Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you would do?

38 replies

PinkAndViolet · 07/04/2022 19:02

DH and I fell out with someone who we were close with. She herself said that there was no coming back from this argument although she said she was terribly sad about it all.
Today when DH was cycling home, he saw her crying on a bench from a distance. She did not see him and he let her be as felt it wouldn't have been right to go to see her. I believe I would have done the same. Aibu or is this a standard response to a situation like this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PinkAndViolet · 09/04/2022 18:23

Why would she orchestrate it when it was her who said she felt there wasn't a way we could all stay friends after this Hmm

OP posts:
swapsicles · 09/04/2022 07:25

I'd have stopped, just briefly at a distance and asked if she was ok.you just don't know what has happened and may need a bit of help. Course she could say she's fine but at least I've tried.
I did ask a random stranger once if they were ok as looked distressed and stayed with her until her friend arrived, ended up crying myself once I'd left as was very sad but hoped she felt a bit more supported for the time she had to wait with me, she did seem to calm down when we were talking rather than just breaking down in the middle of the shopping centre.

Bluebluemoon · 09/04/2022 07:07

I knew it was you from the "friend telling off dc's" thread as soon as I read your OP!

No - your dh did the right thing. It sounds totally orchestrated to me - does she know he rides that route? Sat in public on a bench crying?

She sounded like a right drama llama in the last thread - I wouldn't let her worm her way back in to your life and also I agree it would be inappropriate for your dh to have approached her. She told you in no uncertain terms she didn't want to be friends anymore. Respect her wishes!

girlmom21 · 09/04/2022 07:04

Are you the couple who fell out because "if you've got a problem with my husband you've got a problem with me"?

Of course your husband wouldn't have gone over to her. He's an arse.

I would have gone over to her but, if that thread was you, it's very clear that you didn't care about her like she cared about yiu.

GeneLovesJezebel · 09/04/2022 07:01

I’d have carried on, she knows where you are if she needs help.

whoturnedthesunoff · 09/04/2022 06:59

In this case it's probably best he did nothing

Someone crying on a bench ? They could have been assaulted , robbed , witnessed something, seen a dog attacked , been told of a recent death, felt physically unwell .. so many possibilities so I would always just ask " are you ok, can I help" and move on if they say no . It's not hard to be a little kind

Teeturtle · 09/04/2022 06:50

Well I didn’t remember your last thread, but by the sounds of it your husband did the right thing by not stopping.

Bornsloppy · 09/04/2022 06:45

I also remember your last thread. I think it's probably for the best that you leave her alone.

EdgyNeonAnt · 09/04/2022 06:41

I also remember your last thread and also wouldn't have approached her after the way you both treated her.

EggAndHasBeans · 09/04/2022 05:58

Did you post about the fall out, your DH went to pick up the DC from her?

The only person I have gone NC with hates me with a passion so I probably wouldn't have stopped to see if she was ok, she has rage issues that kinda scare me.

I would have with anyone else if it was just a normal disagreement/fall out.

Turningpurple · 09/04/2022 05:38

I remember you last thread.

He did the right thing. The last thing she needs, after the way you both treated her was him approaching her now.

He didn't really care your kids had misbehaved for her and basically told her he didn't believe her. And it was really recent. If it had been years before, maybe.

You were very dramatic on that thread too. She hasn't been dragged back into your life your husband saw her. That was it. It will happen. Its not a TV show, where once the main characters end a relationship with someone they disappear never to be seen again.

icklekid · 09/04/2022 04:02

I think the fact your still thinking about if it was the right thing to do/ starting a thread means that you would have stopped and checked she was ok. I know it was a tricky situation (I remember your thread too) but it wasn’t so hurtful that you’d wish her harm. I could understand your dh not approaching because of the way you feel out being between them but I don’t see why you couldn’t text her and say he saw her upset earlier and you just want to check in. You fell out because she messaged you about what happened with dh. You didn’t think that was fair and felt you had to back up dh… if you had had really bad news and didn’t have anyone but her to offer support would you want her to message/check in?

WildCoasts · 09/04/2022 00:21

It depends. My instinct is to ask if someone in distress is okay. But if the falling out issue was one where it would be inappropriate or there really was no coming back from it, meaning the last thing they probably want is to interact, then I'd leave them alone. I wouldn't want to because I prefer to support people, but sometimes the contact isn't appropriate.

DysmalRadius · 09/04/2022 00:00

If I was upset, the last thing I would want would be to have to explain myself to someone who I had fallen out with. It's not about how nice a person you consider yourself to be, it's about doing what might actually make the person in distress feel better - if he didn't think his presence would have made things easier for her (which seems likely given how recently this all happened and how she considered him to be antagonistic) then I think he did the right thing.

MangyInseam · 08/04/2022 23:52

I guess it would depend on whether I thought stopping might make her feel worse or just make her mad.

If not, probably. but it's a hard call really.

mycatisannoying · 08/04/2022 23:51

And I would have absolutely stopped to ask if she was ok.

She has dodged a bullet.

mycatisannoying · 08/04/2022 23:49

@TheLightSideOfTheMoon

Nah, I’d have left her to it.

She’s made her feelings clear. Someone else can mop up her tears.

Lovely Hmm
Bunty55 · 08/04/2022 23:39

If i saw someone sitting on a bench crying I would approach them because you never know what has gone wrong in someone' s life do you, and to talk to a stranger is sometimes good medicine as it's easier to talk to a person who won't judge you.

Falling out over children is not the way to deal with a problem as you are showing negative behaviour. Perhaps you should have resolved things at the time ?

Bryonny84 · 08/04/2022 23:02

If I see/saw someone in distress (whether I knew them or not) I would just stop and ask if they were OK. Nine times out of ten they will say yes they are OK and I'll leave it at that. The one time they say no then maybe I could just do one small thing to help. Even if I'd fell out with them.

PinkAndViolet · 08/04/2022 22:15

Well she was sitting on a bench crying so that does change things somewhat. Hmm
It's awkward all round.

OP posts:
youwouldthink · 08/04/2022 19:45

I wouldn't pass a stranger crying without asking if they were ok. This is someone you were close to, a small check on her wouldn't have hurt

misssunshine4040 · 08/04/2022 19:45

@PinkAndViolet

We fell out as she felt we did not trust her. Our kids misbehaved for her and she felt we were blaming her for it, not taking her word etc. Wasn't expecting to have her brought back into our lives like this, in a sort of indirect way so feeling a bit weird about it all although DH is not.
I remember your previous post about the kids.

What a drama about nothing honestly!

She hasn't been "brought back into your lives" again.

Your DH saw her sitting on a bench, no big deal unless you make one out of it

PinkSyCo · 08/04/2022 19:38

We fell out as she felt we did not trust her. Our kids misbehaved for her and she felt we were blaming her for it, not taking her word etc.

And was she right to feel this? Are you and your DH ‘My Johnny can do no wrong’ types? Either way I would have approached her if I saw her sitting alone crying.

Lux523 · 08/04/2022 19:10

I remember your recent thread about this. She looked after your children for you and told your husband upon pickup that they had misbehaved.
He disagreed. You all fell out.

I would have gone and asked if she was ok, especially because we were once friends, it's called kindness.

It sounds like she's better off without you both.

gettingolderandgrumpy · 08/04/2022 18:55

I would’ve gone over , tbh even if it was someone who hurt me badly if I saw then crying I’d go over even if it was can I call someone for you .
I’m not sure why you want peoples opinions guilt ? If so text ask if she’s ok worse that can happen is she ignores you . If you don’t care leave it .

Swipe left for the next trending thread