Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse use of personal mobile for work

211 replies

Petal12 · 08/04/2022 16:25

Hi all, work are intending on introducing multi factor authentication soon. To enter our system we will now need to verify this by authorising on an app we have been told is to be installed on our personal mobile phones. I used to believe in give and take but the last few years have shown the feeling is not mutual and you are simply a number to be used for as long as useful. I like to think I’m not a petty person but can’t get past this. My main bug bear is that I’ve not been asked, just told! Few other points so as not to drip feed

  • Not allowed to log personal devices into the
work WiFi. Why should I use my paid for data to facilitate this? No matter how little it may use. If they do allow me to use the work WiFi, does that mean the internet policy applies when using my phone in breaks i.e I can’t use any number of sites they deem inappropriate?
  • My iphone is quite old and has storage issues every week. I would have to delete other apps that I actually use to allow this google authenticator to download.
  • It’s another point of them being cheap and cutting corners.
  • What if I lose/break my phone?
I’m sure there’s probably security issues that I’ve likely not thought of as well. AIBU?
OP posts:
FredtheCatsMum · 09/04/2022 05:20

@Calandor Noone can read your texts if you use your phone for MFA. You're a slave to your ignorance, as well as rude. If you worked in my organisation I would have explained how it works, and offered you a separate device if you still didn't want to do it. As I said, but no, you tell me to f* off.

So I most certainly wouldn't give you a phone.

ThinWomansBrain · 09/04/2022 05:13

@Calandor

Nudes* not buses
I was confused by the buses Grin You clearly have a very proper prudish autocorrect
ThinWomansBrain · 09/04/2022 05:09

Have used my own phone for MFA in the past, and in my current role for calls. Would rather that than the faff of carrying and remembering to charge two phones TBH. Actually the first role with the MFA I had a work iPhone.
But had a heated discussion with a trustee recently who thought it was acceptable to insist that all staff use their own phones. Errr- client facing staff running help and advice lines, befriending and dementia services - not bloody likely - twat.

Agree that there should be some reciprocity - not allowing you to use work wifi seems petty, unless there are security issues.

Longdistance · 09/04/2022 04:44

Yanbu.
My work somehow thinks it’s acceptable for me to login to work emails from my own phone. I refuse to as I don’t want to respond to emails using my personal phone. If they want me to do that, they can give me a work mobile, which will never happen.

Calandor · 09/04/2022 04:39

@FredtheCatsMum and honestly how dare you. We are employees. Not slaves.

Calandor · 09/04/2022 04:36

Nudes* not buses

Calandor · 09/04/2022 04:35

@FredtheCatsMum

I have just rolled this out at my job (I'm Director of Technology). Most people used their own phones. Those who wouldn't/ couldn't were give a small device which generates a code. They cost about £15, so worth it.

Some people had good reasons, and I respect that. Others were just being arsy, but frankly life's to short, and getting mfa out there too important to worry about that for £15. Using, and keeping, one is more of a nuisance than using your phone for most people.

Just got everyone who wanted one a token and got on with it. No way would I provide a phone for this reason tho. Far too expensive and open to abuse.

It's wrong! I don't want work to have access to monitor my texts, photos or even buses (not that I do those). It's a breach of privacy and can fuck off.

Seriously who are you to have access to my private life? Provide work phones if you want that or pay me an extra £10k a year.

Good god.

Ponderingwindow · 09/04/2022 04:25

We were given multiple options and are ideally supposed to have at least 2 methods available. I’m fine with my personal mobile being the emergency backup, but I wouldn’t want to use it as my regular log in device. I even have unlimited data and a top of the line smartphone and I still don’t want it to be my first method. I work hard to keep my personal mobile as isolated from work as possible because it’s better for work-life balance. Most coworkers respect that.

I have a device I insert in my computer. The phone is just if that is lost or broken and just temporary while they get me a replacement and I know they keep extras in stock.

