Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Mum spanked DD whilst I'm in hospital

516 replies

wantthisbabyout · 08/04/2022 22:43

Currently in hospital after my c-section apologies if this is all over the place as I'm half asleep!

Mum stayed over last night and complained this morning that she hadn't slept all night. We left at 6:45 this morning and she was up. She also said yesterday that she wishes my kids were "normal"

I FaceTimed her today with the kids and DD was upset saying grandma hurt me and my mum said oh it's ok it was only a little spank on the hand as she hasn't been listening.

My DD is the sweetest little girl ever, yes she is very stubborn but you just need to have patience with her.

AIBU to feel like my mum has just lost her temper and probably felt a bit angry and spanked her? I feel so upset about anyone touching my kids.

DH has just popped home now to get some sleepsuits but I dare not tell him because he will be so angry.

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 09/04/2022 19:07

Does the tap have to hurt?

Pumperthepumper · 09/04/2022 19:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

worriedatthistime · 09/04/2022 19:06

@Jannt86 gentle parenting , as in never saying no and no boundaries
There is very clear evidence that children do need boundaries
Ao many parents think their children aren't badly behaved, when in fact they are to most others
Some of these children grow up alright some don't
Your example of many in prison will be extreme violence not a tap on the hand a couple of times throughout childhood , totally different scenario as you well know

brainhurts · 09/04/2022 19:05

@Pumperthepumper
So my child comes home and says they did something naughty, they confess they did it .
I think I would look pretty stupid staying my child has confessed this happened can the adult back them up .

This is distracting From ops post so I won't be defending my reaction to stop a potentially fatal outcome further.

worriedatthistime · 09/04/2022 19:03

@Pumperthepumper kids threaten often to tell their parents even if just told no at times
If you go and ask kids not to be trouble makers outside your house they sometimes threaten to tell their parents
You really seem clueless

Pumperthepumper · 09/04/2022 18:53

[quote brainhurts]@Pumperthepumper
If by would you hit them you mean would I hit my child, no , by punching it would be no TV , no football, and to go to school and say sorry [/quote]
All because you’d believe an adult’s version of what happened over your kid’s? That’s really sad.

brainhurts · 09/04/2022 18:51

@Pumperthepumper
If by would you hit them you mean would I hit my child, no , by punching it would be no TV , no football, and to go to school and say sorry

YvanEhtNiojYvanEhtNioj · 09/04/2022 18:50

Good grief. I hope OP stopped reading this thread. She'll be getting all worked up because of this thread.

latriciamcneal · 09/04/2022 18:48

It's not acceptable to hit people. If someone my daughter trusted hit her I think it would actually traumatise her. She doesn't expect to get hit, it would be such a shock and she would feel so betrayed.

I'm afraid that if someone hit my child that person couldn't have unsupervised contact with them again, and it would be up to my daughter whether she wanted to see the person again or not.

I've never spanked my child's hand. It's unfathomable to me to even think about spanking someone else's child.

Pumperthepumper · 09/04/2022 18:46

[quote brainhurts]@Pumperthepumper
You clearly don't get sarcasm.
If my child said miss stopped me electrocuting themselves, my first thought would be thank you , my second a punishment for my child for being stupid.[/quote]
Would you hit them?

brainhurts · 09/04/2022 18:45

@Pumperthepumper
You clearly don't get sarcasm.
If my child said miss stopped me electrocuting themselves, my first thought would be thank you , my second a punishment for my child for being stupid.

Pumperthepumper · 09/04/2022 18:40

[quote brainhurts]@Pumperthepumper
Some children like to tell there parents everything. They thought telling the parents would distract from the fact they were doing something dangerous, there bad behaviour would be forgotten because I stopped them .
To this day the parent hasn't been in contact, years later, Im not sure how as a parent I would react if my child said ' miss pushed / swatted / solved by Hand away from the plug because I wouldn't stop putting a paper clip in it "
Yes sack her [/quote]
You’re not sure how you’d react if someone did to your kid what you did to someone else’s?

Jannt86 · 09/04/2022 18:40

[quote worriedatthistime]@Jannt86 so also how comes many of us have grown up quite well adjusted adults
My parents prob smacked us maybe 3 times ever , I don't remember the occasions personally just what my mum has told me as they were not regular smackers , im not damaged by it and we have a great relationship and they have a good one with my dc as well
Sometimes people react without thinking [/quote]
Well then it was hardly the staple of your parenting then was it so not exactly a relevant experiment. My own experience was that my own dad was regularly beat up by his dad. He would appear a reasonably well-adjusted man and on the whole he is. However that violence was passed on to his children and I acknowledge that I am a significantly more anxious and emotionally volatile individual than I might be if I'd been parented more gently.

The level of 'damage' that hitting does to a child probably depends entirely on their inherited personality type, the context of the rest of their parenting and the level of violence they were subjected to and at what age. It's logically flawed to state that just because some people were hit and 'turned out ok' that it's an effective parenting method. Sure some people who were hit did develop ok but the fact is that the majority of people in prisons or with unhelpful personality types were subjected to violence or emotional abuse or both as children ie; not all kids who were smacked become criminals but most criminals were smacked as children

I think gentle parenting is more important nowadays too as a lot of the 'protective factors' which might have made it less of a big deal in previous generations are no longer as prevelent. Parents don't tend to have as long to bond with their child as it's far more commonplace for mum to go to work. It's more common for people to have less of a support network as people live away from extended family and we don't associate with our neighbours etc so our 'village' is gone. Kids are more exposed to social media/screentime and nit as able to play and negotiate relationships. This all very much matters.

There's a lot of strong evidence that parental connection is very important in child development and if you want a crude example of this then google Harlow's monkeys. It's pretty obvious that physical violence on some level breaks that connection.

Parenting styles may differ over time but sorry I don't think it's ever again going to be considered acceptable parenting to be physically violent

brainhurts · 09/04/2022 18:38

@Pumperthepumper
Some children like to tell there parents everything. They thought telling the parents would distract from the fact they were doing something dangerous, there bad behaviour would be forgotten because I stopped them .
To this day the parent hasn't been in contact, years later, Im not sure how as a parent I would react if my child said ' miss pushed / swatted / solved by Hand away from the plug because I wouldn't stop putting a paper clip in it "
Yes sack her

Hiphophippityskip1 · 09/04/2022 18:37

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Giraffesandbottoms · 09/04/2022 18:33

I would tell dd that it was not ok for her gran to spank her but that she needs to listen her her gran and do as she is asked

That would be a terrible message to send a child.

Pumperthepumper · 09/04/2022 18:29

[quote brainhurts]**@worriedatthistime

Pumperthepumper she swatted the hand away which would be quicker and a reflex action
Trying to grab it could result in more of a struggle , again your judging a situation without being there
Sometimes we react quickl

Thanks @worriedatthistime
It was a knee jerk reaction, I saw the child ( an older child allowed access to paper clips and allowed to put laptop on charge )told them to stop they didn't , so rather than ask for the paper clip and seeing how close it was to being in the socket I swatted/ pushed / jotted/ moved there hand .
But my bad [/quote]
Enough that they said they would tell their parents? Some swat.

Gowithme · 09/04/2022 18:26

I guess all you can take from this is that your kids are too much for your mum to look after on her own. Maybe she could cope with one at a time, maybe not. Although they are her grandkids they're still not her kids, raised with her routines and with her knowing all their likes and dislikes.

I would tell dd that it was not ok for her gran to spank her but that she needs to listen her her gran and do as she is asked. I would also tell your mum that you feel having more than one child is probably a bit much for her and so you will avoid that situation in future but you do not want her to physically punish you children. If she is not coping then she needs to call you.

brainhurts · 09/04/2022 18:26

@worriedatthistime

Pumperthepumper she swatted the hand away which would be quicker and a reflex action
Trying to grab it could result in more of a struggle , again your judging a situation without being there
Sometimes we react quickl

Thanks @worriedatthistime
It was a knee jerk reaction, I saw the child ( an older child allowed access to paper clips and allowed to put laptop on charge )told them to stop they didn't , so rather than ask for the paper clip and seeing how close it was to being in the socket I swatted/ pushed / jotted/ moved there hand .
But my bad

Pumperthepumper · 09/04/2022 18:24

[quote worriedatthistime]@Tothepoint99 but that is abuse if they hit you hard and for no reason thats very different to a tap in the hand once [/quote]
Does the tap have to hurt?

Pumperthepumper · 09/04/2022 18:24

[quote worriedatthistime]@Pumperthepumper I once grabbed my son by his jacket to stop him walking in the road and he was left with a mark from the zip
Maybe I should of grabbed elsewhere or shouted stop but I reacted there and then in the moment [/quote]
Did you smack him afterwards?

Jannt86 · 09/04/2022 18:22

[quote worriedatthistime]@Jannt86 in your opinion but you don't get to judge others and call them crap parents even if you think you do have the right , you really don't
[/quote]
I didn't say anyone was a crap parent. I said the act of hitting a child is widely acknowledged as crap. There is a difference. Of course we get to call out abusive and unhelpful parenting. In fact it's our duty as a society to call it out within reason. What do you think cps are there for?

worriedatthistime · 09/04/2022 18:22

@Tothepoint99 but that is abuse if they hit you hard and for no reason thats very different to a tap in the hand once

worriedatthistime · 09/04/2022 18:21

@Jannt86 so also how comes many of us have grown up quite well adjusted adults
My parents prob smacked us maybe 3 times ever , I don't remember the occasions personally just what my mum has told me as they were not regular smackers , im not damaged by it and we have a great relationship and they have a good one with my dc as well
Sometimes people react without thinking

Cherryblossoms85 · 09/04/2022 18:20

Eh? She tapped her hand. Not a particularly great parenting technique, but also not abuse or against the law. I think I'm just too old for this site.