Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How are people still watch horse racing/going to the races?

160 replies

savedbyanalien · 08/04/2022 08:55

Utterly barbaric 🤮

All this talk about the Grand National this morning.

Watching people ride these beautiful animals for sport, and if the poor beast were to fall, that's it... straight to the vets to be euthanised.

Dressing up and going to the races is gross. And I say this as someone who enjoyed doing this in my early 20s. I'm embarrassed.

Anyone else agree with me or AIBU?

OP posts:
deadlanguage · 08/04/2022 15:10

@BadLad I’m not sure what the issue is. I added a related point to what she was saying. Conversation also works by expanding on points raised by others.

Sixlegsfoward88 · 08/04/2022 15:08

The image of that fat bastard Gordon Elliott sat on a dead horse that died on his gallops should be printed on every ticket so these people can see what industry they're supporting.

It's insulting to suggest that Gordon Elliott is in any way representative of the industry. There was no greater disgust in reaction to his behaviour than from the people I know from within the racing industry.

Carpy88999 · 08/04/2022 15:05

There was a panorama called 'the dark side of racing' a few years ago. Poor horses getting shipped over from Ireland to British abattoirs and all they did to deserve it was not be very good at racing.

The image of that fat bastard Gordon Elliott sat on a dead horse that died on his gallops should be printed on every ticket so these people can see what industry they're supporting.

Whattodoniw · 08/04/2022 15:04

@toastfiend

Most fallers aren't "sent straight to the vet to be euthanised" - most are a bit stiff for a few days and then are fine. 6 horses have died in the Grand National since 2011, of course that's very sad, but it's not the massacre you're portraying it to be.

I support the racing industry. It's a big source of employment in lots of areas, it does a lot for the equestrian world as a whole (the veterinary facilities in Newmarket are breathtaking in what they can do, developed specifically for the racing industry but available to regular horse owners as well, and I'm so grateful for that after having a horse with a complex neurological issue referred to them) and the horses are treated like kings whilst in training. Having had multiple ex-racers, I am saddened that some ex-racehorses aren't offered any guarantees of responsible rehoming after their careers by more unscrupulous trainers and owners, but more and more is being done to combat this and they are finally being recognised as extremely useful and able horses outside of racing, achieving sensible prices on the market so they can't just be bought by people who wanted a cheap horse but don't have the money, or knowledge, to keep them.

I have far, far more of a problem with aspects of the leisure riding and private horse ownership industry, where people who know nothing about horse ownership and appropriate care buy ponies they don't know how to look after and keep them in miserable conditions, enormously overweight people ride horses they're too heavy for and then wonder why they've got back problems, idiots who over rug and over feed in the name of "love" and riding school horses who plod around the same arena for 4 hours a day having their mouths pulled, backs bounced on and ribs booted by people who don't know any better. Of course everyone has to learn, but life in a riding school is hard and boring for horses and ponies and it can go on for decades, at least racing is a relatively short career. Those things are far more prevalent and far more damaging overall, but no one ever says anything about them.

Excellent post

Cryofthecurlew · 08/04/2022 15:01

I’ve been round animals all my life I’ve no problems with eating meat or horses racing but it’s the way it’s managed is what that bothers me. If we didn’t eat meat then we wouldnt have cows sheep pigs etc we would stop breeding them and as species they would die out. I find this unacceptable where I live native cattle and been used to improve the environment bringing back species of plants birds and invertebrates that have not been seen for many years. The grazing of chalk meadows in a low input low output farming has encouraged many species of plant including rare orchids to return. It is possible to get a balance the same is true for race horses.
There is nothing wrong with humanely euthanising a cow sheep pig or horse and indeed eating all four if you want but it’s the quality of the life that they lead before that needs to improved.

TurningUpMyStereotype · 08/04/2022 15:01

Again, the supermarkets comment really isn’t the gotcha moment that you think it is.

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 08/04/2022 14:58

@latriciamcneal

Same reason they still eat meat and dairy; comfortable denial of the horror they cause for animals in favour of personal enjoyment, convenience or habit.
Oh yay a preachy vegan 🥱. Yet every supermarket you shop in funds these industries. Just saying🤷‍♀️.
TurningUpMyStereotype · 08/04/2022 14:55

I just curious I do accept the chances are small but if you did end up in hospital because you didn’t have your vaccine because of your stance?

Then it would no longer be possible or practical for me to not have treatment. But if there was a treatment not tested on animals, I’d choose that one.

I genuinely don’t get people’s issues with people that want to minimise cruelty to animals.

BadLad · 08/04/2022 14:52

@deadlanguage

Where did I say she was wrong?
as if as if as if

Just in case you missed it,

as if.

You didn't explicitly say she was wrong, you posted as if she was wrong. That's generally how argumentative discussion works, one person makes a point, and then someone makes a counterpoint as if they were wrong.

Somebody else brought people's competing in events to the discussion. They said that six human fatalities in a decade would mean that an event would be cancelled. They even went as far as to use as broad an event as the 100m. Newuser82 pointed out that this was not true because if that were the case marathons would now be banned.

Horses not consenting to being raced is a completely separate point and in no way contradicts Newuser82's point.

LINABE · 08/04/2022 14:51

People generally are too lazy to think about the consequences of things and just don't give a shit.

Cryofthecurlew · 08/04/2022 14:51

I just curious I do accept the chances are small but if you did end up in hospital because you didn’t have your vaccine because of your stance?

Sunflower987 · 08/04/2022 14:49

@veronicagoldberg

You misjudge humanity's empathy. Most people just don't give a fuck about others, animal or human.
This^^
TurningUpMyStereotype · 08/04/2022 14:47

So as you’ve significantly increased your risk of getting and Covid abs ending up in hospital will you decline any treatment because it’s tested on animals?
Or maybe that’s another thread

Not that my medical choices are any of your business, but I weighed up my chance of being seriously ill against having the vaccine and decided against it. I had covid recently, felt rough, but was fine. The chances of me being seriously ill as a very fit and healthy 40 ish year old were/are tiny. As I said, vegans avoid animal products as far as possible and practical. HTH.

deadlanguage · 08/04/2022 14:43

Where did I say she was wrong?

BadLad · 08/04/2022 14:41

You're saying that as if @Newuser82 was wrong in her post. They were not wrong - they were pointing out that someone else's point was wrong.

Your point is completely separate.

deadlanguage · 08/04/2022 14:38

@BadLad

People choose for themselves to compete in the marathon, the same is not the case for racehorses.

A little bit of thought would have made it obvious to you that when she was talking about the London Marathon, she was contradicting this:

If 6 runners had died in the 100m sprint since 2011, it wouldn't be done anymore

Yes, and the point is that’s fine (albeit sad) because because humans make our own choice and risk assessment, but animals don’t exactly sign themselves up.
Cryofthecurlew · 08/04/2022 14:37

”only had vaccinations in childhood”
So as you’ve significantly increased your risk of getting and Covid abs ending up in hospital will you decline any treatment because it’s tested on animals?
Or maybe that’s another thread Grin.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 08/04/2022 14:35

My grandfather worked with horses all his life. He was a stablehand in the Camden underground stables before WWI, lied about his age to join up and then looked after what could be termed the Warhorses. After surviving (barely, but at least the Germans dug him out from underneath bits of horse, stuck a metal plate in his head and then fed and clothed him until he was freed from a POW camp shortly after Armistice Day), he continued to work with horses.

He had a story of how he and the other stable hands thrashed a drunk jockey for being cruel to the horses (now about 100 years ago) and the boss just decided to studiously ignore the summary justice. They loved the horses and did all they could to keep them safe, well and happy.

He wasn't a fan of the National because of how dangerous it was for the horses - he felt that it was too much of a risk for them. And he clearly despised the use of whips in the way they were used for racing. He also detested hunting, as that was a meaningless activity based upon cruelty when, as he put it 'a shotgun's more use than a red jacket if you're trying to keep foxes out of the chickens'. Hunting Otters made him incandescent with fury, coursing was 'a bloody pointless activity when you could use those dogs to catch a couple of rabbits for dinner' and he never quite forgave my grandmother for buying fur coats following a legacy as they were 'for vanity, not warmth' and used to refer to her coats as 'those poor bloody dead things in your wardrobe'.

However, what he also said was that some horses need to race. They love it. You can see the ones who love it beforehand - their ears are up, the energy is obvious; they're excited, they're happy, they know what's coming and they can't wait to do it. And whilst some love the flat, some love going over sticks.

For him, the issue was the money and who he called the Bastards. They were the ones who didn't care if horses were injured as long as they won. They were the ones who made the jumps too big because the punters wanted it to be more exciting and would pay to see horses taking greater risks, not really caring about the deaths other than if they meant the loss of a stake. They were the ones who didn't really give a shit about horses or racing but wanted to go to dress up (presumably in their poor bloody dead things), eat fancy food and never actually look anywhere near the course.

I think he'd approve of the way pressure has been applied to make jumps safer and the changes in animal welfare legislation - but he'd also say that it still isn't enough - the money involved ensures that it isn't enough, but whilst people are prepared to bet more than they have on a particular colour of silk, there will still be too many life ending injuries.

He didn't want racing to end altogether, though - he'd already witnessed the near extinction of heavy horse breeds due to their not being needed anymore and horses were his life and love; the world would be a lesser place without them. He'd have nothing but contempt for people who would say 'so what?' or 'good, they shouldn't have existed in the first place' or 'well, they might die in pain so it's better that they never existed'.

