Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think nursery should pay?

87 replies

Oneshoetwoshoe · 07/04/2022 22:13

NC for this.

Our one year old came home from nursery with only one of her two very first shoes. The nursery was expecting Ofsted the next day so had had a huge clear out. They have subsequently searched high and low and emailed all the parents.

They're a lovely nursery, our baby is happy there and we're really lucky with our baby's key workers. They have both contacted us and offered to buy her a new pair together, which is really kind. However, we emailed the nursery, concerned that they appeared to be having to do so out of their own money, when we thought it was something that the nursery should pay, as a company, rather than what would be an hour's wage for two of their employees. Especially as one is very junior and the other pregnant.

Nursery have replied, telling us to clearly label our baby's clothes and that it isn't their policy to pay for missing property, as it isn't with other nurseries or schools. I get that with schools, when the children are responsible for their own things and I would never assume so with clothes, bags or coats etc, but shoes? I also don't really see how labelling would have helped in this case.

Either way, I don't know enough- really happy to be told IABU. I'm just sad we've lost one of her very first shoes, sad that we might have to buy more unnecessarily, given our financial situation and frustrated that it doesn't feel like the nursery are valuing their staff or responsibilities.

OP posts:
Hiddenvoice · 08/04/2022 09:31

The keyworkers should not have offered to pay for the shoes.
Where are the shoes kept during the day?
Sadly all childrens belongings should be labelled and I wouldn’t send them to nursery with anything you don’t want to get ruined- covered in paint/mud.
Things are easily misplaced and could easily been picked up by another member of staff, child or even parent/caregiver. I don’t think the nursery should pay to replace it.
I understand you’re annoyed and j would complain to them too but I would expect them to replace it.

Dinoteeth · 08/04/2022 09:26

@Bunnycat101

nightsoutasap Like another poster has said that was lovely of you but I don’t think you needed to. I expect my toddlers to have accidents and that means they might wee on their shoes. I don’t think that was your responsibility to replace at all. There have been a fair few times I’ve picked up my youngest and she’s left in wellies as her shoes had been antibacked and drying after an accident.
I agree, I've cleaned shoes after accidents. It happens. I bet if it happened at home mum would clean them.
TabithaHazel · 08/04/2022 09:24

I think if these first shoes were so important for you to keep as a keepsake you shouldn't have sent them into nursery in the first place - especially if they were not labelled. If you had at least labelled them then if they showed up in another kid's bag then they would be able to make their way back to you. I think it's a bit unreasonable for you to even consider wanting the nursery to pay for shoes that your child will probably grow out of in a couple of months anyway.

Anyway, just chalk it up to experience, this is just the beginning of things belonging to your child that will be lost and not a big deal in the grand scheme of things - you can buy relatively cheap but good quality shoes from Sainsburys or Asda these days, so hopefully replacing them won't break your budget this month.

Isonthecase · 08/04/2022 09:19

Unfortunately an expensive but useful lesson for you. Basically don't send your child to nursery in anything you'd be gutted if they lost them, they can't possibly keep track of absolutely everything with so much clothing around that may be special to you but isn't to them. And yes, I know your pain, it still rankles that my child lost one of his lovely fancy shoes on a day out in 2018 🙈

Muchtoomuchtodo · 08/04/2022 09:19

Op’s not coming back are they?

ImustLearn2Cook · 08/04/2022 09:03

How long has this shoe been missing? Is there a possibility that it might be found?

MRex · 08/04/2022 08:54

Old Tshirts are fair game, but shoes aren't throwaway items. I wouldn't make nursery pay, but I would expect an apology and a plan to be more careful with shoes in clear-outs.

DropYourSword · 08/04/2022 08:02

You label EVERYTHING they go in with. Everything. And only ever send them in with cheap stuff.
It's really not realistic to expect them to pay.

AegonT · 08/04/2022 07:59

I would expect nursery (not individual staff) to pay in this situation. They were clearly careless in their clear out. Yes labelling would help but even unlabeled it would be in lost property or at another child's house not in the bin. My children go to school/pre-school/camp in good quality fairly expensive shoes and they've only been lost once (and found again a few days later).

SleepingStandingUp · 08/04/2022 00:32

So you picked her up say I na Wednesday and they had an inspection on the Thursday. So Wednesday when you asked where her shoes were, what did they say? Surely even if they'd been having a sort out, the shoe couldn't have gone far in a few hours?

