Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think nursery should pay?

87 replies

Oneshoetwoshoe · 07/04/2022 22:13

NC for this.

Our one year old came home from nursery with only one of her two very first shoes. The nursery was expecting Ofsted the next day so had had a huge clear out. They have subsequently searched high and low and emailed all the parents.

They're a lovely nursery, our baby is happy there and we're really lucky with our baby's key workers. They have both contacted us and offered to buy her a new pair together, which is really kind. However, we emailed the nursery, concerned that they appeared to be having to do so out of their own money, when we thought it was something that the nursery should pay, as a company, rather than what would be an hour's wage for two of their employees. Especially as one is very junior and the other pregnant.

Nursery have replied, telling us to clearly label our baby's clothes and that it isn't their policy to pay for missing property, as it isn't with other nurseries or schools. I get that with schools, when the children are responsible for their own things and I would never assume so with clothes, bags or coats etc, but shoes? I also don't really see how labelling would have helped in this case.

Either way, I don't know enough- really happy to be told IABU. I'm just sad we've lost one of her very first shoes, sad that we might have to buy more unnecessarily, given our financial situation and frustrated that it doesn't feel like the nursery are valuing their staff or responsibilities.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Blondeshavemorefun · 08/04/2022 16:26

Course they should replace them

They lost them

Clothes you can send in older stuff

You aren’t going to buy two pairs of shoes at this age as they do grow out of them

Dinoteeth · 08/04/2022 15:38

My only guess is its fallen onto the floor, someone has bunged it in "lost property" and someone else has emptied the "lost property" box in the drive to reduce clutter.

That's the only logical explanation.

Giraffesandbottoms · 08/04/2022 15:26

I do really struggle to understand a reasonable scenario where someone would just carelessly bin a fucking shoe mid week. It doesn’t make a lot of sense to me. Like how much stuff are they binning hurriedly and why?! Where was the shoe? Aren’t they in a cubby? Didn’t they realise at home time that your child had only one shoe?

Crimesean · 08/04/2022 13:30

If you hadn't labelled the shoes then YABU - it'll be in the nursery T&Cs that parents must label everything.

Try Stikins, they're really good on shoes.

TheyCallMeJune · 08/04/2022 13:29

Who in their right mind would just bin a shoe? Let alone one that's clearly brand new!

Ozanj · 08/04/2022 13:24

I own a nursery: we tell parents to label all clothing and shoes. It they don’t then we will not take responsibility for loss. If they do then we’ll cover it fully

Ponderingwindow · 08/04/2022 13:08

You really do need to label every single item. When something drops or gets misplaced, it’s the only way to get the item back to the right child. It’s only going to get harder as they get older.

You can use a pen, but I find custom name labels work better because you can remove them when you want to resell or donate. They also stand out more and are very quick to apply. You can order them in huge packs that will seem expensive, but you need tons of them and the pack will last a long time.

Don’t let the nursery workers replace the shoes. They are ridiculously underpaid.

Even just caring for my one child, I have lost one of her shoes at that age. It just fell off somewhere as we went about our errands one day. I always bought the best for learning to walk soft shoes that only a few brands made back then so they were very expensive. I had to just accept it and buy a new pair. Thankfully she was close enough to moving up a size I could just do it a tiny bit early.

GirlsTalk250 · 08/04/2022 12:55

I think shoes are different from clothes, as the advice is to buy properly fitted shoes for little feet which are expensive. Fine if they get muddy or covered in paint, as they can still be worn, but losing them forces you to buy another expensive new pair.

The nursery was responsible for the shoes, and they lost them. Why should you pay for their carelessness?

Foolsrule · 08/04/2022 12:40

The nursery should not have needed to have a clear-out in advance of Ofsted coming. This raises huge red flags for me.
They should replace the shoes. Most decent independents and some big chains would do this as a matter of course.

TonksInPurple · 08/04/2022 12:17

Collected my daughter from nursery and her shoes in the cloakroom were a size to small and very well worn, some other parent or nursery worker had accidentally or purposefully swapped them. Never got them back it was very annoying.

MRex · 08/04/2022 12:08

It really shouldn't be inevitable for so many clothes to be lost. Mittens and socks - sure, they can easily get caught up in other things. Scrumpled Tshirts and trousers might occasionally get left and put in the lost bucket. Each child however has one pair of shoes and one coat; you might put them on the wrong child, but leaving a child with none and chucking out shoes just sounds utterly chaotic. Ratios at this age are 1 to 3 kids, and "rooms" for this age are 9-12 kids; there isn't a need for the environment to be chaotic and that isn't at all desirable if the goal is happy kids. What else isn't noticed or left as not mattering? DS is older, we've lost and found a lot of mittens (possible some didn't come back, but common to turn back up weeks later) and he's occasionally been put in the wrong coat that we swap back. One toy illegally taken in got briefly lost and then found. That's it; ultimately not so much as a missing T-shirt.

Chasingaftermidnight · 08/04/2022 11:34

I agree with the general principle of not sending anything to nursery that you aren’t prepared to lose, but shoes are different. Children spend a lot of time in them and you should buy decent ones, which cost money. Assuming the parent has labelled them, they should come home from nursery with both shoes.

I agree with you. I think the nursery as a business should replace them as it has obviously been thrown away by mistake. There’s no way in hell I’d allow the keyworkers to replace them out of their own pockets though.

BuffyFanForever · 08/04/2022 11:27

@Soontobe60 have you ever worked with very young children? Believe me they don’t need a football pitch area to lose an item. It’s usually a much beloved item that disappears as if with the fairies! Labelling won’t remove the issue but you’d be surprised how much it can help!

Sherrystrull · 08/04/2022 11:05

@Holskey

Only send your child to nursery in clothes you don't mind being lost or ruined

Um no, I'm not prepared to lose a shoe. I don't think we should have the expectation that shoes will go missing and that we should just buy new ones.

OP Yanbu

Um yes.

I've worked in schools for years and things get lost. Other children take things home by mistake and then don't return them. Things get scooped up with other things and misplaced. It happens.

I sent my kids to nursery in old clothes and either old wellies or hand me down shoes. They only wore them when they were outside and then when home they wore their proper fitted shoes. It doesn't seem to have affected their development.

MajorCarolDanvers · 08/04/2022 10:42

I don't think either the staff or nursery should pay.

It's a run if the mill hazard.

Only send in clothing you don't mind being absolutely destroyed or lost.

ASDA and Primark and second clothes and shoes are ideal.

Dinoteeth · 08/04/2022 10:26

Op I have sympathy and I get it, my kids only had one pair of shoes at a time at that age.
My guess is nursery want kids in slippers / indoor shoes. Helps keep the floors clean etc.
Her outdoor shoes should have gone in her bag or shelf, fallen on the floor or something and someone else stupidly binned it instead of checking the bags, or shelf where they were?

Sounds like there has been a lot of clutter, unclaimed, spare clothes lying around too.

ladycarlotta · 08/04/2022 10:21

I think this is your first painful lesson not to send anything you care about into nursery. I also totally get that this is an emotive moment with it being your child's first shoe.

You can definitely get cheap first walkers that are adequate for very small children's feet - try Dottyfish or buy second hand. Nursery is definitely a playwear only environment as I've learned the hard way.

We lost one of my kid's first shoes when she removed it in the buggy and I guess flung it away without my noticing - I was gutted at the time but it actually meant that the surviving shoe was in very good condition and since it was no longer usable I stuck it in one of those box frames to display in her room forever. So it was actually quite a nice way of having a keepsake, when I might have passed them on to another family otherwise.

mummyh2016 · 08/04/2022 10:17

@SpringIntoChaos

I'm honestly staggered at some of the responses on this thread!!

Whilst I totally agree that things do get lost/taken home by the wrong child/ruined by paint etc (I'm a primary school teacher so know FULL WELL how things go missing!) I don't believe FOR ONE SECOND that this is one of these moments!