But then again, people who have actually witnessed death on a battlefield tend to feel differently about things compared to those who have never known anything more than a little discomfort and existential angst from a position of absolute affluence.

Cryofthecurlew · 08/04/2022 14:33

I think some loss is inevitable but that applies to all horses and friends eventer heading for Badminton slipped on the road busted it’s front tendon and had to be destroyed. But we can reduce loss I’ve seen unfit horses at point to point meetings making them more prone to injury, poorly bred horses it’s hard to breed a Derby winner but you’re definitely not going to breed one if you breed rubbish with rubbish, horses bred from with shockingly bad confirmation and temperament, age limits need to be raised to encourage trainers to back horses when they are older and more safely measure need to be introduced at race courses. Money is being put into retraining of race horses but probably more need to be done and those who can’t be retrained should be humanely destroyed in the environment they are familiar with.

TurningUpMyStereotype · 08/04/2022 14:33

Don't be ridiculous. Everything has been tested on animals. Maybe the conpany that produces the products you use didn't do it themselves but, at some point in history some company tested every ingredient in there on animals. Therefore allowing every other company to claim "not tested on animals".
Are you vaccinated? Have you drunk alcohol? Do you use gas energy? All of these products were tested and are still being on animals for possible long term side effects.

Vegans avoid animal products as far as is possible and practical. I don’t know why people try to do this ‘gotcha’ thing with people that try to minimise their negative impact to animals. I don’t drink alcohol and only had vaccinations in childhood.

Newuser82 · 08/04/2022 14:32

@BadLad

People choose for themselves to compete in the marathon, the same is not the case for racehorses.

A little bit of thought would have made it obvious to you that when she was talking about the London Marathon, she was contradicting this:

If 6 runners had died in the 100m sprint since 2011, it wouldn't be done anymore

👍🏻🙈
ForTheLoveOfSleep · 08/04/2022 14:23

@TurningUpMyStereotype

Unless you are vegan, use only products not tested on animals, and happy not to take medication when ill then I find this over sentimental vomiting a bit hysterical.

I am vegan and obviously don’t use products tested on animals. As for medication, I’m fortunate enough not to have needed any since I became vegan many years ago. I campaign to stop animal testing though, at the moment people have no alternative which isn’t their fault.

Don't be ridiculous. Everything has been tested on animals. Maybe the conpany that produces the products you use didn't do it themselves but, at some point in history some company tested every ingredient in there on animals. Therefore allowing every other company to claim "not tested on animals". Are you vaccinated? Have you drunk alcohol? Do you use gas energy? All of these products were tested and are still being on animals for possible long term side effects.
ronjobbins · 08/04/2022 14:22

@MiniTheMinx

Unless you are vegan, use only products not tested on animals, and happy not to take medication when ill then I find this over sentimental vomiting a bit hysterical.
Behave Hmm
CrotchetyQuaver · 08/04/2022 14:21

Racehorses live like kings, it costs vast amounts to breed them and keep them in training. Those that are entered for a race are thoroughly prepared in advance, if there's any doubt in the day that they're maybe not fit to run then they'll be pulled. ANYTHING to do with horses carries a risk which their connections are fully aware of. Don't think for one minute that people don't give a damn if the worst happens, you couldn't be more wrong.

No I don't think it's "barbaric" but each to their own. Only clever brave bold horses would run the national and many of those that do go on to have wonderful lives post racing. One old horse I knew who had run in the GN had a wonderful life as a working horse for many years, loved his new job, met the Queen a few more times and the day he didn't want to do it any more aged 25 his owner did what was necessary. And was very sad about it even though it was inevitable that day would come. He would never have been happy rotting in a field being retired. A truly exceptional horse and I would think that applies to all the runners.

Cryofthecurlew · 08/04/2022 14:21

”I’m not sure how easy it it to retrain a racehorse to an eventer or a riding school horse.”
A lot depends on if they are flat horses or hurdlers. IME and other those that run on the flat especially those that run over short distances are often difficult to retrain and highly unlikely to ever settle as riding school horses because as a general principle the standard of the average rider in your average riding school is pretty low. Riding stables have liability insurance and owners have to ensure horses provided are exceedingly safe. Hurdlers are easier and point to pointers even easier to retrain but again many will be happy or suitable in a riding school environment. Thoroughbreds did make good eventers but the tough requirements of eventing mean that good confirmation particularly legs and feet, no previous tendon injuries all problems seen in ex race horse means that many are not suitable. Secondly the emphasis now placed on dressage and the changes in course design now increasingly favours warm bloods.
Of course there are exceptions but generally retraining and rehoming ex racehorses is not a doddle it requires consistent knowledgeable training and a competent rider.