Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jimmy Saville documentary on Netflix

365 replies

AlternativePerspective · 07/04/2022 12:39

Have just watched this, obviously we all know what he did and the absolutely reprehensible individual he was.

But watching the documentary and all the clips they played, even if he hadn’t committed all those hideous acts, he was a really creepy repulsive bloke. So why did the nation love him so much?

I’m not talking royals and other celebs etc, but ordinary people. The people who filed past his coffin after his death, and mourned his passing, sent in hundreds of tributes etc. Why? He was just so repulsive. Or is it just me?

OP posts:
Silverclocks · 08/04/2022 09:34

Remember you're not allowed to dislike someone just because they're odd or "creepy" even (especially?) now. That would be all kinds of wrong and he was doing so much "good".

Cravingsweets · 08/04/2022 09:25

pervy old man!

Cravingsweets · 08/04/2022 09:25

I'm late 50s and of that era. Yes, he was odd, but a lot of the comments you heard him make in the documentary - along the lines of 'what are you doing later?' and suggestive comments about girls - were totally commonplace in those days

This is so true. It was no "normal" for grown men to ask little girls "have you got a boyfriend?", and "Am I too old for you?" etc. Little girl shyly and awkwardly giggles, the audience laughs completely validating the Percy old man. Standard stuff. I can think of an interview with a young Britney Spears where that exact thing happened. It's shocking but it was normal Sad

PermanentTemporary · 08/04/2022 09:09

He was a big name - really big. If I ended up being invited regularly to say Emma Thompson's house to hang out as part of a circle of friends, I'd want to go.

kierenthecommunity · 08/04/2022 09:03

I personally had only joined the police five years before he died, so didn’t hear of any rumours within the organisation then about any big wigs meeting up with him. But there were rumours in the 80/90s about his Friday club. It wasn’t just police officers apparently, it was other influential men who he was rumoured to have ‘in his pocket.’ To do what though - no one elaborated.

Malibuismysecrethome · 08/04/2022 08:58

Kieranthecommunity just interested to know if, to your knowledge, any rumours or reports about JS ever reached the police. I find it hard to believe that senior police had time to drop by his flat for tea and a chat most Fridays. Maybe this was just his PR in action. Strange man all round.

kierenthecommunity · 08/04/2022 08:52

The poster who said people lived near him knew a lot of gossip about him were right. There were many rumours in Leeds, most of which I assumed was just people being malicious. I was naive enough to think there was no way anyone would have sex with corpses at the LGI morgue. As an older woman, and police officer I’ve since realised that is far from the most revolting perversion a human can have.

There were also rumours about ‘young girls’ but by this I assumed they meant girls in their early 20s - so distasteful but not illegal

I enjoyed JFI for the show not him - I thought he was odd. I also met him as a young child with my mum in Roundhay park. She encouraged me to say hello but didn’t like him after the encounter. He spoke to me in a really odd way - not inappropriate but it was apparent he didn’t really like children, or at least couldn’t naturally converse with them. His JFL segments were obviously scripted

fiftyandfat · 08/04/2022 08:49

The middle aged nurses at Stoke Mandeville knew what he was like, but nobody listened/ listens to middle aged women.
Not much has changed IMO.
Men like this still groom, abuse, court the people in power. They infiltrate all our public institutions. Social media only makes it easier.

OnlyTheTitosaurusOfTheIceberg · 08/04/2022 07:04

@Chasingaftermidnight

I know how easy it is to say ‘I knew all along’, but I genuinely did always think he was creepy. I certainly didn’t suspect what he actually was and I was totally shocked by the scale of his offending but I did always think he was a creep.

But then again, lots of people (not just his victims) must have known what he was and didn’t say anything.

Rolf Harris I was really, really surprised by. Never thought he was creepy. So it goes to show you can’t necessarily rely on your creepdar anyway.

This sums it up for me too. There were special things I wanted to do as a child but I never wrote to Jim’ll Fix It because I didn’t want to meet him.

I loved Rolf Harris and Stuart Hall though, so that completely blindsided me.

AsTreesWalking · 08/04/2022 06:55

In my late 50s, I liked watching JFI, but never wanted to be on it. Like pps, I thought JS rather scary because of his oddness.
I did love RH, though, especially his 'do you know what it is yet?' paintings. But I read an extract from his autobiography when I was in my teens, and remember him talking about trying to jolly colleagues along by saying 'cheer up it may never happen!' Obviously, this is not an indication of paedophilia, but I did think it crass and rather bullying. Just a tiny counter-balance to all our surprise about him.

