Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what % of income you pay on your mortgage?

112 replies

ErinAndTonic · 08/04/2022 09:29

Particularly dual income homes who can still afford holidays each year. Currently we have a smallish mortgage and I only pay 10% of my income on it, my partner earns more so covers the rest and all bills etc.

We're considering moving to a bigger house and our mortgage would treble. He can afford his portion and with my recent pay rise I would pay a third while he pays two thirds and the bills etc (he earns significantly more than me). At the moment we have several holidays per year and I'm trying to figure out what the average people are paying mortgage wise against their salaries whilst still affording holidays.

We tend to do two long haul trips a year and two short haul for example. We don't have to budget at the moment but would need to be a bit more careful if we moved, which I'm looking at but thought I'd ask here too. We don't have children so there are no nursery fees, childcare expenses etc to worry about so that does give us more disposable income. This house is incredible but I don't want to be bogged down in bills so that we can't enjoy our lives anymore, especially after the past few years!

OP posts:
DarleneSnell · 09/04/2022 09:49

19% of net income. Childcare bill isn't too far behind!

RussianSpy101 · 09/04/2022 09:47

We have a similar lifestyle to you @ErinAndTonic at least 3 foreign holidays a year.
Our mortgage is 10% of our monthly net income.
We have 3 children.
We didn’t borrow as much as we were able to as we were previously mortgage free and are quite debt averse so didn’t want to take on a huge amount as we enjoy our lifestyle too much to sacrifice any of our holidays. We are also lucky to live in an area where houses are fairly cheap so we have a fairly big house in a lovely area for a fraction of the price it would be elsewhere.
No other debt .

MrsR87 · 09/04/2022 09:47

Ours is about 10% of our net dual income. We overpay it though so we end up paying about 15% most months.

We had DS in lockdown and before that we did big holidays in the Caribbean and a few weekend breaks in Europe and Uk.

Now we have DS, childcare is more than our mortgage a month and when the next one comes along at the end of the year there will be a period of time when childcare will be all of my net wage!

Ilostit · 09/04/2022 09:46

About 8% but we have school fees too! If I ask those on as they’re like 2nd and 3rd mortgages it’s 28%!

BulletTrain · 09/04/2022 09:43

20% after tax. I'd go higher if we needed but our 3 bed townhouse with office is plenty big enough. The only reason we'd be moving would be to get a garage/be detached. If you need more space do it - don't if you don't! Not right now given the market.

Teeturtle · 09/04/2022 09:41

It has varied between about 10-33% of total household income, depending upon whether both or only one of us was working. Was quite a stretch at the 33% end of the scale.

Chely · 09/04/2022 09:39

Under 15% now, we're a single income household. It was around 30% when we had 2 incomes but we were less comfortable then.

OrangeIsTheNewRed · 09/04/2022 09:36

About 30%, after tax.

TheFlis12345 · 09/04/2022 09:07

Our joint income is very similar to yours will be OP (around £115k). Our mortgage is £2100 a month so nearly a third of take home. We don’t have children either so still have plenty of disposable income. We spend quite a bit on food and drink but still easily save £2k a month which could be your holiday fund.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 09/04/2022 08:49

Our mortgage is 14% of after tax combined income but we overpay so its more like 17%

LoudSnoringDog · 09/04/2022 08:48

22%

princesspq · 09/04/2022 08:45

We are decent earners and pay about 20%, i think the monthly payments are high compared to anyone else i know but we can afford it, at the moment we are prioritising our disposable income on getting things for the house each month and decorating, however if we wanted we could afford holidays. Do you mean you would be paying 16% of you sole earnings? What percentage is your husband's and how do you work out holidays? DH earns slightly more than me (60/40) but everything goes into one pot, and i feel 20% is affordable

MissyB1 · 09/04/2022 08:31

After tax 30% of our dual income. And school fees for our ds on top of that 😱

hamstersarse · 09/04/2022 08:29

I pay 10% of my income, single earner house

Onlyrainbows · 09/04/2022 08:26

10% before tax, 15% after tax. 5 bedroom house. One high earner, one average earner

Cultureclub · 09/04/2022 08:14

I've always been happy with around 20% although I went from only about 8% until I built an extension.
Car finance and fuelling has become shockingly expensive and when multiplied for two cars has really started to impact.
Both our cars are paid for at present but if we were to enter new finance arrangements in the next few years the percentage costs would certainly pact how high we could go on the mortgage.

Winenight · 09/04/2022 07:56

We have a similar income to you. I only work pt but we have some income from BTLs. However I wouldn’t recommend the BTL route. IMO the returns aren’t worth the risk & tying up masses of capital. The government squeezes every last drop out of private landlords, and then adds in new taxation and regulations. Once we’re able to get a reasonable price for ours we will sell. Any surplus we save we will put in a S&S isa- probably index tracker funds.

In basic figures, our mortgage repayments cost £850 a month. Childcare for 3 children is a bit more, maybe £900-£1000. (That will go down in time). Then we have food shopping, bills, clothes for the kids, fuel & insurance for the cars and so on. We own our cars outright and have no credit card debt or personal loans. Holidays are just a few nights away in a cottage a few times a year. I would guess that we save around £1500 a month between us - I’m going to monitor this going forward as we’re also looking at moving up in the future.

However, unless an absolutely amazing and unmissable house comes on the market we’re not going to buy at the moment. House prices are bubbling, the market is crazy and there’s a looming threat of interest rate rises and inflation. So worst case scenario is you overpay for a house and then your mortgage payments increase, just as everything else gets more expensive. I should caveat that I don’t own a crystal ball and prices may keep on rising!

So the questions I suppose to ask yourself are- can you withstand interest rate rises on your new mortgage payments? Have you savings or investments you can draw on if the worst happens? Will you regret overpaying now if prices fall in the future? Will you regret not buying now if they continue to rise? Do you have to increase your mortgage by so much or is there a cheaper house option? How old are you, and how long do you want to be paying a mortgage for? What pay increases are you expecting?

Good luck with deciding!

ErinAndTonic · 08/04/2022 15:53

That is a good point, redundancy would mean we were in a sticky spot I'd imagine. We would both get a healthy payout but there would be more pressure to find something sooner Vs in this house where my contribution is so minimal that it wouldn't be too noticeable to him if i was out of work for a short while. He is lucky that his redundancy package would likely clear our mortgage so it's a good barrier for him.

Agree with what others say re. The bills, I have asked before if he would want me to contribute more to our living expenses in general but he's always said he is comfortable as we are, and means I have the disposable income for holidays etc. i do spend a lot of my money in the interiors for the house, furniture, cleaner, garden furniture, general sprucing etc so I do spend on us not just myself. But equally so does he, he covered half my share of the Maldives trip for example.

Once I earn more it will balance out fairer, but we have been together almost 17 years and has been working for both of us with us sharing similar level of disposable income.

Another option is for us to stay put and convert our loft and extend. We already had a large kitchen extension when we moved in, but converting the loft would give me an office (one of the main issues I have is working and then subsequently trying to relax in essentially the same room!)

It's not like we need more space for the two of us anyway, some things are just nice to haves Vs essential.

OP posts:
LaWench · 08/04/2022 13:36

10% of joint income after tax. We could have traded up and stretched our finances but we are very cautious after a previous redundancy to ensure that either one of us could pay the bills should the worst happen.

gwenneh · 08/04/2022 13:16

14% of our post-tax (dual) income.

NoSquirrels · 08/04/2022 13:12

@ErinAndTonic

My partner would cover all household bills but I would cover all of my own bills ie phone bill, food shopping, gym membership and i'd probably pay for us to have a cleaner.

Then once I get my pay up above 40k I'd contribute either further into the mortgage or against the bills.

Like I say, good for you if your DP is OK with that.

I suppose I’m just coming from the perspective that if it was me in the higher-earning person’s position, I wouldn’t be happy with that as household bills are unavoidable and a big chunk of living expenses. I’d rather subsidise holidays and discretionary spending.

And from my POV if I was the lower earner I’d expect to pay household bills for my own sake.

But you’ll be better off the way you’re doing it if everyone is happy so crack on.

ErinAndTonic · 08/04/2022 13:08

My partner would cover all household bills but I would cover all of my own bills ie phone bill, food shopping, gym membership and i'd probably pay for us to have a cleaner.

Then once I get my pay up above 40k I'd contribute either further into the mortgage or against the bills.

OP posts:
Mouldyfeet · 08/04/2022 13:00

Sole income and its 40%!

It's shit and I have to work loads of overtime to pay for any fun stuff. When my fixed term ends next year I expect it will more like 50%.

NoSquirrels · 08/04/2022 13:00

Sorry, just seen you don’t plan children.

Why won’t you be paying household bills, though? In your scenario I’d think you should both be contributing relative to your incomes so if DP earns 2x what you do then you pay proportionately to that.

If your DP is happy with the split though guess that’s good for you!

Mushrooms0up · 08/04/2022 12:58

20% of net on mortgage. We also budget 8% for holidays which gives us a healthy budget for a few trips each year

Swipe left for the next trending thread