EliyanahM · 08/04/2022 00:30

Also, my daughter came out of nursery a few months ago wearing wellies, I thought ok, her shoes must have been destroyed, went out bought her new shoes. Easter break and I get handed a plastic bag with her (now far too small) shoes in, stinking of piss. Lol

EliyanahM · 08/04/2022 00:28

Basically the key workers shouldn't have offered to pay, it's not that YABU thinking the nursery should be the ones to pay, because it's only in the scenario that someone other than you is paying, because they offered. But they shouldn't have offered because if they did that every time an item went missing they'd not have any wages left.

thirdfiddle · 08/04/2022 00:26

We only usually had one pair of shoes for toddlers. They shouldn't be going around in badly fitting ones, and properly fitted ones are expensive, and they grow out of them so often. I don't think most people have the money to have multiple pairs of shoes let alone throwaway ones every time a toddler changes size.

thirdfiddle · 08/04/2022 00:23

Not unreasonable. The nursery should pay, not members of staff out of their own pocket. Do you have anything else like trainers or wellies he could wear for a day or two to see if it turns up? Depending on how tight money is I'd try to absorb the cost, but it is on their watch and shoes are not throwaway items for toddlers.

You have now learned that they do take shoes off, so definitely label them. We just have a big pack of those washable sticky labels and stick them on everything. Even in shoes they last long enough - more wear but less washing.

SleepingStandingUp · 08/04/2022 00:17

Is the issue here how much you're spending o shoes for nursery given that replacing them would costs several hours wages? It's nursery, don't NT send them in best stuff, or expensive shoes etc especially given money is tight

medicmummm · 08/04/2022 00:11

DS had “nursery shoes” usually cheaper supermarket ones or Clark’s outlet as they would only be played in and get messy.

DS also lost a school shoe at school once, it was named and they paid for a new pair. Also had a shirt damaged by another child and made the other child buy him a new one! It’s private though if that makes a difference (although nursery also are)

Best of luck… perhaps a cheaper spare pare for nursery are the answer

surreygirl1987 · 08/04/2022 00:05

I think you are being very unreasonable. Things go missing. Those poor staff members thinking they had to pay for it themselves! Staff at my nursery always seem worried when my sons' things go missing / get damaged, but I've made it clear it doesn't matter (and I only send my boys to nursery in cheap second hand things anyway!).

CrabbyCat · 08/04/2022 00:03

We labelled shoes and coats at nursery, but not clothes, I just sent them in older stuff. Shoes we didn't label until we got a message about another child having come home in a mismatching pair of shoes. On checking, we realised it was DS who had the mismatching pair. They were only 0.5 size different and whilst original different coloured (blue and grey) versions of the same model shoes, with dust and dirt on them they looked the same. We'd never have noticed the mix up if the other parent hadn't. From that point on, we labelled, I really hadn't thought previously about how many almost identical shoes a nursery juggles!

BFPDec21 · 08/04/2022 00:02

@Sherrystrull

Only send your child to nursery in clothes you don't mind being lost or ruined.
We quickly came to this realisation and I'd say this is the best advice.

Lots of things get lost at nursery over time and jumpers will get lost at school as well. Did you say anything immediately and wait for them to look the same day?

I think they're right about the labeling and it's one of those things that you'll have to replace yourselves. I wouldn't think of asking them to pay for it.

Notcreativeatall · 07/04/2022 23:54

Were they labelled?
YABU - i actually find it quite sad that the key workers were offering to replace- they are responsible for looking after the child not really her belongings

MrsIglesias · 07/04/2022 23:53

Nurseries are really really struggling right now. Lots are close to closing. Read the latest Early Years Alliance survey. Lost shoe is annoying but won't happen again. There's lots of shoes in charities shops. Id leave it.

Muchtoomuchtodo · 07/04/2022 23:51

Labels or having your dc’s name in the shoe is very likely to have helped in this situation . You don’t mention @Oneshoetwoshoe if they were labelled but the advice that the nursery gave hints that they weren’t.

Also who picked her up and took her home with only one shoe? Things are usually found more easily the same day so why would they have left with just one shoe?

I think you and your partner (if you have one) need to chalk this up to experience and learn from it to avoid a reoccurrence.

ittakes2 · 07/04/2022 23:50

Sorry you need to label your items.

RobynNora · 07/04/2022 23:49

I think YANBU. My young toddler’s last pair of shoes cost £40 and I’d be well peeved if they were thrown in the bin in an Ofsted clear out. I don’t spend much on clothes but never skimp on shoes so I’d be annoyed at that sort of carelessness. The nursery rather than staff should pay, I agree. So nice of them to offer to split costs though

Walkingalot · 07/04/2022 23:48

I still label my DS's stuff and he's at High School, lol. Honestly, this is the first of numerous items being lost. Yes, it's sad, her first shoes, I get it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread