedPurple · 09/04/2022 14:42

I agree with others that it's quite early to lose hope.

I always ask interviewers when I can expect to hear back from them. Of course, they don't always stick to it but it can be useful to have some sort of time frame.

morethanspice · 09/04/2022 14:27

Same happened to me, interviewed in December for an nhs post. Got told they expected to tell us by the end of the week. Still no feedback other than it says interview attended on my account. Got another job now but feel the nhs should have better standards

Spearpeas · 09/04/2022 14:20

I hope that people anybody involved or are potentially to be involved at some point in recruitment read this thread and learn that you should get back to all interviewees whatever the outcome, within a reasonable timeframe.

It is humiliating when you are not paid this basic courtesy and damages the company’s reputation. It tells you everything about what kind of an employer they would have been, too.

KatherineofGaunt · 09/04/2022 14:13

Thank you for the replies. I'm glad this isn't a common thing. It feels pretty horrible, tbh, and it wasn't even my job interview!

I'd love to know why people voted I'm being unreasonable. In what way?

We can keep fingers crossed but it was a job in a small independent shop, so I can't imagine the guy would still be deliberating. He's the only manager, I think.

I'll ask DH if he wants to send a polite follow-up on Tuesday or something.

OP posts:
IceVolcanoes · 09/04/2022 12:33

Agents can be appalling for that too. They really bother and harass you about a role, persuade you to apply… then nothing. It’s totally unprofessional.

It’s not ok to leave candidates hanging for weeks either. There is literally no reason why you can’t let them know the timescales involved. None at all. If the interviews are taking place over a period of weeks, just tell people that and give a date when they can expect to hear from you. If it drags on beyond that date, a bulk email explaining there’s been a delay is not an enormous task for an HR department to achieve.

It makes the company look terrible if they’re keeping people waiting for weeks with no information.

ThinWomansBrain · 09/04/2022 11:41

Also incredibly pissed off with agencies that don't get back to candidates with feedback - but I am looking for senior level roles, if they are to thick to realise that who I use for recruitment in the future will include a judgement on how they treat candidates, their loss.
Started a new role a couple of years ago, picked up on linkedin by an agency, who called immediately to see if I wanted to recruit. Response was "yes, I do, but given that your consultant X has yet to get back to me regarding a role I applied for, why do you imagine I would use an agency that does not treat candidates with respect?"

ThinWomansBrain · 09/04/2022 11:32

rude - I also think it's rude when saying, we have other candidates to see, second interviews are on X date - and then get back to you a week or so after that; I agree with PP that an email takes no time, whether that's a blanket email to those not shortlisted, or an individual one to the candidates that have taken time out to prepare for and attend an interview.
I took great delight recently is telling an organisation that got back to me a couple of weeks after the planned second interview date that I was no longer interested because of their delay.

CapMarvel · 09/04/2022 11:25

I wouldn't give up hope yet, these things always take longer than people expect.

But yes, a polite thanks but no thanks email takes virtually no effort but makes a world of difference. If someone has taken the time out of their day to interview it's the very least they should be doing.

dayswithaY · 09/04/2022 11:13

It's quite normal in retail to take ages to get back to an applicant. Twice, I've chased up job roles after weeks of silence for them to tell me, yes you have the job but the process took longer than expected.

But, my teenager has recently been to several interviews and two of them never bothered to get back in touch, so we assume it's a no. Incredibly rude, if someone has taken the time to travel to an interview and prepare, and you've actually sat and spoken with them, for you not to send a one line generic email to let them know.

My adult child had three - yes three - interviews with one company and every single time he had to chase them up for a response. The last time being "we went with another candidate ". That's fine, but the whole process took three months. That's way too long for someone to stay invested, hopeful and primed for interviews.

Employers hold all the cards it seems, but what happened to manners?

Lucyccfc68 · 09/04/2022 11:12

I agree with Grasshole.

If the last interview for candidates was on Thursday, it’s only 2 days since they finished interviewing.

I have recently been recruiting for some degree apprenticeship roles. After the closing date, I had over 200 CV’s to read and decide on a short list of 10 for first interview. Within a day of the closing date, I had 10 people chasing me for a response to their application!

I short listed, arranged first interviews and then e-mailed every applicant with a response. After the first interviews, I then had to get the managers together to decide on the short list for 2nd interviews and let everyone know. The second interviews take place over 2 days, but a week apart as myself and the managers have very busy jobs and lots of meetings already booked in.

We do our very best to get back to everyone within the shortest time scale possible, but 2 days after an interview is massively premature.

Grasshole · 09/04/2022 11:02

As someone who interviews and hires people, I think you're being a little premature. We sometimes don't get back to people until early the following week depending on other people we're interviewing.

Also, judging by a lot of the copy and paste applications that we get that have no effort put into them, I don't see why anyone would expect an employer to get back to every applicant.

We generally get back to people who have actually put effort into their application, and we always get back to people we have interviewed.

IceVolcanoes · 09/04/2022 11:02

It’s incredibly easy to automate a thanks but no thanks reply for applicants you aren’t going to interview.

There is no excuse for not feeding back to applicants you interview. Even less so for just ghosting them. No matter how many applications you had, if you interviewed them, you have time to contact them to say they’ve been unsuccessful.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 09/04/2022 10:55

@Teeturtle

I don’t agree that employers need to go back to every applicant, but yes they should definitely go back to every interviewee in my opinion. Don’t dwell on it, don’t respond (other than a polite follow up perhaps), all this shows is a failing on their part.
I don’t agree that employers need to go back to every applicant Why not?
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 09/04/2022 10:54

YANBU - usually when this subject comes up though a load of recruitment wonks turn up and "explain" why it's fine never to tell people they didn't get the job (quite often bemoaning the fact that 100s of people had the temerity to apply for a vacancy when only 3 were any good). It isn't fine, it's rude , but it seems to have become normalised

IceVolcanoes · 09/04/2022 10:43

@ExplodingElephants

I hear you. I went for a job interview on Tuesday, radio silence ever since. Although my husband can probably win as he didn’t hear for three months once! He was an internal candidate too and asked several times only to be told he ‘interviewed really well but they weren’t sure’. Also they had this totally odd policy where internal candidates could only get a payrise of no more than 10% so the most he could get for the job was £27.5k. Whereas the external candidates (that were eventually appointed) got £35k. DH got the last laugh though when he got a far higher paid job elsewhere.
That’s dreadful. Retention of good staff should be a priority. Treating them poorly and having ridiculous policies is indicative that it’s not a great place to work.
ExplodingElephants · 09/04/2022 10:37

I hear you. I went for a job interview on Tuesday, radio silence ever since. Although my husband can probably win as he didn’t hear for three months once! He was an internal candidate too and asked several times only to be told he ‘interviewed really well but they weren’t sure’. Also they had this totally odd policy where internal candidates could only get a payrise of no more than 10% so the most he could get for the job was £27.5k. Whereas the external candidates (that were eventually appointed) got £35k. DH got the last laugh though when he got a far higher paid job elsewhere.

IceVolcanoes · 09/04/2022 10:23

I think anyone recruiting should give feedback to everyone they actually interview. It’s only fair to do so. And to do it in a timely manner.

I interviewed for a job over a month ago. The panel were incredibly positive and told me outright that they’d be inviting me for a second interview during the interview. Then emailed within an hour to say that the admin team would be in touch. Then… nothing.

I’ve emailed twice to chase it up and been told they’re really busy recruiting fit lots of roles and they will get back to me. That was 3 weeks ago. Nothing since…

It’s so unbelievably unprofessional. Even if they offer me the job at this point, there’s no way I’m interested. Job interviews are a two way street. And I’m distinctly unimpressed.

The really crazy thing is that this is a highly skilled, experienced professional role in an industry with a skills shortage. I have a good job already. I have other interviews did. other posts. It’s not a ‘keep her on the back burner’ situation.

But even if it were - it’s just polite and professional to get in contact with people you’ve interviewed.

Foxyloxy1plus1 · 09/04/2022 10:15

I agree with AlternativePerspective.

It’s very rude to ignore interviewees and doesn’t send out a good message about how you treat people.

AlternativePerspective · 09/04/2022 10:10

I don’t see why employers can’t go back to every appplicant.

Most job applications are done online these days, and if the system can generate a “thank you for your application” email, then it is perfectly possible to write something into that system that when an application is ejected it sends out a “thank you for your application, unfortunately we will not be taking your application further at this stage.”

And yes, not getting back to an interview candidate is bloody rude, and indicative that he’s probably had a lucky escape.

Swipe left for the next trending thread