Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

As a mother would you do this? AIBU

236 replies

Swayingpalmtrees · 08/04/2022 14:33

My parents (late sixties) have been pretty much 'shielding' since March 2020 with very few exceptions. They are not CEV but feel worried about catching covid.

The exceptions however are ALWAYS to go to my brother's house, they do not visit anyone else inside (no other relatives, or their siblings etc) and have rarely been anywhere else since the pandemic started. My mother has anxiety and she is still terrified of covid (apart from to visit my brother, wife and family, who lives in C.London and uses the tube daily, small kids =high risk so not irrelevant)

My birthday fell on mothers day this year and I organised a family lunch, outside in the garden near their house at a small hotel so she would be comfortable, the weather was so nice and warm we were very lucky. My mum told me she couldn't come, cases were going up too fast she was too worried (even outside) I only made the lunch outside so she could come. It was heated, with blankets and covered just in case of rain and miles from anyone else - organised by the hotel GM. I was upset, but accepted her wishes to keep herself safe.

I have just found out she went to my brother's house the day before, inside his house for dinner with his extended family and she didn't tell me.

I am now coming to the conclusion she is using covid as an excuse not to see us: the back story is that he has always been the golden child, this was made public even when we were very young, it was a family joke it was so bad, but it is something I am used to. I didn't think she would take it this far though.

I now have no interest in organising to visit her again (this is happened more than once that she has been to see him but can't risk seeing anyone else)
Am I being unreasonable to stop bothering?

I feel I am wasting my time organising anything else in the future for her or with her. I feel a level of guilt as she tells me she is depressed and has anxiety so I worry it isn't kind to stop bothering, but it is very hurtful she can choose to 'risk' seeing my brother etc but can not 'risk' sitting outside with me on my birthday and mothers day.

It feels very deliberate.

OP posts:
Dobbyismyabsolutefav · 08/04/2022 16:21

@diddl In response to your question, I posted a longer message earlier which also applies to when a Mother leaves a child, which is my own experience.

Gladioli23 · 08/04/2022 16:20

This sounds really upsetting for you OP, I think it can be really hard when we are nice people ourselves to understand why others would be dreadful.

To remind you exactly how reasonable you're being: as I wrote this post there were 479 votes on the poll, and 100% said YANBU.

Nanny0gg · 08/04/2022 16:19

@Swayingpalmtrees

It feels like she is playing some kind of game, I can't explain it, but it feels wilful and using special family occasions to do it.

I had ordered mothers day balloons for the table and bunting, she had a huge bouquet of flowers ready and presents from my children that were handmade. I wanted to spoil her (even though it was my birthday) because I recognised the last two years have been rubbish for her. I feel so so hurt.

Do you feel you were over compensating to get her attention?

She doesn’t deserve it

Swayingpalmtrees · 08/04/2022 16:14

What feels more powerful is to give up, and say I have tried and it is a non starter. As from said so eloquently ""some questions don't need answers anymore" I have my answer don't I. I am not a priority, I wasn't as a small child and I am not now. And all the balloons, love and care in the world is not going to change it. A bitter pill to swallow.

I have been on MN for years (name change for this) and so know about the narc thing, I did look into it and suspect she is a covert introverted narcissist, she is always needing to be the poor victim. It is very hard to deal with, as she demands attention and everyone else to make up for her life, disappointment and if you don't she will turn it back on you.

I am sure she hopes I will get upset and create some kind of drama, this will just be feeding straight into her narrative that he is the better child, and she made the right decision. I am not giving her the satisfaction of being hurt or injured.

I am going to look after myself for once, and get over this and quietly shut the door. I am keeping a copy of this thread so I don't weaken in time. I don't ask anything of her, I have always been the giver in our relationship - and it stops today. I am fortunately going to Devon tomorrow and I can turn off my phone and forget about her. I don't think I will have time to ring at Easter either. Two guesses where she will be, and I would rather not know.

OP posts:
noirchatsdeux · 08/04/2022 16:14

The only way to win is to not play.

I had to do this with my mother 20 years ago...around the time her own mother died, my mother started to try with the whole 'pitting the children against each other' bollocks, involving me and my older brother. My older brother was the 'winner' I was the 'loser'...all based on how much money we made, what type of house we owned...even down to who was married/not married. Her own mother had done it all her life with her 9 children.

I refused to participate, made it clear that I was happy as I was and wasn't going to be jumping through any hoops to try and keep up with my brother. I tried keeping in touch with my brother once my mother had gone back to our home country, but it was so one sided I gave that up, too. I'm now glad both live on the other side of the world, if they were here I know my mother would favour seeing my brother over me.

There's barely a week goes by when I don't wish I had a 'normal' family dynamic...but then I just remember that I don't, I'm not going to, and for the sake of my own mental health I need to concentrate my energies on the people who actually care and are there for me.

Kennykenkencat · 08/04/2022 16:11

@Hobnobswantshernameback

I have been non contact with my mother for almost a decade after years of similar treatment op Step away It's liberating
I walked out on mine at age 21. I was made out to be a totally useless daughter who made her life a misery.

I don’t think her life improved when I left.
The problem was with her not me. She drove me away only to find the problems were still there. I just wasn’t there to be the verbal punching bag any more.

TrashyPanda · 08/04/2022 16:10

How very hurtful.
Sadly, you are never going to win.
Your brother will always be the favourite, and his children too.

All you can do is to guard your heart.
Don’t make special arrangements to see her.
And don’t feel you have to listen to her excuses, far less validate them. Just cut her short, tell her you are fed up with her behaviour, but you accept that is the way she is, so you want to move on. No point in any further discussion.

Make sure she knows how her actions hurt you and grandchildren. Every single time..

AnastasiaRomanov · 08/04/2022 16:10

I have a friend in a very similar situation but it’s her son playing games. He’s definitely using Covid as an excuse to avoid her, but will do other things that are more ‘risky’.
You mother doesn’t deserve you. I would back right off and leave her to her favourite son.

SpringsSprung · 08/04/2022 16:05

She sounds a bit like my mum. She's not gone ANYWHERE with my 7yr old daughter since she was born and is terrified of covid so that's been the excuse since March 2020. Yet whenever her friends all meet up at Wetherspoons she's there! If I dare to point out the hypocrisy, I immediately get accused of begrudging her "One little lunch in a pub with her friends she hardly sees" Confused

rookiemere · 08/04/2022 16:05

My DM also has health anxiety around Covid and I would say that some of her decisions aren't entirely rational or logical.

So we weren't allowed to visit for 10 days after we had visitors at Christmas- even though we were happy to take tests - but she was ok with us all coming up after that even though DS was back at school and in contact with far more people than our visitors who were either retired or wfh or on disability benefits and hardly ever go out.

I don't know anything about the golden child thing though as I'm an only.

Kennykenkencat · 08/04/2022 16:04

@Swayingpalmtrees

I would 100% tell her and in writing, even if just an email so you have time to think about what you want to say. Then I would step completely back from her

I have done this before, what happens is she has a total meltdown and calls everyone in the family to see how awful I am, how much I have broken her. I can't run the risk again because she weaponises any discord and uses it as justification for her actions.

'no wonder we don't want to see swaying, shes always so difficult, look at this card she sent me. So ungrateful after everything I have done for her' or words to that effect.

If I say nothing she can't call me the aggressor.

But it leaves me feeling wounded and toothless, and oddly silenced.

I think in some families people try and try to make their parents love them and they get hurt over and over.

It is great if other family members notice but ultimately you can’t change who your mother is. You can only change the response you have to her.

Any words you use will be used against you so it silences you and she knows this.

However there is a difference between silence and being silenced

It is not toothless to step away. You don’t need to say anything. Just don’t be available when she calls.
If she sends round her flying monkeys then explain that you were hurt by her choice of only seeing your brother whilst Covid is around and as Covid is going to be around for many years to come then you thought she was effectively ending your relationship
I would point out that if a table in a garden away from other people was not acceptable but indoor dining with Tube users and small children was it didn’t leave anything to be interpreted any other way.

Stride into obscurity and leave her and your brother to it.

Also be very aware if at any stage they get back in touch then it will be because they want something.

Probably to look after your mother in her twilight years.

Hobnobswantshernameback · 08/04/2022 16:03

I have been non contact with my mother for almost a decade after years of similar treatment op
Step away
It's liberating

nettie434 · 08/04/2022 16:02

If this was just about Covid, she would not be visiting your brother regularly and going into his house.

It must be so hurtful for you. From what you've said, it doesn't seem as if talking to her or writing a letter directly would help anything. I don't think you should feel guilty that she tells you that she experiences depression and anxiety. It's actually really sad that you are so used to feeling that you are treated differently to your brother that you would compromise your own sense of self esteem and self worth for a mother who has treated her children so differently.

Calennig · 08/04/2022 16:02

I were you, as sad as it is, I would cut my losses with her. Don’t go out of your way again to arrange something for her. Let her make the effort from now on. & if she never does, keep your head high and your dignity and spend time with people who actually appreciate you.

This - spend the time and engery on your DH and kids.

I'd go with bright and breezy on the phone and changing subject when she talks about her depression or be busy and have to go - possibly wait till she calls you.

You can't change how she behaves but only how you react to it - so give her less opportunity to reject and hurt you.

AntiHop · 08/04/2022 16:02

Once you go no contact, you'll go through a grieving process. Time will heal to a certain extent. You'll feel less hurt than now, as the current situation is like a wound that isn't allowed to heal.

diddl · 08/04/2022 16:01

@Dobbyismyabsolutefav

Wise words *@littleOwl153* 'Mourn the Mother you wish you had and let her go'
Yes-but what do you do with the mother that that leaves you?
MzHz · 08/04/2022 16:01

@givethatbabyaname

Tell her 🤷‍♀️

Tell her you’re hurt and wounded.

Ask her to justify why she turned down an outdoor lunch but accept and indoor dinner.

Make her say the words. And if she doesn’t, tell her that you know she can’t bring herself to say them.

Nothing will change. You just have to accept it and move on. She’s not going to change and she’s leaving you with no other choice.

Tbf, I can’t recommend this.

I asked my own mum why she felt it appropriate to move house without telling me where she was moving to etc etc

The answer “well we were never that close” came back.

Nobody needs to hear that from their mother

It’s better to take the hint from the actions. Vote with your feet and leave them to it.

In my own opinion. Tbh, it also felt important to ask the question, I just never factored on the response

I don’t think about her at all anymore. I don’t get triggered by slush fests like hallmark holidays etc, it gets easier.

Living well is the best revenge, even better if they never get to see it, only hear about it.

incognitoforthisone · 08/04/2022 16:00

Really do not feel like calling her ever again!!!

That sounds like the best option, frankly. But I appreciate that it's not that easy, though - nobody wants to feel like that about their mum. The emotions of being hurt by a parent are so much more complicated being hurt by a parent than it is being hurt by anyone else.

You don't mention your dad - is he of the same opinions on all this as your mother, or does he just go along with what she says/wants to keep the peace? Could you speak to him and ask him outright why your mother did that to you and what he thought about it? And what about your brother? Does he know what she did to you? What does he think of her behaviour in general?

I'm sorry you're going through this. You sound absolutely lovely.

FrydayFish · 08/04/2022 15:59

Unfortunately a lot of us have to accept that a lot of parents are cu*ts.
I would go NC and try and avoid repeating the pattern with your own children.
Good luck.

Nnique · 08/04/2022 15:57

OP has said this about her brother:

My brother enjoys being centre stage with Mummy, as he calls her. And loves seeing it hurt me, so I am low contact with him as result. It feels toxic and not a good place to be.

I know there’s a load of guff on MN with narcissism being diagnosed willy-nilly here, there and everywhere. But in this case, @Swayingpalmtrees, there are certainly shades of that kind of dynamic. I think it’s worth reading up a bit in case there are strategies and techniques that ring true for you and also maybe have a look on the ‘Stately Homes’ threads - you will learn a lot there about FOG (Fear, Obligation, Guilt).

It’s hard to let go of emotional responses that have been built into us from childhood and these often persist into adulthood (the need for love and the anguish when it isn’t given, the pain of not being wanted, the guilt of feeling responsible in some way for that person’s happiness when they have absolutely no regard for yours, and so on) but you can do some work to release yourself from some of that.

Flowers
CJsGoldfish · 08/04/2022 15:56

I'm so sorry OP. It's just hurtful.
I would simply withdraw. No letter, no confrontation, just be done.
She can't play games without you as a participant.
You just live your best life with your own little family who love you and appreciate you and don't look back.
I know it's easier said than done but you know by now that nothing you say will make a difference. Take care of YOU.

Dobbyismyabsolutefav · 08/04/2022 15:55

Wise words @littleOwl153 'Mourn the Mother you wish you had and let her go'

FromOurHatsToOurFeet · 08/04/2022 15:54

How do you stop caring? Lots of people saying it is a relief to let go, I would love to do that how do switch off from caring about her, missing her? I feel she has a hold on me

Drop your end of the rope. Be breezy and non-committal. There's no point in trying to have it out with her - you've tried and she just lied to your face! I used to mutter "some questions don't need answers anymore" on repeat. Meaning it doesn't matter why she does this. Once you stop questioning the behaviour and what you may have done to cause it, you take the next step, which is not to care about the behaviour. Acceptance. And with that distance you have the mind space to build the walls so that when she comes to you for something, without thinking or pause you bat it back for your brother to deal with. She chose him, he gets to deal with the good and the bad - whatever you do would never be good enough so why on earth would you try? It becomes very liberating Grin

LuckySantangelo35 · 08/04/2022 15:54

YANBU OP
Fuck her

BoredZelda · 08/04/2022 15:54

that’s deliberate- she sounds vile OP I’m sorry

To be fair, my MIL has a golden boy who isn’t my husband. It’s really obvious to us and can be problematic, but it would be very unfair to call her vile.

OP, just stop trying and console yourself with the fact you won’t be the one having to be there to provide care when she needs it.