Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘If no one had children…’

138 replies

WomanStanleyWoman · 08/04/2022 10:33

Whenever there’s a thread on MN about not wanting children, someone will inevitably pop up to say ‘Well, if no one had children, the human race would die out’ or ‘It’s all very well not wanting children, but someone has to raise the next generation - good luck getting a doctor or anyone to look after you in your old age if everyone takes that attitude’.

It shouldn’t need saying because it’s so bloody obvious, but I see this argument so often on MN that I really start to wonder. So here it is:

People are NOT suddenly going to stop having children en masse. According to Wikipedia, Mumsnet had 119 million unique users in 2018. Obviously that doesn’t equate to 119 million individuals, but it does give you an idea of how much traffic a site primarily promoted to parents gets. Even if half the active MN users are childless (unlikely), I still don’t think we need to panic about the end of the human race as we know it just yet.

Just as there are people who can have children but choose not to do so, there are people who cannot have biological children who will make huge financial and emotional investment in IVF or surrogacy. Just as there are countless people who plan to have children, there are plenty of unplanned pregnancies where the parents decide to keep the baby. People will always want and have children. They’re not like the Yellow Pages or high street retail - there won’t come a point where everyone just uses the internet instead.

So does anyone really believe ‘If no one has children, we’d be screwed’ is a valid argument? Or are these people simply just trying to justify their disapproval of the voluntarily child-free?

OP posts:
YetiTeri · 08/04/2022 17:35

@veevee04

The population will eventually decrease people are having less children .
Oh FFS this has been explained over and over. If people aren't dying they don't need to be replaced. The population will continue to grow regardless of declining birth rate.
mydogisthebest · 08/04/2022 17:29

@SpotALeopard

Yanbu. It’s a pointless argument because it ain’t gonna happen. Most humans want children to a greater or lesser extent. There are some things nobody much fancies, but you’ve just got to get on with them because someone’s got to do it.

Having kids is not one of these. There’d be a moral dilemma about my choice not to have children if most people felt like me, but they demonstrably don’t.

I think you will find, if asked, that a huge amount of couples/women with children give very little thought as to whether or not they want children.

So many "accidents" it's untrue plus lots of couples/women have children "because it's what you do"!

No wonder so many regret it when it is too late

mydogisthebest · 08/04/2022 17:27

@Dairymilk50 what do you find odd that any childless person has time to give a second thought. (I think you mean childfree).

Are we not meant to be concerned about overpopulation and the bleak futures for existing and future children?

I have nieces and nephews and am concerned for their future and, if they have children, those childrens' futures.

I am also concerned for the planet and the animals, plants etc on it which us lovely humans seem determined to destroy.

SpotALeopard · 08/04/2022 17:22

Yanbu. It’s a pointless argument because it ain’t gonna happen. Most humans want children to a greater or lesser extent. There are some things nobody much fancies, but you’ve just got to get on with them because someone’s got to do it.

Having kids is not one of these. There’d be a moral dilemma about my choice not to have children if most people felt like me, but they demonstrably don’t.

Mummy1608 · 08/04/2022 17:21

To clarify I think having or not having children are both completely reasonable individual choices. But yes, we are trending to have not enough babies in the UK and in most economically developed countries. Disastrously low birth rates in rich city states like Hong Kong, Singapore. But also very low here and elsewhere in Western europe

Mummy1608 · 08/04/2022 17:19

Yabu because UK birth rate is far below replacement level.

Dairymilk50 · 08/04/2022 17:19

@whumpthereitis

It is generally used as a defensive statement though, like there’s a greater moral component in someone choosing to have children than there actually is. People, in the west at least, have children because they want them, because they have the biological drive to.

It comes down to the fact that people lash out when they feel their life choices are being attacked. The childfree (of which I am one) do it too. I do think in many ways it is getting better for the childfree as it’s becoming less of an unusual choice. It is only relatively recently though, in the great scheme of things, that women actually have the freedom to make that choice for themselves. Those that do still face pushback and disapproval for making that choice. People been made to feel like they have to justify their perfectly reasonable life choices is invariably going to lead to them feeling utterly fucked off.

I think if the ‘childfree agenda’ is anything, it’s ‘don’t treat us as somehow lesser, quit asking us to explain ourselves, and respect our choices without passsing negative comment’. A lot of people genuinely can’t seem to comprehend that there’s no universal formula for happiness, and that that not everyone wants the same things. I don’t know if it’s lack of imagination, resentment, or ego.

This
EmpressCixi · 08/04/2022 17:18

@whoatealltheeggs

No I’m not suggesting life expectancy has not increased. I stated it has increased?
How else do you measure life expectancy...you do it using life tables.
I was adding to your post which was a bit too simplistic. The reason why life expectancy at birth was so low was because so many children never grew up. Your post makes it sound like the average adult died at 48 if a man or 52 if a woman, which is not the case.
Please follow the link I inserted. It will show you what I mean that life expectancy at birth is not the best way to demonstrate the actual increase in pensioner age adults.

veevee04 · 08/04/2022 17:17

The population will eventually decrease people are having less children .

Dairymilk50 · 08/04/2022 17:16

@Orangutanteddy

The less people who have kids the better, environmentally speaking. The world is hugely overpopulated. If the human race did die out, so what? We're a violent, war-like parasitic species.
I think comments like this are quite unhappy and bitter AF. I find it odd that any childless person has time to give it a second thought. If you don't want children that is your choice and people who DO want kids it's also THEIR business.
finebutfedup · 08/04/2022 17:13

Just wish people would admit that they're not having kids as a selfless gift to society, but because they want them

*wantED!!

I think most if not all those who harp on about it are jealous of the childfree Grin

whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 17:00

Those are average whole life expectancy

How else do you measure life expectancy?

whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 16:56

It shows if you were male and made it to age 20 in 1900, you could expect to live until age 63.

Exactly if you made it to 20, much fewer did than today.

whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 16:53

Of course infant mortality impacted life expectancy 100 years ago. Just like today not everyone dies or lives at 81. Are you saying life expectancy hasn't increased?

EmpressCixi · 08/04/2022 16:51

static.ons.gov.uk/visual/2015/09/expected_age_to_reach2.csv

Is interesting. It shows if you were male and made it to age 20 in 1900, you could expect to live until age 63. A hundred years later, if you are male and age 20 in 2000, you could expect to live to age 76.

EmpressCixi · 08/04/2022 16:39

@whoatealltheeggs

To be blunt...the problem is not that people are having children but that people are living so long. It's unpalatable but it's true.

Why do so many not understand that this is the driver of population growth. Birth rates have been declining for decades. In 1900 life expectancy was approx 52 for women & men 48. By 1951,women lived to 72 and men to 66. Today our median population age is 40.5.

Those are average whole life expectancy which were seriously deflated due to high infant mortality rates. If you survived infancy, your adult life expectancy wasnt that short. The average 1900 woman did not die at 52.
YetiTeri · 08/04/2022 16:35

Net migration will go through the roof. The reason? 19% of the world's land surface will become unliveable.
The reason? Uncontrolled population growth.

The single best thing people can do for the environment is have less/no children.

whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 16:33

To be blunt...the problem is not that people are having children but that people are living so long. It's unpalatable but it's true.

Why do so many not understand that this is the driver of population growth. Birth rates have been declining for decades. In 1900 life expectancy was approx 52 for women & men 48. By 1951,women lived to 72 and men to 66. Today our median population age is 40.5.

EmpressCixi · 08/04/2022 16:31

Ugh i hate how these threads always devolve into dehumanising humans to the status of parasites and not a even form of life worth saving unlike a blooming dandelion.

whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 16:29

Where are all these extra humans going to live, work etc? As it is our hospitals can't cope with the number of people, GP's can't cope, the education system can't cope. There are not enough houses, far far too many cars on the roads, the trains and buses are, in many places, overcrowded.

I don't think you understand. The UK population will not continue to grow much more & the main driver of it will be immigration.

"Change will also be driven by an ageing population, with the number of people aged 85 set to almost double between now and 2045 from 1.7 million to 3.1 million. Between now and 2045 there will be an estimated 1.4 million more deaths than births. But the population will still grow by 3.9 million, driven by net migration, with an estimated 5.3 million more people coming to the UK than leaving."

Comedycook · 08/04/2022 16:26

To be blunt...the problem is not that people are having children but that people are living so long. It's unpalatable but it's true.

waterlego · 08/04/2022 16:26

@Orangutanteddy

The less people who have kids the better, environmentally speaking. The world is hugely overpopulated. If the human race did die out, so what? We're a violent, war-like parasitic species.
Yes, this.
whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 16:25

I don't know what an acceptable rate is but we need far less people in the UK than we presently have. There were 613,936 births in 2020, a ridiculously high number even if it is lower than previous years.

The increase in population is due to immigration & people living longer. In 2020 there were more deaths then births.

mydogisthebest · 08/04/2022 16:21

@whoatealltheeggs

Where I live I don't see much evidence of homelessness but I know it's a thing!

As I said, if it is falling, then good. Needs to fall even more or the future for children and future children is more than bleak

What do you want it to fall too? What is an acceptable rate?

I don't know what an acceptable rate is but we need far less people in the UK than we presently have. There were 613,936 births in 2020, a ridiculously high number even if it is lower than previous years.

Where are all these extra humans going to live, work etc? As it is our hospitals can't cope with the number of people, GP's can't cope, the education system can't cope. There are not enough houses, far far too many cars on the roads, the trains and buses are, in many places, overcrowded.

Yes if money was put into health, education, transport etc it would help but, let's be honest, that is not likely to happen is it?

whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 16:07

The birth ratee_ in the UK has been falling since the Seventies, but it has now hit record lows. The number of children per woman stands at 1.58 in England & Wales, almost half the post-Second World War peak of 2.93

Swipe left for the next trending thread