Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘If no one had children…’

138 replies

WomanStanleyWoman · 08/04/2022 10:33

Whenever there’s a thread on MN about not wanting children, someone will inevitably pop up to say ‘Well, if no one had children, the human race would die out’ or ‘It’s all very well not wanting children, but someone has to raise the next generation - good luck getting a doctor or anyone to look after you in your old age if everyone takes that attitude’.

It shouldn’t need saying because it’s so bloody obvious, but I see this argument so often on MN that I really start to wonder. So here it is:

People are NOT suddenly going to stop having children en masse. According to Wikipedia, Mumsnet had 119 million unique users in 2018. Obviously that doesn’t equate to 119 million individuals, but it does give you an idea of how much traffic a site primarily promoted to parents gets. Even if half the active MN users are childless (unlikely), I still don’t think we need to panic about the end of the human race as we know it just yet.

Just as there are people who can have children but choose not to do so, there are people who cannot have biological children who will make huge financial and emotional investment in IVF or surrogacy. Just as there are countless people who plan to have children, there are plenty of unplanned pregnancies where the parents decide to keep the baby. People will always want and have children. They’re not like the Yellow Pages or high street retail - there won’t come a point where everyone just uses the internet instead.

So does anyone really believe ‘If no one has children, we’d be screwed’ is a valid argument? Or are these people simply just trying to justify their disapproval of the voluntarily child-free?

OP posts:
MabelsApron · 08/04/2022 13:32

@nellesvilla No, but now I'm depressed that she's not the only one behaving like this!

NellesVilla · 08/04/2022 13:32

*begin, not being

NellesVilla · 08/04/2022 13:26

@MabelsApron, your colleague’s first name doesn’t being with ‘G’, does it?
And I’m much like you, but I do drive (for work- I work with vulnerable people in the sticks), and I have a dog (a lovely little rescue).

whumpthereitis · 08/04/2022 13:23

Are childfree people required to have children to prop up the economy, or do future governments need to consider falling birth rates and adjust to that? Hopefully without compelling people to have children they don’t want. Didn’t work out too well for Ceaușescu.

People make the argument because children are indeed needed to prop up the current way of life in this country (and indeed whatever country is facing falling birth rates), and to ensure the ‘survival’ of the country going forward. There absolutely isn’t a shortage of people worldwide, however. The human race itself will survive just fine, it’s civilizations that are feeling their mortality (as they have done throughout history).

Personally speaking, I don’t think I’ve ever encountered that’s had children solely out of a sense of patriotism.

MabelsApron · 08/04/2022 13:15

@ComtesseDeSpair

Frankly I don’t really care if people choose to have children or what argument they want to make for it. As long as they don’t expect me to alter my blissfully happy childfree life out of concern for their offspring (“OMG, I hate how SELFISH everyone is nowadays, using all the planet’s resources and ruining it with their long haul flying and meat consumption for ever meal, what about the planet MY CHILDREN will have to live on??”), which I’ve absolutely no intention of doing because I don’t give a stuff about their children, then all is well.
I have a colleague with 5 kids and 4 cars including one gigantic diesel van who loves to lecture the rest of us on how we're not considering the planet her children will inherit. They all eat meat and dairy, fly abroad, drive everywhere etc.

I'm a vegetarian with no kids, I don't drive and I don't fly abroad. Upon hearing this, she suggested I could do more by becoming vegan.

I absolutely loathe her.

Antarcticant · 08/04/2022 12:52

he smug superiority especially since most child free people tend to be surrounded by furry pets which are just as bad “environmentally” for carbon footprint as is a human child.

You're overlooking the fact that many pets are rescued, not bred. They and their footprint were already there when their owner adopted them.

