Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘If no one had children…’

138 replies

WomanStanleyWoman · 08/04/2022 10:33

Whenever there’s a thread on MN about not wanting children, someone will inevitably pop up to say ‘Well, if no one had children, the human race would die out’ or ‘It’s all very well not wanting children, but someone has to raise the next generation - good luck getting a doctor or anyone to look after you in your old age if everyone takes that attitude’.

It shouldn’t need saying because it’s so bloody obvious, but I see this argument so often on MN that I really start to wonder. So here it is:

People are NOT suddenly going to stop having children en masse. According to Wikipedia, Mumsnet had 119 million unique users in 2018. Obviously that doesn’t equate to 119 million individuals, but it does give you an idea of how much traffic a site primarily promoted to parents gets. Even if half the active MN users are childless (unlikely), I still don’t think we need to panic about the end of the human race as we know it just yet.

Just as there are people who can have children but choose not to do so, there are people who cannot have biological children who will make huge financial and emotional investment in IVF or surrogacy. Just as there are countless people who plan to have children, there are plenty of unplanned pregnancies where the parents decide to keep the baby. People will always want and have children. They’re not like the Yellow Pages or high street retail - there won’t come a point where everyone just uses the internet instead.

So does anyone really believe ‘If no one has children, we’d be screwed’ is a valid argument? Or are these people simply just trying to justify their disapproval of the voluntarily child-free?

OP posts:
MabelsApron · 08/04/2022 15:43

Me neither @mydogisthebest! Maternity is at a 10 year high in my workplace, my department has 15 currently off. The majority of my colleagues have 3+ as did the friends I had in my 20s. If anything it feels like the birthrate should be going up…

whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 15:41

Where I live I don't see much evidence of homelessness but I know it's a thing!

As I said, if it is falling, then good. Needs to fall even more or the future for children and future children is more than bleak

What do you want it to fall too? What is an acceptable rate?

mydogisthebest · 08/04/2022 15:33

@whoatealltheeggs

I know that supposedly the birth rate is falling in the UK (difficult to believe when everyone you go there are tons of babies and toddlers)

😆 Why do you think statistics are false based solely on your surroundings?

It was meant as a light hearted comment but, certainly where I live, I see little evidence of families/women having less children.

As I said, if it is falling, then good. Needs to fall even more or the future for children and future children is more than bleak

gannett · 08/04/2022 15:31

@BrightYellowDaffodil

In my experience, those who get huffy about other people choosing not to have children deserve to be ignored. They generally seem to fall into three categories (those who regret having children and don't see why you should dodge the bullet; those who genuinely think you're missing out because they haven't got the brain power to understand that different people enjoy different things; and those who think you've copped out of life's obligations because "It's just what you do!") and none of them is an adequate excuse for spouting martyred nonsense of how their heavy lifting in life is preventing the human race dying out.
Ding ding ding.

I've been hit by the "but the human race will DIE OUT" one before. I was like... and? Is that meant to be a bad thing? While I love individual humans, I am entirely uninvested in the species' long-term survival.

I also consider it low-key homophobic given how often gay friends have been told "but if everyone was like you the human race would DIE OUT".

chisanunian · 08/04/2022 15:26

I do have a problem with the suggestion that people who choose not to have children are somehow damaging the future economy through their selfishness.

Whoever is suggesting that?

KosherDill · 08/04/2022 15:24

@Orangutanteddy

The less people who have kids the better, environmentally speaking. The world is hugely overpopulated. If the human race did die out, so what? We're a violent, war-like parasitic species.
Exactly.

If a magic genie gave me one wish, I'd wish humans away and leave this poor planet to the other species.

whumpthereitis · 08/04/2022 15:11

It is generally used as a defensive statement though, like there’s a greater moral component in someone choosing to have children than there actually is. People, in the west at least, have children because they want them, because they have the biological drive to.

