Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How are people still watch horse racing/going to the races?

160 replies

savedbyanalien · 08/04/2022 08:55

Utterly barbaric 🤮

All this talk about the Grand National this morning.

Watching people ride these beautiful animals for sport, and if the poor beast were to fall, that's it... straight to the vets to be euthanised.

Dressing up and going to the races is gross. And I say this as someone who enjoyed doing this in my early 20s. I'm embarrassed.

Anyone else agree with me or AIBU?

OP posts:
BadLad · 08/04/2022 11:05

@MrsArchchancellorRidcully

I can't wait for the grand national. Love it!!

I'm also a full member of Chester zoo which works hard to protect animals who are at risk of becoming extinct.

Are you going to bet on it?
toastfiend · 08/04/2022 11:02

To be fair, they carry on running and jumping because they're herd animals with a strong flight instinct, if their adrenalin is pumping and all their buddies are galloping one way then they'll gallop with them. It's not for the love of it.

That being said, it's very obvious when they don't have the love for it and those horses will be retired quickly. It's an expensive game, a reluctant horse won't win so pointless keeping them in training.

MrsArchchancellorRidcully · 08/04/2022 11:00

I can't wait for the grand national. Love it!!

I'm also a full member of Chester zoo which works hard to protect animals who are at risk of becoming extinct.

CaveMum · 08/04/2022 11:00

I’ve found the research article I referred to up thread.

Title - Survival Analysis of Training Methodologies and Other Risk Factors for Musculoskeletal Injury in 2-Year-Old Thoroughbred Racehorses in Queensland, Australia.

“The age that training commenced also affected the hazard of MSI and DMD, with increasing age associated with a higher hazard of injury. This finding is consistent with a previous study reporting a higher hazard of DMD in horses that commenced training at 21 months and above older than (91). In contrast, another study reported that the age that training commenced did not affect the hazard of DMD (35). The difference in findings may be due to the case definition of DMD. The case definition of DMD in the study by Verheyen et al. (35) included all incident cases of DMD, regardless of the number of training days lost. The case definitions reported by Jackson et al. (91) and the current study were at least five and seven consecutive days lost to training, respectively.”

Link: europepmc.org/article/MED/34796223

There are other studies, which this one cites, that draw the same conclusions but it’s not possible to link to them as they are behind paywalls.

Georgeskitchen · 08/04/2022 10:52

It's important to remember that these horses are bred for jumping and if you watch when a jockey is unseated those horses will carry in running and jumping with the rest iof the field

Nicholethejewellery · 08/04/2022 10:48

YABVU. Horseracing isn't cruel, it's just a bit of fun and is exercise for the horse. You can't force a horse to race, they have free will. There are regularly cases of horses declining to race - if they lock their legs in position, a group of fully trained handlers can fail to move them. Thoroughbreds that aren't inclined to race are quickly diverted to other activities, be that showjumping, police work or being utilised as part of the animal food industry. I believe historically they could also find a use in the glue-making business though synthetic substances have made this less of a career option now.

I'd certainly agree with you that individuals shouldn't be able to keep horses. All horses should be stabled with registered trainers and should not be available for people to just buy because they fancy having a horse to ride. But horses involved in racing benefit from the highest welfare standards of any horses. (Police horses are well looked after too of course but risk attacks from the public.)

The Grand National is a wonderful event and it's no wonder it's one of the highlights of the sporting calendar. My tips this year are Santini 40/1 and Fortescue 28/1, back them each way with a bookmaker who pays out at least 7 places.

TurningUpMyStereotype · 08/04/2022 10:48

And pray tell what do you propose we do with the horses that no longer have a use? Rough estimates are that there are about 8,000 broodmares, 200 stallions, 4,200 foals, 4,300 yearlings and then 7,500 horses in training as we speak.

This isn’t a valid argument to continue the cruelty. People also use it for continuing to eat meat. We can break the cycle, but people don’t want to because their wants come first. I rescue animals, my friend specifically rescues horses, some of us care about the animals, not the cash they can make us. Humans are hugely flawed, the things we value are wrong.

Cryofthecurlew · 08/04/2022 10:38

I’ve been round horses including race horses all my life. Whilst I accept that very significant injury and death do occur in racing (of all types) and during training the idea that horses don’t enjoy it or are being forced to race is absolute rubbish. No horse can be forced to race and most trainers quickly recognise those who just aren’t going too. I also believe that horses are happier doing the job they were bred to do rather than being kept as pets living an idle life amd often in unsuitable conditions and ultimately. I would rather a horse died doing what it loves doing and was bred to do than it is kept in unsuitable conditions; thoroughbreds and their cousins Arabs are the formula 1 of the of the horse world and need competent handling/riding and care.
Having said all of this I do have concerns about the way many horses are kept, horses are herd animals and have evolved to eat grass/fibre and to be constantly on the move, cooping a horse (be it a race horse riding school horse or Olympic dressage horse) in a 12’ x12’ box and feeding in a diet that it has not evolved to eat and often over feeding that inappropriate diet rigging horses excessively and separating it from other horses by barriers has a physical and mental detrimental and results in habits that if we see in zoo animals concern us and an greater increase in a whole of variety of physical conditions.
But people both those of own and ride horses and those who know nothing about then see this as desirable and acceptable and often because it’s done because we “love” them.

Pumpfive · 08/04/2022 10:37

When I was a child, we owned a race horse and the horse broke its leg and it wasn't put down. My parents part owned the race horse with a few others, one of whom owned a farm and they kept the horse.

CaveMum · 08/04/2022 10:37

@TurningUpMyStereotype

Definitely, but you can never eliminate risk in it’s entirety.

Well you can. Ban it.

And pray tell what do you propose we do with the horses that no longer have a use? Rough estimates are that there are about 8,000 broodmares, 200 stallions, 4,200 foals, 4,300 yearlings and then 7,500 horses in training as we speak.
Pellewsmate · 08/04/2022 10:36

I don't follow racing and only every catch glimpses of it while switching channels, but from what I've seen it appears that some horses enjoy it, otherwise why would they continue once the jockey has fallen off? I feel the same when people complain about Crufts, some of those dogs appear to be having the time of lives. I personally consider running a complete waste of calories but judging by the thousands that enter marathons some people must enjoy it.

Lucimaya · 08/04/2022 10:35

Each to their own but these days the attendees seem to care more about drinking lots of alcohol and tacky outfits. It's more a drinks fest.

CaveMum · 08/04/2022 10:33

@thetemptationofchocolate

Lots of people who go racing (as punters) don't really know much about horses. So they don't know that they don't finish growing until they are 5 or 6. Horses are raced on the flat at 2 years old, they are started with a rider as yearlings. That's far too young IMO and it's no surprise to me that many don't last. It isn't just their physical maturity that's in question but they are still babies at 2 - it would be like making a 6 year old child do competitive sport. Imagine the mental damage that can be done. I used to go racing quite often, but I don't go now. Maybe I am just being sentimental in my old age but I can't bear to watch now.
There has been research done showing that racing at a younger age actually prevents injuries as the horse grows older. Of course I can’t for the life of me find the link to the research (it was done in AUS/NZ) but if I can find it I’ll post a link.
CaveMum · 08/04/2022 10:30

Just to add, as others have said, racing happens almost every single day in the UK - off the top of my head there are 3 days with no racing this year - 23-25 December.

With that volume of racing there are inevitably injuries and sadly fatalities. The fatality rate in British Racing in 2021 was 0.21% which equated to 216 horses from 91,287 runs.

deadlanguage · 08/04/2022 10:29

@MiniTheMinx

Unless you are vegan, use only products not tested on animals, and happy not to take medication when ill then I find this over sentimental vomiting a bit hysterical.
Vegans take medication. Being vegan is about avoiding the exploitation and suffering of animals wherever possible. It’s not possible for most people to never take medication, but horse racing is wholly optional. Not the same thing at all.
EdgyNeonAnt · 08/04/2022 10:28

It is awful, YANBU. Would much rather see the people who still bet on it regardless being made to run round and jump obstacles, now that would be entertaining!

Ahgoonyegirlye · 08/04/2022 10:26

‘ If 6 runners had died in the 100m sprint since 2011, it wouldn't be done anymore.

Why are our lives more important than theirs?’

Is that a serious question? Presumably you’re a vegan then?

TurningUpMyStereotype · 08/04/2022 10:24

Definitely, but you can never eliminate risk in it’s entirety.

Well you can. Ban it.

thetemptationofchocolate · 08/04/2022 10:23

Lots of people who go racing (as punters) don't really know much about horses. So they don't know that they don't finish growing until they are 5 or 6. Horses are raced on the flat at 2 years old, they are started with a rider as yearlings. That's far too young IMO and it's no surprise to me that many don't last.
It isn't just their physical maturity that's in question but they are still babies at 2 - it would be like making a 6 year old child do competitive sport. Imagine the mental damage that can be done.
I used to go racing quite often, but I don't go now. Maybe I am just being sentimental in my old age but I can't bear to watch now.

CaveMum · 08/04/2022 10:21

I’ll bite. I work in racing, it’s the second most popular spectator sport in the U.K. and brings in millions for the U.K. economy.

Is racing perfect? No. Is it the height of depravity? Also no.

I’m not a big fan of the National, I’m a Flat person really, but it is part and parcel of our sport. The National is nothing like the race it was 20 years ago, heck if you saw some of the fences 50 years ago you’d be horrified! Can we do more to make it, and racing in general, safer? Definitely, but you can never eliminate risk in it’s entirety.

BadLad · 08/04/2022 10:18

@TurningUpMyStereotype

Says who? Isle of Man TT racing still happens despite a number of fatalities comparable to six since 2011.

There’s a difference between humans that choose to take risks and animals that get no choice. I’m actually Manx and there are people who would like to see it banned due to the fatalities as well as the disruption it causes to the island.

I understand that. I'm contradicting the point that an event involving people would have been banned if it had caused six fatalities in a decade.
AllOfUsAreDead · 08/04/2022 10:15

[quote savedbyanalien]**@AllOfUsAreDead* This. So many aspects of your life only occur because of cruelty to animals. Not saying its fine, it's really not, but you're getting hysterical over one thing and it's not even the biggest offender in animal cruelty, by a long shot.*

Where have I said this is the only act against animals I'm against?

I'm only talking about it now because the grand National is on this weekend and it's in the news. [/quote]
Make some more threads on the other aspects of animal cruelty then I'll believe you. Otherwise it is just another one of those where people act all outraged and then get distracted by the next thing to be outraged on and forget about this.

TurningUpMyStereotype · 08/04/2022 10:15

Says who? Isle of Man TT racing still happens despite a number of fatalities comparable to six since 2011.

There’s a difference between humans that choose to take risks and animals that get no choice. I’m actually Manx and there are people who would like to see it banned due to the fatalities as well as the disruption it causes to the island.

bluebeau · 08/04/2022 10:14

YABVU imo OP

Everyone involved in horse racing loves the horses, you can see that with the jockeys, trainers, owners at every race . The animals are looked after extremely well and these are RACE horses and they enjoy doing it.

I hate seeing horses fall but as someone mentioned above it's not actually as common as you think. I wish they didn't put them down afterwards but I can see why they do.

I'm sure it also can improve in areas of welfare but its hardly barbaric

toastfiend · 08/04/2022 10:14

Your point re: why are our lives more important to theirs applies to my point about leisure riding and private horse ownership, too - I wouldn't want to live in miserable conditions with my mental and physical needs not being met, but no one ever says a word about that aspect of the equestrian world, probably because that would mean they'd feel uncomfortable about taking their little darlings to the local riding school or pony trekking whilst on holiday.