Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Mum spanked DD whilst I'm in hospital

516 replies

wantthisbabyout · 08/04/2022 22:43

Currently in hospital after my c-section apologies if this is all over the place as I'm half asleep!

Mum stayed over last night and complained this morning that she hadn't slept all night. We left at 6:45 this morning and she was up. She also said yesterday that she wishes my kids were "normal"

I FaceTimed her today with the kids and DD was upset saying grandma hurt me and my mum said oh it's ok it was only a little spank on the hand as she hasn't been listening.

My DD is the sweetest little girl ever, yes she is very stubborn but you just need to have patience with her.

AIBU to feel like my mum has just lost her temper and probably felt a bit angry and spanked her? I feel so upset about anyone touching my kids.

DH has just popped home now to get some sleepsuits but I dare not tell him because he will be so angry.

OP posts:
Sunnytwobridges · 09/04/2022 01:15

@hackettblue

I really despair about the raising of children in this day and age, these are the children of the future and if they can’t deal with any sort of chastisement I pity the future. Your DD had her hand smacked by grandma for gods sake get over yourself. I speak as a mother who has 2 beautiful daughters nearing their 40s the elder of which was a nightmare child / of course must be all my fault that I didn’t have experience, but she was occasionally smacked - shock horror - usually when she became hysterical about something or other which was rapidly followed by a quick calm down and cuddles. Ironically she has worked in the childcare sector for the last 22 years with fantastic results and laughs to this day about what a little shit she was and how she can ‘spot’ likewise children within an hour of meeting them. She has grown to a beautiful caring woman and in no way was ‘traumatised’ by the occasional smack - get over yourselves for gods sake.
I agree.

She got popped in the hand if she’d slapped her it would be a different story.

mathanxiety · 09/04/2022 01:13

Desperate exhausted woman resorts to whatever she has to, trying to do the best for her family. Shocker.

PMSL.

You are serious?

AnnesBrokenSlate · 09/04/2022 01:07

A tap is different from a slap and both are different from a spank. If posters really think the best use of their time is conflating words with different meanings and winding up someone who has just given birth then that is their call. But it's not what MN is supposed to be for.

SmellyOldOwls · 09/04/2022 01:04

@mathanxiety

Of course it wasn't acceptable, but does the OPs mother know that it's not acceptable now?

@FrankLeeSpeaking, the gran was apparently a lovely mum in her younger days but has changed to the point where the OP's brothers have noticed she has 'lost her mojo with the kids and lacks patience'.

Honestly, if I were the gran here and it was all too much for me, I would just say so, not complain about my grandchildren not being 'normal', but still cross my fingers and think it would be ok because I could always resort to smacking.

Desperate exhausted woman resorts to whatever she has to, trying to do the best for her family. Shocker.
Kanaloa · 09/04/2022 00:54

@AnnesBrokenSlate

I wouldn't call a hit on the hand 'a spank' because it isn't. I also don't believe that the posters whipping up drama have never had to catch a child's hand, or tap it away if they were going to touch something hot/dangerous etc. OP you've given birth. You're coping with a lot of emotions- take time to draw breath. And get off MN. At this time of night, at the weekend, it's full of gfs. It's the last place a new mum should be.
Catching up a child’s hand is nothing like smacking them because they’re naughty?

I see it constantly on here. Oh he was about to shove a metal screwdriver in the plug socket I HAD to slap him what else could I do? Erm well if you were close enough to slap you were close enough to move/redirect.

But whether you believe it or not I’ve got through four children without ever needing to ‘tap’ their hands away from something dangerous. I either removed dangerous items or moved them away. Although I have noticed ‘tap’ is used only by people who slap kids. They don’t like words like slap/hit and prefer the less accurate ‘tap.’

mathanxiety · 09/04/2022 00:54

@pinkyredrose, the child's crime was 'not listening'.

And none of the OP's children are 'normal', according to the grandma.

mathanxiety · 09/04/2022 00:51

Of course it wasn't acceptable, but does the OPs mother know that it's not acceptable now?

@FrankLeeSpeaking, the gran was apparently a lovely mum in her younger days but has changed to the point where the OP's brothers have noticed she has 'lost her mojo with the kids and lacks patience'.

Honestly, if I were the gran here and it was all too much for me, I would just say so, not complain about my grandchildren not being 'normal', but still cross my fingers and think it would be ok because I could always resort to smacking.

Selma22 · 09/04/2022 00:49

@Prudencia

If a man claimed that he hit his wife because of her behaviour would that be acceptable *@pinkyredrose* ? Hitting little children to allow an adult to take out their anger and frustration on a small child is completely unacceptable.
It doesn't work that way.If a woman claimed that her husband controls what she eats,what tv she watches,when she leaves house it would be domestic violence and emotional abuse...yet we do that to children to raise them correctly. I don't agree with children but the parallel with you don't do it to adults don't work...plenty of things we don't do to adults and plenty of things we do that we don't do to children.
AnnesBrokenSlate · 09/04/2022 00:46

I wouldn't call a hit on the hand 'a spank' because it isn't. I also don't believe that the posters whipping up drama have never had to catch a child's hand, or tap it away if they were going to touch something hot/dangerous etc.
OP you've given birth. You're coping with a lot of emotions- take time to draw breath. And get off MN. At this time of night, at the weekend, it's full of gfs. It's the last place a new mum should be.

Teenagehorrorbag · 09/04/2022 00:45

I'm torn. In theory I don't have a problem with a tap on the hand - for example to say 'no, don't touch that' or whatever. Spank to me means a big old whack on the bottom - hard. I've never heard of a spank on the hand - but if DD said grandma hurt her then it must have been quite physical!

Then again - My DD used to pull the wallpaper off the wall. From crawling to about 2, I think. I tried and tried and to get her to stop, including smacking the back of her hand (not hard) and saying 'no, that's naughty, Mummy is cross'. It never stopped her - eventually we stripped the paper and painted the wall.....Grin.

A year or so later, she was on grandma's lap and saw her gold cross and chain and played with it. Granny said 'that's my cross'. DD then got off her lap, ran to the wall and pointed to it, and slapped her hand saying 'cross'. Made us all laugh - she had learnt that cross meant a slapped hand, and that it related to the wall - but it never stopped her stripping the paper!

I suppose my lesson was that slapping doesn't achieve your aim even if you do think it's OK. I don't think a tap would be a big deal although you clearly need to set some agreed guidelines for discipline. But an aggressive whack which really hurt your DD is a different thing. But you need to talk this through and if she goes against your parenting practices after that then you will need to restrict access.

Prudencia · 09/04/2022 00:42

If a man claimed that he hit his wife because of her behaviour would that be acceptable @pinkyredrose ?
Hitting little children to allow an adult to take out their anger and frustration on a small child is completely unacceptable.

EthelTheAardvark · 09/04/2022 00:42

@pinkyredrose

Why did she do it, was your daughter misbehaving or putting herself in danger?
Whether OP's daughter was misbehaving is irrelevant, it doesn't justify hitting her. Even if she was putting herself in danger, it would only be acceptable it that was the only way to rescue her, e.g pushing her out of the way of something dangerous. Hitting her on the hand doesn't sound like that.
Bunty55 · 09/04/2022 00:39

[quote Tilltheend99]@Bunty55 how ridiculous! Looking after the grandchildren for one night while your child has a c-section is hardly being taken advantage of. I really think that people shouldn’t have children if they can’t factor in the possibility of having basic, low level, grand parenting responsibilities one day.[/quote]
Well actually I did not mean for one night. I meant children who use their mothers as childminders without thinking it through.

Grandparents should be there for fun, not for childminding.

pinkyredrose · 09/04/2022 00:33

Why did she do it, was your daughter misbehaving or putting herself in danger?

Tilltheend99 · 09/04/2022 00:33

@Bunty55 how ridiculous! Looking after the grandchildren for one night while your child has a c-section is hardly being taken advantage of. I really think that people shouldn’t have children if they can’t factor in the possibility of having basic, low level, grand parenting responsibilities one day.

Carla2601 · 09/04/2022 00:33

@wantthisbabyout there are a whole lot of pious, smug women on here. You have just been through an overwhelming experience. You are your mums baby so she will have potentially been v worried about you and also sleep deprived which she’s presumably not used to.

It’s not ideal, and I’m sorry it’s happened, and you’re not being unreasonable. But I’d ignore the witch hunt and just have a chat with your mum when things have settled down.

Good luck ☺️

Selma22 · 09/04/2022 00:31

Well you should obviously report her to police and make sure you never see her again!