It comes down to the fact that people lash out when they feel their life choices are being attacked. The childfree (of which I am one) do it too. I do think in many ways it is getting better for the childfree as it’s becoming less of an unusual choice. It is only relatively recently though, in the great scheme of things, that women actually have the freedom to make that choice for themselves. Those that do still face pushback and disapproval for making that choice. People been made to feel like they have to justify their perfectly reasonable life choices is invariably going to lead to them feeling utterly fucked off.

I think if the ‘childfree agenda’ is anything, it’s ‘don’t treat us as somehow lesser, quit asking us to explain ourselves, and respect our choices without passsing negative comment’. A lot of people genuinely can’t seem to comprehend that there’s no universal formula for happiness, and that that not everyone wants the same things. I don’t know if it’s lack of imagination, resentment, or ego.

whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 15:08

I know that supposedly the birth rate is falling in the UK (difficult to believe when everyone you go there are tons of babies and toddlers)

😆 Why do you think statistics are false based solely on your surroundings?

mydogisthebest · 08/04/2022 15:05

I know that supposedly the birth rate is falling in the UK (difficult to believe when everyone you go there are tons of babies and toddlers) but, if true, it has to be a good thing.

As another poster said, you can't keep adding to the numbers in order to pay for the older ones as where would it ever end?

I have seen quite a few posts where posters say their children are likely to be the carers wiping the childfree posters' bums or be a surgeon, find a cure for cancer etc.

Some may but most will just do an ordinary job and maybe not even wipe their parents' bums (meaning their parents may need a carer).

The tax argument also doesn't work as unless they have some high flying job paying masses of tax they are far more likely to take more out of the system than they ever pay in.

I do know quite a few childfree by choice couples but by far the majority of my friends and neighbours have children. Lots have 2 but quite a few have 3 or 4.

Some neighbours of mine in their 30's are expecting their 5th child. The woman has worked 2 years in the 16 years since she left school and the man has worked 3 years in the 18 years since he left.

He likes to tell people that they don't work because they are not mugs like us. I can't work out how they are getting benefits but they are obviously cheating the benefit system. Who knows whether their children will work when they have such terrible role models.

Knittingchamp · 08/04/2022 15:02

It'd be great for the environment if humans died out.

whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 14:58

We don't necessarily need more dc to support the ageing population, there could be more tax reforms instead eg higher CGT, wealth taxes, higher social care levy etc. The growing gap in inequality will make it more palatable.

whumpthereitis · 08/04/2022 14:54

It’s not necessarily about being a doctor in 2043, OP. It’s about having a workforce who are paying taxes to pay for services society needs, including those needed by older people in their retirement.

Indeed. It’s a problem that requires a better solution, even if it systemic overhaul, than putting the onus on individuals to have children they don’t want (which would introduce a whole host of other problems). Realistically this is what needs to be done rather than kicking the can down the road.

Governments that have tried to control birth rates aren’t exactly thought well of, for good reason.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 08/04/2022 14:46

@Orangutanteddy

The less people who have kids the better, environmentally speaking. The world is hugely overpopulated. If the human race did die out, so what? We're a violent, war-like parasitic species.
Dsis decided not to have children, and there is no way I would have criticised her decision, or tried to change her mind. It is her life, and her choice.
ComtesseDeSpair · 08/04/2022 14:43

Frankly, many of the people who claim that their DC will be our future taxpayers paying tax to support childfree people like me in old age are a) claiming back far more in tax credits themselves than they actually contribute in tax and b) seem likely to have DC who’ll be doing the same themselves with their own families - so they seem to be exacerbating the money pyramid problem rather than solving it.

Chasingaftermidnight · 08/04/2022 14:36

It’s not necessarily about being a doctor in 2043, OP. It’s about having a workforce who are paying taxes to pay for services society needs, including those needed by older people in their retirement.

A falling birth rate alongside an ageing population is potentially a big economic problem.

I can’t remember the exact figures - if you Google you’ll find them - but the proportion of working age people in the population is predicted to drop while the proportion of retirees increases dramatically in the coming decades.

But you are right that we don’t necessarily need people to have children to fix that problem, because we can fill the gap with immigration.

