Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To put in a complaint about this housing officer?

134 replies

NetflixMom21 · 08/04/2022 10:36

On the housing register. Owed a complete homelessness relief duty and have an urgent need to move because of violence within the home and high medical needs for both me and children. Just been put forward for a property the other side of the county to be closer to family who can provide support for all of this.

Every time I have been nominated for a property the rules change, for example, this time round was proving residency for where my family members live. A few weeks ago they accepted bank statements, now they are saying they do not. I have provided every bit of evidence they need but it seems like the goal posts move dramatically every few weeks whenever a property comes up, so I questioned this on my portal and expressed my frustration at the rules seemingly changing whenever I get offered a property. (In my past experience of them, they are just an extremely challenging and rude team of people anyway).

This morning I got quite a confrontational phone call from one of the workers saying they didn’t appreciate turning up to work and seeing my message first thing this morning (I literally just questioned why bank statements were accepted a few weeks ago but not now). They then went onto say that I am ‘leapfrogging’ people who live in the area and have been waiting for years and so on. Well I doubt many of those people have experienced trauma and violence in their home and have high medical needs which is why they are still waiting and not on a higher band…

She was rude, confrontational and insensitive - almost making it seem like I should be thankful that I have taken a house that other people in the area should be entitled to instead… without taking into consideration all the shit circumstances we have which is why we have to leave our lives behind and move to a different part of the county…

I’m so tempted to put in a complaint… but is it worth it?!

OP posts:
Hospedia · 08/04/2022 14:15

I did ask and you pointed out that question had already been answered?

She didn't say how many, just that she'd turned some down as they were unsuitable in terms of disability needs. Maybe RTFT?

Mangogogogo · 08/04/2022 14:10

So as others have said the houses will be owned by different housing associations, livin etc. so they have different rules.
In my professional experience housing officers tend to be fucking mint or absolute shite.
Do you have anyone professionally supporting you? I find complaints from my clients go nowhere but when I do it on their behalf it goes far.

ivykaty44 · 08/04/2022 14:05

@Hospedia I did ask and you pointed out that question had already been answered?

Hospedia · 08/04/2022 14:02

how many properties?

Dunno. Ask the OP maybe?

I think you are forgetting the buildings insurance cost, the income collection and recovery costs, the management cost, the compliance checking, the fire risk assessments, the administration of lettings and tenancy changes, dealing with ASB, court costs etc. I could go on and on but there are many more costs than just repairs. The annual gas servicing alone would cost nearly 3 weeks worth of rent.

Checked the Housing Revenues Account for my council and that's all accounted for, even with all of that included their Housing account is in profit by over £8 million and I can see that is the case with other posters councils too. Face it, council housing pays for itself. The evidence is there in black and white.

ivykaty44 · 08/04/2022 13:51

@Hospedia how many properties?

NeverDropYourMooncup · 08/04/2022 13:50

@HundredMilesAnHour

The tenants will have also been paying for it via their rent payments as rents cover the costs of running/managing the property.

It's incredibly naive to think this. You really believe their reduced rent covers all the costs? Dream on.

Actually, tenant rents run at a profit on the balance sheet. They more than cover the costs. It's the law. All the costs, maintenance, repairs, etc, all have to come out of the revenues from rent and benefits. Councils are not allowed to put in any additional funding, though, so where private maintenance companies charge enough to make a profit of their own, that money comes directly out of what the tenants as a whole have paid - the more the companies charge, the more the pot is depleted.
Sluj · 08/04/2022 13:43

I think you are forgetting the buildings insurance cost, the income collection and recovery costs, the management cost, the compliance checking, the fire risk assessments, the administration of lettings and tenancy changes, dealing with ASB, court costs etc. I could go on and on but there are many more costs than just repairs. The annual gas servicing alone would cost nearly 3 weeks worth of rent.

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 08/04/2022 13:41

@Brefugee

I think you sound a tiny bit entitled. You are extremely lucky to get a LA house.

i'm sure OP is deeply thankful that DV has lead to her getting a house near her family. Deeply deeply thankful.

