Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘If no one had children…’

138 replies

WomanStanleyWoman · 08/04/2022 10:33

Whenever there’s a thread on MN about not wanting children, someone will inevitably pop up to say ‘Well, if no one had children, the human race would die out’ or ‘It’s all very well not wanting children, but someone has to raise the next generation - good luck getting a doctor or anyone to look after you in your old age if everyone takes that attitude’.

It shouldn’t need saying because it’s so bloody obvious, but I see this argument so often on MN that I really start to wonder. So here it is:

People are NOT suddenly going to stop having children en masse. According to Wikipedia, Mumsnet had 119 million unique users in 2018. Obviously that doesn’t equate to 119 million individuals, but it does give you an idea of how much traffic a site primarily promoted to parents gets. Even if half the active MN users are childless (unlikely), I still don’t think we need to panic about the end of the human race as we know it just yet.

Just as there are people who can have children but choose not to do so, there are people who cannot have biological children who will make huge financial and emotional investment in IVF or surrogacy. Just as there are countless people who plan to have children, there are plenty of unplanned pregnancies where the parents decide to keep the baby. People will always want and have children. They’re not like the Yellow Pages or high street retail - there won’t come a point where everyone just uses the internet instead.

So does anyone really believe ‘If no one has children, we’d be screwed’ is a valid argument? Or are these people simply just trying to justify their disapproval of the voluntarily child-free?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Stellamar · 09/04/2022 23:18

data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.TFRT.IN

Information on world fertility rates. Even including all the developing world, the overall rate is 2.4, so we're not far off the point where world population will start to drop. Even if couples all still chose to have 1 child each, it's not going to stop the population decline.

No need to panic yet about the species dying out. But social change will occur, and it will happen in our lifetime. Tax and pensions and social care models will have to change, as well as many other things. Some people do categorise this as a "crisis".

Information about abandoned houses in Japan.

asia.nikkei.com/Life-Arts/Life/As-Japan-s-empty-homes-multiply-its-laws-are-slowly-catching-up

WomanStanleyWoman · 09/04/2022 19:43

[quote Mummy1608]@WomanStanleyWoman you have (deliberately?) Only quoted a small part of my comments. I was responding to this part of your op, which is unreasonable in my view:

People are NOT suddenly going to stop having children en masse. According to Wikipedia, Mumsnet had 119 million unique users in 2018. Obviously that doesn’t equate to 119 million individuals, but it does give you an idea of how much traffic a site primarily promoted to parents gets. Even if half the active MN users are childless (unlikely), I still don’t think we need to panic about the end of the human race as we know it just yet.

Your way of estimating birth rates based on mumsnet users (!) is scientifically flawed. That is why i explained that the UK birth rate is way below replacement level. As it is across western europe and in other rich countries like China. People HAVE suddenly stopped having children en masse, so that part of your op is factually incorrect.

I did go on to say that of course any individual couple is free to choose whether or not to have children and they are both reasonable choices. I was only disagreeing with your unscientific and ill-informed statements about birth rate.[/quote]
The quote was direct and complete. How can you complain about that?

As for saying my ‘estimates are scientifically flawed’, you’re making a fool of yourself, frankly. I’ve never claimed I was estimating birth rates or anything of the kind. I was making the point that parenthood is in no danger of becoming a niche status. My comments weren’t scientific because they weren’t meant to be. As for being ill-informed, are you really using China as an example? A country that for decades forced people by law to have no more than one child?

OP posts:
Hawkins001 · 09/04/2022 17:04

@WomanStanleyWoman

Whenever there’s a thread on MN about not wanting children, someone will inevitably pop up to say ‘Well, if no one had children, the human race would die out’ or ‘It’s all very well not wanting children, but someone has to raise the next generation - good luck getting a doctor or anyone to look after you in your old age if everyone takes that attitude’.

It shouldn’t need saying because it’s so bloody obvious, but I see this argument so often on MN that I really start to wonder. So here it is:

People are NOT suddenly going to stop having children en masse. According to Wikipedia, Mumsnet had 119 million unique users in 2018. Obviously that doesn’t equate to 119 million individuals, but it does give you an idea of how much traffic a site primarily promoted to parents gets. Even if half the active MN users are childless (unlikely), I still don’t think we need to panic about the end of the human race as we know it just yet.

Just as there are people who can have children but choose not to do so, there are people who cannot have biological children who will make huge financial and emotional investment in IVF or surrogacy. Just as there are countless people who plan to have children, there are plenty of unplanned pregnancies where the parents decide to keep the baby. People will always want and have children. They’re not like the Yellow Pages or high street retail - there won’t come a point where everyone just uses the internet instead.

So does anyone really believe ‘If no one has children, we’d be screwed’ is a valid argument? Or are these people simply just trying to justify their disapproval of the voluntarily child-free?

Society I'm guessing would develop creation of human life, via other methods e.g. Human cloning etc
Mummy1608 · 09/04/2022 17:00

I've just checked and the total fertility rate in England was 1.59 children per woman in 2020. That's far far below replacement level at 2.1/2.2 and is continuing to plummet.

Solutions include (arguably) better maternity and paternity leave rules, better options for flexible working, and more got funded nursery hours.

As I say, of course everyone is free to choose whether or not to have children. But people HAVE stopped having children en masse: that is the bit of the OP I'm saying is plain wrong.

wanttomarryamillionaire · 09/04/2022 16:55

I genuinely don't understand why some people are so bothered by other people deciding not to have kids. I have a friend who never wants children and the sheer amount of people who seem offended by her life choice and try to persuade her otherwise is astonishing.

Mummy1608 · 09/04/2022 16:53

@WomanStanleyWoman you have (deliberately?) Only quoted a small part of my comments. I was responding to this part of your op, which is unreasonable in my view:

People are NOT suddenly going to stop having children en masse. According to Wikipedia, Mumsnet had 119 million unique users in 2018. Obviously that doesn’t equate to 119 million individuals, but it does give you an idea of how much traffic a site primarily promoted to parents gets. Even if half the active MN users are childless (unlikely), I still don’t think we need to panic about the end of the human race as we know it just yet.

Your way of estimating birth rates based on mumsnet users (!) is scientifically flawed. That is why i explained that the UK birth rate is way below replacement level. As it is across western europe and in other rich countries like China. People HAVE suddenly stopped having children en masse, so that part of your op is factually incorrect.

I did go on to say that of course any individual couple is free to choose whether or not to have children and they are both reasonable choices. I was only disagreeing with your unscientific and ill-informed statements about birth rate.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 09/04/2022 16:46

I also consider it low-key homophobic given how often gay friends have been told "but if everyone was like you the human race would DIE OUT"
I've never heard anyone say something like that.

It's awful and very outdated considering many same sex couples have DC through alternative methods.

Stellamar · 09/04/2022 11:10

Replacement fertility rate is 2.1 children per female. It's already below that across the entire developed world. The only reason the population is increasing is because of immigration from the developing world. As PP said when women are educated they delay marriage and childbearing and gave fewer children. The developing world will follow and world population is predicts to peak around 2050 and then start to decline.

China is now trying to encourage people to have more children after years of restricting births.

It's interesting. There will be massive social change. I do wonder what will happen. Empty houses that no one wants - prices will go down . Will we gather together in cities or spread out? Retirement as a concept will probably have to go - if you're fit enough you'll have to work til you drop. Environmentally it's good news but societies will have to adapt.

I don't think humans will ever die out though. The population will probably stabilise at a certain level.

WomanStanleyWoman · 09/04/2022 09:07

I also consider it low-key homophobic given how often gay friends have been told "but if everyone was like you the human race would DIE OUT".

Yes, sadly I have heard this argument made towards gay people; albeit not for some years now. It’s even more ridiculous, because apart from the fact that there’s zero chance of everyone turning gay’, even that wouldn’t prevent people having children. All it would prevent is unplanned pregnancies.

OP posts:
WomanStanleyWoman · 09/04/2022 09:01

@Mummy1608

Yabu because UK birth rate is far below replacement level.
That doesn’t make me unreasonable.
OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock1 · 09/04/2022 08:12

Fewer people having children would also be good.
Many have 1 or 2 DC in Eastern Europe similarly now in Ireland and the UK.

My parents both came from a family of 9 DC.
They had 4.
The 4 DC has 1 or 2.

Plenty of couples are saying "no thanks" generations of family are skipping due to much later pregnancies.

First time grandmother at 70 whereas it was average to have great grandchildren by 70's in the past.

It'll continue to change, my niece's aren't planning DC they're focusing on careers and a good lifestyle.

There'll always be outlines who have a football team.

Those who have repeated pregnancies due to cultural or religious reasons.

Some of my grandmother's generation had a child every other year with contraception banned for religious reasons.

Stellamar · 08/04/2022 21:46

An increasing population is an environmental problem. A falling population is an
economic problem. However, I don't think there are very many people who decide whether or not to have a child based on the economy or the environment. It's usually mainly driven by whether they personally do or do not want to experience being a parent. The other arguments are then used to shore up the decision that has already been made.

toconclude · 08/04/2022 19:59

@Orangutanteddy

The less people who have kids the better, environmentally speaking. The world is hugely overpopulated. If the human race did die out, so what? We're a violent, war-like parasitic species.
Alternatively we are a communicating, social, creative species...
mydogisthebest · 08/04/2022 18:55

@whoatealltheeggs

Are we not meant to be concerned about overpopulation and the bleak futures for existing and future children?

Are you concerned about overpopulation in the UK though because that's not down to lots of children.

I am concerned about overpopulation of the planet. I am also concerned about the overcrowding of the UK.

I am just so so happy that me and DH decided not to have children and as we are now both in our 60's we won't, hopefully, get to see the awful consequences of overpopulation and climate change

waterlego · 08/04/2022 18:37

Just wish people would admit that they're not having kids as a selfless gift to society, but because they want them.

I have two children and I absolutely admit this. My decision to have children was completely selfish. I wanted them. I didn’t want to go through my whole life without having that experience of being a mother. I was still in my twenties when I had them and was very naïve at that time about the environment and the impact of my bringing two extra humans into the world. If I could go back now, I might make a different choice. (And I always have to add as a disclaimer at this point that I really, really love my children and am very glad they exist).

Mummy1608 · 08/04/2022 18:22

To clarify, the proportion of immigrants in the UK is low. But it is rising because of our below-replacement birth rate

Mummy1608 · 08/04/2022 18:20

Well this thread explains why the government haven't done anything to mitigate the impact of the ageing population, most people seem unaware of the countries demographics.

This, 100%. If it wasn't for net migration, the UK population would be declining rapidly. As a result the UK demographic is changing (increasing proportion of immigrants). I'm an immigrant myself (and a mum) so I think this isn't necessarily bad: we desperately need migrants to fill shortage jobs. I am in a shortage job. But it's fascinating that i often see the same people who worry about having too many economic migrants, don't understand that the only solution is more uk-born children.

ExMachinaDeus · 08/04/2022 17:55

So does anyone really believe ‘If no one has children, we’d be screwed’ is a valid argument?

No it’s just another stick with which to beat women. Each child born in the west uses up around 4 times the resources of a child born elsewhere. If you truly want to do something about the global environmental crisis, best thing is not to have children. (And don’t drive a car.)

But these two things are seen as almost a human right.

whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 17:48

Fewer people having children would also be good.

But people are having less children!

It would be hard at first but give it a few generations and it would sort itself out

Well this thread explains why the government haven't done anything to mitigate the impact of the ageing population, most people seem unaware of the countries demographics.

pangolina · 08/04/2022 17:47

Those people also assume that everyone believes the continuation of the human race is a good thing.

whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 17:45

Oh FFS this has been explained over and over. If people aren't dying they don't need to be replaced. The population will continue to grow regardless of declining birth rate.

Not forever it won't unless people stop dying 🤔.

whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 17:43

Are we not meant to be concerned about overpopulation and the bleak futures for existing and future children?

Are you concerned about overpopulation in the UK though because that's not down to lots of children.

whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 17:41

@EmpressCixi The reason why life expectancy at birth was so low was because so many children never grew up

I'm aware of this

Your post makes it sound like the average adult died at 48 if a man or 52 if a woman, which is not the case.

Nope, I wasn't saying that

Life expectancy at older ages has dramatically increased.

www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/birthsdeathsandmarriages/lifeexpectancies/articles/howhaslifeexpectancychangedovertime/2015-09-09

The link you posted just has numbers on the left side & nothing else. Besides my point was population has increased because of people living longer which is true.

IncompleteSenten · 08/04/2022 17:41

The planet would be a hell of a lot better off if humans did go extinct.

Fewer people having children would also be good.

It would be hard at first but give it a few generations and it would sort itself out

SpotALeopard · 08/04/2022 17:35

I guess that’s what I meant by to a greater of lesser extent, @mydogisthebest. The human race has done pretty well at keeping itself going through people who, even if not actively trying, aren’t too fussed. I was/am very fussed about not having children, so they were never simply going to happen to me (and I’m mightily thankful I live in a time and place where I have choice in the matter).

Swipe left for the next trending thread