Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘If no one had children…’

138 replies

WomanStanleyWoman · 08/04/2022 10:33

Whenever there’s a thread on MN about not wanting children, someone will inevitably pop up to say ‘Well, if no one had children, the human race would die out’ or ‘It’s all very well not wanting children, but someone has to raise the next generation - good luck getting a doctor or anyone to look after you in your old age if everyone takes that attitude’.

It shouldn’t need saying because it’s so bloody obvious, but I see this argument so often on MN that I really start to wonder. So here it is:

People are NOT suddenly going to stop having children en masse. According to Wikipedia, Mumsnet had 119 million unique users in 2018. Obviously that doesn’t equate to 119 million individuals, but it does give you an idea of how much traffic a site primarily promoted to parents gets. Even if half the active MN users are childless (unlikely), I still don’t think we need to panic about the end of the human race as we know it just yet.

Just as there are people who can have children but choose not to do so, there are people who cannot have biological children who will make huge financial and emotional investment in IVF or surrogacy. Just as there are countless people who plan to have children, there are plenty of unplanned pregnancies where the parents decide to keep the baby. People will always want and have children. They’re not like the Yellow Pages or high street retail - there won’t come a point where everyone just uses the internet instead.

So does anyone really believe ‘If no one has children, we’d be screwed’ is a valid argument? Or are these people simply just trying to justify their disapproval of the voluntarily child-free?

OP posts:
whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 10:48

It’s another good reason to encourage immigration too - if enough existing UK people don’t want children, people with children will be happy to move in!

That's presumptuous though Younger countries will be the future & will start to prosper & emigrating won't be so attractive. Plus potential immigrants will have more choice as lots of countries will want/need them. There's a reason China is trying to push the 3 child thing.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 08/04/2022 10:47

In my experience, those who get huffy about other people choosing not to have children deserve to be ignored. They generally seem to fall into three categories (those who regret having children and don't see why you should dodge the bullet; those who genuinely think you're missing out because they haven't got the brain power to understand that different people enjoy different things; and those who think you've copped out of life's obligations because "It's just what you do!") and none of them is an adequate excuse for spouting martyred nonsense of how their heavy lifting in life is preventing the human race dying out.

jay55 · 08/04/2022 10:47

If we all chose to have 3+ kids, good luck getting a school place Grin
It balances out to 1.7, some people have none, some have loads.
Those of us with none are doing are bit for those who want 3.

WomanStanleyWoman · 08/04/2022 10:46

I also wonder what would happen if I had a child in order to make sure we had doctors in the future, only for them to grow up to tell me they want to be a painter or a ballet dancer or a graphic designer. Would I have to say ‘Sorry, I know you faint at the sight of blood and got an F in your Biology GCSE, but you’ll have to go back and retake it again and again until you pass because I only agreed to parenthood on the basis that you’d fill a hypothetical vacancy at St. Thomas’s in 30 years’ time’?

OP posts:
JenniferBarkley · 08/04/2022 10:45

I think it's usually said in response to people begrudging things like benefits or flexibility to work etc. Parents (and other carers) should be supported by the welfare system (where necessary), the workplace and society in general. The fact that we're all left fighting over scraps is the problem.

whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 10:45

Overpopulation in much of the west is caused by people living longer though, birth rates have been falling for sometime.

SleeplessInEngland · 08/04/2022 10:44

" The less people who have kids the better, environmentally speaking. The world is hugely overpopulated."

This is a truism, but the real enviornmental issues are caused by using the wrong types of energy sources. We are slowly rectifying that, prossibly too late, but it's too simplistic to say 'too many people'.

My take, FWIW, is: enviornmentally-conscious people having childen is a net postive if that mindset is passed on, because people who don't care about it will have kids anyway.

MintyMoocow · 08/04/2022 10:44

@Orangutanteddy

The less people who have kids the better, environmentally speaking. The world is hugely overpopulated. If the human race did die out, so what? We're a violent, war-like parasitic species.
As are all life forms. We just happen to be better at this stuff than all the others.

I like people generally, I love large numbers of them individually.
It is easy to say wouldn’t it be a good idea if there were less of us, but who would you choose to dispense with?

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 08/04/2022 10:44

Yeah there’ll always be people - it doesn’t really matter if some people don’t have children!

It’s another good reason to encourage immigration too - if enough existing UK people don’t want children, people with children will be happy to move in!

whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 10:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

CounsellorTroi · 08/04/2022 10:42

I agree with you. I actually think it’s more valid to point out that if everybody had children we would be totally screwed, because overpopulation is a fact that everyone can see.

Nicholethejewellery · 08/04/2022 10:39

Usually when people express this view they are using it to justify them having children they can't afford to raise without state support. It's the old straw man fallacy, Person A believes people shouldn't have lots of children if they can't afford to raise them, so Person B counters with a deliberate misinterpretation and exaggeration, saying if nobody had children we'd die out. Person A suggested nothing of the sort of course.

Like all straw man arguments, the person expressing the view is doing so because they can't come up with a proper counter-argument.

Orangutanteddy · 08/04/2022 10:37

The less people who have kids the better, environmentally speaking. The world is hugely overpopulated. If the human race did die out, so what? We're a violent, war-like parasitic species.

Swipe left for the next trending thread