Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse use of personal mobile for work

211 replies

Petal12 · 08/04/2022 16:25

Hi all, work are intending on introducing multi factor authentication soon. To enter our system we will now need to verify this by authorising on an app we have been told is to be installed on our personal mobile phones. I used to believe in give and take but the last few years have shown the feeling is not mutual and you are simply a number to be used for as long as useful. I like to think I’m not a petty person but can’t get past this. My main bug bear is that I’ve not been asked, just told! Few other points so as not to drip feed

  • Not allowed to log personal devices into the
work WiFi. Why should I use my paid for data to facilitate this? No matter how little it may use. If they do allow me to use the work WiFi, does that mean the internet policy applies when using my phone in breaks i.e I can’t use any number of sites they deem inappropriate?
  • My iphone is quite old and has storage issues every week. I would have to delete other apps that I actually use to allow this google authenticator to download.
  • It’s another point of them being cheap and cutting corners.
  • What if I lose/break my phone?
I’m sure there’s probably security issues that I’ve likely not thought of as well. AIBU?
OP posts:
DGRossetti · 09/04/2022 10:30

Can I ask if you have any idea why it doesn't work on my Apple Watch? I get the alert but then get a connection error when I click on the alert.

My first thought would be making sure that the watch has the correct synchronised time. A few ms difference counts.

Then I'd check the certificate chain to make sure the watch can be trusted.

That's assuming that Apples security infrastructure allow the watch to provide the key.

BambinaJAS · 09/04/2022 10:30

Your phone should have two profiles:

  1. Personal

All of your own apps and data stored here.

  1. Work

This part of the phone would be encrypted and also only have access to apps that were safe from a company perspective.

Its actually fairly straightforward. I use my fingerprint to access my work emails and intranet via my phone.

cakeorwine · 09/04/2022 10:30

They wouldn't like it as, it would then mean fewer of them would be employed to fix the problems that using Microsoft routinely seems to create

It's not Microsoft who create my IT problems at work.

cakeorwine · 09/04/2022 10:29

That would have the added bonus of not being expected to work at times when one was not at work. Why shouldn't every employee be given such a generous offer

I could easily restrict that on people. Access between certain times of day.
Access only in the work place
Access from certain IP addresses.

Monitoring logins from out of hours.

It does amaze me the times some people logon to the system.

jgw1 · 09/04/2022 10:28

@cakeorwine

In which case perhaps the solution is to not use Microsoft accounts that can be accessed so easily

Try telling that to your IT department.

They wouldn't like it as, it would then mean fewer of them would be employed to fix the problems that using Microsoft routinely seems to create.
cakeorwine · 09/04/2022 10:27

In which case perhaps the solution is to not use Microsoft accounts that can be accessed so easily

Or restrict logins from only the work IP address.
Or just from work devices that are registered on Azure directory.

jgw1 · 09/04/2022 10:27

*So in your case, I would restrict your login to the work device you use.

This would mean that anyone who used your login details from elsewhere would be blocked.

Job done

No need for MFA, No need for a phone*

That would have the added bonus of not being expected to work at times when one was not at work. Why shouldn't every employee be given such a generous offer?

cakeorwine · 09/04/2022 10:25

In which case perhaps the solution is to not use Microsoft accounts that can be accessed so easily

Try telling that to your IT department.

cakeorwine · 09/04/2022 10:25

@jgw1

You seriously think it’s reasonable to supply a phone for an app that spits out a code over 90 seconds or you click approve to log yourself in. We used to have dongles at work but they are tiny and a pain in the arse to keep.

If my employer wanted me to make widgets at work or at home, then of course the first thing one would ask for would be a widget making machine.
If my employer wanted me to use a phone for work, then it is only logically that they would supply a phone. If they don't deem it important enough to supply a phone then that is their choice.

So in your case, I would restrict your login to the work device you use.

This would mean that anyone who used your login details from elsewhere would be blocked.

Job done

No need for MFA, No need for a phone

etulosba · 09/04/2022 10:24

Were, not we’re.

jgw1 · 09/04/2022 10:23

@cakeorwine

I don't think some people understand how potentially easy it is to access a Microsoft account.

In theory, you just need an email and a password.
And the internet.

So the job of IT is to ensure that the person accessing it is the person who they say they are and then to ensure that they are only able to access the right things they need.

There are plenty of ways to make it as difficult as possible for someone who can't use MFA to ensure that the person who claims to be them accessing the system is the person.

If you can't / won't use MFA, then IT need to know that the device they are accessing it with or the location they are accessing it from is authorised to access it.

In which case perhaps the solution is to not use Microsoft accounts that can be accessed so easily?
etulosba · 09/04/2022 10:23

Personally, if people couldn't supply such information, then they should probably have to be office based so they could supply a desktop phone

No need to be office based. Calls to my work phone we’re forwarded to my desktop or laptop wherever I was.

jgw1 · 09/04/2022 10:22

You seriously think it’s reasonable to supply a phone for an app that spits out a code over 90 seconds or you click approve to log yourself in. We used to have dongles at work but they are tiny and a pain in the arse to keep.

If my employer wanted me to make widgets at work or at home, then of course the first thing one would ask for would be a widget making machine.
If my employer wanted me to use a phone for work, then it is only logically that they would supply a phone. If they don't deem it important enough to supply a phone then that is their choice.

cakeorwine · 09/04/2022 10:21

I don't think some people understand how potentially easy it is to access a Microsoft account.

In theory, you just need an email and a password.
And the internet.

So the job of IT is to ensure that the person accessing it is the person who they say they are and then to ensure that they are only able to access the right things they need.

There are plenty of ways to make it as difficult as possible for someone who can't use MFA to ensure that the person who claims to be them accessing the system is the person.

If you can't / won't use MFA, then IT need to know that the device they are accessing it with or the location they are accessing it from is authorised to access it.

etulosba · 09/04/2022 10:18

Why would anyone use their own home laptop for work?

Using your own means that you have full control of it.

Testingprof · 09/04/2022 10:17

@jgw1

What do you think a company should do to implement MFA to people who were reluctant to either use or supply a phone number?

If an employer requires employees to use a phone then they should supply the phone. It really is not complicated.

You seriously think it’s reasonable to supply a phone for an app that spits out a code over 90 seconds or you click approve to log yourself in. We used to have dongles at work but they are tiny and a pain in the arse to keep.

@Bonbon21 the OPs doesn’t take her security/privacy seriously if she’s walking around with an old iPhone that has storage issues as it’s very likely she doesn’t have the latest security patches on her device. If you have a similar issue paying mcafee isn’t taking your security/privacy seriously at all. I don’t pay for their service as they don’t protect macs and id wouldn’t be kicking up a stink about this app as it’s already installed on my phone as I do take my security seriously and having MFA active on your accounts (personal) is an absolute must for security purposes. Look at the WhatsApp’s hijack attack and what protects you from easily falling foul to it.

cakeorwine · 09/04/2022 10:15

Why would anyone use their own home laptop for work

There are times people might want to be at home and access their work emails or folders.

It's possible with Microsoft to do that.

You could be anywhere in the world and as long as you can access the internet, you can logon and access your account.

That's why extra layers of security are needed - as in theory, anyone anywhere can logon to the internet, type in your email and password - and access the system.

jgw1 · 09/04/2022 10:11

@cakeorwine

Why should the "massive overhead" of providing mobile phones be paid for by employees

Where do you think money comes from in a company?
The magic money tree?

Personally, if you were my employee, I would take you out of automatic MFA and then ask you to register the device you accessed the system with.

I would also implement extra security on your login so we would look for suspicious activity.

As far as I can tell you are saying that employees should subsidise businesses so that the bosses can continue to make far more money than they need. Am I correct?
jgw1 · 09/04/2022 10:10

@cakeorwine

Personally, if people couldn't supply such information, then they should probably have to be office based so they could supply a desktop phone.

If you wanted to WFH, then you should be able to follow a WFH policy which should include an ability to authenticate remotely using either your mobile phone or a landline.

Alternatively, you could take people out of automatic MFA and then implement a policy that in such cases, people had to register the device they access with was ok.

Then they could login with that device which would be ok. However, if that's what you wanted to do, then you would have to tell IT if it got lost so they could remove access.

In other words, they would know that if you logged in a home laptop, then that's ok. But if your laptop got stolen, you would have to tell IT.

Why would anyone use their own home laptop for work? If one needs a laptop for work surely work should supply it and set it up appropriately?
cakeorwine · 09/04/2022 10:05

Why should the "massive overhead" of providing mobile phones be paid for by employees

Where do you think money comes from in a company?
The magic money tree?

Personally, if you were my employee, I would take you out of automatic MFA and then ask you to register the device you accessed the system with.

I would also implement extra security on your login so we would look for suspicious activity.

Madickenxx · 09/04/2022 10:03

Depending on the type, your company may well have a backup option to use in case the app goes down. We use dongles for business continuity purposes. This is not widely advertised as more expensive but an option for those who don't have a smartphone or who refuses to use a personal device.

Personally it's not a battle I chose to pick but each to their own.

cakeorwine · 09/04/2022 10:02

Personally, if people couldn't supply such information, then they should probably have to be office based so they could supply a desktop phone.

If you wanted to WFH, then you should be able to follow a WFH policy which should include an ability to authenticate remotely using either your mobile phone or a landline.

Alternatively, you could take people out of automatic MFA and then implement a policy that in such cases, people had to register the device they access with was ok.

Then they could login with that device which would be ok. However, if that's what you wanted to do, then you would have to tell IT if it got lost so they could remove access.

In other words, they would know that if you logged in a home laptop, then that's ok. But if your laptop got stolen, you would have to tell IT.

jgw1 · 09/04/2022 10:01

*So supply a work mobile just so you can receive a code or a text message?

Which services or employees would you sack or which costs to your customers would you increase to pay for these massive overheads?*

If my employer deems it necessary for me to receive a code or text message then they need to ensure that they supply the equipment for that to happen.

Why should the "massive overhead" of providing mobile phones be paid for by employees?

Bonbon21 · 09/04/2022 09:59

@cakeorwine*...*@littledrummergirl has said it all for me.

cakeorwine · 09/04/2022 09:56

@jgw1

What do you think a company should do to implement MFA to people who were reluctant to either use or supply a phone number?

If an employer requires employees to use a phone then they should supply the phone. It really is not complicated.

So supply a work mobile just so you can receive a code or a text message?

Which services or employees would you sack or which costs to your customers would you increase to pay for these massive overheads?