Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want older children breathing and blowing raspberries in my babies face?

168 replies

UberUbers · 07/04/2022 20:44

I'll be completely upfront, I feel a touch germ 'phobic' at the minute after just getting over my second bout of covid and a nasty bug a couple of weeks prior. My poor baby has had it all along with me.

I know 'germs are everywhere and can't be avoided, you can't wrap babies in cotton wool' yada yada, but I feel really uncomfortable with older children coming right up to his face and breathing on it / blowing raspberries, peppering hin with spittle.

I really don't like it and want to ask that it stops, but AIBU?

OP posts:
DockOTheBay · 08/04/2022 07:23

[quote Porcupineintherough]@DockOTheBay how sad that no one wanted to make you giggle and wriggle. Babies usually thing raspberries are the best thing ever. Impressed that you remember your first few months though.[/quote]
I don't have any older siblings or cousins, and adults don't blow raspberries right in your face because its bizarre. Tummy maybe, or feet?

ReadyToMoveIt · 08/04/2022 07:20

I doubt my children remember having raspberries blown at them either, seeing as it mainly happened before they were 6 months old. By the time they’re at an age that they are would remember it happening they tend to have grown out of laughing at raspberry noises.

Porcupineintherough · 08/04/2022 06:25

@DockOTheBay how sad that no one wanted to make you giggle and wriggle. Babies usually thing raspberries are the best thing ever. Impressed that you remember your first few months though.

DockOTheBay · 08/04/2022 06:04

@CrikeyItsACroc

Jesus. M Give your head a wobble. Stop denying your child a normal human experience.
I had no idea getting raspberries blown in your face was an expected part of life. I guess I must be missing out on a "normal human experience" as I'm pretty sure nobody has ever done this to me.
phishy · 08/04/2022 05:29

YANBU, I visited a cousin’s 2mo baby recently and was careful that his older siblings didn’t get in his face too much, it’s instinct to want to protect a baby.

The question is why don’t you feel able to ask them not to blow raspberries in his face? Does your DH make you feel guilty?

montysma1 · 08/04/2022 05:07

Yes it would. I dont let my kids do it to each other or to me. I dont want covid or anything else.

CrikeyItsACroc · 08/04/2022 04:59

Jesus. M
Give your head a wobble. Stop denying your child a normal human experience.

Flittingaboutagain · 08/04/2022 04:57

I have told older children to go play elsewhere if they are unable to play without getting in my baby's face. I have also had lots of parents of older children say to them be careful not too close to the baby etc so I'm with you OP.

Isladogs · 08/04/2022 04:54

You're a stepmum on mumsnet so of course you're being unreasonable.

You're not btw. I totally get it. We have caught covid twice and then norovirus from my DSC. Seeing your baby ill and knowing where they have caught that sickness from, your natural instincts kick in and you want to protect them from that. Seeing the spittle on your baby's face will literally be showing you germs passing from one body to another and your natural instinct will be to prevent that. The problem is, because they are your baby's siblings they will get closer to your baby more often than any other child or person who might pass on germs, but because they are not your own children you feel awkward to tell them not to spit or blow raspberries on your baby the way you might feel able to if they were your own children.

I absolutely love how my DSC interact with my baby. It literally melts my heart to watch the bond they have and I wouldn't want to prevent that at all but it gives me the fear when they kiss her face when they have a visibly running nose or when they are playing a game involving touching her face and i don't know if they've got clean hands (we have issues getting them to wash them, they'll scratch their bums, wipe after the toilet, pick their noses and not wash their hands or say they have when they haven't. We're working on it.). After covid and norovirus I have been much stronger in being able to say, "darling, you need to wash your hands before you play with the baby like that" or "if your nose is runny let's blow kisses/kiss her feet instead" whereas before I would be nervous to in case it would somehow stop them from playing with her or make them feel like they couldn't. It hasn't, they still play and interact with her all the time.

I would definitely ask them to stop, but instead of phrasing in a negative, "don't do this" way, then I'd try saying, "with covid and us catching it a couple of times now, to try make sure baby doesn't catch it again instead of blowing raspberries why don't we..." and give an alternative way for them to interact and play with your baby instead.

Kanaloa · 08/04/2022 04:17

@Poppins2016

My 3.5 year old has a wonderful, close and affectionate relationship with my 6 month old. This includes kisses and blowing raspberries. Occasionally this means that he passes on a bug (my baby has had colds, chicken pox and norovirus, all caught from his brother...) but I wouldn't dream of telling my oldest that he can't demonstrate affection just in case he makes the baby unwell, I feel the long term relationship between the two siblings is far more important.
I mean at 10 and over most children should understand that you can ‘demonstrate affection’ without spitting on people.

I wouldn’t want my child to blow raspberries on me and I don’t blow raspberries on them so it stands to reason I don’t let them do it to each other. There’s loads of more appropriate ways to show affection to a baby sibling - tickling, singing nursery rhymes, peek a boo, reading stories to them, hugging them. No reason for a 10/11 year old to be blowing raspberries in someone’s face.

Poppins2016 · 08/04/2022 04:00

My 3.5 year old has a wonderful, close and affectionate relationship with my 6 month old. This includes kisses and blowing raspberries. Occasionally this means that he passes on a bug (my baby has had colds, chicken pox and norovirus, all caught from his brother...) but I wouldn't dream of telling my oldest that he can't demonstrate affection just in case he makes the baby unwell, I feel the long term relationship between the two siblings is far more important.