FredtheCatsMum · 09/04/2022 03:43

I have just rolled this out at my job (I'm Director of Technology). Most people used their own phones. Those who wouldn't/ couldn't were give a small device which generates a code. They cost about £15, so worth it.

Some people had good reasons, and I respect that. Others were just being arsy, but frankly life's to short, and getting mfa out there too important to worry about that for £15. Using, and keeping, one is more of a nuisance than using your phone for most people.

Just got everyone who wanted one a token and got on with it. No way would I provide a phone for this reason tho. Far too expensive and open to abuse.

Calandor · 09/04/2022 03:43

Yeah it does my head in too. So I log into work emails on Safari every time. I don't allow monitoring. It's not like I take buses or anything but I'd like the choice.

I'd ask if they're willing to provide a work mobile. If they want control it shouldn't be over your personal phone. Mine refused this so I warned them I wouldn't be available outside work hours.

littledrummergirl · 09/04/2022 02:25

Yanbu.
An employer is paying for your time. If they want you to use equipment then they should provide it.
Otherwise you should be able to claim any expenses back.

I would love to know what would happen in an employment tribunal if you were on minimum wage but then had to deduct expenses from this. Could that put an employer in breach of minimum wage laws?

Sarahzb · 09/04/2022 01:42

OKTA just takes the time to log in. No drama

ImInStealthMode · 08/04/2022 23:25

Or your partner pays for your phone and has said "no" to installing this App

If one of my team told me that their partner was controlling them to this extent I'd be talking to HR for completely different reasons. Wow.

cakeorwine · 08/04/2022 22:59

How do you normally access your systems?

If you mainly work from home, then it should be possible to get a call to your home phone.

If you are at work, then you can get it to ring your desktop phone.

It doesn't always have to be Microsoft Authenticator you use. I suppose it's how your IT team feel about the level of MFA they need.

TheRealityCheque · 08/04/2022 22:12

[quote Petal12]@NorthSouthcatlady how are you pushing back? Unfortunately, I’m in a very male dominated company and the few women who actually stand up to stuff usually get the eye roll and a reputation as trouble makers - I’ve literally just got over the part timers holiday allowance argument whereby a male manager decided part timers got op much![/quote]
Tell them you don't own a mobile phone.

You have a family one that sometimes you have and sometimes your partner does so can't guarantee you'd have one when you need it.

Or your partner pays for your phone and has said "no" to installing this App.

Or just that you don't have storage space.

They have no right to insist. If they want you to use this technology (which is great, TBF) they need to facilitate it.

Geezabreak82 · 08/04/2022 22:04

My work introduced this recently and I was a bit annoyed because it’s not easy to get them to give you a work phone, regardless of what level you work at (big charity employer). My biggest issue with it is that I don’t use my personal phone for work at all, so I’m not in the habit of making sure I have it with me when I sit down to work. I’ve had to run to find it a number of times recently when my computer has decided to do a 2FA check unexpectedly when I’m due to join a meeting. We use the Microsoft system and I’ve had to download an app onto my phone. You can get a text message or even a phone call with the code though so if it’s the Microsoft system it could be set up to ring your desk phone with the code.

Petal12 · 08/04/2022 22:03

Yes it is give and take and I give a lot but never seem to get much in return - I often end up feeling a bit of a mug in all honesty. I love my job but am rapidly growing to dislike the people in charge and the way they’re going about things - the pandemic, their reaction to it and how they treat their very loyal staff has been a real eye opener in the last 2 years or so. I am already looking for another job.

OP posts:
ImInStealthMode · 08/04/2022 21:54

I agree with you completely @Baystard. I'm a manager now but I wasn't for the first 12 years with my employer. They're not perfect, but there's give and there's take.

I cant imagine spending 30 or 40 hours a week working for an organisation I resented and begrudged so completely. What a waste of life.

SergeiL · 08/04/2022 21:53

@Baystard has it right. Give and take. Feels like a small thing to give to me.

Baystard · 08/04/2022 21:37

I'm a manager.

If a member of staff said "I'm sorry but my phone is elderly and already overloaded / not a smartphone" I'd be onto IT to get a solution in a shot.

If they were obviously lying, or just refused out of awkwardness, I'd be disappointed in the attitude and assume they really disliked our organisation.

OP it's about give and take. Do you never make a quick/infrequent personal call on work time? Do they dock your wages if you're 5 minutes late the day you get stuck in traffic? Do you have a work biro in your handbag?

If it's genuinely because your phone isn't capable then fair enough.

If it's because you won't give your employer an inch, and would rather they incur a not insignificant expense rather than doing something which costs you nothing, then I think you should start looking for a new job.

Pixiedust1234 · 08/04/2022 21:26

You can tell who are the managers and who are the lowly employees on this thread. The "leave if you hate that job" brigade think the op is being petty...

Wasn't there something that kicked off in the beginning of covid where employers had to pay for laptops, desks and chairs if they expected their employees to wfh as it wasn't right for them to expect their staff to use their personal items?

Don't let them push you into deleting your own apps to accommodate theirs...cfs!

Phormiumjester2 · 08/04/2022 21:25

It just sounds petty & pointlessly militant to me.

jgw1 · 08/04/2022 21:15

@247SylviaPlath

* I think a lot of the posters don’t understand what this app will be. It’s a ‘token’ on your phone, you type in a chosen passcode and they give you a code in return. This code is entered into your laptop to prove it is you that is logging in.

Nobody is accessing your phone, no data is transferred, nobody is having to work from their phone. It is literally a case of typing a passcode and getting given a verification code in return.

The whole idea of pushing back on this is beyond petty - it’s actually embarrassing for the OP (people would definitely be laughing at you for this)*

Exactly this. The level of vehemence people feel towards their employers makes me wonder why they still work there. MFA is to increase security in a time of unprecedented attacks. Given most of the cyber risk in an organisation will be around its staff (someone clicking on the wrong link) it’s not unreasonable to ask staff to support measures which will increase cyber security.

The sheer pettiness of some of the responses on here are unreal. For those of you who hate your employers that much to get your knickers in a twist about stuff like this, go and do something else ffs, life is much much too short. Alternatives for those without smart phones will be offered, but for most people, it should be no issue at all.

Hmm

And if my employer wants to increase security they can pay for a phone to do so, if it is that important to them.
247SylviaPlath · 08/04/2022 21:13
  • I think a lot of the posters don’t understand what this app will be. It’s a ‘token’ on your phone, you type in a chosen passcode and they give you a code in return. This code is entered into your laptop to prove it is you that is logging in.

Nobody is accessing your phone, no data is transferred, nobody is having to work from their phone. It is literally a case of typing a passcode and getting given a verification code in return.

The whole idea of pushing back on this is beyond petty - it’s actually embarrassing for the OP (people would definitely be laughing at you for this)*

Exactly this. The level of vehemence people feel towards their employers makes me wonder why they still work there. MFA is to increase security in a time of unprecedented attacks. Given most of the cyber risk in an organisation will be around its staff (someone clicking on the wrong link) it’s not unreasonable to ask staff to support measures which will increase cyber security.

The sheer pettiness of some of the responses on here are unreal. For those of you who hate your employers that much to get your knickers in a twist about stuff like this, go and do something else ffs, life is much much too short. Alternatives for those without smart phones will be offered, but for most people, it should be no issue at all.

Hmm
Tiredmamaaa · 08/04/2022 21:06

@Womencanlift

We have this and use it to log in, both in morning and if we lock our system during the day. Takes 2 seconds each time.

I am someone who is absolutely against having emails on my personal phone as agree on the separation between work and home but an app that takes less than a minute a day, I can’t get worked up about that

I’m the exact same and totally agree.

It really takes 2 seconds each day, would use little to no data and means you don’t need to use any negative energy to fight something that isn’t worth the fight. I’d say choose your battles if your company are terrible. This wouldn’t be one worth arguing over in my opinion.