Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

As a mother would you do this? AIBU

236 replies

Swayingpalmtrees · 08/04/2022 14:33

My parents (late sixties) have been pretty much 'shielding' since March 2020 with very few exceptions. They are not CEV but feel worried about catching covid.

The exceptions however are ALWAYS to go to my brother's house, they do not visit anyone else inside (no other relatives, or their siblings etc) and have rarely been anywhere else since the pandemic started. My mother has anxiety and she is still terrified of covid (apart from to visit my brother, wife and family, who lives in C.London and uses the tube daily, small kids =high risk so not irrelevant)

My birthday fell on mothers day this year and I organised a family lunch, outside in the garden near their house at a small hotel so she would be comfortable, the weather was so nice and warm we were very lucky. My mum told me she couldn't come, cases were going up too fast she was too worried (even outside) I only made the lunch outside so she could come. It was heated, with blankets and covered just in case of rain and miles from anyone else - organised by the hotel GM. I was upset, but accepted her wishes to keep herself safe.

I have just found out she went to my brother's house the day before, inside his house for dinner with his extended family and she didn't tell me.

I am now coming to the conclusion she is using covid as an excuse not to see us: the back story is that he has always been the golden child, this was made public even when we were very young, it was a family joke it was so bad, but it is something I am used to. I didn't think she would take it this far though.

I now have no interest in organising to visit her again (this is happened more than once that she has been to see him but can't risk seeing anyone else)
Am I being unreasonable to stop bothering?

I feel I am wasting my time organising anything else in the future for her or with her. I feel a level of guilt as she tells me she is depressed and has anxiety so I worry it isn't kind to stop bothering, but it is very hurtful she can choose to 'risk' seeing my brother etc but can not 'risk' sitting outside with me on my birthday and mothers day.

It feels very deliberate.

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 08/04/2022 22:48

Hope, it's always hope that keeps us trying.

Oh I know that, it was hope that kept me going with my brother. But as adults we are also responsible for our own emotions and there comes a point where we have to recognise that despite our actions over the years, nothing has changed and we end up disappointed over and over again. For me the point was a throwaway comment from by brother at a party when he was drunk. Hopefully for the OP, this will be the catalyst to taking steps to recognise she needs to stop trying to make a broken relationship work.

AnastasiaRomanov · 08/04/2022 22:37

This desperate attempt to keep trying to get what you never had is very very common. The child in you is trying to get what you never had. Been there, done that. I am still doing it. At some point you have to accept that your mother will never change. Will never be able to meet that need, fill that howling gaping hole. There’s no point in trying to understand why or how. Minimise contact, protect yourself and hold your head high.

Nanny0gg · 08/04/2022 22:27

@Swayingpalmtrees

Can I ask sincerely do you think I am being a doormat? That is pretty strong. I am not usually a doormat :(

I was trying to give her a really nice day. Between us my dh only booked that particular hotel so we could organise this for her. He knew how much it would mean to me to see my mum. He is appalled, very very quietly appalled and spent all day trying to make it up to me but I still sat in the bathroom crying on my birthday and mothers day for longer than I should have done. I felt oddly abandoned. Ridiculous at 42 years old and told myself to get it together. Washed my face, fixed a smile for the kids as they were trying so hard.

Demeaning, feeling demeaned now it probably is becoming like that yes.

I think you're searching for what you give your children. And you'll sadly never get it from your mother

I think you should quietly distance yourself from her and your brother (where is your father in all this?).Nothing dramatic. Just don't be available

And when she needs something or someone she'll have Golden Boy to call on

AnastasiaRomanov · 08/04/2022 22:22

@Swayingpalmtrees

Quite often the golden child takes after the parents and relishes their golden child role

^this, he could not be happier! He was always very competitive so won hands down from birth it seems. My mother used to call him a genius, genuinely - her very own her milky boy child. And he basks non stop, there is no way he feels pressure, any problems he is immediately on the phone for money (my mother has given him tens of thousands over the years secretly) He doesn't mind that she fusses over him, sits back and lets her crack on. I don't need to go into it, I just need to get over it. I have had an amazing life with a lovely family of my own, loyal and steadfast friends and I am proud of who I am, and how I turned out having parented myself pretty much! Not a bad job at all given I had no handbook Grin It is their loss, it truly is. As is the case for all of us that haven't mothers that could care, but choose not to.

I can so relate to this. It hurts so much but you’ve come out the other side a better and stronger person. Good on you!
MzHz · 08/04/2022 22:16

But yea, back to @Swayingpalmtrees, rise up love, you’re in great company with us and we know you’re wonderful, your h and kids know, and that means you’re good enough

MzHz · 08/04/2022 22:15

@BoredZelda

I asked my own mum why she felt it appropriate to move house without telling me where she was moving to etc etc

The answer “well we were never that close” came back.

I can see how that would hurt, but when my brother, who I had spent 30 years trying to get approval from and working hard to keep a relationship with him, announced to a room full of people that we didn’t get on, it was like a weight was lifted. We are really LC now, I don’t feel obliged to do anything with him, or go to any of his events, or to be the one who keeps the peace when he is complete wanker to me or my daughter. We were invited to his 50th, and to chip in for his big present and I could easily respond with a “no thanks’ The last ten years have been way better for me. I realise it is a different relationship than that of a mother, but we are a really close family.

Thanks @BoredZelda, up to that point I’d thought we WERE close.

Then the scales fell from my eyes, her and my dsis had done so much to hurt me, I’d not even appreciated what they’d done until that point, I have never been so rocked to my core.

But now I have VLC with sis and Nc with my exDM.

Life’s better when you give up at the point where it’s clear you’re never going to win/exist.

When you grow up in this dynamic you don’t see the signs, it was the comments of others that brought most home.

It does still cross my mind that I must be an awful person to have such treatment, but then I remember that it’s because they’re awful people at their cores and I’m not, which is why they went to such lengths to hurt me. Well they have lost their feed now, I dropped the rope.

HopelesslyOptimistic · 08/04/2022 22:00

Put your energy into you, as many have said, you sound so lovely & thoughtful. You will never know her motive for the preference of your sibling, but, there will be a time once you have stepped back that the void alarm bells will start ringing very loud. She will then be scratching her head thinking why oh why the change. Good luck and please leave darling brother and his family to pick up the slack to help care for her as she goes down the path of light. Good luck, be strong and happy.

Mulhollandmagoo · 08/04/2022 21:44

@LittleOwl153

Very low contact is the way to go. Write that letter. But instead of posting it to her - set light to it. Drop it in the fire and let it go. Mourn the mother you'd hoped you had and let her go.

Don't contact her going forward, let her contact you. Brush off any contact she makes, leave her to it.

And remember when she needs ACTUAL care... golden boy can do that too.

I agree with every single word of this! Try some therapy, otherwise if she ever does need anyone to care for her, she will expect it to be you, your brother will be nowhere to be seen, so you will feel obligated and it will destroy you.

You sound so lovely, and I know you'll be hurting Flowers but if you step back you will feel better, it's all about self preservation. If she's on any social media, unfollow her so you don't see her posts, don't call her, and if she calls you, keep it short and formal, or tell her you're in the middle of something and you'll call her back when you're free. Take back the power and control.

Perrymenopausal · 08/04/2022 21:39

I’ve been there too OP

My brother is the golden child. I spend years trying to get my mums attention but nothing I ever did was good enough. She’d pick fault in everything I did and made excuses for my brother (like when he forgot her birthday etc).

It hurt and made me feel shit for many years.

Fast forward to now, we are very low contact. I see her 2/3 times a year for an hour or so and we will exchange a few text messages each month. This suits me, she no longer upsets me as I have not given her the power to do it. I joke with DH and play bingo with the things she will do / say. She’s so predictable but it just goes over my head. She alternates between passive aggressive and being tearful.

Yes it’s hard at first, but the feeling of being free from it made me feel better. I decided to opt for sanity.

Sadly, your mum will not change but you can change how you respond to her.

Best of luck OP

autienotnaughty · 08/04/2022 21:34

I would definitely step back. You don't have to decide right now what that will look like you can figure it out as you go along.

RealBecca · 08/04/2022 21:27

People want what they cant have. Leave her to it. Pretend not to notice, send a card in the post next time and celebrate with your own children. Theres no game to win if theres noone else playing.

billy1966 · 08/04/2022 21:23

OP,
I really hope you will re read this thread because there are so many great points from so many.

I think that if you really honestly start with yourself and ......

why you are pushing a relationship with a woman who is vile

  1. Pushing your children to make gifts.
Doing balloons and such completely over the top fuss for a woman who you know at your core takes pleasure in hurting you.

Want your children to witness this on a loop.

Not seem to have any realisation how damaging to your children to see you humiliated regularly by this woman.

You have had a life time of this behaviour.

You write clearly that your children have clocked your mothers behaviour, yet you insist on them seeing your humiliation on a loop.

I am really sorry for you because it obviously is very painful for you.

However, it is really fxxked up.

You need to give that head of yours a wobble and get help.

I dread to think what your children would say about this dynamic.

Accept your REALITY with your mother.
Deal with it.

Step away and start thinking of your legacy with YOUR children.

Because as I read it your legacy is going to be that you were a pity, spending your life chasing a vile woman who got her kivks humiliating you.

You deserve better.

Your children deserve better than seeing this version of you.

Step away, find your self respect.
Change the narrative of your childrens memory of who you are.

You deserve to be remembered as better than this.Flowers

Noisyprat · 08/04/2022 21:22

I'm sad for you OP, you sound lovely. I have experienced similar, it's the blatant lies that have hurt me. I tried many times to speak to my parents about it but they weren't interested. In the end I realised that I had to find my own coping mechanism (I didn't want to go no contact).

For those say that the OP 'knew it was going to fail', you really don't understand. There is real pull to try and please your mother, show her you care and love her and to live up to her expectations. Eventually you have a light bulb moment when you realise that whatever you do won't be good enough and you simply stop trying and focus your energy elsewhere. I think the op is at this point, well I hope she is, and she can clear her thoughts and be in control of the relationship.

Best wishes to you op.

tillylula · 08/04/2022 21:19

I'd just cut her off and not say anything. Block them all. Sorry to hear that you have gone through this. Feeling unwanted by a parent is awful

RiverSkater · 08/04/2022 21:10

Read her book 'But it's your family' first. I couldn't attach an image of it, sorry!

RiverSkater · 08/04/2022 21:07

I've found this author very helpful, plus she has a Facebook group and a podcast.

You aren't alone. At all.

As a mother would you do this? AIBU
Keeponmoving2213 · 08/04/2022 21:06

@Swayingpalmtrees

She cancelled 15 hours before the lunch, so we couldn't even cancel the arrangements with the hotel, and I had to sit there surrounded by her balloons and bunting fluttering in the breeze. It wasn't fun.
Op this is taking it too far It’s like you knew it was going to be a fail And then luxuriated in it
Coconut80 · 08/04/2022 21:04

Im in tears reading your posts, your hurt and pain is glaring. I hate that she has made you feel you arent enough. I have been married 25 years and had this treatment from my inlaws. Parties, christenings etc my dh and family not invited. Years of childcare for golden brother but none for us. What hurt most was repeated extended family holidays abroad that we were never invited to as my dh had once said he didnt like the heat. It killed me my kids being denied a holiday with their cousins. DH repeatedly challenged FIL about us not being invited and how hurt we were but it happened nearly every year and we only ever found out by accident. The rejection of dh and esp our kids was bloody painful. Eventually I took a step back and realised my own family of 4 were fabulous and enough so I focussed entirely on them. Kids now uni age barely see grandparents, they are now suffering health problems they are late 70s and I sure as fuck will not be helping, golden brother can do it all. They reap what they sow. Please protect yourself and cut contact as much as possible. Much love its so hardxx

NewtoHolland · 08/04/2022 21:01

Reading your posts you've been on a journey in this thread. Well done OP. It's not easy to stop seeking the love and kindness you so deserve from your mother, but you're right that you're knocking at a door that won't be opened.

I hope in your relationships with other friends and family you have the love, warmth and kindness you should have from your mum.

Self compassion is a beautiful tool for helping cope in this situation, there are lots of workbooks on it around if that's your kind of thing.

Well done for moving forwards and for nuturing loving relationships with your DC.

RiverSkater · 08/04/2022 20:58

@Keeponmoving2213

@BoredZelda

Hope, it's always hope that keeps us trying.

When there is a toxic person in your life you hope that things will be different, every time.

It kept me with my narcisstic sister despite the abuse.

Unless you have been in this kind of relationship you cannot judge.

You boomerang ever hopeful that this time they will see how lovely caring kind devoted you are, or even that you are hurting. It's exhausting. Yet it becomes addictive and you ultimately trauma bonded to this person.

OP, I totally get you. I've got some resources to post which I hope will help. 💐

Keeponmoving2213 · 08/04/2022 20:49

@BoredZelda

I agree with you *@Keeponmoving2213*
We are a tiny minority!
Changeee1546789 · 08/04/2022 20:39

OP I’ve not RTWT. Couldn’t read and not leave a comment. Your post has brought me to tears. You sound like an amazing, kind person and your DM doesn’t deserve you. I have issues with my own DM - not to the same extent - but being the oldest and a girl, I’ve never been good enough - my little DB who is the youngest is the golden child. My DH could not believe it when we met. One time I went to visit from overseas, I was pregnant, she asked me to move onto the sofa as DB was there for a night and needed a bed due to his stressful job.

I’m positive there’s some amazing advice here. You are enough OP, and you don’t deserve this. [Flowerscake]

Curlygirl06 · 08/04/2022 20:38

We always knew my brother was the golden child, the favourite of my mum, although she always denied it. He was dad's favoured child, mostly because he was mum's and dad usually did what mum wanted.
We found out how favoured he was when my mum died, and although things have been changed it still hurts.
My dad is not well now, I'm very much of the can't be arsed brigade now- ring him every now and then, visit every now and then but I'm not making a big effort.
The one thing I really would like is to ask my mum why she did what she did, why she treated him so much better than me and my sibling, especially at the end. We had what I thought was a good relationship but obviously not good enough. My dad, when he would have been capable of explaining why we were treated so differently, couldn't come up with a reason, and I'm never going to get closure on why.
My advice is get to the can't be arsed stage, detached vague interest, it's much better.

BoredZelda · 08/04/2022 20:33

I agree with you @Keeponmoving2213

BoredZelda · 08/04/2022 20:32

I asked my own mum why she felt it appropriate to move house without telling me where she was moving to etc etc

The answer “well we were never that close” came back.

I can see how that would hurt, but when my brother, who I had spent 30 years trying to get approval from and working hard to keep a relationship with him, announced to a room full of people that we didn’t get on, it was like a weight was lifted. We are really LC now, I don’t feel obliged to do anything with him, or go to any of his events, or to be the one who keeps the peace when he is complete wanker to me or my daughter. We were invited to his 50th, and to chip in for his big present and I could easily respond with a “no thanks’ The last ten years have been way better for me. I realise it is a different relationship than that of a mother, but we are a really close family.