DockOTheBay · 08/04/2022 03:58

@Sweetpeasaremadeofcheese

I think people are being weirdly harsh on you here. If they are 10+ there is no harm asking them to please not do that, remember how sick the little one got from covid? We don't want that again, do we? I say similar to my own kids about their little brother and they understand fine, no harm done and they are younger than 10.
Yeah i agree that you could just explain why. I wouldn't like someone blowing on my face - not for germ reasons it would just be irritating - so I don't think YABU to want them to stop.
DockOTheBay · 08/04/2022 03:57

Depending on the age of the older kids, you could move them on to a different way of interacting. "Oh I'm not sure baby likes raspberries in his face, have you tried blowing them on his feet, I bet that would make him laugh!"

Or distract them by asking them to do something like show the baby their favourite toy, or the drawing they did at school, or their new t shirt - you don't have to tell them off, just move them on to something else if you see them doing it.

Kanaloa · 08/04/2022 03:27

You should tell them not to blow raspberries - I find that rude and wouldn’t let my kids do it.

However, siblings will pass germs to one another. It’s just part of life with older kids and babies. I mean it spreads even in workplaces, of course young kids will spread it at home. It’s unfortunate but inevitable.

Sweetpeasaremadeofcheese · 08/04/2022 03:06

I think people are being weirdly harsh on you here. If they are 10+ there is no harm asking them to please not do that, remember how sick the little one got from covid? We don't want that again, do we? I say similar to my own kids about their little brother and they understand fine, no harm done and they are younger than 10.

Thymeout · 08/04/2022 00:38

I'm not in the least germphobic but even I would draw the line at blowing raspberries in a baby's face.

It's the end of winter, we're all a bit rundown and whatever the line the government is pushing covid has not gone away. In the last few weeks, A&E and the ambulance service have routinely been overwhelmed, schools are full of it and travel severely disrupted. Because of my age, I've just had my fourth vaccination, but the take-up for teenagers has been disappointing, they've only just released it for younger school kids and not at all for babies.

I don't think Op is being unreasonable in wanting to protect her baby from whatever new variant is causing this wave, as well as the usual colds, coughs and sickness bugs. It's miserable for a baby to try to feed with a blocked up nose or have its sleep disrupted by coughing.

It's just common sense.

UberUbers · 08/04/2022 00:27

@LampLighter414

The baby will catch whatever the siblings have anyway without them blowing raspberries. That's what happens when you live together and play etc.

YABU.

Also the way you have phrased your first post you seemed to completely disregard that these older children are your child's siblings. I wonder if this attitude shows up elsewhere in your life?

Baby wouldn't necessarily catch whatever they've got when they're ill if reasonable precautions are taken such as the no raspberries thing. As I said above my DP didn't catch covid despite the rest of us having it after they picked it up at school.

Thankfully they were almost asymptomatic apart from a slightly runny nose, but me and baby were miserable with it. I'm still having some worrying cardiac symptoms now over a month later.

Your last paragraph is frankly rubbish, I thought it was obvious I was referring to family. A stranger in the street is hardly going to come and blow raspberries on a babies face now are they?

OP posts:
LampLighter414 · 08/04/2022 00:11

The baby will catch whatever the siblings have anyway without them blowing raspberries. That's what happens when you live together and play etc.

YABU.

Also the way you have phrased your first post you seemed to completely disregard that these older children are your child's siblings. I wonder if this attitude shows up elsewhere in your life?

stormswiftlysweetafton · 08/04/2022 00:10

I don't think there's a problem with telling the older child not to blow raspberries in the baby's face, but unless they're currently ill, I don't think you can stop them from getting very close, face to face. (If they are ill, I think it's okay to explain that we try not to share our germs. But by the time they have symptoms, the damage may already be done.)

Not wanting spittle from one child in the face of the other seems perfectly reasonable, even between siblings. It's not polite behaviour.

MarbleQueen · 07/04/2022 23:55

I wouldn’t let my older children do this to my baby. Having spit on your face is not nice regardless of how much “fun” it is and 10 year olds know this dam well.

This is something kids like to do to others but they don’t like it done to them.I’ve never heard any kid ask for someone to blow raspberry’s on their face and leave them with a face full of spit.

phoenixrosehere · 07/04/2022 23:43

OP, YANBU.

It doesn’t matter whether the children are related or not. Such behaviour is not acceptable from children that old enough to to be blowing raspberries on a baby’s face. Adults wouldn’t like it if another adult did it to them so why is it ok for a baby? I wouldn’t let my own children do that to a baby. There are many other ways to bond with a baby than that.

Maray1967 · 07/04/2022 23:35

Some of the responses here are rather strange. There is no way I would have allowed DS1 to do this to dS 2, and he was 7 years older not 10 plus.
OP, just say, as kindly as possible, no blowing raspberries at his face. He’d love you to show him x toy etc …

Freddiefox · 07/04/2022 23:19

I don’t think yabu, but I think you can teach them how to interact, maybe they can blow raspberries on his arm instead?

Daydreamsinsantafe · 07/04/2022 23:16

We are a nuclear family and both of us don’t like the older children touching the baby’s face without washed hands or too much kissing on the lips etc.
We also don’t do that because germs are easily spread. Surely that’s just common sense to try and keep a baby healthy?

When we all got covid, baby included, it came from school so it’s not an undue paranoia.

UberUbers · 07/04/2022 22:43

@Cherrysoup

Blowing raspberries is definitely covering him in spit, pretty icky if on his face, it’s very unhygienic, I don’t think it’s unreasonable to tell them not to do that. Yanbu.
Thank you for understanding where I'm coming from
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread