Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse use of personal mobile for work

211 replies

Petal12 · 08/04/2022 16:25

Hi all, work are intending on introducing multi factor authentication soon. To enter our system we will now need to verify this by authorising on an app we have been told is to be installed on our personal mobile phones. I used to believe in give and take but the last few years have shown the feeling is not mutual and you are simply a number to be used for as long as useful. I like to think I’m not a petty person but can’t get past this. My main bug bear is that I’ve not been asked, just told! Few other points so as not to drip feed

  • Not allowed to log personal devices into the
work WiFi. Why should I use my paid for data to facilitate this? No matter how little it may use. If they do allow me to use the work WiFi, does that mean the internet policy applies when using my phone in breaks i.e I can’t use any number of sites they deem inappropriate?
  • My iphone is quite old and has storage issues every week. I would have to delete other apps that I actually use to allow this google authenticator to download.
  • It’s another point of them being cheap and cutting corners.
  • What if I lose/break my phone?
I’m sure there’s probably security issues that I’ve likely not thought of as well. AIBU?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DGRossetti · 11/04/2022 12:05

but I think the whole idea very badly thought out.

Well, yes. But don't just blame IT for that ....

SucculentChalice · 11/04/2022 11:08

I had this with some lecturing I do at a university part time. They wanted me (and all lecturers) to download an app on my phone to take the student attendance register. Its clearly a huge potential breach of data protection laws and has obvious risks if the phone is stolen or hacked. But even more mundanely, I bought a new phone which proved to be faulty and had to return it recently. I deleted all information on it but I don't know how easy it is to retrieve it if a person were so intended, particularly if its sold onto a third party as a reconditioned phone.

I didn't actually download the app and its caused mild disaproval and more work (unpaid) on my part, but I think the whole idea very badly thought out.

Whatalovelydaffodil · 09/04/2022 19:38

@SergeiL

Goodness me! Yes let’s all carry two phones - two phones that will stay in the world forever - because we refuse to install an app!

I was told I had to get a work mobile and I refused. I don’t want to carry two phones and I am plenty grown up enough to separate work and home.

Perhaps they could think of a different way that doesn't involve a phone at all!
PinkSparklyPussyCat · 09/04/2022 19:34

Thanks @cakeorwine and @DGRossetti. If work ever go down that route (and I don't think they will), I would be expecting a contribution towards my mobile bill.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 09/04/2022 18:42

So they’ve offered an alternative and you’re still not happy? Am I missing something?

KatieB55 · 09/04/2022 17:59

Our work do this too and I also have a number generating app for other software. No office phone or alternative offered.

DGRossetti · 09/04/2022 17:54

Can that be disabled so clients can't contact you outside of office hours? I remember a few years ago a customer asking for my mobile number and getting the arse when I said

I can't speak for all systems. 3cx (last one I fully administered) was pretty comprehensive. You could set OOH, diverts, hunt groups, pickup groups, custom messages for different times as well as plumb it into landline numbers for geographical convenience.

cakeorwine · 09/04/2022 17:07

@PinkSparklyPussyCat

There's a middle ground where you can install the voip softphone onto a personal phone so people can call you without needing your personal number.

Can that be disabled so clients can't contact you outside of office hours? I remember a few years ago a customer asking for my mobile number and getting the arse when I said

We were told to forward our desk phones to our mobiles when lockdown started. A lot of people did, but I wouldn't as I thought it was a cheek as it meant I'd have to turn my phone down from 5pm. Customers can email me and if it's important enough we can have a Teams call, if not they can wait.

You can put it on Do Not Disturb - sometime you can set it to only be available during office hours.

Few people at work have my mobile number. That's for absolute emergencies.

But they can contact me via VOIP

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 09/04/2022 17:02

There's a middle ground where you can install the voip softphone onto a personal phone so people can call you without needing your personal number.

Can that be disabled so clients can't contact you outside of office hours? I remember a few years ago a customer asking for my mobile number and getting the arse when I said

We were told to forward our desk phones to our mobiles when lockdown started. A lot of people did, but I wouldn't as I thought it was a cheek as it meant I'd have to turn my phone down from 5pm. Customers can email me and if it's important enough we can have a Teams call, if not they can wait.

karmakatte · 09/04/2022 16:53

Employers have no right to insist you use your personal phone for work.
That being said, the company I work for offers a 10% discount on our cell phone bills to those of us who choose to use our personal phones for work. They have no control over the use of our phones or the content we choose to access.
Perhaps, you could suggest this to the poers that be at your place of employment.

DGRossetti · 09/04/2022 16:37

There are plenty of ways to annoy users with IT policies.

Don't worry, I'm working on plenty more. Grin

cakeorwine · 09/04/2022 16:25

Same as the ludicrous change your password every hour and it has to be 40 characters long with upper, lower, number and symbols, no repeated characters, can't be a previously used one for the past 10 years and rhymes with "butter" in Sanskrit policies. Which are guaranteed to make people write them down

There are plenty of ways to annoy users with IT policies.

DGRossetti · 09/04/2022 13:54

We also have it so the code remembers you for a bit if you are logging in from a recognised device. So you don't need to enter a code everytime.

"Conditional access" - of which MFA is a single strand.

Goodsecurity should be almost unobtrusive. Getting someone to 2FA every single time is guaranteed to raise the annoyance factor (and thus non compliance) with very little increase in security.

Same as the ludicrous change your password every hour and it has to be 40 characters long with upper, lower, number and symbols, no repeated characters, can't be a previously used one for the past 10 years and rhymes with "butter" in Sanskrit policies. Which are guaranteed to make people write them down ....

LimeSegment · 09/04/2022 13:21

I'm normally all about workers rights and against companies taking advantage but this is the pettiest thing I've ever heard. But what if I don't have a phone... But you do! But what if it can't run the app... But it can! But what if it's got no room... How are you planning on using your phone normally then if that's the case?

What's next... Your work didn't supply you with a pair of undies so you go commando every day?

OneTC · 09/04/2022 11:56

My husband lays in bed moving his arm up and down to get his steps in for his watch which rewards him for doing steps. He gets a free coffee if he does 10K

Grin
cakeorwine · 09/04/2022 11:43

@RiverSkater

Just turn up at work with a dead phone and say you need to charge it to get the code to log on.
We also have it so the code remembers you for a bit if you are logging in from a recognised device. So you don't need to enter a code everytime.

It's a balance to ensure users are kept on side versus security requirements.

RiverSkater · 09/04/2022 11:38

Just turn up at work with a dead phone and say you need to charge it to get the code to log on.

ImInStealthMode · 09/04/2022 11:35

Why would anyone use their own home laptop for work?

When we had to WFH (Thank god that's over) my employer were very happy for me to take my entire 2-screen desktop set-up home with me.

Unfortunately space in my flat means it would have dominated either my lounge or bedroom, or involved set up and take down every single day. Instead I opted to use my own laptop with an employer supplied keyboard and mouse. It was much more convenient for me, and actually less so for them as the single screen meant it took me longer to do some tasks.

cakeorwine · 09/04/2022 11:35

Actually - I read that wrong. I read it as not using personal devices at work.

cakeorwine · 09/04/2022 11:33

@Anniegetyourgun

In my place of work you're not even allowed to use your own devices for work purposes.
Which probably means they don't allow remote access and have locked down the IT system so only certain devices can access the system.

So you wouldn't need to be WFH and need a way of verifying your credentials remotely.

There would be authentication methods in the location itself.

Anniegetyourgun · 09/04/2022 11:30

In my place of work you're not even allowed to use your own devices for work purposes.

Brefugee · 09/04/2022 10:39

MFA is fine, asking you to BYOD is, IMO, a step too far but i can't get too excited about it if the alternative is 100% office based work. The key, for me, is the company must ask not tell you to do this, and if you don't want to for any reason at all they need to provide an alternative.

Having said that: we all get an iPhone (i hate iPhones but that is what we get). The only people who don't get a company phone, are the interns, and they get a token and for some access they use their email as the authenticator.

cakeorwine · 09/04/2022 10:37

@DGRossetti

I do have an issue with VOIP on a personal phone.
It's just from the data perspective - when it's using mobile data.

I love the soft phones though.

Whatalovelydaffodil · 09/04/2022 10:36

Having a mobile phone is not compulsory. If you have one it's your personal possession. Nothing to do with them.

DGRossetti · 09/04/2022 10:34

(TL;DR - if I were managing this, I would ensure there was a zero-cost way for employees that have a problem with it. Especially if you worked in a role where you were not allowed a mobile device on the shop floor.)

Seems this thread has descended into a vat of deliberate ignorance, with some posters staking their position in advance of understanding the broad picture, let alone the nuances.

Generally my view is that if you are expected to make & take calls away from your desk then you should be supplied with a mobile, contract, pink fluffy case and so on.

But if you are at a desk I'd set up a voip softphone.

There's a middle ground where you can install the voip softphone onto a personal phone so people can call you without needing your personal number.

(Ideally I'd put everything through voip as all calls get recorded.)

None of which has anything to do with 2/MFA which can be delivered without a fucking phone anyway.

At a very minimum, 2FA should be mandatory for any connection made from outside the premises.

Our setup is simple login to computer, but then 2FA into any system from there. We use gSuite (or whatever it's called this week) so you get challenged logging into that, then you can use your gMail account to access further systems. In addition some systems also mandate 2FA (hence my keyring of sites on my authenticator).

In my previous role, we were processing very vulnerable peoples data under various DWP contracts. These contracts allowed the DWP to rock up anytime to conduct a data security audit. It would have been a serious breach if they found (a) employees without ID badges, and (b) employees accessing systems without MFA

Having left that, I'm under the PCI-DSS cosh (not for the first time in my career) and while they aren't quite so hot on ID badges, they are on network segregation and ensuring verified access by - guess what ? - MFA.

This is hardly the bleeding edge of security. I was using an RSA token 16 years ago.

Meanwhile, it still seems industry SOP to call me up and demand that I prove my identity to some random caller. Worse than that: some random caller who can't understand why I don't want to tell them anything