Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

My sister wants me to change my hair for her wedding. Reasonable or unreasonable?

420 replies

Purple1998 · 07/04/2022 14:30

Hello! I just want some opinions.

Basically I'm a bridesmaid for my sister next year, I wear dreadlock extensions, they're quite expensive and they need fitting in every few months. My sister has said to me she or should I say "told" me that I'm not having dreads in for her wedding... granted I won't because it's her day, but my boyfriend thinks she's out of order because he thinks she's basically telling me to not be myself. What do you think? He recons I should say something but I don't think I want to cause agro and would rather her just be happy on her day, not that my hair should make her otherwise... she was a bit cheeky about it because I did tell her that they're expensive and was hoping she wouldn't bring them up, but she replied with "money can't buy taste" Hmm

Do you think she's being reasonable?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
HangingRock25 · 09/04/2022 08:51

@clpsmum You are very misinformed. As someone with a History degree, and minor studies in Sociology, I can tell you that dreadlocks are predominantly worn by white people, and were originally a white hairstyle going back earlier than Cleopatra. Dreadlocks, are a WHITE person's hairstyle. Also, I say this as a POC. You are misinformed.

clpsmum · 09/04/2022 08:47

[quote HangingRock25]@clpsmum It is predominantly worn by WHITE people. You are confusing dreadlocks with braids/cornrows.[/quote]
No I'm
Not I know the difference between dreadlocks and braids. Dreadlocks are predominantly worn by black people

clpsmum · 09/04/2022 08:46

@milkyaqua

Dreadlocks have been, in my view, appropriated from Rastafarians.
I agree
milkyaqua · 09/04/2022 08:19

Dreadlocks have been, in my view, appropriated from Rastafarians.

HangingRock25 · 09/04/2022 08:08

@clpsmum It is predominantly worn by WHITE people. You are confusing dreadlocks with braids/cornrows.

clpsmum · 09/04/2022 08:02

[quote HangingRock25]@clpsmum Do you realise how ignorant you sound when you wrongly bring race into it and call other posters racist?[/quote]
Not ignorant at all. People saying they find a hairstyle that is predominantly worn by a race of people disgusting IS racist

clpsmum · 09/04/2022 08:01

[quote PutinIsAWarCriminal]@23clpsmum

PutinIsAWarCriminal
I absolutely HATE dreadlocks, they are disgusting as a minimum. how to offend a whole culture ...*

Could you be a bit more racist ffs

Errrm, are you calling me racist or the pp I was quoting? Just in case anyone jumps in, the hating dreadlocks comment was copied into my post because I was calling their remark offensive!![/quote]
@PutinIsAWarCriminal no sorry I was calling the person you were quoting racist. I was agreeing with you although I can see I wasn't clear sorry

lightisnotwhite · 09/04/2022 00:18

@Thenose

"You want her to be happy, and you know it will make her happy, so no reason not to do it."

What a weird position. Are you saying that we should do something whenever it will make someone else happy, regardless of our own feelings about it?

Well yes if you are invited to someone else’s event.

If you don’t agree with the invitees invitation, don’t attend. It’s a request not a summons.

XenoBitch · 09/04/2022 00:00

Your sister is BVU. She ought to be focused on getting married, and what both herself and her groom look like. Is she really going to be throwing her wedding album into a fire when viewing it in years to come.. because of your hair?
She sounds like a total Bridezilla. I know someone who was asked to get rid of his blue hair.. and he was not even in the wedding party. Was just a guest.

inmyslippers · 08/04/2022 21:57

so when black women straighten their hair , how does that work then ? im just asking out of curiosoty because obviously caucasian people have straight hair .. so isnt that coping as well , iv always wondered this when ever this cultural appropitation stuff rears its head

^^ straight hair doesn't just grow out of white peoples heads though....

SquirrelG · 08/04/2022 21:26

White women wearing dread locks is not overly common. So let's not pretend like it is.

I live in a rural town in NZ and have seen plenty of white women with dreadlocks.

Also, dreadlocks have been around forever, and were worn by people of all colours, so give over with all this "white people shouldn't have them" rubbish. Maybe do a bit of research?

PutinIsAWarCriminal · 08/04/2022 20:57

@23clpsmum

PutinIsAWarCriminal
I absolutely HATE dreadlocks, they are disgusting as a minimum. how to offend a whole culture ...*

Could you be a bit more racist ffs

Errrm, are you calling me racist or the pp I was quoting? Just in case anyone jumps in, the hating dreadlocks comment was copied into my post because I was calling their remark offensive!!

MrsSkylerWhite · 08/04/2022 20:31

clpsmum

Barkingmadhouse
I can see her point of view, dreadlocks are awful and will affect the photos“

Really?
Have you seen Walking Dead? Michonne’s hair is nothing short of magnificent.
Ezekiel’s is glorious, too.

No way can either of those people’s hair be described as awful in any way.

HangingRock25 · 08/04/2022 20:30

@clpsmum Do you realise how ignorant you sound when you wrongly bring race into it and call other posters racist?

clpsmum · 08/04/2022 20:28

@ElenaSt

I wouldn’t want somebody with dreadlocks as my bridesmaid if I’m honest. But there’s ways and means to go about asking nicely if they would have a different hairstyle at my expense for the occasion.
So You realise how racist this makes you sound
clpsmum · 08/04/2022 20:26

@Barkingmadhouse

I can see her point of view, dreadlocks are awful and will affect the photos. Do you think she felt forced (probably by family) to have you as a bridesmaid but doesn't actually want you as one because of your look? Would you not being a bridesmaid create issues with the wider family for her? I know of I had a sister with dreadlocks I wouldn't want her as a bridesmaid
Do You realise how racist this makes you sound.
HangingRock25 · 08/04/2022 20:24

@clpsmum As has been explained on this thread, it has nothing to do with race whatsoever.

clpsmum · 08/04/2022 20:24

@heartofgrass

Hmm I'm torn on this one.

On one hand I don't think it's reasonable to ask someone to change their look but on the other I think FAKE dreadlocks tend to look awful (85% of the time?) and not only do they look awful, i feel they're bordering on cultural appropriation (I'm assuming you're a white woman). So yes, i would also suggest to my sister that perhaps she might want to change up her style as I wouldn't want other guests at my wedding to be offended or to snigger at my bridesmaids hair.

Why are you assuming she is white?
clpsmum · 08/04/2022 20:23

@PutinIsAWarCriminal

I absolutely HATE dreadlocks, they are disgusting as a minimum. how to offend a whole culture ...
Could you be a bit more racist ffs
PutinIsAWarCriminal · 08/04/2022 20:07

Love your dreads @Purple1998, they suit you.
On the cultural appropriation comment, I always thought that dreads weren't necessarily a black ownership thing, I just thought they were a symbol of being connected to the Earth? In black people its about being connected to the land their ancestors were taken from, and with white people it was back to earth hippy, rather than try-to-look-black. Whatever race or reason, I think they look fab, a good friend in their 40s has been growing them since their teens.

HulaTheHedgehog · 08/04/2022 19:58

@Blanketpolicy

Honestly, I think you are a very attractive lady, but your hair looks "dread"ful. I think the picture a couple of posts above your picture looks amazing. But dreads are marmite, some will love and some will hate.

If someone I loved had them in your style, I would still think the hair looked dreadful but its nothing to do with me how they choose to have their hair. She either accepts you as you are or doesn't ask you to be a bridesmaid and you accept that.

I agree with this. The OP is attractive, and I don't think dreadlocks are cultural appropriation, because as many people have said, many white people had them YEARS before POC.

BUT (and sorry @Purple1998,) I don't think these particular dreadlocks look good at all, and I can see your sister's point.

gamerchick · 08/04/2022 19:51

@abc4321

Having looked at your photos, I confess that I can see your sister's point of view. You're stunning but your hair style would look quite a strong statement as a bridesmaid, and for her wedding photos. Plus they're extensions so you can somewhat time when you take them on and off.

Sorry to go against the flow, I'm just being honest.

Then she shouldn't have asked her to be bridesmaid. You dont ask and then lay down the law
abc4321 · 08/04/2022 19:41

Having looked at your photos, I confess that I can see your sister's point of view. You're stunning but your hair style would look quite a strong statement as a bridesmaid, and for her wedding photos. Plus they're extensions so you can somewhat time when you take them on and off.

Sorry to go against the flow, I'm just being honest.

chaosrabbitland · 08/04/2022 19:22

@Purple1998

Wow, I can't believe how many responses this got! As you can see there's way to many to reply individually however I would like to clear a few things. I don't think my boyfriend is trying to stir shit or be malicious i think it's more the fact he doesn't want someone telling me what I can and can't do and loves me for me. I can see how it may come across but I don't think the goal is drama, plus that is something I personally want to avoid hence why I will just look into doing something else with my hair. I just wanted to know what the majority opinion was and if I was maybe over looking it too much? Because my partner got really upset over it.

Also as for "cultural appropriation" ... I am a white woman. However there's nothing racist or inappropriate about me loving and wearing dreads... a race doesn't own a hair style, I wouldn't dare tell a black person they're doing cultural appropriation for dying their hair blonde? Dreads originally came from Egypt, and through history have been worn by Christian's, vikings, and other ethnicities.

Some people have asked to see my dreads to see if they look nice so I've dropped a picture I think they do, which is my opinion 🤷🏻‍♀️

My sisters comment about money buying taste was cheeky but it is okay because she's my sister but it did grate on me a bit because she meant it, she's always hated how I've dressed etc. to the point where years ago she bought me a hideous pencil flower dress for her first daughters christening that she wanted me to wear... (I always dress appropriately for occasions and I would like to add there's nothing particularly "out there" about my style other than my hair I spose. I'm quite a girly girl tbh. But yeah I think my bf has just had enough of her always wanting to mold me when she has an opportunity to, she comes across embarrassed of me most of the time. But tbh I'm not all that bothered. I can understand why he is though.

Thanks for sharing your opinions

aww i just revisited this thread and saw you put a pic up , you are really lovely in a bit of a nice hippy way , honeslty if my 14 year old wanted to model herself after your look when shes an adult ,id be perfectly happy and not bothered in the slightest , you are stunning and dont need to change anything until you want to
WalkingOnTheCracks · 08/04/2022 19:20

It's a spiritual belief and it also states this in the bible.

So, having looked into this, dreads aren't mentioned anywhere in the Bible.

There are many references in the Old Testament to not cutting off any hair.

But...

a) they all apply to men
b) there are also a bunch of instructions not to let hair grow long
c) all those instructions - both for growing the hair and not growing it - are directed at the Children of Israel. So, the Jewish people.

So who's culturally appropriating whom?