Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so upset - ‘incident’ at nursery

195 replies

Redskiesatnight · 08/04/2022 20:01

DD is 2, nearly 3. Today when collecting her at nursery I was told she had been violent to another child. Child 1 was lying down on the floor, DD and child 2 went over and tried to hold them down so they couldn’t get up. When they tried to get up, DD and child 2 started hitting them until nursery staff intervened.

I’m absolutely devastated, we have never had a bad report about her before. I was only saying this morning how kind she is - she says ‘sorry’ if she accidentally steps on your foot, pretends to feed her cuddly toys snacks etc. She’s never been violent at home. I suppose if she had hit another child in self defence or because they had snatched a toy I could understand why it happened, but it seems like she thought it was all a big joke Sad

I’ve requested to watch the footage next week, we told her off when we got home and reiterated that hitting is naughty and unkind. For the rest of the evening she’s been really upset saying ‘I hit another child’ and crying.

I guess I’m just looking for reassurance that my daughter isn’t a future bully and I haven’t failed as a mother. I can’t stop crying and I don’t really know why, I’m just shocked I think. Any wisdom gratefully received Sad

OP posts:
PrivateHall · 09/04/2022 10:54

Stop feeling bad, chalk it up to experience. You sound like a lovely mum, nursery will know this and won't be 'judging' you or dd. You are ok, try and enjoy a lovely weekend with dd Flowers

cherryonthecakes · 09/04/2022 10:49

@PinkSyCo

If they were all 2 years old?

Yeah.

They push, snatch, bite, struggle to share or take turns, tantrum, cry, do insane things because, you know, they're very, very small children.

It happens. They will grow out of it.

OP’s DD is almost 3. I am not being pedantic, but there is a huge difference developmentally between a just turned 2 year old and a 3 year old. But yes toddlers do do all of those things you listed (apart from not usually the biting) but they don’t generally gang up on another child for absolutely no reason. I am not saying at all that her DD won’t grow out of it but it needs to be addressed.

You can't assume that they malicious intentions- "ganged up"

Pre-schooler logic doesn't make sense to adults but there could have been some weird logic there. For example, many parents "stop" a child escaping while tickling. How would a 2/3 year old know that doing that to another child at nursery isn't ok? It's not right but I can see why a pre-schooler used to play fighting and tickling at home wouldn't know not to do that at nursery.

OP- sometimes little kids do naughty things. Their brains aren't developed enough to control impulses and they don't have the ability to empathize so wouldn't be able to explain why home and nurseries would have rules like kind hands.

Your daughter is the same daughter that you've always thought she was and this probably isn't the last time that she'll do something impulsive and not consider consequences. If she was school age and doing this then I'd be worried but this is an age where it's normal to be working on emotions.

Her behaviour yesterday doesn't mean that she's destined to be a bully. My kids did things like bite, hit etc but by the time that they went to Reception, all of that stopped and they could use words or actions like getting adult involvement to deal with things.

A small point- kids don't feel remorse until much older. If she says sorry for accidentally stepping on toes then it's because she's picked it up as a thing to say. She probably didn't remember the incident earlier in the day so next time there's no need to bring it up again with her. She's upset that she's been told off but needs telling off at the time for things to be most effective. Keep on praising her kindness though- carrot definitely works better than stick.

CaptainMyCaptain · 09/04/2022 10:01

@TheNameOfTheRoses

She is a toddler. I wouldn’t be using words such as ‘nasty’ to describe either the child or the child’s behaviour.

I would also have expected the staff ti have intervened before when the two dcs were on the top of the child on the floor. Verbally should have been enough.

It probably took seconds. Staff might have been sitting with other children and got there as fast as they could.. 'Nasty' isn't a great word to use but she was probably upset by the incident too.
NuffSaidSam · 09/04/2022 09:57

@PinkSyCo

If they were all 2 years old?

Yeah.

They push, snatch, bite, struggle to share or take turns, tantrum, cry, do insane things because, you know, they're very, very small children.

It happens. They will grow out of it.

OP’s DD is almost 3. I am not being pedantic, but there is a huge difference developmentally between a just turned 2 year old and a 3 year old. But yes toddlers do do all of those things you listed (apart from not usually the biting) but they don’t generally gang up on another child for absolutely no reason. I am not saying at all that her DD won’t grow out of it but it needs to be addressed.

All of those behaviours are developmentally normal through the pre-school years, including in nearly/just turned 3 year olds.

Biting is also a normal behaviour. You can see that from how many people's children have been bitten or have bitten someone.

They didn't 'gang up' on the other child. And it wouldn't have been for no reason (see child logic). As the OP said, she thought it was a big joke. They probably just both thought sitting on someone would be funny! Kids do like to climb/sit on adults for a laugh don't they? Lots of kids will play rough and tumble and sit/climb on each other. You're looking at it from the perspective of an adult, not a small child.

Obviously, she needed to be told it's not ok and why. And she has been. By nursery. And at home. That's sufficient.

NuffSaidSam · 09/04/2022 09:51

@PinkSyCo

My daughter has also been hit/bitten at nursery previously so I do know how it feels.

I’m not having a pop at you OP, because you do sound genuinely concerned about your DD’s behaviour and are obviously trying hard to teach her right from wrong. As a mum of 5 though, unless I was exceptionally lucky, don’t accept that all toddlers go around hitting and biting each other.

ALL toddlers don't bite/hit, but a lot of them do. It's normal behaviour for this age group.

That doesn't mean EVERYONE does it.

Like having toileting accidents, for example, it's developmentally normal at that age, but not every child will have accidents after potty training.

Not every single child is the same. That's why it's useful to look at research into child development rather than rely on anecdotes from your/your friend lives, look at the bigger picture.

Parth · 09/04/2022 09:49

Your child is at the beginning of a long journey during which she will learn to exert control over her impulses. This process takes years, and some people never manage to gain this ability fully even as adults. A toddler is right at the beginning of this process, and cannot be expected to do so successfully, as previous posters have shown by examples of the things that they did themselves at that age.

You can take this as a learning/teaching opportunity, and gently guide her as she begins the process of learning how to control her impulses. Do not expect instant results, it is something that you will probably have to go through repeatedly as a parent over the years, well into the teens and probably even into early adulthood.

PinkSyCo · 09/04/2022 09:48

If they were all 2 years old?

Yeah.

They push, snatch, bite, struggle to share or take turns, tantrum, cry, do insane things because, you know, they're very, very small children.

It happens. They will grow out of it.

OP’s DD is almost 3. I am not being pedantic, but there is a huge difference developmentally between a just turned 2 year old and a 3 year old. But yes toddlers do do all of those things you listed (apart from not usually the biting) but they don’t generally gang up on another child for absolutely no reason. I am not saying at all that her DD won’t grow out of it but it needs to be addressed.

NuffSaidSam · 09/04/2022 09:47

As I keep saying this is what shocked/upset me. I guess I thought seeing the footage would help me figure out how it reached that point (in ‘toddler’ logic if you see what I mean). If she had just given another child a whack because they took a toy there would be more sense to it. It’s the nature of what happened that upset me. It seemed very unkind for a 2 year old rather than reactionary if you see what I mean.

You've already said in your OP, she thought it was a big joke.

There's your answer. There's your toddler logic. This search for her motivation as if she's some kind of serial killer is ridiculous.

She thought it would be funny. It isn't. That's been explained to her. The end.

Mamapep · 09/04/2022 09:42

This is such a massive overreaction, calm down.

Changechangychange · 09/04/2022 09:41

And it is totally normal two year old behaviour, unfortunately 🤷‍♀️

PinkSyCo · 09/04/2022 09:40

My daughter has also been hit/bitten at nursery previously so I do know how it feels.

I’m not having a pop at you OP, because you do sound genuinely concerned about your DD’s behaviour and are obviously trying hard to teach her right from wrong. As a mum of 5 though, unless I was exceptionally lucky, don’t accept that all toddlers go around hitting and biting each other.

NuffSaidSam · 09/04/2022 09:40

@PinkSyCo

I wonder if all you posters telling OP not to worry, her DD’s behaviour is totally normal would be quite so blase about it if it were your child getting hit by two others while lying there minding their own business? Confused
If they were all 2 years old?

Yeah.

They push, snatch, bite, struggle to share or take turns, tantrum, cry, do insane things because, you know, they're very, very small children.

It happens. They will grow out of it.