Honesty people a bit of perspective.Just explain that it isn't acceptable and if disciplining is needed these are the methods used (naughty step etc).
Slap on a hand is hardly worth making a huge deal over.Just enforce that and leave it be.No need for drama

WingingItSince1973 · 09/04/2022 00:28

@Prudencia

Some posters will condone anything if it is done by themselves or by their mother. If a Mil hit a child, or a Dad there would be an uproar. It is not acceptable to try and justify hitting and frightening a small child. Once someone starts to resort to physical punishment they do it again and again. Those posters who try to justify hitting, should be ashamed of themselves.
@Prudencia absolutely agree. Am shocked people think smacking is OK in any situation, all because it was ok back in the day. To the pp above with the amazing daughter who calls children little shits! I'm afraid smacking kids back in the bygone years didn't stop generations of children growing up to be abusers or dealing with anger issues. I hate it when people say we are producing a generation of wussies if we don't discipline them like we were as children! What absolute rubbish. No one should be hitting children full stop. Doesn't matter how challenging they are or how tired you are. I have my dgs regularly and he has had major meltdowns because of sen and although being pushed to my limit no way was I going to make myself feel justified by hitting him. Op I hope you have a swift recovery. I've had 3 sections and I know how hard it is to be away from your children with the added pressure of thinking their gm is resorting to smacking. She needs to be told that's not acceptable. I wouldn't go as far as to say no contact but she needs to know that it's no on! But please don't dwell on it. Enjoy your new addition and make sure you rest!
FrankLeeSpeaking · 09/04/2022 00:26

@mathanxiety

The context is in the OP.

She was apparently 'not listening'.
Also, the OP's children are apparently not "normal".

She had never spoken to her mum about spanking because it hasn't happened before, though the OP's brothers have mentioned problems when gran dealt with their kids.

Just because smacking was normalised in some families in days gone by doesn't mean it was acceptable.

Of course it wasn't acceptable, but does the OPs mother know that it's not acceptable now?

I personally wouldn't leave the mother in sole charge again, either, because it seems like she can't cope with the children for any length of time. Of course the OPs daughter is going to be unsettled with a new baby, her parents out of the house etc etc. I wouldn't make a huge deal out of it with my mum based on the OP, though.

ineedafairygodmother · 09/04/2022 00:21

Firstly Congratulations on your new baby and speedy recovery OP Thanks

I personally don't agree with any form of smacking/spanking a child whether it leaves a mark or not. There's other ways to teach a child right from wrong.

If your in the UK, it's illegal for anyone without PA to smack a child and considered abuse for anyone with (or without) PA to smack a child and leave a mark

Prudencia · 09/04/2022 00:20

Some posters will condone anything if it is done by themselves or by their mother. If a Mil hit a child, or a Dad there would be an uproar.
It is not acceptable to try and justify hitting and frightening a small child. Once someone starts to resort to physical punishment they do it again and again. Those posters who try to justify hitting, should be ashamed of themselves.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 09/04/2022 00:20

Bloody hell, there's some really shit parents and grandparents on here

The op left the morning of the smack , it's not like the women had the dcs over night on her own the parents were there.

I didnt hit my children and wouldn't dream of hitting my grandchildren and I'd be furious if anyone else hit them .

KnowingMeKnowingYouAhaaaa · 09/04/2022 00:18

It's amazing how many people justify smacking with "it never did my son/daughter any harm", just because it was acceptable in the 70s and 80s doesn't make it acceptable in current times. My parents smacked us as children, it wasn't nice and only happened when they lost control, when we wouldn't do as we were told. They didn't sit us down and explain what we'd done wrong they shouted, chased and smacked. Fast forward 30 odd years I have my own young children, there is zero hitting and if they misbehave we don't lose control we explain what they did wrong, sit them on the bottom step of the stairs for 5 min or however long, they calm down and think about what they've done. They aren't frightened of being hit and they are polite and generally well behaved. My own parents look after them too and understand the errors of their ways hitting us, they'd never dream of even tapping their hands. Granted they have a lot more time and patients now but they just wouldn't get mad enough to resort to what they did when we were children. I accept its what most parents did back then, it wasn't right though.

EthelTheAardvark · 09/04/2022 00:18

@ScrollingLeaves

‘Smacking’ and ‘spanking and ‘tapping’ are words used by abusers to justify attacking kids. Use the correct words. Your mother assaulted your child

I think it seems clear here there was no abusive hitting and beating going on here.

OP's mother admits to hitting a small child. Define the difference between an adult hitting a child and an adult abusively hitting a child, and explain how a child is supposed to tell the difference.
ScrollingLeaves · 09/04/2022 00:17

@NewandNotImproved

@ScrollingLeaves explain attacks that are not abusive on kids? You’re embarrassing yourself.

All attacks are abusive, you are right, but this incident does not on the face of it seem to have been a violent, vicious, full on attack which is what abuse to children can be like. It was one smack on the hand ( unless OPs mother was lying).

So the OP has had a warning to never leave her mother alone in any stressful situation with the children again, but this can be repaired imo if her mother apologises to the child.