Don't be so ridiculous. Clearly I meant she is lucky that LA homes are available. Not that she is being offered one because of her lucky circumstances. Honestly I just despair at the ease people are offended.

@hundredmilesanhour It's incredibly naive to think this. You really believe their reduced rent covers all the costs? Dream on
Our local authority actually gained a £2m profit from social housing 2019-20. Which was reinvested in building/improving social housing. It's not that LA have a reduced rent rate. It's that private landlords inflate rents.

Bearfrills · 08/04/2022 13:35

It's incredibly naive to think this. You really believe their reduced rent covers all the costs? Dream on.

Council housing pays for itself via the rental collected and, in the case of older properties, has paid for itself many times over. A lot of council properties arent that much cheaper than comparitive private rentals and some of them are actually more expensive, the difference between social housing and private housing is that there is no markup to cover mortgage costs, letting agents fees, etc. The trade off is that properties are often older, can be fairly basic, and are almost always unfurnished and uncarpeted. My LA'S housing revenue account in the last year collected approx £36 million in rent and their total expenditure on their properties was around £29 million - this includes spending in the current refresh they're doing of roofing and kitchens.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 08/04/2022 13:35

@Septimius

“Well I doubt many of those people have experienced trauma and violence in their home and have high medical needs”

You’re so wrong about this.

Absolutely.

It took 17 years here because, like the OP, I wasn't technically homeless. But everybody was nice to me, even when I was asking them to withdraw an offer for an unsuitable property so it wasn't counted as an offer and to please bear in mind that I must have step free access as stated in the Occupational Therapist report - perhaps my contacts came across less 'venting'?

Sometimes it's hard to understand just how much effort people are putting in behind the scenes to try and help. To then feel they're being bollocked for asking for things they have to ask - and if the rules have changed, they've changed, or it's a different HA with different requirements, there's nothing they can do about it - well, it's going to be hard and the temptation to call somebody and try to explain 'I am doing all I can, don't have a go at me about stuff I have absolutely no control over' must be very strong.

As you are yet to be offered a suitable property, OP, I'd suggest gritting your teeth and emailing back to say something along the lines of

'Having reflected on our conversation today, I think I need to apologise for the tone of my email.

I am finding this situation very difficult as we feel constantly under threat of further violence.

I was upset to find out that the evidence I had already provided for the previous property was not acceptable for this latest one. I realise that these requirements are not something you have control over and it was unfair of me to take my fear and frustration out on you and I want to say I am sorry.

I really do appreciate the efforts you are making to find me a home where we can be safe and my children's medical needs can be met and if there is any additional documentation you require, please do let me know'.

Essentially, even if you don't believe it, telling somebody 'That was unfair of me, I'm sorry' is better than hackles up and snapping at them.

LakieLady · 08/04/2022 13:26

I used to work with homeless/at risk of homelessness clients. Some of them were absolutely appalling in the way they treated council staff, who were mostly trying their damnedest to help them.

They do a shitty job, constantly dealing with people who are in desperate circumstances, with an ever-shrinking pool of homes, staff being cut year after year because of spending cuts, more and more complex bureaucracy and so on. The pressures on them are relentless.

It's not the officer's fault that the rules have changed, she won't be the one that's changed them, and you were directing your ire at the wrong person.

HundredMilesAnHour · 08/04/2022 13:22

The tenants will have also been paying for it via their rent payments as rents cover the costs of running/managing the property.

It's incredibly naive to think this. You really believe their reduced rent covers all the costs? Dream on.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 08/04/2022 13:22

@romdowa

I'd get a house first and then lodge a complaint. Complaining first might go against you and make them even more difficult
Yes I agree, house first!
Hospedia · 08/04/2022 13:21

OP has said she turned some down as they were not suitable for her children's disability needs and they were not able to be adapted/permission for adaptations was refused.

ivykaty44 · 08/04/2022 13:19

whenever I get offered a property.

how many properties have you been offered and have you turned any of them down?

Hospedia · 08/04/2022 13:19

You'd be "fucking raging" if someone told you to be grateful. Why would someone have to tell you to be grateful. Do you think being grateful is belittling and that you are just entitled without having to give one one word of thanks?

No one should have to put up with shitty behaviour lest they appear ungrateful, being someone's verbal whipping post is not the price you have to pay for services. OP (and other people in need) are just as deserving of dignity and respect as those administering the services.

Hospedia · 08/04/2022 13:15

OP, yes I'd write a letter of complaint to the senior housing officer. I would also contact the local Councillor for the area you are moving to, or ask a family member to, and enlist their help in sorting out the application - local elections are coming up next month so they'll be motivated to be helpful.

Do you have a support worker at all? I don't know what the situation is now post-covid but a friend leaving domestic abuse a few years ago had a support worker from the local domestic abuse service who was there to advise on things like housing and benefits. If you do then ask him/her to contact the council where you're moving to and see if an agreement can be reached on what paperwork is needed.

I worked in a job that provided a service to housing associations and councils and we used to have to deal with the tenants directly. The attitudes we were faced with were atrocious, I much preferred dealing with the paying public. This was a service that would cost a normal customer between £300-£600 but the tenants used to get it free because the HA or council were covering the cost. How is it that those customers that were paying were friendly and polite yet those getting it for free weren't?!

The tenants will have also been paying for it via their rent payments as rents cover the costs of running/managing the property.

ivykaty44 · 08/04/2022 13:13

housing officers are in short demand and there is a reason for that, I worked alongside them in a previous role and wouldn't want their job for all the money in china.

They may have had the rules change or whoever was dealing with it was new - but bank statements are regularly not used as proof of address, you can change your address on your bank statements easily and thats why they regularly can't be used.

trying to find housing for people in their own district is difficult and they will have a number of cases similar to yours, and be juggling with many people on their back. Unfortunately your case isn't unique and its very sad and disturbing you're having to go through this, but there are more.

give them a break and vote for a party that will build more social housing

Brefugee · 08/04/2022 13:13

I think you sound a tiny bit entitled. You are extremely lucky to get a LA house.

i'm sure OP is deeply thankful that DV has lead to her getting a house near her family. Deeply deeply thankful.

Itsbackagain · 08/04/2022 13:10

@ForTheLoveOfSleep

almost making it seem like I should be thankful that I have taken a house that other people in the area should be entitled to instead

So she didn't actually say this? Are you not thankful? I understand that aboslutely awful circumstances are at play here but still I think you sound a tiny bit entitled. You are extremely lucky to get a LA house.

The housing officer sounds very frustrated and she handled the situation babdly. However, how many emails/phone calls do you think she gets a day from people angry and frustrated about why they don't have a house yet? Why they are in a low band? Why are they not priority? They have been bidding for years but still nothing?

The HO is only human and she has a difficult job.

This!
FreddyVoorhees · 08/04/2022 13:09

If I'm reading this correctly, you've been dealing with this department for some time and have turned down a number of potential properties but are chasing and chasing for them to magic something suitable out of thin air.

I appreciate that you have certain requirements but you're on one hand saying you have to move NOW but then turning down everything you're being offered.

I've worked in the sector and believe me, it's horrible. You're supposed to be all milly molly mandy 24/7 whilst you've got people screaming at you because you can't give them what they think they deserve, only what is actually available. Best will in the world, it strips you of any charm you did have going into the role.

EndaDay · 08/04/2022 13:08

@Silverhairedcat

You'd be "fucking raging" if someone told you to be grateful.

Why would someone have to tell you to be grateful. Do you think being grateful is belittling and that you are just entitled without having to give one one word of thanks?

Appalling.

NetflixMom21 · 08/04/2022 13:07

@EndaDay hopefully this never happens to you, or you might actually end up growing some compassion for others. Take care

OP posts:
EndaDay · 08/04/2022 13:06

Frustrating but it's still not her fault is it. She just happens to be the poor sap telling you about the rule change.

NetflixMom21 · 08/04/2022 13:06

@EndaDay well no it’s not her trying to get me out of it - she openly said it wasn’t fair for people like to skip the queue above other people living in the area - so more like being forced to help rather than wanting to, because if it was solely down to her, I’m sure the house would be going to someone else who she felt was ‘deserving’

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread