Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Mum spanked DD whilst I'm in hospital

516 replies

wantthisbabyout · 08/04/2022 22:43

Currently in hospital after my c-section apologies if this is all over the place as I'm half asleep!

Mum stayed over last night and complained this morning that she hadn't slept all night. We left at 6:45 this morning and she was up. She also said yesterday that she wishes my kids were "normal"

I FaceTimed her today with the kids and DD was upset saying grandma hurt me and my mum said oh it's ok it was only a little spank on the hand as she hasn't been listening.

My DD is the sweetest little girl ever, yes she is very stubborn but you just need to have patience with her.

AIBU to feel like my mum has just lost her temper and probably felt a bit angry and spanked her? I feel so upset about anyone touching my kids.

DH has just popped home now to get some sleepsuits but I dare not tell him because he will be so angry.

OP posts:
Jannt86 · 10/04/2022 10:38

@toomanydogsandcats

It's ironic how the angriest and most aggressive posters are in the anti hand tap team. Abusive behaviour can be verbal or written as well as touching someone's hand.
The only thing I have said that could be marginally interpretted as aggressive was in retaliation to somone in the 'other camp' calling a small child a spoiled brat and with very little context at that. Being honest and not tolerating viscious and out of date attitudes isn't aggressive. You can close your ears to the evidence all you want but gaslighting people isn't going to work
Nennypops · 10/04/2022 10:33

we have no idea if the nan is just past being able to handle looking after her young grandchildren and does if more out of obligation than really wanting to or if the sweet little girl that can be stubborn and needs patience is a pain who wants her own way and wont shut up moaning till she gets it requiring a saint to deal with her . who knows? something does trigger the nan to make that comment and i dont think its because shes some sort of demon

You've left out the third possibility, namely that she wants to look after her grandchildren but doesn't give a small child leeway for being upset about the change in the routine and the absence of her mother, and thinks it's OK to hit her.

PupInAPram · 10/04/2022 10:29

@toomanydogsandcats

It's ironic how the angriest and most aggressive posters are in the anti hand tap team. Abusive behaviour can be verbal or written as well as touching someone's hand.
I think there are people being extreme and aggressive on both sides of the divide, but also people being reasonable and civil on both sides.
Newhousesad · 10/04/2022 03:21

I agree this is completely unacceptable. Hope you’re ok OP and your DD is too

chaosrabbitland · 10/04/2022 01:53

@coolbean

I'd be so upset 😭 and the comment "I wish your kids were normal" what kind of nan says this?! I'd be furious! I'd put her at a distance from that moment personally...
we have no idea if the nan is just past being able to handle looking after her young grandchildren and does if more out of obligation than really wanting to or if the sweet little girl that can be stubborn and needs patience is a pain who wants her own way and wont shut up moaning till she gets it requiring a saint to deal with her . who knows? something does trigger the nan to make that comment and i dont think its because shes some sort of demon
Nennypops · 09/04/2022 23:51

[quote worriedatthistime]@Pumperthepumper kids threaten often to tell their parents even if just told no at times
If you go and ask kids not to be trouble makers outside your house they sometimes threaten to tell their parents
You really seem clueless [/quote]
It's not a great idea to accuse someone else of being clueless when you have failed to learn basic grammar.

Nennypops · 09/04/2022 23:46

@Cherryblossoms85

Eh? She tapped her hand. Not a particularly great parenting technique, but also not abuse or against the law. I think I'm just too old for this site.
She didn't tap it. There would be no point in tapping. She smacked in order to cause pain, and she succeeded.
Nennypops · 09/04/2022 23:45

[quote worriedatthistime]@Pumperthepumper she swatted the hand away which would be quicker and a reflex action
Trying to grab it could result in more of a struggle , again your judging a situation without being there
Sometimes we react quickly [/quote]
Even quicker would be to shout at the child. Saying "Stop! It's dangerous!" takes half a second.

coolbean · 09/04/2022 23:44

I'd be so upset 😭 and the comment "I wish your kids were normal" what kind of nan says this?! I'd be furious! I'd put her at a distance from that moment personally...

Nennypops · 09/04/2022 23:44

[quote brainhurts]@Nennypops
As I said we don't know what caused her to be smacked, was she playing up and gran lost her temper, was she doing something dangerous.
I don't condone the losing temper but can relate to the knee jerk reaction of gran seeing dander and child not listening.
[/quote]
Fairly obviously she wasn't doing something dangerous, otherwise grandma would have told OP. If this woman were subject to knee-jerk reactions that cause her to lose her temper and hit people, again I'm sure OP would have mentioned it. It's pretty obvious that she reserves her hitting for small children and she can't sensibly pretend that anything the child did justified it unless she would hit an adult in exactly the same circumstances.

Nennypops · 09/04/2022 23:40

[quote worriedatthistime]@Nennypops except many of them aren't children who are smacked
So you are just making a huge assumption
I know people who don't smack but also don't have other boundaries and there children are poorly behaved [/quote]
It's hardly surprising that parents who don't impose boundaries may have poorly behaved children. However, all over the world parents and teachers manage to impose boundaries very successfully without hitting children.

chaosrabbitland · 09/04/2022 23:36

[quote worriedatthistime]@Pumperthepumper kids threaten often to tell their parents even if just told no at times
If you go and ask kids not to be trouble makers outside your house they sometimes threaten to tell their parents
You really seem clueless [/quote]
yes agreed worried she does a lot, and already has stated upthread shes a teacher , i find that worrying in itself , all i can say is wouldnt last five minutes teaching in the huge secondary school my dd goes to , i think standing there like a twat speaking in a calm gentle voice wouldnt be stopping the violent fights between students that sometimes occur lol

LizzieW1969 · 09/04/2022 22:02

Both my DH and I were smacked when we were growing up. Yet my DM and MIL would never think of smacking their DGDs, as they know that we don’t do that. My DM once threatened to ‘whack’ DD1 when she was 4 years old, I warned her never to do that again and she hasn’t.

Wherever we stand on the issue of smacking as a form of discipline, it’s completely inappropriate for a grandparent to take it upon themselves to smack a child. So the OP’s DM was completely out of order for that reason alone.

However, there are some very OTT responses here. There’s no need for any draconian response here. The OP should tell her mum that smacking her DD was unacceptable and she must never do it again. They have a good relationship so they can surely talk this through and move on.

Pumperthepumper · 09/04/2022 21:38

@woodhill

Yes but it's an adult world and you are trying to be professional at work

Do you never shout at your husband or at your parents when you lived at home. At least you can be yourself there. You are not trying to out on an act itms

Yes, but I don’t hit them! That’s my point, hitting is not instinctive, in the same way shouting is.
woodhill · 09/04/2022 21:36

Yes but it's an adult world and you are trying to be professional at work

Do you never shout at your husband or at your parents when you lived at home. At least you can be yourself there. You are not trying to out on an act itms

Pumperthepumper · 09/04/2022 21:01

Raising one’s voice is also not an effective / appropriate form of discipline. Of course it happens- we are all human. But I certainly wouldn’t use it as an example of how to parent well.

Also, raising a voice (to shout if a kid leans over to tough a candle, for example) is an instant reaction. I can’t think of a single time a colleague has slapped my hand away from something dangerous. Or tapped me, or smacked me or any of the other vocabulary trotted out on here. It’s like that reaction is controlable around adults but miraculously, not children.

toomanydogsandcats · 09/04/2022 20:53

It's ironic how the angriest and most aggressive posters are in the anti hand tap team. Abusive behaviour can be verbal or written as well as touching someone's hand.

Bizawit · 09/04/2022 20:15

[quote worriedatthistime]@Pumperthepumper no its doesn't have to hurt it can just be a shock
Same if someone raises a voice who doesn't normally it causes most to stop even for a second or two
Gosh my kids have told me their brothers hurt them when I have been there and seen what happened , at times
There kids , they aren't silly at times
I would never not intently believe my child but I would listen and get as much info from them and any others that were there first and foremost so I could make a better informed judgement[/quote]
Raising one’s voice is also not an effective / appropriate form of discipline. Of course it happens- we are all human. But I certainly wouldn’t use it as an example of how to parent well.

