Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Mum spanked DD whilst I'm in hospital

516 replies

wantthisbabyout · 08/04/2022 22:43

Currently in hospital after my c-section apologies if this is all over the place as I'm half asleep!

Mum stayed over last night and complained this morning that she hadn't slept all night. We left at 6:45 this morning and she was up. She also said yesterday that she wishes my kids were "normal"

I FaceTimed her today with the kids and DD was upset saying grandma hurt me and my mum said oh it's ok it was only a little spank on the hand as she hasn't been listening.

My DD is the sweetest little girl ever, yes she is very stubborn but you just need to have patience with her.

AIBU to feel like my mum has just lost her temper and probably felt a bit angry and spanked her? I feel so upset about anyone touching my kids.

DH has just popped home now to get some sleepsuits but I dare not tell him because he will be so angry.

OP posts:
Giraffesandbottoms · 09/04/2022 17:17

I don’t understand why where she has been hit matters. Does it matter? Is a hand really better than a bottom?! Is an arm/leg less bad?!

Pumperthepumper · 09/04/2022 17:16

@dummyd

Good idea. Then you won’t be assaulting a child.

Didn't I you say it's ok to hit a child if they are about to touch a candle? Or did I misread that?

Yes, you misread that. I’ve already explained it to you.
dummyd · 09/04/2022 17:12

Good idea. Then you won’t be assaulting a child.

Didn't I you say it's ok to hit a child if they are about to touch a candle? Or did I misread that?

dummyd · 09/04/2022 17:11

I don’t condone smacking children. I don’t think a sharp tap on the hand to make a point to a particularly recalcitrant child is abusive, damaging etc, and I wouldn’t mind if my mother had done it to my DC if they were being very naughty or to stop them doing something dangerous- but I do recognise that many parents wouldn’t do like it.

Exactly right. I don't think anywhere here has justified physical punishment, just stated the reaction to it is too far. It's not abuse anymore than shouting at your child for not tidying up is abuse.

Physical punishment often can be abusive, likewise shouting. People need to use their critical thinking. Your not doing any favours to those of us who were abused, or others who still are being abused by blowing this out of proportion. The mums comments about 'normal' were off though, sounds like she's overwhelmed and maybe impatient.

BellaVita · 09/04/2022 17:01

Yes we are in contact with nice SIL Smile @Juniper68

Giraffesandbottoms · 09/04/2022 15:48

Surely the fact that the daughter is upset by being slapped on the hand is the issue? It can’t have been a playful or gentle slap within the context, I don’t think .

For everyone comparing smacking adults and children; you’re wrong. Smacking a child,1/3 your size, who is vulnerable and has no means of defending themselves or getting help, who trusts you as their parent or caregiver in a most naive way to treat them properly…it is immeasurably worse than slapping an adult. How you treat your child is how you child will develop their sense of self, see themselves for years to come. If you slap them and call them names etc it will fuck them up.

It’s impossible to know exactly what happened as none of us were there but the fact of the matter is it shocked and upset the daughter.

woodhill · 09/04/2022 15:19

@jacks11

Good lord, some of the posts on here are ridiculous. And I really doubt if some of the more “hardline” posters would actually do what they are encouraging op to do. I think it is either that they enjoy the drama or are being ‘keyboard warriors”.

I don’t condone smacking children. I don’t think a sharp tap on the hand to make a point to a particularly recalcitrant child is abusive, damaging etc, and I wouldn’t mind if my mother had done it to my DC if they were being very naughty or to stop them doing something dangerous- but I do recognise that many parents wouldn’t do like it. A tap- when it is a genuine sharp tap, and not done with much force, is different to being beaten/hit/punched- but as I say I recognise others feel differently and would never lay a finger on anyone else’s child.

All of that said, I do think the sensible and reasonable thing to do- given that OP’s mum has no history of being abusive, though clearly is struggling to manage young children given OP’s brothers have also noticed that she seems to lack patience with their children- would be to sit her mum down and have an honest and frank discussion about what happened, explain that op and her husband will not tolerate any physical chastisement at all and ask her to respect that. Unless her mother has a history of deviousness or ignoring OP’s requests, that should be sufficient. Along with perhaps being more aware of her mother’s limitations and only request childcare accordingly. There is absolutely no need to jump to “never allowing her to see the children”, going low or no contact or refusing to ever leave her in a room with children without supervision. That is how you destroy relationships, possibly within the wider family too, and I strongly suspect that OP’s mother would bring much that is positive into the lives of her grandchildren, losing that over a situation that can easily be addresses is absolutely ridiculous.