DietOrDie · 08/04/2022 14:34

Also, the population argument in environmentalism is now thought to have been quite racist originally, which makes it unreliable. The argument being that one, single, childless westerner produces more carbon than an enormous family in parts of less developed countries, so there clearly is a strong lifestyle component when it comes to carbon footprint.

If I had DC then they would be living the life of a westerner, not that of a subsistence farming sub Saharan. In other words, it's more effective from a climate change point of view for me to be child free than for a subsistence farming sub Saharan to have fewer or no children.

One of the more effective interventions, if you wanted to reduce birth rates, is to educate the girls. When you do that they tend to start reproducing later, have fewer children overall, and be better able to provide for the ones they do have. Perhaps someone will be along now to claim that educating girls in Africa or Afghanistan (or providing access to contraception) is racist.

whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 14:28

to 60? unlikely

Blossomtoes · 08/04/2022 14:23

@whoatealltheeggs

Overpopulation in much of the west is caused by people living longer though, birth rates have been falling for sometime.
Life expectancy is also heading down. I fully expect it to plummet now.
MabelsApron · 08/04/2022 14:21

@nellesvilla I hear you. I do get the strong sense from that particular colleague that having given society the gift of five future taxpayers, she's entitled to use up as much resource as she likes, and those who haven't given society that gift need to repent by being as frugal and environmentally-conscious as possible.

whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 14:20

Christmas should be taken in turns. Pre dc I always had to work christmas which annoyed me simply because I was a Londoner to didn't need to travel back from "home".

MabelsApron · 08/04/2022 14:17

@mumoblue I tend to hear it most at work. We have a lot of battles over time off at Christmas (I've worked 7 of them in a row) and other special times of year. Many times, parent colleagues have suggested that the childless people in the team should work the anti-social days/shifts and see that as taking on for the team on behalf of those who are contributing future workers who'll pay our pensions etc. It may not be entirely meant but the attitude behind it certainly is, in my experience.

As I said earlier in the thread, I want voluntary euthanasia to be legalised. I'd absolutely use it (the idea of being in a nursing home is abhorrent to me) and I'd have something to counter the narrative with...

WomanStanleyWoman · 08/04/2022 14:05

@twinsetandpearl

Oh dear OP someone has a childfree agenda don't they

Anyway whilst we aren't going to suddenly stop having children the fact is that the current birth rate in Europe is falling below that which is economically required to sustain economies

What ‘agenda’ would that be?

I don’t have any problem with people wanting and having children. Why would I? I do have a problem with the suggestion that people who choose not to have children are somehow damaging the future economy through their selfishness.

Tell me - do you have children? And if you do, was it because you wanted them, or because you thought they might possibly qualify as a doctor in 2043?

OP posts:
Getoff · 08/04/2022 13:54

I don't think OP has gone far enough with her objections.

  1. The human race is in no danger of dying out due to lack of breeding.
  2. A 99% reduction in the number of humans on the planet, achieved gradually via a lower birth rate, would be a good thing.
  3. It doesn't actually matter if the human race dies out. At most, we care about what the planet will be like during our grandchildren's lifetimes, when exactly after that the human race ends, and how, isn't really an issue for us.
NellesVilla · 08/04/2022 13:41

@MabelsApron, I know I shouldn’t judge (it upsets meat eaters) but this one is also the type to order shitloads of foie gras and massive legs of ham (and other unfortunate creatures) at xmas, and then ask me why I have the audacity to be a child-free vegetarian.
I know not all families are like this, but she and her brood are such rampant mega-consumers and meat eaters. They don’t give a toss about how they get something, and feel that whatever they want has to be sourced now.
I feel that some large families give other families a bad name. Ooh, controversial. I bet the vipers of Mumsnet will come for me now!!

Mumoblue · 08/04/2022 13:41

I only really hear this argument when people are talking about others being rude to them or acting inconvenienced when they’re out with their kids in public. (And the UK can be rather cold towards people just trying to get around with a buggy or a small kid).

But I don’t think it’s really meant seriously. And I don’t think everyone should have kids either, and I certainly think more people should have one. Lots of people seem to view having an only child as something sad or selfish, which I don’t get.

Swipe left for the next trending thread