There is no reason to think that people who don't bother to get their pets neutered are more likely to be childfree. If anything, we childfree people are far more conscious of the need for meticulous birth-control, be it in humans or animals. I wish I could have been 'spayed' at sexual maturity, as my cats were, instead of having to wait until my 40s to have a hysterectomy.

whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 12:50

The argument being that one, single, childless westerner produces more carbon than an enormous family in parts of less developed countries, so there clearly is a strong lifestyle component when it comes to carbon footprint.

exactly!

picklemewalnuts · 08/04/2022 12:50

The declining birth rate alongside increased life expectancy is a significant issue. Government pensions for the retired are paid by those who are in work. If the latter steadily reduces while the former steadily increase, the youngsters will have a huge burden of tax and care responsibility.

It's morally neutral, imo. Some people reduce the drain on the planet by being child free, others support the future economy by having children.

Across the globe, we're going to have to be a bit more flexible to let people go where they are needed.

PenelopePufferfish · 08/04/2022 12:49

It's really complex tbh. I did politics and economics at uni and declining birth rates are actually bad news from a purely economic perspective. Also, the population argument in environmentalism is now thought to have been quite racist originally, which makes it unreliable. The argument being that one, single, childless westerner produces more carbon than an enormous family in parts of less developed countries, so there clearly is a strong lifestyle component when it comes to carbon footprint. People who came up with the population argument were most likely influenced by wealthy westerners who don't want to change their lifestyle or stop using fossil fuels, but find it easy to blame that lot over there who have loads of children.

So I'm going to say yabu. Because I think there is some truth to the argument even if you disagree with it.

I don't know which one I agree with and I can see both sides; clearly it's true that more babies, especially western babies, are worse for the planet, however low birth rates also means an ageing population, which is bad for the economy and quality of life. I know lots of babies will just grow into old age, so the problem could continue. So I can see why you might object to that argument too

whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 12:49

@2Gen I don't care if someone has 10 dc or 0 dc but the narrative that everyone is having loads of dc is BS. "23 nations - including Spain and Japan - are expected to see their populations halve by 2100." & the half that is left is going to be older.
Developing countries do have more dc but there are socio economic reasons for that so who am I to criticise.

whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 12:43

Errr... No. Unless your cat is going to give birth to 1-3 + humans, who each give birth to 1-3 + more humans and so on. The child is an infinitly bigger footprint.

I'm sure children have a bigger footprint although I actually didn't realise pets were bad until recently. However the idea that each person is having X kids who then have X kids isn't true otherwise most western countries wouldn't be seeing population declines in the near future.

2Gen · 08/04/2022 12:42

@whoatealltheeggs

Overpopulation in much of the west is caused by people living longer though, birth rates have been falling for sometime.
Yes, and the western nations and Japan are not having enough children to even replace the existing populations, never mind become overpopulated. Some people are even predicting population collapse if we don't start to have larger families, such as Elon Musk. It is going to become more problematic for us in the not so distant future, as there will be far fewer people working, and more elderly people who need support if not total care. Are we to become like Nazi Germany and start euthanising those who need caring for? As a previous PP said, whom would we dispense with? Who would decide who should live and who should die? Who among us has that right? No one IMO! Anyway, every so often, the population has been, and will continue to be, culled, either by our own doing with war, or by natural means such as famine, natural disaster or plague. The overpopulation theory is fear-mongering , anti-human propaganda.
whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 12:41

I'm curious about the argument that people use to say that we shouldn't reduce the numbers of children being born because we need to support the existing people eg through healthcare, pensions etc (people need to pay in so others can take out). Someone above mentioned pensions as being like a big Ponzi scheme.

Where does the narrative come from that birth rates need to be reduced? They have reduced dramatically already in the west.

Studies predict the below. Obviously any change on that scale in terms of demographics needs planning for.

The number of under-fives will fall from 681 million in 2017 to 401 million in 2100.
The number of over 80-year-olds will soar from 141 million in 2017 to 866 million in 2100.

thecatsthecats · 08/04/2022 12:40

It doesn't need to be justified by other people having children.

Human beings don't have an inalienable right to existence any more than any other species, any more than they have a right to be supported by younger humans.

To bring this argument out as some sort of trump card suggests that the person making the argument suffers from some sort of mental limitation, or is suffering from delusions of existential importance.