My own grandparents definitely chastised us at times- though I don’t think ever smacked me, definitely did get a sharp tap to the hand on occasion (once to stop me putting my hand into something dangerous) and were stricter than my parents. We worked out that there were different rules at granny and grandpa’s than at home. It wasn’t confusing or distressing. They were lovely, warm and caring people who adored us. We had a wonderful relationship and my grandmother remains is one of my favourite people- I still miss her. Had my parents cut them out of our lives/reduced their presence in our lives for one (relatively minor) transgression, without even speaking to them about it, I would not have had the love and support I got from my grandparents and my childhood (and adulthood, for that matter) would have been the poorer for it.

OP- just speak to your mum. She’s your mum, for goodness sake- it’s ok not to agree with what she’s done and even to be upset by it- but communicate that to her, ask her not to do it and move on. Obviously, if she ignores your wishes again, then you need to address this issue more significantly, but give her the opportunity to explain what happened, understand your point of view, and the opportunity to make it right.

Excellent post Jacks
Pumperthepumper · 09/04/2022 15:17

[quote brainhurts]@Pumperthepumper
Ok , next time I see a child trying to electrocute themselves rather than my obvious Hugh overreacting to stop them I will Stand and watch them while asking for them too hand it over .
If you see someone in danger you do what's needs at the time . [/quote]
Good idea. Then you won’t be assaulting a child.

jacks11 · 09/04/2022 15:12

Good lord, some of the posts on here are ridiculous. And I really doubt if some of the more “hardline” posters would actually do what they are encouraging op to do. I think it is either that they enjoy the drama or are being ‘keyboard warriors”.

I don’t condone smacking children. I don’t think a sharp tap on the hand to make a point to a particularly recalcitrant child is abusive, damaging etc, and I wouldn’t mind if my mother had done it to my DC if they were being very naughty or to stop them doing something dangerous- but I do recognise that many parents wouldn’t do like it. A tap- when it is a genuine sharp tap, and not done with much force, is different to being beaten/hit/punched- but as I say I recognise others feel differently and would never lay a finger on anyone else’s child.

All of that said, I do think the sensible and reasonable thing to do- given that OP’s mum has no history of being abusive, though clearly is struggling to manage young children given OP’s brothers have also noticed that she seems to lack patience with their children- would be to sit her mum down and have an honest and frank discussion about what happened, explain that op and her husband will not tolerate any physical chastisement at all and ask her to respect that. Unless her mother has a history of deviousness or ignoring OP’s requests, that should be sufficient. Along with perhaps being more aware of her mother’s limitations and only request childcare accordingly. There is absolutely no need to jump to “never allowing her to see the children”, going low or no contact or refusing to ever leave her in a room with children without supervision. That is how you destroy relationships, possibly within the wider family too, and I strongly suspect that OP’s mother would bring much that is positive into the lives of her grandchildren, losing that over a situation that can easily be addresses is absolutely ridiculous.

My own grandparents definitely chastised us at times- though I don’t think ever smacked me, definitely did get a sharp tap to the hand on occasion (once to stop me putting my hand into something dangerous) and were stricter than my parents. We worked out that there were different rules at granny and grandpa’s than at home. It wasn’t confusing or distressing. They were lovely, warm and caring people who adored us. We had a wonderful relationship and my grandmother remains is one of my favourite people- I still miss her. Had my parents cut them out of our lives/reduced their presence in our lives for one (relatively minor) transgression, without even speaking to them about it, I would not have had the love and support I got from my grandparents and my childhood (and adulthood, for that matter) would have been the poorer for it.

OP- just speak to your mum. She’s your mum, for goodness sake- it’s ok not to agree with what she’s done and even to be upset by it- but communicate that to her, ask her not to do it and move on. Obviously, if she ignores your wishes again, then you need to address this issue more significantly, but give her the opportunity to explain what happened, understand your point of view, and the opportunity to make it right.

Justcallmebebes · 09/04/2022 15:12

She smacked her hand? She's a loving mother/grandmother? Get a grip people

brainhurts · 09/04/2022 15:12

@Pumperthepumper
Ok , next time I see a child trying to electrocute themselves rather than my obvious Hugh overreacting to stop them I will Stand and watch them while asking for them too hand it over .
If you see someone in danger you do what's needs at the time .

Pumperthepumper · 09/04/2022 15:06

@brainhurts

These are older children, trusted to plug laptops/ tablets into charge . Old enough to remove safety plugs . If saying no don't do that didn't work , why would please give me the paper clip .
Surely better than hitting them, no? Not even worth a try?
brainhurts · 09/04/2022 15:03

These are older children, trusted to plug laptops/ tablets into charge . Old enough to remove safety plugs .
If saying no don't do that didn't work , why would please give me the paper clip .

Jannt86 · 09/04/2022 15:00

@brainhurts

I work with children, one ( older knew better ) was trying to put a paper clip into a plug socket. I did say " no don't do that " was totally blanked so I swatted there hand away . The child said they would report me , go ahead , I will ask your parents would they rather you be electrocuted Shock
Am I understanding this right? You work with kids and rather than put safety plugs in your outlets you slapped one of your client's hands? Please say I'm wrong Shock
Pumperthepumper · 09/04/2022 14:53

@brainhurts

I work with children, one ( older knew better ) was trying to put a paper clip into a plug socket. I did say " no don't do that " was totally blanked so I swatted there hand away . The child said they would report me , go ahead , I will ask your parents would they rather you be electrocuted Shock
Why didn’t you just take the paper clip from them?
brainhurts · 09/04/2022 14:52

I work with children, one ( older knew better ) was trying to put a paper clip into a plug socket. I did say " no don't do that " was totally blanked so I swatted there hand away . The child said they would report me , go ahead , I will ask your parents would they rather you be electrocuted Shock

Pumperthepumper · 09/04/2022 14:51

@toomanydogsandcats

The outpourings of drama, the police, no contact, that's what is making me chuckle. I mean seriously, some of you have way too much h time on your hands Grin
You’re the one hanging about pretending to be amused!
Pumperthepumper · 09/04/2022 14:50

@dummyd

But tapping their hand away from say, a lit candle is different to hitting the back of their hand to stop them doing it again.

Shouldn't be hitting kids 😇

Seriously, is it's as abusive as you say to sway a hand that it warrants police intervention and such, it shouldn't be done in any scenario. If a child is reaching for a candle you say 'no dear, don't touch' - not hit them.

No, that’s the previous posters wording. Moving their hand away from a lit candle is not the same as hitting (smacking, tapping) their hand to stop them doing it again.
Pumperthepumper · 09/04/2022 14:49

But you'd seriously call them in the first place? Let me guess, NC with mil too?

No, I said I’d call them if I thought the situation warranted it. No, not NC with MIL. Just against hitting children.

dummyd · 09/04/2022 14:45

But tapping their hand away from say, a lit candle is different to hitting the back of their hand to stop them doing it again.

Shouldn't be hitting kids 😇

Seriously, is it's as abusive as you say to sway a hand that it warrants police intervention and such, it shouldn't be done in any scenario. If a child is reaching for a candle you say 'no dear, don't touch' - not hit them.

toomanydogsandcats · 09/04/2022 14:41

The outpourings of drama, the police, no contact, that's what is making me chuckle. I mean seriously, some of you have way too much h time on your hands Grin

dummyd · 09/04/2022 14:40

@Pumperthepumper

Yes, the police can be shit. I doubt they’d care about a girl being hit, you’re right.
But you'd seriously call them in the first place? Let me guess, NC with mil too?
NeedleNoodle3 · 09/04/2022 14:30

The smack isn’t acceptable, from reading your posts it sounds as if your DM isn’t up to looking after your DD.

Pumperthepumper · 09/04/2022 14:21

@toomanydogsandcats

The thread that keeps on giving Grin
Which bit is making you laugh? The ones that think you shouldn’t hit children, or the ones who thing you should?
toomanydogsandcats · 09/04/2022 13:56

The thread that keeps on giving Grin