Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Mum spanked DD whilst I'm in hospital

516 replies

wantthisbabyout · 08/04/2022 22:43

Currently in hospital after my c-section apologies if this is all over the place as I'm half asleep!

Mum stayed over last night and complained this morning that she hadn't slept all night. We left at 6:45 this morning and she was up. She also said yesterday that she wishes my kids were "normal"

I FaceTimed her today with the kids and DD was upset saying grandma hurt me and my mum said oh it's ok it was only a little spank on the hand as she hasn't been listening.

My DD is the sweetest little girl ever, yes she is very stubborn but you just need to have patience with her.

AIBU to feel like my mum has just lost her temper and probably felt a bit angry and spanked her? I feel so upset about anyone touching my kids.

DH has just popped home now to get some sleepsuits but I dare not tell him because he will be so angry.

OP posts:
Ninjaexpress · 09/04/2022 07:59

@PinkCheetah

I can't believe some of the responses in this thread. The child had their hand smacked by grandma. But some of you all reacting like the child was kicked, punched, left bloodied, bruised and left for dead!! Get a grip. Just tell grandma that's not the way you wish to discipline your children and not to do it again. But going NC over this is OTT.
Thank goodness, just what I was thinking.
PupInAPram · 09/04/2022 07:53

I think the word spank softens it too much. I know it's an American term, but maybe when discussing it with your mum, say 'strike'or 'hit'. People make mistakes, which is understandable as long as it's acknowledged as such.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 09/04/2022 07:52

My mum spanked us all the time.
She never laid a finger on any of her precious grandchildren and she has mine a lot.
I think you need to tell dh but have a chat with your mum later when the heat has gone out of the situation.

Carbiesdreamhouse · 09/04/2022 07:49

This seems to be the fifth thread on smacking I've seen today Confused

Member869894 · 09/04/2022 07:49

Granny snacks child's hand. Hardly the end of the world is it? Just tell her not to do ir again and explain to child that granny won't do it again. Absolutely no cause for the ridiculous posts on this thread

saggyhairyass · 09/04/2022 07:47

Bit weird the I Wish Your Kids Were Normal comment. But besides that, just tell your mum to not do it again, because it's unacceptable. How does a child learn what is acceptable by an adult acting unacceptably?

Spannwr1971 · 09/04/2022 07:46

My kid drives me to despair, I've never smacked him, not even a tap on the hand. It sets a very unpleasant parenting precedent, and belongs in the past. Who the hell does she think she is?

user1487194234 · 09/04/2022 07:45

I would tell your DH
Apart from anything else your DD might
I have never hit my DC
Was smacked as a child and did resent
But I think your mum sounds like she is not coping

Nothappyatwork · 09/04/2022 07:41

It does sound like it’s all got a bit too much for grandma and I think we do forget this and it’s yet another of those things you only learn to really understand when you’re in the position yourself. I’m not massively old I’m probably 15 years away from grandchildren, 10 at least but the idea of having a toddler all day and then overnight as well it’s just incomprehensible. I know I could not do it I’m not saying I would smack the little mite. I just wouldn’t put myself in a position where I might lose my temper sufficiently to do it .

Notahappywife · 09/04/2022 07:41

In addition the “I wish your kids were normal” comment proves IMO that your mum might not be a monster but she clearly isn’t coping left alone with your kids.

Ps. Congratulations & seedy recovery 🎉

FedUp79 · 09/04/2022 07:40

Why smacking hasn’t been banned in England I don’t know. There is no excuse to hit another person. I grew up with a physically (and psychologically) abusive mother and whilst my experience was far worse than a smack, there is still no excuse. Reasoning with, even a young child, works far better.

OP you need to talk to your DH and discuss whether your DM has the patience to look after your children. Hope you recover soon after your c-section and congratulations.

Juniper68 · 09/04/2022 07:40

Those minimising, do you smack your dcs?

Benjispruce4 · 09/04/2022 07:39

The ‘normal’ comment is far more worrying to me than the smack in the hand. Then I again I was brought up with smacking and I’m ok with that. I think you need far more information. Good luck with your new baby.

Notahappywife · 09/04/2022 07:38

It only could’ve been a smack on hands from grandma’s perspective, but the child felt physically hurt so it doesn’t matter if it was just on hands or full on whack on the bum.

It’s not about the pain intensity is it? We don’t apply this to domestic abuse victims do we? We don’t ask how hard they’ve been hit, and if it’s just a slap on a cheek it’s fine 🙄

I’ve been smacked few times as a child by my “loving” grandad, who just wanted to teach me a lesson and I clearly remember flinching years later when he raised his hand… I was truly scared of physical punishment even though it wasn’t that hard probably, nevertheless humiliating.

PinkCheetah · 09/04/2022 07:38

I can't believe some of the responses in this thread. The child had their hand smacked by grandma. But some of you all reacting like the child was kicked, punched, left bloodied, bruised and left for dead!! Get a grip. Just tell grandma that's not the way you wish to discipline your children and not to do it again. But going NC over this is OTT.

Fredstheteds · 09/04/2022 07:35

MIL told me once that if mine didn’t behave she would smack him- she never has or will have my child without supervision. Smacking us out dated. Not easy as OP is in a place where she needs the help! Hopefully you will be reunited with your family soon !

Ponoka7 · 09/04/2022 07:32

"however have noticed since she has gotten older she's lost her mojo with kids and lacks patience."

So she's struggled to cope. I'm getting to the stage were I know I couldn't look after a child between 8 months and nearly 2, overnight and all day. I've told my DD this. I have done childcare for her children from six weeks and babysat other people's from the same.
Let her help with practical stuff, lifting the baby to you, tidying going out with the older ones etc, after a good night's sleep, but make it clear that it wasn't ok and it doesn't happen again.
It's interesting how we don't expect older men to look after young children. You can't fake being able to cope and it's unfair for someone to plan babies but need a lot of family help.

OrlandointheWilderness · 09/04/2022 07:31

Blimey some serious over reaction here. She smacked her hand!

Fadeout83 · 09/04/2022 07:30

This really seems like a simple problem to solve. “Mum, smacking as discipline isn’t acceptable in our house. I’m not happy it happened. Please don’t do it again. Thanks”.

Have you ever discussed discipline methods with your mum? If not, as is evidenced in this thread, times have changed and some grandparents simply don’t know better.

Good lord the overreactions though. This is your mother and your child’s grandparent. I assume they otherwise have a lovely relationship. Have a chat before banishing her and explain clearly the boundaries.

HangingRock25 · 09/04/2022 07:27

A tap on the hand is totally ok. I really hate the anti-discipline sentiment on here. Thankfully, not being in the UK we are not beholden to the woke tripe and smacking that is reasonable is perfectly allowed here. Your mum didn't abuse your child. In fact, it was only a tap on the hands, not even a smack on the bum. So your mum was actually very mild and was being responsible as a grandparent. Please don't listen to the anti-discipline woke garbage on here. You know your mother is not an abuser.

WonderingWanda · 09/04/2022 07:24

My DM smacked me as a child but has never smacked my kids because I made nit clear how they were to be discliplined. Of course she shouldn't have done it but it sounds like she isn't really coping. Does she normally ook after your daughter on her own or was this just a one off and she is out of her depth? It is quite normal for once great parents to forget how to deal with children or to be surprised by the exhaustion of always being on the go. Lovely children can still be demanding and exhausting just being themselves.

If I were you I would explain to your Mum that it must never happen again but also invest a bit of time in teaching her how to manage your daughter. Also remember that your daughter is your world so you have all the time in the world for being patient with her but other people may want her to be a little bit more compliant a bit quicker....as may you now you have a new baby (also still not suggesting smacking is a way to achieve this, just trying to help you see howit might have happened). I don't think you need to jump straight to banning your mother from your life etc, people make mistakes. It seems like your Mum won't cope with lack of sleep or long stints of childcare and now you know. Congrats on the new baby too!

Marvellousmadness · 09/04/2022 07:22

She is the "sweetest little girl".
At the same time you say she is stubborn and you need patience to deal with her.

So basically she sounds like a handful
Doesnt give your mother the right to smack her though. But it was just a smack on the hand. Not assault as some pp's have mentioned Jeez Confused...

Just tell her to not do it again

anne2650 · 09/04/2022 07:19

It was a hand slap. Sounds like you're overreacting a bit. Speak to your DM and let her know that you're unhappy and you don't want it to happen again. Move on.

Egghead68 · 09/04/2022 07:18

Don’t leave your children alone with her again.

MummyGummy · 09/04/2022 07:16

Of course YANBU. Smacking has just been made illegal in Wales, I hope England will follow soon and this is why it’s needed. No adult has the right to physically punish a child. You witnessed the distress it caused your daughter. She was probably very unsettled being away from you and her grandmother should have been comforting and understanding, not loosing her patience/temper.
And the ‘not normal’ comment on top, your mum clearly can’t cope with looking after them please don’t ever ask her to again.

Swipe left for the next trending thread