Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Rishi Sunak’s wife is NOT elected OR in a public role but she is a woman

903 replies

BigGreenSpacehopper · 08/04/2022 09:05

Have you noticed that Zac Goldsmith (elected), Mark Carney (role of significance to all of us as Govenor of the Bank of England), 4th Viscount Rothmere (controlling shareholder and Chair of the Daily Mail) all have non Dom status but no mention is really made. However, a woman, who has no public role, has never said anything public, is being criticised for her non Dom status?

And yes she’s getting massive dividends but I imagine as it’s family money there is a massive pre-nup in place so it’s not like Rishi will be able to run off with it!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Blossomtoes · 08/04/2022 14:30

Silly me - I thought the Labour Party were claiming the moral high ground

Did you? Why did you think that?

BambinaJAS · 08/04/2022 14:29

[quote Clavinova]He is the chancellor, raising NI contributions for the poorest in society

From April 2022, anybody earning more than £9,880 a year will pay 1.25p more in the pound.

From July 2022 the point at which employees start paying NI will increase to £12,570.

Combining those two measures means that in the 12 months from April 2022, anyone earning less than about £34,000 will pay less NI than they did last year. Anybody earning more than that will pay more.

An employee on £20,000 a year will pay £178 less NI in 2022-23 than they did the previous year.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-58436009[/quote]
All of that is nominal cash terms.

And that is only NI.

What do you think happens when benefits only get uprated by 3.1% when inflation hits 10%?

That marginal NI decrease gets eaten.

People are left much poorer in real term. Period.

No amount of mental gymnastics will obfuscate that fact. It was a mind-boggingly terrible idea to raise NI now because this also affects employment.

Also, could he have been more cynical with his "I will reduce income tax in 2024 by 1 point" nonsense?

He is am empty suit who happens to be backed by a world class PR and Marketing firm.

Thats all he is. He has no idea that sometimes real politics is hard work.

Clavinova · 08/04/2022 14:28

Blossomtoes

Silly me - I thought the Labour Party were claiming the moral high ground.

OnlyFoolsnMothers
Clavinova can you raise a family on 35k given the current costs of living?

How long is a piece of string? How many children? Where do they live - North East England or London? Mortgage or social housing? Single parent earning £35,000? Do they run a car...?

Alexandra2001 · 08/04/2022 14:26

@Clavinova

That’s a red herring because it’s a totally different issue but are the Tories going to return the donations from Russian oligarchs?

Are Labour going to return donations from the 'Chinese spy'?

I agree Clav, once Ms Lee has been prosecuted and shown to actually be a "Spy" then all monies should be returned but as i understand it, she has committed no crime whatsoever.

Sunak's wife's family are strong backers of Modi... and who does Modi support?
Putin, the man who orders the killing of women and children in Ukraine, whose soldiers rape to death women and children, who today killed 39 at they waited at a train station, who wrote "for the children" on the air burst missile.

The Sunaks are benefiting from tax loop holes he himself will not close (saving themselves millions) so when you get your paltry £150 of your CT bill (whilst it went up £220 p.a.) or hear about the latest Russian war crime... consider what these people really think about us.

SueSaid · 08/04/2022 14:25

'Stick a fork in Sunak. He is done now.'

Confused

Oh maybe we could have several threads called 'the fall of Sunak' like the tedious Bozo ones. Look how that went.

SueSaid · 08/04/2022 14:24

'Indeed she does pay the tax she should as the system is geared to appease the rich.'

The system is geared to pay tax in the country earned in this case.

Tax laws are annoying. I loathe tax dodgers who work off shore for example. but what you can you do. It isn't the person's fault for living within the tax rules.

That is separate to Sunak needing to increase NI to recoup the costs of the pandemic.

BambinaJAS · 08/04/2022 14:23

@Wnkingawalrus

If I earned that much money and was married to somebody at the heart of government. You can bet I would be wanting large chunks of it helping to pay the poorest and most marginalised.

You have no idea what she does with her money. There are plenty of people in need in India. Maybe she prefers to focus her philanthropic efforts in her country of birth.

You are deluded.

What she does is tax arbitrage on a global scale. This costs many ££ millions.