Jovanka · 08/04/2022 06:32

That zombie thread is Shock to read it now. And a clear example of how a group dynamic can reinforce each other’s (in this case flawed) perceptions against one lone voice. ‘Did he not fix it for you?’ Shock Shock

justfiveminutes · 08/04/2022 06:06

I never met him but grew up watching him on Jim'll Fix It and TOTP. I didn't love him, and was largely unaware of his charity work, but didn't think he was creepy either. He was just another tv presenter, and the only discussion about him I remember having with my family was how ridiculous his clothes were.

I wrote to JFI and was jealous of the girl who got in a cab and said 'follow that car'. I think she ended up in France.

His on-screen comments didn't seem particularly odd to me at the time. It was not unusual for older men to be creepy around young girls. Programmes like On The Buses and the Carry On films were very popular and normalised it.

Even in real life, men got away with being frighteningly pervy. Newspapers counted the days until celebrity children were 16 and 'old enough'. Bosses patted your bum. Parents warned their kids to stay away from certain people in the community but they were tolerated. A male French teacher at my school was famous for teaching everyone the same sentence in their first lesson - will you sleep with me tonight. Another teacher married a pupil within a year of her leaving school. I remember genuinely feeling that it was my job to keep myself safe from such people and unwanted attention was my own fault.

AlternativePerspective · 08/04/2022 05:26

Bloody hell that thread. Shock having said that, iirc there were other threads at the time saying similar to the OP of that thread where a lot of people did comment on the rumours and speculation and made their opinions well known. But they were deleted as being not in the spirit/in bad taste etc.

And then the truth came out soon after.

OP posts:
IamtheDevilsAvocado · 08/04/2022 05:24

@MrsPelligrinoPetrichor

His manner of speaking was really odd and Rolf Harris spoke the same to a certain extent. All that breathy now then, now then nonsense. Urghh.
Never liked him-even as small child...

As an adult, before all the vile abuse came out in the I always thought that he was just a bundle of clichéd sayings... With no real soul /heart...

Willowowisp · 08/04/2022 05:19

He was always weird and I remember asking my mum how someone that old can run a marathon. But like most kids in the 80s, I watched JWFI every week. My parents were never keen on him though.

sashh · 08/04/2022 04:51

@AnotherPoster

I'm late 50s and of that era. Yes, he was odd, but a lot of the comments you heard him make in the documentary - along the lines of 'what are you doing later?' and suggestive comments about girls - were totally commonplace in those days. I don't mean I approve of them, but whenever I hear people talking in the 70s, clips from game shows, vox pops, etc, I am shocked by how much has changed in what is deemed acceptable.

So yes, we all thought he was eccentric and odd, but his public persona was very much one of doing tireless work for charity. Of course, knowing what we now do, it is impossible to hear his comments and not see them as creepy.

I'm 55, the 70s were very sexist, on TV and off.

And little girls were often put in a position to kiss older men. If you went to see Santa you sat on his knee and gave him a kiss.

A theatre company comes to school, a little girl is picked to kiss one of the actors.

For teachers dating a student was almost a perk of the job. I don't remember it at my school, but it was a girls school run by nuns, and we knew which nun not to go anywhere near.

The VI form was at my brother's school, the headmaster was friends with my parents. He told a story about how he's been contacted by someone from the fire station next tot he school to appologise because some of the firefighters had been watching the new VI form girls arrive and making comments to each other, the headmaster's response was, "Don't worry, it's the same in our staffroom"

So this is a head teacher, who is so not bothered by adult men eyeing up 16 year old girls and thinking it's not just OK but it is funny. And this was a year before I went to that VI form.

oakleaffy · 08/04/2022 04:49

@Tdetfrgrgf

Bloody hell!

Some of the comments from 2011 are astounding.

Some detested Savile at the time, but many were duped by his ''Charidee'' persona.

oakleaffy · 08/04/2022 04:45

Mum {Stepmum}detested him at the height of his ''Fame''
She actually cried one Christmas Day as her parents were wittering on about him being ''Marvellous'' and ''Doing so much for Charity'

Mum said ''I think he's horrible, and there is something very distasteful about him''

She was proved right.
Vile pervert.

flyhighshiningstar · 08/04/2022 03:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

ihatethefuckingmuffin · 08/04/2022 02:50

The anonymous letter that was handed over to West Yorkshire police and nothing done. I lived up there and it was well known about him and I was banned from writing in to the show. Moved near BBC studio and again banned from top of the pops and the studio. He came to visit my school in Leeds didn't see him as I wasn't allowed to go to school that day.
But as others have said. He blackmailed and threatened people to stay quiet.

Journalists writing about him well before he died, nothing followed up on.
His journalist mate from Leeds not aware of the rumours yet they were rife up there including him being in a paedo ring.

Advising the royal family wtaf. Maggie begging the queen for years about making him a Sir, she should have carried on listening to whatever voice was screaming no fucking way.

BBC not wanting to air the original documentary about the victims from friends reunited, so it was handed over to ITV.
Member of the nutters club at Broadmoor before he was handed the keys to the place because the patients recognised him as one of them.

His victims started going to the police way back in the 50's and every single on of his victims were bad!y let down by several police forces.

This pdf about the investigation into his years at broadmoor is shocking and potentially triggering for some.

<a class="break-all" href="https://www.google.com/url?q=assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/323458/Broadmoor_report.pdf&sa=U&ved=2ahUKEwjpk7WmqYP3AhWSTcAKHYGsAC0QFnoECAoQAg&usg=AOvVaw3ahSPiuBlnN57PqMvZVCkI" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">www.google.com/url?q=assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/323458/Broadmoor_report.pdf&sa=U&ved=2ahUKEwjpk7WmqYP3AhWSTcAKHYGsAC0QFnoECAoQAg&usg=AOvVaw3ahSPiuBlnN57PqMvZVCkI

Redglitter · 08/04/2022 01:22

When you watch the documentary now knowing what we do, some of his comments are absolutely appaling. He's basically admitting on camera to being a sexual predator. God he must have had a right laugh at the fact he was so blatant & still got away with it.

Comeoninandclosethedoor · 08/04/2022 01:13

@AnotherPoster

I'm late 50s and of that era. Yes, he was odd, but a lot of the comments you heard him make in the documentary - along the lines of 'what are you doing later?' and suggestive comments about girls - were totally commonplace in those days. I don't mean I approve of them, but whenever I hear people talking in the 70s, clips from game shows, vox pops, etc, I am shocked by how much has changed in what is deemed acceptable.

So yes, we all thought he was eccentric and odd, but his public persona was very much one of doing tireless work for charity. Of course, knowing what we now do, it is impossible to hear his comments and not see them as creepy.

Yes I'm in my late 50s and this was my view of him too.

In fact I came away with the opposite reaction to you op after watching the documentary. I came away with a better understanding of how everyone had been duped because I had mainly remembered the "how's about that then boys and girls" zany but creepy image but had forgotten how intelligent, intuitively bright, and manipulative he was until I saw him again in this documentary. Yes he was repulsive but he knew when to wheel it in and when to become serious, when he could dominate and when he could speak perilously close to the truth. And evidently, he was supremely good at fund-raising, very self disciplined and energetic and determinedly dedicated to his own aggrandisement and his career as a prolific paedophile. I don't think anyone knew how to handle him. And like all psychopaths, he was fearless and callous, exploited the weak and made sure he had a hold over people who could potentially expose his crimes. The supposed subterfuge which allowed him to beguile everyone was that he was a humble man dedicated to raising money for good causes, but he covered this up by playing the eccentric old rogue who loved the limelight. It was a very clever ploy which allowed the psychopath to hide in plain side.

Redglitter · 08/04/2022 01:08

@Tdetfrgrgf

That thread didn't age well did it 🙈

Interesting to see the responses at that time

Tdetfrgrgf · 08/04/2022 01:04

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/1338776-Cult-of-Celebrity

Interesting thread. A very vindicated OP.

VashtaNerada · 08/04/2022 00:23

As a child I desperately wanted to go on Jim’ll Fix It. I never saw him as creepy because I simply had no idea that adults could behave in a sexual way towards children, it was completely outside my frame of reference. As an adult I thought he was an odd character with secrets but genuinely didn’t hear the rumours. At the time of the Louis Theroux doc I actually thought he was asexual and ashamed of it, so made up the stories about having girlfriends. Perhaps I’m naive but it really did come as a shock to me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread