Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pils paying for meal out

169 replies

numananumana · 09/04/2022 03:33

So we invited pils to ours, they suggested we all go to our local pub for Sunday dinner. We explained we couldn't really afford it and offered to cook Sunday dinner at home. Pils offered to treat us which was lovely so we said yes. When we arrive at the pub fil says "right our treat, you just pay for the drinks" So we ended buying drinks for us, 2 dd's and ils, then when food is finished dd's want pudding mil helps then decide but then doesn't go to order it (you pay as you go at this pub) so I end up going up. All in we spent £40 Aibu to say if someone says my treat they mean the whole bill?

OP posts:
TolkiensFallow · 09/04/2022 08:21

The etiquette is to pay if you are offering to treat - to me the only exception I’d if you’d ordered something hugely extravagant such as a bottle of champagne.

Indicatrice · 09/04/2022 08:18

It sounds like PIL resented the offer as soon as they made it and tried to claw it back by making you pay for drinks and dds’ desserts.

What are they like usually, do they turn up expecting to be fed?

Sswhinesthebest · 09/04/2022 08:17

Well you’ll turn them down next time.

Ineedaduvetday · 09/04/2022 08:17

@DropYourSword

And they bought a meal out.

But Pils didn't say that, they said they 'treat' OP and to me that means the total cost of the meal out including drinks etc. To me that is very different to buying a main course only.

rookiemere · 09/04/2022 08:15

@Iwonder08 it sounds like PILs were very keen on eating out - I mean as a guest I think it's somewhat rude to insist on going to a restaurant when your host has bought ingredients and offered to make a meal.

Iwonder08 · 09/04/2022 08:14

YABU. If you don't have money to spend/don't want to spend it then don't go out. I think it was also bad manners to say you cant afford a meal out and essentially putting your in laws in position to offer to take you out. You should have declined. Decent people would always offer to pay for drinks at least even if they were invited out.

rookiemere · 09/04/2022 08:10

@hattie43 real nice to make your hosts pay for expensive drinks and desserts when told that they would be paying.
Surely etiquette dictates that guests pay for a meal in its entirety after enjoying free lodging.

Xmasbaby11 · 09/04/2022 08:09

Yanbu. It is thoughtless of pil. £40 is loads of money to shell out when you weren't expecting to pay anything. It's obviously not a lot of money to them if they don't think it's a big deal.

hattie43 · 09/04/2022 08:08

@rookiemere

Also it's not like OP demanded they be took out for lunch, she was perfectly happy to prepare a free meal for them at home.
Maybe they thought it nice that OP didn't have to slave away in the kitchen .
hattie43 · 09/04/2022 08:07

@Divaship

You should have said "no" to your kids when they asked for pudding, they probably didn't need it after a huge roast anyway especially as you say you couldn't afford it. You do sound rather tight in all honesty, we went for a roast last weekend and it was £18 each for roast beef, not including a glass of red wine and a G&T but we chose to add those, the bill for hubby and I alone came to well over £50. You should be grateful that he offered to pay as I'm sure that he paid a significant amount already to feed everyone. In all honesty, if you can't afford a round of soft drinks for everyone, you shouldn't be accepting in the first place, and it's very entitled of you to expect pudding to be bought for your kids too (you probably would have spent more buying ingredients for a sunday roast cooked at home than buying a round of drinks).
I agree . It's normal etiquette to pay for a round of drinks if someone takes you out for a meal . No different to taking a bottle of wine to a dinner party invite . Rude to turn up empty handed .
rookiemere · 09/04/2022 08:06

Also it's not like OP demanded they be took out for lunch, she was perfectly happy to prepare a free meal for them at home.

rookiemere · 09/04/2022 08:04

@Divaship have you read any of the OPs subsequent posts ? She explains most of your odd assumptions.

Divaship · 09/04/2022 08:02

You should have said "no" to your kids when they asked for pudding, they probably didn't need it after a huge roast anyway especially as you say you couldn't afford it. You do sound rather tight in all honesty, we went for a roast last weekend and it was £18 each for roast beef, not including a glass of red wine and a G&T but we chose to add those, the bill for hubby and I alone came to well over £50. You should be grateful that he offered to pay as I'm sure that he paid a significant amount already to feed everyone. In all honesty, if you can't afford a round of soft drinks for everyone, you shouldn't be accepting in the first place, and it's very entitled of you to expect pudding to be bought for your kids too (you probably would have spent more buying ingredients for a sunday roast cooked at home than buying a round of drinks).

KatieKat88 · 09/04/2022 08:02

@numananumana

I agree badly managed I think we were on the spot. We bought first round and were surprised but thought fair enough. Second drink fil said to dh let's go to the bar ordered his drinks and stood back while dh paid. Yes he should have said. We did get water for table they had that too. We never had a second drink. Dessert I never mentioned it was mil who did. Dh was at bar with fil and mil just looked at me so I felt awkward and just paid. Dh didn't know about dessert till after. We paid £40 for drinks and dessert, think food was just over £50 so nearly split. I'm annoyed because we wouldn't have gone if I'd known.
I think you're fair enough to be annoyed when it was all their idea. At this point though chalk it up to experience and next time don't go! Generally it'd be nice to split like that but if you've said you can't afford it and they've said they'll treat you YANBU.
hattie43 · 09/04/2022 08:00

@A580Hojas

Your pil sound a bit thick. They clearly don't understand the meaning of "our treat".
I think this is unfair . People won't assume someone who says they're skint literally can't afford one round of drinks . A lot of people say they're skint but you'd never equate it to no seriously we cannot afford anything other than tap water .
numananumana · 09/04/2022 07:57

I agree badly managed I think we were on the spot. We bought first round and were surprised but thought fair enough. Second drink fil said to dh let's go to the bar ordered his drinks and stood back while dh paid. Yes he should have said. We did get water for table they had that too. We never had a second drink. Dessert I never mentioned it was mil who did. Dh was at bar with fil and mil just looked at me so I felt awkward and just paid. Dh didn't know about dessert till after. We paid £40 for drinks and dessert, think food was just over £50 so nearly split. I'm annoyed because we wouldn't have gone if I'd known.

OP posts:
SandyY2K · 09/04/2022 07:56

They should have paid for EVERYTHING. At least you know for next time.

Setthescenes · 09/04/2022 07:56

If I was in charge of buying drinks and had no money to spend it would be tap water all round

You can't choose what someone else orders - and the fact PILs chose alcoholic drinks makes it even worse, they evidently don't appreciate what 'can't afford it' means.

Why should the OP have to be uncomfortable? The PILs previously said they would treat them. They didn't caveat it with "except drinks and puddings". And I think posters underestimate how hard it can be being put on the spot.

It's easy with hindsight to see what could/should have been said, but ultimately here the PILs have been unreasonable.

A580Hojas · 09/04/2022 07:49

Your pil sound a bit thick. They clearly don't understand the meaning of "our treat".

Daisydoesnt · 09/04/2022 07:46

Well in that case you should have bought them a drink and got yourselves tap water. And yes a pp suggested when they said they wanted dessert you say well granny and grandad are paying so you'll have to ask them

Or they could have had ice cream when you got home.

If you bought the first round (when you could have just asked for a jug of tap water - absolutely nothing wrong with that) how did they manage to get another round out of you. Did you offer? Or had you left your card at the bar?

Ponoka7 · 09/04/2022 07:46

, I would say that if someone offers to buy you a meal it doesn't necessarily include the extras such as dessert,

Someone? Possibly, but a ok off GP out with their GC, then of course they buy a desert.

I'm not doing much better than my DD. When we go out with her two children we go halves. I get a set price carvery which comes with a drink and no desert (thanks to calorie counting). The children have a fancy layered chocolate ice-cream, it's money well spent seeing their reactions. They should have paid for desert.

numananumana · 09/04/2022 07:45

@Soontobe60

I’d have said ‘We’ll get the first round in’ as a gesture anyway. After all, if you had cooked a Sunday lunch for them at home you would have spent a similar amount on food, drinks and the actual cost of cooking the meal. So in reality, you’re not actually £40 down are you?
I shop at Aldi I could do a roast dinner for 6 for less than £10!
OP posts:
rookiemere · 09/04/2022 07:45

Oh well, I guess their next invite to stay will be lost in the post.
I'd be very reluctant to host them again and if I did, would never be going out for a meal with them again unless you did totally separate bills.

GiltEdges · 09/04/2022 07:44

We have money we didn't want to spend it there as it was earmarked for food, bills etc.

Im sorry but that’s ridiculous. If you needed the money for food and bills then you needed to grow a backbone and say no.

DockOTheBay · 09/04/2022 07:43

@parrotonthesofa

Well in that case you should have bought them a drink and got yourselves tap water. And yes a pp suggested when they said they wanted dessert you say well granny and grandad are paying so you'll have to ask them.
Yeah if they said this at the beginning before you ordered, that was the opportunity to say no, or only order water, or tell them you could only afford soft drinks or whatever.
Swipe left for the next trending thread