Cycles dividends through many different countries and regulatory regimes, so in the end she likely pays close to 0% effective tax on her "earnings".

Does that sound to you like a person who actually cares about the average person in society?

People have the pitchforks out because she has been playing both ends against the middle, for her own benefit. In India, she had the power and influence to get away with it. UK? Not so much. Public opinion matters, specially the optics.

The chickens have truly come home to roost.

Stick a fork in Sunak. He is done now.

saraclara · 08/04/2022 14:22

@Iggly

YABU

It’s literally a requirement of being a minister that you declare interests.

It is, and he did.

I'm no fan, but let's at least get the facts straight.

SleeplessInEngland · 08/04/2022 14:21

Oh dear, the thread has degenerated into posting Guido Fawkes links.

Patchbatch · 08/04/2022 14:16

@JaniieJones

'Greed. Pure and simple and wrong. He is the chancellor, raising NI contributions for the poorest in society whilst a family member doesn't bother to pay the tax that she should.'

The 'poorest' on benefits won't pay anyway and the threshold for ni has been raised so those on lower incomes won't pay from July. He had to do something to pay for the massive pandemic debt.

She does pay the tax she should. In the UK on her UK income, in India on her income from India. Why aren't people understanding this?

People understand it just fine, not sure why you think they don't. Indeed she does pay the tax she should as the system is geared to appease the rich.
OnlyFoolsnMothers · 08/04/2022 14:14

@Sirzy

As the wife of the chancellor, especially at a time when things are so tough for so many, they should be applying some logic and not making the decision to save themselves millions while others can’t eat.

I can’t find a way to look at it which doesn’t make it completly immoral

Exactly- paying her fair share of tax wouldn’t affect their lifestyle at all- the £50 a month they’ve taken from me and the next to nothing energy help means for my family our standard of living is dropping!!!
OnlyFoolsnMothers · 08/04/2022 14:13

Clavinova can you raise a family on 35k given the current costs of living? Oh I see 35k rich, Rishi Sunak and his wife just a little bit wealthier than most….perlease
Clearly she’s not a non dom- her life is here- the tax rules are disgusting and they as shady as they come

Sirzy · 08/04/2022 14:12

As the wife of the chancellor, especially at a time when things are so tough for so many, they should be applying some logic and not making the decision to save themselves millions while others can’t eat.

I can’t find a way to look at it which doesn’t make it completly immoral

Blossomtoes · 08/04/2022 14:12

@Clavinova

That’s a red herring because it’s a totally different issue but are the Tories going to return the donations from Russian oligarchs?

Are Labour going to return donations from the 'Chinese spy'?

I asked first. You have no answers other than whataboutery and copy and paste @Clavinova.
Clavinova · 08/04/2022 14:08

He is the chancellor, raising NI contributions for the poorest in society

From April 2022, anybody earning more than £9,880 a year will pay 1.25p more in the pound.

From July 2022 the point at which employees start paying NI will increase to £12,570.

Combining those two measures means that in the 12 months from April 2022, anyone earning less than about £34,000 will pay less NI than they did last year. Anybody earning more than that will pay more.

An employee on £20,000 a year will pay £178 less NI in 2022-23 than they did the previous year.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-58436009

SueSaid · 08/04/2022 14:06

'Greed. Pure and simple and wrong. He is the chancellor, raising NI contributions for the poorest in society whilst a family member doesn't bother to pay the tax that she should.'

The 'poorest' on benefits won't pay anyway and the threshold for ni has been raised so those on lower incomes won't pay from July. He had to do something to pay for the massive pandemic debt.

She does pay the tax she should. In the UK on her UK income, in India on her income from India. Why aren't people understanding this?

Clavinova · 08/04/2022 13:50

That’s a red herring because it’s a totally different issue but are the Tories going to return the donations from Russian oligarchs?

Are Labour going to return donations from the 'Chinese spy'?

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 08/04/2022 13:49

@Volhhg

You have to declare your partner/spouses income for tax credit and universal credit purposes even if in reality you are financially independent of each other. People go to prison for basically what Sunak suggests is no ones business but his wifes. It's not Mysogyny to point this out. What they are saving with this non Dom scheme is peanuts to them as billionaires.
Good point - and the Sunaks are living in social housing.
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 08/04/2022 13:48

[quote Clavinova]I also question her non dom status. Is the UK really only a temporary residence and not her “natural home”?

Probably not if Labour/a Labour coalition are in government.

If so we have a Chancellor making far reaching decisions for a country that he plans to leave permanently in a relatively short time. That’s pretty relevant information to the electorate.

Could be worse - some people in Brussels making far reaching decisions for a country they have never lived in. Don't vote for the Lib Dems if you are worried - they want to rejoin the EU.

I'd also point out that for all Labour's noise on the issue, they've been more than happy for the non dom rules to exist throughout all of their periods in Government.

Indeed - are Labour pledging to hand back the £5 million plus they received in donations from Indian steel magnate (and non-dom) Lakshmi Mittal?

In the meantime, I see that shadow chancellor Rachel Reeves had a little telling off by the parliamentary commissioner for standards last week;

order-order.com/2022/04/01/shadow-chancellor-did-break-commons-rules/[/quote]
Labour policy at last election was to abolish non-dom tax treatment.

But don't let the truth get in the way of a bit of Labour bashing.

www.reuters.com/article/uk-britain-politics-labour-nondom-idUKKBN1W60FZ

Volhhg · 08/04/2022 13:46

You have to declare your partner/spouses income for tax credit and universal credit purposes even if in reality you are financially independent of each other. People go to prison for basically what Sunak suggests is no ones business but his wifes. It's not Mysogyny to point this out. What they are saving with this non Dom scheme is peanuts to them as billionaires.

AutumnDays21 · 08/04/2022 13:44

It seems both of them had a US Green Card until 2020 declaring that the US was their permanent home and requiring them to pay US tax on worldwide income.

Who is behind Sunak?

www.theguardian.com/politics/2022/apr/08/rishi-sunak-akshata-murty-us-green-cards

Blossomtoes · 08/04/2022 13:41

are Labour pledging to hand back the £5 million plus they received in donations from Indian steel magnate (and non-dom) Lakshmi Mittal?

That’s a red herring because it’s a totally different issue but are the Tories going to return the donations from Russian oligarchs?

Femalewoman · 08/04/2022 13:38

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

I think it’s different sorry- he just made decisions that made life unbearable for millions and his family pot of money is overflowing and underpaying- I feel no sympathy for either of them
Yep,

Greed. Pure and simple and wrong. He is the chancellor, raising NI contributions for the poorest in society whilst a family member doesn't bother to pay the tax that she should.

The loophole should be closed for both men and women.

Calennig · 08/04/2022 13:35

I did think listening to this "debate"on radio this morning that there was pleanty that Rishi Sunak has done in his role that can be criticized.

I have to also admit some of the comments from Labour about his unelected wife do add to the whole feel that Labour is quite misogynistic.

At same time I don't think have a obviously rich chancellor at this economic time is great optics and it's interesting timing in the Tory party with leadeship murmuring.

But either there's an issue with Non dom status - and these men should also be called out as they have actual positions of influence or there isn't.

Clavinova · 08/04/2022 13:33

I also question her non dom status. Is the UK really only a temporary residence and not her “natural home”?

Probably not if Labour/a Labour coalition are in government.

If so we have a Chancellor making far reaching decisions for a country that he plans to leave permanently in a relatively short time. That’s pretty relevant information to the electorate.

Could be worse - some people in Brussels making far reaching decisions for a country they have never lived in. Don't vote for the Lib Dems if you are worried - they want to rejoin the EU.

I'd also point out that for all Labour's noise on the issue, they've been more than happy for the non dom rules to exist throughout all of their periods in Government.

Indeed - are Labour pledging to hand back the £5 million plus they received in donations from Indian steel magnate (and non-dom) Lakshmi Mittal?

In the meantime, I see that shadow chancellor Rachel Reeves had a little telling off by the parliamentary commissioner for standards last week;

order-order.com/2022/04/01/shadow-chancellor-did-break-commons-rules/

Swipe left for the next trending thread