Changechangychange · 09/04/2022 09:40

@PinkSyCo

I wonder if all you posters telling OP not to worry, her DD’s behaviour is totally normal would be quite so blase about it if it were your child getting hit by two others while lying there minding their own business? Confused
My child has a permanent scar on his face from a two year old clawing at him. I am obviously not happy about it (thankfully it is pretty small now but it looked terrible for the first six months). I don’t blame the two year old, or think she is a future bully though.

Neither do I think that there is any point in serious ongoing punishment in a child of that age - obviously at the time you remove them, make them apologise, fuss over the injured child, etc. But a two year old doesn’t have the cognitive ability to understand why they are still being punished days later, so you have to move on.

Redskiesatnight · 09/04/2022 09:35

@PinkSyCo

I wonder if all you posters telling OP not to worry, her DD’s behaviour is totally normal would be quite so blase about it if it were your child getting hit by two others while lying there minding their own business? Confused
My daughter has also been hit/bitten at nursery previously so I do know how it feels.
OP posts:
Changechangychange · 09/04/2022 09:35

DS was a biter between 18-36 months, still has a small scar on his face where some child clawed him when he was 2, and used to regularly thump me for amusement as a toddler (literally, he wasn’t doing it in anger, he just found it hilarious).

Now an extremely gentle and sensitive, shy five year old. Two year olds lash out physically for all kinds of reasons that make no sense to adults.

ludocris · 09/04/2022 09:34

@PinkSyCo

I wonder if all you posters telling OP not to worry, her DD’s behaviour is totally normal would be quite so blase about it if it were your child getting hit by two others while lying there minding their own business? Confused
People are saying her behaviour is fairly standard and that with the right guidance she'll learn that it's not acceptable, not that her behaviour is perfectly fine and sod the poor child on the receiving end....
worriedatthistime · 09/04/2022 09:28

@PinkSyCo no they wouldn't
I can't believe how many people wouldn't reiterate to their child that hitting is not ok either and would just leave it, the child is nearly 3
I would def of discussed it at that age when we got home as mine would of fully understood , so a quick , we don't hit and its not nice would of been said
Mine haven't grown up to worry about life they are now 18 & 16 but always knew if they were badly behaved at school etc sometimes a punishment may follow at home , so we backed up that bad behaviour is not acceptable

Inmyonesie · 09/04/2022 09:27

When my child was in reception they bit their friend in the face! I was shocked! They are now the kindest, most gentle 10yr old.

PinkSyCo · 09/04/2022 09:24

I wonder if all you posters telling OP not to worry, her DD’s behaviour is totally normal would be quite so blase about it if it were your child getting hit by two others while lying there minding their own business? Confused

worriedatthistime · 09/04/2022 09:20

I would of told mine off at home as well at nearly 3 , they do understand so saying ifs not ok to hit is fine which is all the OP seems to off done

ludocris · 09/04/2022 09:13

@CoffeeDay

OP I've been having the same problem since DD started preschool and was in pieces the past few weeks. Reading this thread made me feel much, much better. She never hits or bites at home but started doing that every day. I can only presume that due to the pandemic she's not used to being in a room with so many children and gets overwhelmed too quickly. Even though the staff were kind about it, it made me feel like a huge failure and I felt exactly like you. Here are some things I did at home or realisations that I had regarding the whole situation:
  • I've always been a people pleaser and was also shy and conforming as a child. Seeing my daughter cause issues is triggering because I know I can't control her behaviour and that makes it impossible for me to make everyone like me/us.
  • Children only develop empathy around age 4 where they understand that hitting hurts someone else. 2-3 is the wild west so you can only tell them rules like "We don't hit".
  • What worked well was promising a reward if she didn't hit anyone. If she requests anything during the week, I'll tell her we can do that if she plays nicely and doesn't hit anyone. If she managed a week of good behaviour then she'll get the reward with a positive reminder it's because she was well-behaved at nursery. These are not big things, but something like a bath bomb or one of those magazines that come with a toy.
  • I didn't tell her off but do remind her throughout the day that hitting isn't ok. It's possible that she might have seen something in a children's video where "battling" was part of the storyline. If I happen to notice something like that in a book or cartoon then I tell her it's only fine for stories, and not ok in real like.
  • I also put emphasis on the importance of friends. The idea being if she hits people then they won't want her being her friend. So I talk to her about her birthday party or attending other peoples parties and how much fun that will be if she does her best to make friends.

Everyone else including DH tells me to just laugh it off but it's still mortifying to do the pick-up from nursery every day not knowing what might have happened that day. However this thread makes me realised that all these kids turn out just fine in the end!

I could literally have written your post about my DS. In the last few weeks in particular we've had more reports of pushing children/throwing toys than we've had of being good. But the last couple of days this week were much better. I don't know whether it's because we've spoken to him a lot about it, whether it's down to incentivisation (no iPad/treat if you're unkind today), or whether it's just been a phase. The short and long of it is, it does make you feel sad and worried when your child misbehaves. However, I think if they can have good days it indicates they're not fundamentally unable to control themselves, they just need constant guidance and boundaries until they learn these things for themselves.
CoffeeDay · 09/04/2022 08:42

OP I've been having the same problem since DD started preschool and was in pieces the past few weeks. Reading this thread made me feel much, much better. She never hits or bites at home but started doing that every day. I can only presume that due to the pandemic she's not used to being in a room with so many children and gets overwhelmed too quickly. Even though the staff were kind about it, it made me feel like a huge failure and I felt exactly like you. Here are some things I did at home or realisations that I had regarding the whole situation:

  • I've always been a people pleaser and was also shy and conforming as a child. Seeing my daughter cause issues is triggering because I know I can't control her behaviour and that makes it impossible for me to make everyone like me/us.
  • Children only develop empathy around age 4 where they understand that hitting hurts someone else. 2-3 is the wild west so you can only tell them rules like "We don't hit".
  • What worked well was promising a reward if she didn't hit anyone. If she requests anything during the week, I'll tell her we can do that if she plays nicely and doesn't hit anyone. If she managed a week of good behaviour then she'll get the reward with a positive reminder it's because she was well-behaved at nursery. These are not big things, but something like a bath bomb or one of those magazines that come with a toy.
  • I didn't tell her off but do remind her throughout the day that hitting isn't ok. It's possible that she might have seen something in a children's video where "battling" was part of the storyline. If I happen to notice something like that in a book or cartoon then I tell her it's only fine for stories, and not ok in real like.
  • I also put emphasis on the importance of friends. The idea being if she hits people then they won't want her being her friend. So I talk to her about her birthday party or attending other peoples parties and how much fun that will be if she does her best to make friends.

Everyone else including DH tells me to just laugh it off but it's still mortifying to do the pick-up from nursery every day not knowing what might have happened that day. However this thread makes me realised that all these kids turn out just fine in the end!

Redskiesatnight · 09/04/2022 08:21

Do 2 year old really go together planning to stop another child getting up and then start hitting them? It sounds like the bad behaviour of a much older child and wonder if you have been given the correct information about what actually happened?

Her speech is nowhere near good enough to say ‘hey, let’s go hold that child down and hit them if they try to get up’. I suppose she could have copied the other child, or they her. But it all sounds really strange for their age.

Just now she dropped a cardboard book box which caught my nose on the way down. She just said ‘sorry mummy’ and stroked it. Now she’s shouting for daddy because ‘mummy hurt face’ Sad

OP posts:
Redskiesatnight · 09/04/2022 08:15

@Huevosrotos

I think you were right to tell her off at home. As described, there was a nasty and scheming element to the incident which does go beyond normal naughtiness and your DD is old enough to understand it's wrong. Although I struggle with the description of what happened. Do 2 year old really go together planning to stop another child getting up and then start hitting them? It sounds like the bad behaviour of a much older child and wonder if you have been given the correct information about what actually happened?
As I keep saying this is what shocked/upset me. I guess I thought seeing the footage would help me figure out how it reached that point (in ‘toddler’ logic if you see what I mean). If she had just given another child a whack because they took a toy there would be more sense to it. It’s the nature of what happened that upset me. It seemed very unkind for a 2 year old rather than reactionary if you see what I mean.
OP posts:
queenMab99 · 09/04/2022 08:05

My grand daughter hit another child with a toy frying pan in the home corner at nursery, because 'she wouldn't do as she was told' her mother was mortified as she had never been smacked at home, she was nearly 4 at the time and was quite bossy. She is now 15 and not a psychopath.

Swipe left for the next trending thread