Jannt86 · 09/04/2022 19:58

[quote worriedatthistime]@Jannt86 gentle parenting , as in never saying no and no boundaries
There is very clear evidence that children do need boundaries
Ao many parents think their children aren't badly behaved, when in fact they are to most others
Some of these children grow up alright some don't
Your example of many in prison will be extreme violence not a tap on the hand a couple of times throughout childhood , totally different scenario as you well know [/quote]
Absolutely there's a difference and one tap on the hand is unlikely to be anywhere near as damaging as persistent aggression but it's the principle. I would still take massive issue with anyone who physically assaulted my child and at the very least it'd be a big red flag to me that they aren't coping with their babysitting duties which is pretty much what I've said in a pp.

What you're describing isn't gentle parenting it's permissive parenting. This also has it's own issues and it's entirely possible to be a gentle parent without being a permissive parent it's just arguably harder work which is IMO why people prefer to just pretend that smacking is better...

Pumperthepumper · 09/04/2022 19:30

[quote worriedatthistime]@Pumperthepumper no its doesn't have to hurt it can just be a shock
Same if someone raises a voice who doesn't normally it causes most to stop even for a second or two
Gosh my kids have told me their brothers hurt them when I have been there and seen what happened , at times
There kids , they aren't silly at times
I would never not intently believe my child but I would listen and get as much info from them and any others that were there first and foremost so I could make a better informed judgement[/quote]
So if it doesn’t hurt, why do it?

Runmybathforme · 09/04/2022 19:28

When my kids were small, it was common practice to give them a " little tap " on the hand , thank goodness those days are over. Some of the posters on here seem way over the top just have a quiet word with her.

worriedatthistime · 09/04/2022 19:20

@Pumperthepumper no its doesn't have to hurt it can just be a shock
Same if someone raises a voice who doesn't normally it causes most to stop even for a second or two
Gosh my kids have told me their brothers hurt them when I have been there and seen what happened , at times
There kids , they aren't silly at times
I would never not intently believe my child but I would listen and get as much info from them and any others that were there first and foremost so I could make a better informed judgement

worriedatthistime · 09/04/2022 19:15

@Pumperthepumper how Am i cold and intolerent , you don't know me
You seem a bit clueless and think that your right and all are wrong
The scenario where i asked children to move on from my property was because they were damaging it and one also had a knife in their hand , trying to cut bushes etc
This was dangerous and i asked them to stop doing it and they said I will tell my mum your telling us off, well wasn't an issue as I went and told the num myself that their young child had a knife
Mum was horrified , the child denied it but then when pressed by mum admitted it
That isn't cold thats about having a childs welfare considered as they could of hurt themselves
Lucky the mum took my word at least to start with , rather than slam the door in my face and say my child never lies
Adults lie too so its always tricky but often we know our own children and I know if mine are lying or just being loose with the truth

Pumperthepumper · 09/04/2022 19:14

[quote worriedatthistime]@Pumperthepumper so you believe a kid every time over an adult
Kids also lie , its a case of listening to both sides and getting the facts
Are you the sort of parent that of your child is told off at school you go marching in as there is no way your little darling did anything wrong and it must of been someone else
Normally when things happen there are multiple accounts , I don't instantly believe or nor believe, I try and establish the facts first and foremost [/quote]
Does a tap have to hurt to be an effective deterrent?

worriedatthistime · 09/04/2022 19:10

@Pumperthepumper so you believe a kid every time over an adult
Kids also lie , its a case of listening to both sides and getting the facts
Are you the sort of parent that of your child is told off at school you go marching in as there is no way your little darling did anything wrong and it must of been someone else
Normally when things happen there are multiple accounts , I don't instantly believe or nor believe, I try and establish the facts first and foremost