The nursery have admitted to throwing the shoe away ffs...it hasn't been 'lost'...they THREW IT AWAY 🤦‍♀️

It wouldn't have made an ounce of difference if it had been labelled in this instance. They were in an 'Ofsted Panic' (totally get this by the way) and the shoe was chucked out!

Of course they should replace it...shoes are bloody expensive! This isn't a vest or a pair of socks we are talking about here!

I'd most definitely be going back and reminding them that they need good feedback from parents whilst Ofsted are on site 🤔

It got thrown away because they believed it was lost. Nursery didn't just take a shoe off a random child and decide to throw it away! You work in a school, if the same thing happened at school would you expect school to replace it? No. And definitely don't threaten to leave bad feedback with ofsted to get them to replace. These people have to look after your child, and whilst I know they won't do anything to your daughter you might find there's a bit of a frosty atmosphere or might not go out of their way to help you the way they normally do.
Soontobe60 · 08/04/2022 10:15

@BuffyFanForever

Always always label shoes. They are actually something that goes missing ALOT more than you would think with little ones. It was very kind of the staff to offer to buy another pair (definitely wouldn’t take them up on this though) but the nursery were never ever going to pay for that!
How can shoes in a room in a private nursery go missing? It’s not like the children have an area the size of a football pitch to play in!
Soontobe60 · 08/04/2022 10:14

@Mummy1608

You can get shoe labels. I would label everything from now on.

We've also lost stuff at nursery but only when it was unlabelled. I still don't label everything but I label stuff I don't want to lose

If the shoe is lost, then a label wouldn’t have made any difference!

I’m in the nursery should pay camp. There will only be a few children in the same room as the OPs baby, so how hard should it have been to ensure their baby came home in the same shoes she arrived in? The only way it could have ended up in another child’s bag is if a member of staff mistakenly put it there. It could have come off whilst the baby was playing, in which case a quick search of the toy boxes would turn it up. It sounds to me that someone has unknowingly thrown it away. It’s irrelevant who that was, but the Nursery should pay, or at least offer compensation towards another pair of shoes.

00100001 · 08/04/2022 10:02

"lots of issues we have created by wearing shoes."

Caused by ill fitting, poor quality shoes.

Plumbear2 · 08/04/2022 09:56

You label everything, especially with babies because they are unable to say that item is mine.

BuffyFanForever · 08/04/2022 09:55

Always always label shoes. They are actually something that goes missing ALOT more than you would think with little ones. It was very kind of the staff to offer to buy another pair (definitely wouldn’t take them up on this though) but the nursery were never ever going to pay for that!

SpringIntoChaos · 08/04/2022 09:54

I'm honestly staggered at some of the responses on this thread!!

Whilst I totally agree that things do get lost/taken home by the wrong child/ruined by paint etc (I'm a primary school teacher so know FULL WELL how things go missing!) I don't believe FOR ONE SECOND that this is one of these moments!

The nursery have admitted to throwing the shoe away ffs...it hasn't been 'lost'...they THREW IT AWAY 🤦‍♀️

It wouldn't have made an ounce of difference if it had been labelled in this instance. They were in an 'Ofsted Panic' (totally get this by the way) and the shoe was chucked out!

Of course they should replace it...shoes are bloody expensive! This isn't a vest or a pair of socks we are talking about here!

I'd most definitely be going back and reminding them that they need good feedback from parents whilst Ofsted are on site 🤔

JudgeRindersMinder · 08/04/2022 09:51

I think people who are basically saying you should suck it up are missing the point!
The shoe hasn’t “gone missing” or been “mislaid”, it’s been thrown up when the nursery were having a clear out for an inspection.

A clear out which shouldn’t have been necessary as the place should be kept in proper order all the time, not just because they know they’re getting an inspection!

Absolutely pursue this with the management of the nursery, when my kids were that age they only possessed 1 pair of shoes at a time because I bought quality rather than quantity and I was paying approx £40 a time and that was 20-25 years ago!

A Cardigan or similar going AWOL I could just about live with, but not their bloody shoes-how are they supposed to go outside in 1 shoe??

Swipe left for the next trending thread