Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think stepmothers and MIL's get a hard time on mumsnet

37 replies

Verity226 · 08/04/2022 10:32

Why is that?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
C8H10N4O2 · 08/04/2022 16:04

@Verity226

The MIL's are all overbearing, the stepmothers are all cruel. I don't understand it.

Meanwhile in the real world the people I know with MIL's get on with them just fine, and the stepmothers I know are perfectly pleasant to their stepchildren.

Because "dog bites man" is not a story, its everyday. "Man bites dog" on the other hand triggers discussion.
Trulyweird1 · 08/04/2022 15:49

Thing is, as at least one pp has said, we are not getting a random sample of relationships with MIL or Stepmum. We only get threads raised when there is as inside, and the posters on those threads may identify with the OP.
In the real world, a cross section would not be so skewed.

Chloemol · 08/04/2022 15:48

@Verity226

From wiki ‘ In 2018, Mumsnet had 1.3 billion page views from 119 million unique users’

Then think about the actually quite small number of posts on mil and step parents. Then take a closer look at those posting, often the same ones again and again, so actually a very small number of actual users of the site

Maybe it’s just because you get a hard time as a mil/step parent. Like anything in life you will always get those who are liked and those who are not, whatever the relationship is

And certainly on the mil ones there are numerous posts about how nice the posters mil is

So as I say, rude or not, get some perspective and get a grip

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 08/04/2022 15:44

*their

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 08/04/2022 15:44

Definitely insecurity. I’m a SM to a 7 year old and me and her Mum get along great. The amount of other people who think it’s there business to query “how involved” I am and “how upsetting” this must be for her Mum is ridiculous. In reality her Mum is happy that her daughter is safe and secure and has a fantastic relationship with me and her Dad, just as we love that she is so happy with her Mum and stepdad. Some people are odd.

Can’t really speak for MIL as mine is dead but I’m pretty sure my own DM likes my DH more than she likes me HmmGrin

funinthesun19 · 08/04/2022 15:38

With regards to stepmothers, some people think stepmothers are an extension of the father, so she instantly has responsibility towards the children in the same way as (if not more than!) the father himself. It’s no secret on here that often stepmums are held to higher standards than than the fathers.

FridayBluezzzz · 08/04/2022 14:29

Step mums seem to be dammed if they do and dammed if they do. I think lots of people project their own issues into others.

I had a incredibly difficult MIL. You don’t know what it’s like until you have to deal with it. An adult comes into your life who acts as if they have some control and say over everything. It can deeply effect your relationship with your DH.
I think when people get on with their MIL they can’t understand why there can be an issue.

JamSandwich89 · 08/04/2022 12:32

Hmmm... I guess there could be a few reasons.

People are more likely to post about issues than things going great.

Also, maybe the in-laws relationship tends to be a bit more complex than a kind of... direct relationship with your own parents? It's you, OH, and in-laws and OHs can feel stuck in the middle if their parents and wife/husband/partner are having issues... so I guess it's reasonable to ask for outside viewpoints if OH isn't wanting to get too involved or disagrees with you regarding the PILs? Though I guess it's uncommon to see a FIL post. Hmm

For stepmums, and ILs actually, I think anything where different families are joining together, can naturally have issues, big or small. Sometimes we don't realise something that's normal to our family isn't normal for other families until we're a bit mushed together!

I have seen a fair few negative posts about DILs. Normally complaining about their choices for the GC. Sometimes threads here can get quite vicious both ways!

2Gen · 08/04/2022 12:21

@PuffinMcStuffin

My MIL is rude to me, and intentionally hurtful and antagonistic. Everyone around me has commented on it.

Some people are lovely, they probably don't impact those around them enough to cause them to go to a forum for advice.

This! When our relationships are going well, we don't tend to reach out for advice as well... we don't need it! We don't need to vent nor have a rant either. I don't like my MIL much, but have little to nothing to do with her so I don't need to post but when people do post about having a good relationship with their MIL's as well as wishing I did too, I'm happy for them because it boosts my faith in humanity a bit. I've only ever had one MIL but in the past, have really, really liked and become fond of a BF's mum, she was absolutely lovely ( the BF was not so lovely, unfortunately!), so it's not always the case that people hate their MILs, or their kids' SMs, we just don't hear about the positive relationships as much. I have a DS and I must admit, I am a small bit concerned that his future wife might not like me, but hopefully I've learnt a thing or two off MN and from life itself. I hope I can be a likeable MIL at least!
Narwhalelife · 08/04/2022 12:13

Totally agree, i started a step parent support thread in the relevant section on here and it’s going nicely.

Step mothers are dammed if do or don’t. Too involved ‘they are not your children’ want to take a step back ‘what if it was your child’.

Being a step parent is hugely complex and emotional. It’s not for anyone who isn’t on that role to comment in my opinion.

My MIL is odd, but ok, no complaints bless her ☺️

Flickflak · 08/04/2022 12:13

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Verity226 · 08/04/2022 12:13

@Chloemol

Get a grip

The posts are a small proportion of people from the millions who ar3 actually on MN

They're not though are they..

Get a grip yourself, rude person.

OP posts:
Chloemol · 08/04/2022 12:10

Get a grip

The posts are a small proportion of people from the millions who ar3 actually on MN

AntarcticTern · 08/04/2022 12:02

Many people I know have a tricky relationship with their PILs (definitely FILs as well as MILs!) in real life. IMO that is accurately reflected on MN!

PenelopePufferfish · 08/04/2022 12:01

It's true that people are less likely to post when they don't have issues. That's why I love the fashion and baby names boards! Places where people post without any dramatic issues. I think the more serious boards are helpful and important too though. I just need light relief sometimes

Seymour5 · 08/04/2022 12:00

I’m a MIL. I have a DIL & a SIL. My DC were mature adults when they chose their partners, and I respect that those partners, and their children, will come first in their lives. We get on pretty well in general, as a family.

Parents who think they will always be the most important person in their child’s life, are, IMO, heading for a big disappointment!

PurpleDaisies · 08/04/2022 11:59

If you looked at the relationships board, you’d think everyone had problems. People post when they’ve got issues.

PenelopePufferfish · 08/04/2022 11:59

@TwoPenguins

No idea. But God yes. I was actually told on a thread where I asked for advice on how to make first weekend of kids staying with us (had just moved in together) as easy for them as possible, that he should not bring the children to our house as I may kidnap them because I lost my own baby several years back. Absolutely unbelievable (and completely heartbreaking when reading it).

In real life their mum and I (and my partner) get on very well. The kids are happy and settled and we share care 50/50. Their mum actually made a 'step-mum' card with them for me on Mother's Day. So it's not all the drama it is on mumsnet.

🙄 ah mumsnet! It really is the gift that keeps on giving.

I agree with you though, that outside mumsnet there is waaaaay less drama. Thank god

Favourodds · 08/04/2022 11:58

I think their aren't that many positive step mum posts on here, which is kind of understandable because 'I like my step-children and have a happy blended family' is a weird non-post.

It is quite sad reading 'I don't like my step-children' posts. Often the children involved are very young. I think anyone who's from this kind of family, or close to someone who is, is aware of the impact it does have on children.

Which isn't to say I think step-mums are always in the wrong or deserve a hard time, I think it's just an emotive topic.

Ikeatears · 08/04/2022 11:51

I sometimes think it's because a lot of people are unable to put themselves in someone else's position.
For example, with mil, some forget that, for example, dh is the mum's child, just in the same way that our child is ours or that we are our mother's child. It's seen as a position of 'other' somehow.
The same with step parents, we forget that our child is very much a part of their life in many cases and the step parent's life and that of their children is no less important than our own or our children's.
How would I feel as a MiL who has loved, supported, guided and cherished my children to be sidelined by my son and my son's wife (I only have ds not dd) as though I suddenly don't matter as much as her mum or that I'm an inconvenience or interfering? It must be hard to move from being a mum to being a MiL and navigate the relationships successfully.
As stepmum (I am one), I've been very, very lucky in that dsd's mum is very supportive, very encouraging of our relationship and never ever resentful of the bond that dsd and I have formed over many years. I know anecdotally though, that this is unusual. I don't know how I would have felt to be micro-managed or criticised for my (always well intentioned) efforts with dsd.
If I wrote about mine and dad's relationship on here, I'm sure I would get criticised for "over-stepping" but in our family (which included dsd's mum) I am absolutely confident that I do not. Some people would be totally unable to see that.

Viostep · 08/04/2022 11:50

@TwoPenguins that's so cruel. Mumsnet can be really horrible sometimes Flowers your blended family sound lovely.

PenelopePufferfish · 08/04/2022 11:46

Oh why? Wicked stepmother/annoying mother in law stereotypes.

It goes both ways though. People stereotype ex wives too (and I'm not one of those - yet anyway Wink. Of course it could happen on day).

Basically, lazy, misogynistic stereotyping which we have all been conditioned into believing.

ImAvingOops · 08/04/2022 11:46

I'm not so sure. I think people get a treated according to their behaviour. I've seen loads of threads where the step mother is told that the problem is her lazy arse husband and that she's doing everything right. And other threads where a step mum is very cold and uncaring towards the kids and gets told this. Step parents aren't an homogeneous mass, all behaving and being treated the same way.
Same with mils. The problem seems to be that mils who get posted about are the ones treating their dil as a baby breeder who ceases to have any importance once she's delivered a baby and whose time is totally free to carve up according to the in-laws demands. Few people post about their lovely mils.

TwoPenguins · 08/04/2022 11:46

Thank you. It was awful.

SleeplessInEngland · 08/04/2022 11:46

MILs are nearly always the villains on here and yes, it is boring. Some deserve it of course but it's almost like second-hand annoyance at husbands projected onto them at times.

Swipe left for the next trending thread