ComtesseDeSpair · 08/04/2022 12:40

Frankly I don’t really care if people choose to have children or what argument they want to make for it. As long as they don’t expect me to alter my blissfully happy childfree life out of concern for their offspring (“OMG, I hate how SELFISH everyone is nowadays, using all the planet’s resources and ruining it with their long haul flying and meat consumption for ever meal, what about the planet MY CHILDREN will have to live on??”), which I’ve absolutely no intention of doing because I don’t give a stuff about their children, then all is well.

Antarcticant · 08/04/2022 12:36

It would be better for the billions of other species on the planet if the human race did die out, so I don't accept any 'preserving the human species' argument as a reason for having children, because we are an utter menace who don't deserve the planet we've colonised.

LimeSegment · 08/04/2022 12:35

the smug superiority especially since most child free people tend to be surrounded by furry pets which are just as bad “environmentally” for carbon footprint as is a human child.

Errr... No. Unless your cat is going to give birth to 1-3 + humans, who each give birth to 1-3 + more humans and so on. The child is an infinitly bigger footprint.

GingerFigs · 08/04/2022 12:34

I'm curious about the argument that people use to say that we shouldn't reduce the numbers of children being born because we need to support the existing people eg through healthcare, pensions etc (people need to pay in so others can take out). Someone above mentioned pensions as being like a big Ponzi scheme.

So if we reduce birth rate now we can't support those in existence, so we just have to keep adding more and more people to the planet to support those already here? Is there a point at which we can stop doing that? Have we missed that point?? But surely if we keep increasing numbers on the planet then we're screwed due to resources.

Sorry I'm probably not explaining my point very well - I think having lower birth rates wouldn't be a good thing environmentally but I've seen it on MN (and other places) that people think we have to keep birth rates up to support those in existence - if you think this or understand the argument can you explain it (I'm not being goady, just can't understand how constantly increasing is a good thing.)

LimeSegment · 08/04/2022 12:32

Totally agree OP, if you choose to have kids ok but it's pretty ignorant to justify it that way. Even worse is "my children are going to grow up and do great things, one of them might solve world peace/climate change/etc". So so ignorant, as if one person can just "find the solution". No, they will be one of billions of faceless consumers like we all are.

Not having dc is the best gift to earth you could make.

I have dc btw so I'm not judging having them, just the weird justification.

Chely · 08/04/2022 12:27

I really don't care of people choose to remain childless, stop at 1 or whatever.
I find it amusing when others think it perfectly reasonable to have a pop at me for having many children, like I give 2 fucks what they think.

I don't see childless life choice becoming popular enough to cause extinction.

EmpressCixi · 08/04/2022 12:25

Given that birth rate is well below replacement rate, it’s a more logical fear than that of runaway population growth due to too many babies.
I don’t think it’s used to shame the child free so much as to stop the smug superiority especially since most child free people tend to be surrounded by furry pets which are just as bad “environmentally” for carbon footprint as is a human child.

MJ123 · 08/04/2022 12:24

I still really struggle to understand why people feel the need to comment on other people's reproductive decisions tbh.

ImplementingTheDennisSystem · 08/04/2022 12:22

YANBU.
People who say "imagine if everyone..." are just plain thick.
If every single person in the UK - all 70 million of them - decided to holiday in Devon during the same week in August, it would create a total societal collapse!
The same would happen if every single person in the UK - all 70 million of them - decided to bake a cake at the same time this Sunday!
Or anything else that you can imagine.
But WE'RE ALL DIFFERENT and make different choices so we will never see any of these scenarios happen!

SexyLittleNosferatu · 08/04/2022 12:21

Or are these people simply just trying to justify their disapproval of the voluntarily child-free?

It's this but very few, if any, will admit that.

twinsetandpearl · 08/04/2022 12:20

Oh dear OP someone has a childfree agenda don't they

Anyway whilst we aren't going to suddenly stop having children the fact is that the current birth rate in Europe is falling below that which is economically required to sustain economies

Swipe left for the next trending thread