Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child doesn't seem to like nanny?

53 replies

AdifferentGoat · 08/04/2022 08:33

Simple as that. My child is approx one and a half years old and protests when nanny takes over so I can head to work. For context, I have unusual hours so a nanny fits in better as opposed to nursery (for now).

I really like our nanny, she has a ton of experience but is also very caring. She's older as far as nannies go and she was honest in the interview and stated this had been a problem when she was interviewing. Age wasn't a problem for me and I liked her immediately. But the constant howling from DD irks me and I do feel bad for nanny as well.

From my end, I stay out of nanny's hair when I'm working from home and I trust her to do her job without interference from me. We will talk and sometimes she'll make suggestions or vice versa - in essence we have a good relationship.

DD is my first child so I'm a bit new to ' each age' it happens. In interests of avoiding dripfeeds, nanny has been with us for around eight months (give or take a month).

I don't know what I'm asking her but is it normal for a child to protest this much? In fairness to nanny there are times DD is happy with her but approx 70% of the time, DD gets upset when nanny is around. Could it be DD is protesting as knows nanny taking over means mummy is leaving? I don't know. She has given me no reason to distrust her.

OP posts:
KylieCharlene · 08/04/2022 08:52

I'd not be comfortable leaving my DD with her, sorry.
How is your dd with other wider family members/friends?
Is she like this with other people?
You and nanny may have a good relationship but the reason you've employed her is to look after your dd and it isn't working out well.
I may like the woman but I'd not feel comfortable knowing my DD was unhappy and at an age where she can't really tell me why.
Eight months is a long time and your dd should really have formed a relationship with her by now.
If it was a couple of weeks then, yes, understandable- but it's been nearly half of your dd's lifetime that this woman has been with you.
What does nanny say about your dd's relationship with her?
I think if I'd been looking after your dd all these months and we were still having issues I'd have come to you and maybe said something about this not working out.
It can't be pleasant for her.

AdifferentGoat · 08/04/2022 08:37

To add to above, I can see it hurts nanny's feelings too (DD is vocal with her NO). I have tried to help them bond but having nanny give her treats and I talk well of her to DD. DD also sees that nanny and I have a warm relationship so I'm stumped!

OP posts:
DragonMovie · 08/04/2022 08:37

In my experience, this is absolutely how it is when both mum and childcare are in the house. I don’t have an experience with nannies but my sister has a friend who looks after her 2y2m daughter and she cries as soon as she comes in the door even when it’s just a social visit. It’s one of the advantages of nursery - mum is out of sight and out of mind for the children and they settle quickly each day and eventually aren’t unsettled at all (for lots of kids). Other kids are just more attached to mummy. I find that my son is happier to go to nursery when I’ve spent quality time with him in the Eve or morning and when this isn’t possible he’s much more clingy.