Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think nursery should pay?

87 replies

Oneshoetwoshoe · 07/04/2022 22:13

NC for this.

Our one year old came home from nursery with only one of her two very first shoes. The nursery was expecting Ofsted the next day so had had a huge clear out. They have subsequently searched high and low and emailed all the parents.

They're a lovely nursery, our baby is happy there and we're really lucky with our baby's key workers. They have both contacted us and offered to buy her a new pair together, which is really kind. However, we emailed the nursery, concerned that they appeared to be having to do so out of their own money, when we thought it was something that the nursery should pay, as a company, rather than what would be an hour's wage for two of their employees. Especially as one is very junior and the other pregnant.

Nursery have replied, telling us to clearly label our baby's clothes and that it isn't their policy to pay for missing property, as it isn't with other nurseries or schools. I get that with schools, when the children are responsible for their own things and I would never assume so with clothes, bags or coats etc, but shoes? I also don't really see how labelling would have helped in this case.

Either way, I don't know enough- really happy to be told IABU. I'm just sad we've lost one of her very first shoes, sad that we might have to buy more unnecessarily, given our financial situation and frustrated that it doesn't feel like the nursery are valuing their staff or responsibilities.

OP posts:
Stompythedinosaur · 07/04/2022 23:44

Items get lost sometimes at childcare. It is just one of those things. If you had your dc with you all the time, things would also get lost and need replacing. It is just one of those things that happens.

Clearly not appropriate for low paid employees to pay for new shoes though.

RussianSpy101 · 07/04/2022 23:43

YABU to expect them to pay. YABU to not label every item that goes to nursery aswell.

Just buy new shoes.

@nightsoutasap complete overkill. Would never expect an item to be replaced due to an toileting accident. Is it really financially sustainable for you to do that for each child who has an accident?

Brett239 · 07/04/2022 23:39

No, the nursery is not responsible. Buy a few pairs so you have spares.

Loginmystery · 07/04/2022 23:38

@Giraffesandbottoms

Don’t buy second hand shoes - they are moulded to the feet of the previous owner and that’s not actually good. Shoes are one of the things you definitely should not buy second hand. And should buy quality.

I think YANBU. They lost the shoe and should replace it!

I agree with this completely. I would never buy second hand shoes for the reason above and also I think the nursery should be able to pay for the shoes.
Holskey · 07/04/2022 23:36

Only send your child to nursery in clothes you don't mind being lost or ruined

Um no, I'm not prepared to lose a shoe. I don't think we should have the expectation that shoes will go missing and that we should just buy new ones.

OP Yanbu

WhereHasSpringSprungTo · 07/04/2022 23:26

My dcs nursery stipulated to label everything inc pants and vests.
Id just leave it. It was nice of the workers to offer but i wouldn't accept nor would i expect the nursery to pay.
Common sense says to at least label expensive items.

Ps you can get printed labels specifically for shoes

Kanaloa · 07/04/2022 23:25

@Tumbleweed101

Labelling really helps everyone. If your child is there for a long day they may not be with the same staff you handed them to at the end of the day. I often end up with children I don't care for during the main part of the day at the end of the day and have no idea whose coat/shoes is who. I just hope my colleagues have kept everything in the right place.
But surely (well when I’ve worked in childcare) if you pick up a shoe you don’t go ‘oh no label. Oh well, bin it.’

You look at all the babies in the room, see who has shoes on, see one baby has only one shoe and it’s the same as the one you’re holding, and put it on that child/put both shoes in that child’s bag. Or ask around, or put it in the post and found. You don’t just throw a shoe in the bin.

Bunnycat101 · 07/04/2022 23:25

nightsoutasap Like another poster has said that was lovely of you but I don’t think you needed to. I expect my toddlers to have accidents and that means they might wee on their shoes. I don’t think that was your responsibility to replace at all. There have been a fair few times I’ve picked up my youngest and she’s left in wellies as her shoes had been antibacked and drying after an accident.

Wineat5isfine · 07/04/2022 23:22

Oh good lord 🤦🏼‍♀️

Kanaloa · 07/04/2022 23:22

@Sherrystrull

Only send your child to nursery in clothes you don't mind being lost or ruined.
Really? I’ve worked in nurseries for years and yes you have to accept that clothes may get paint or messy play on them but you shouldn’t just be resigned to shoes being thrown away. I would expect a parent to be pretty annoyed if their kid came to nursery with two shoes and went home with one - and as for be prepared to lose them most people can’t afford a new pair of shoes every time nursery loses a pair.
FruitToast · 07/04/2022 23:09

I wouldn't expect nursery to pay. A 1 year old can't be responsible for their shoes but neither can nursery workers if they weren't labelled and therefore they don't know who they belong to, staff take breaks and staff have to room swap throughout the day to maintain ratios. We label EVERYTHING (even the £1 Primark sunglasses) that goes into nursery and it normally finds its way home, albeit sometimes a week or 2 later. Take this as a learning experience, replace with some cheap Asda first walkers for nursery shoes, get yourself some stick in name tags and NEVER send anything expensive or with sentimental value to nursery.

MyOtherProfile · 07/04/2022 23:05

Bit worrying they were having a big clear out for ofsted. The inspection comes at short notice now so this doesn't happen and they get a glimpse of normal life at the setting.

AWombleScorned · 07/04/2022 22:59

YABU

froi · 07/04/2022 22:58

@nightsoutasap

I own a day nursery and I would replace as they have clearly been thrown away in error. In fact, I recently replaced a pair (of bloody expensive) shoes as a child wet themselves which went in the shoes. Obviously not our fault, but the goodwill gesture goes a long way
That's very kind but I would say totally overkill! (Unless the child wet themselves due to negligence or forgetting a nappy for some reason, which I assume it wasn't!)
froi · 07/04/2022 22:55

Whilst I generally agree with 'don't sent them to nursery in anything you would care if it got ruined', shoes are different.

If a child is at nursery on a regular basis they should be wearing properly fitted shoes, which are unlikely to be 'cheap' or 'something you'd be happy to lose'. What's the point in getting properly fitted supportive shoes, and sending them in wearing ill-fitted cheap shoes, just in case they get lost? Especially when nursery can be up to 5 days a week- they would spend 5 days in crappy shoes and only 2 days in proper shoes.

So I'm with you OP, that the principle is rubbish. I would bite the bullet and replace them myself rather than ask the staff to though.

AppleKatie · 07/04/2022 22:53

Whilst i agree that you should expect things to come out of nursery covered in paint and occasionally wee! Water bottles and cardigans get lost etc…

Shoes not so much. They should be taken off a one year old whilst they are inside and securely stored for when they are needed. Shoes are expensive and necessary and a 1 year old is not developmentally capable of caring for them themselves. They must have been taken off by an adult and not stored correctly - therefore the nursery is at fault and should pay.

Dontfuckingsaycheese · 07/04/2022 22:49

Is your baby walking outside?? Until then we didn’t have shoes anyway.

Giraffesandbottoms · 07/04/2022 22:47

@mrsrobinsonshandprints

We are designed not to wear shoes and more expensive ones have better measures in place to mimic what the foot needs more, as opposed to cheap shoes which have flat soles and no support. Expensive shoes have more of a shape to them and more support to help

nightsoutasap · 07/04/2022 22:47

I own a day nursery and I would replace as they have clearly been thrown away in error. In fact, I recently replaced a pair (of bloody expensive) shoes as a child wet themselves which went in the shoes. Obviously not our fault, but the goodwill gesture goes a long way

Tumbleweed101 · 07/04/2022 22:45

Labelling really helps everyone. If your child is there for a long day they may not be with the same staff you handed them to at the end of the day. I often end up with children I don't care for during the main part of the day at the end of the day and have no idea whose coat/shoes is who. I just hope my colleagues have kept everything in the right place.

Bunnycat101 · 07/04/2022 22:43

So in all of the years my two have been at nursery they have never lost a single item. School and summer camps we’ve lost tons of stuff especially cardigans, hats, water bottles etc. I would be really cross about a shoe going missing from a child in the baby room but I would not be allowing key workers to pay for it.

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 07/04/2022 22:40

@Giraffesandbottoms

Don’t buy second hand shoes - they are moulded to the feet of the previous owner and that’s not actually good. Shoes are one of the things you definitely should not buy second hand. And should buy quality.

I think YANBU. They lost the shoe and should replace it!

See I don't believe this, buying expensive shoes as they are better for your feet is I think a marketing ploy. We were designed to not wear shoes, lots of issues we have created by wearing shoes.

But op, no I don't think nursery should pay

Mummy1608 · 07/04/2022 22:39

You can get shoe labels. I would label everything from now on.

We've also lost stuff at nursery but only when it was unlabelled. I still don't label everything but I label stuff I don't want to lose

gingergiraffe · 07/04/2022 22:35

Personally, I agree with what others have said about not sending your child to nursery with clothes that you would worry about being spoilt or lost, but shoes? These are expensive if you get them fitted and I can’t understand why just the one would go missing. Surely the staff or parent checked the child at the end of the day? I think the actual nursery should pay to replace them.

transformandriseup · 07/04/2022 22:31

I think I may have felt the same as OP when I first sent my baby to nursery especially as shoes are so expensive but now she is almost three her clothes are forever getting covered in paint or come back with holes in. I wouldn't expect anyone to replace anything lost or damaged when I can just send her in old clothes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread