Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Laser eye surgery - experiences/thoughts/risks?

82 replies

MumofCandR · 07/04/2022 11:54

I'm considering having laser eye surgery done. I have strong myopia and have done since I was 12 I'm now mid 40s. I have worn glasses all my life and am not considering this for aesthetic reasons, but for me the absolute bonus would be the feeling of freedom, being able to see in the shower, in the sea. Glasses not steaming up when wearing a mask, etc. Have you had laser eye surgery and what has been your experience/ would you recommend? My concern would be the small risk of complications and regretting not sticking with glasses as being able to see is so precious. AIBU to consider? What do I need to think about?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WalkingOnTheCracks · 09/04/2022 08:13

I had mine 21 years ago, and it was great.

Couple of things...

As a few people have said, go to a highly-qualified surgeon to whom this is a very dull thing to do. When I had the assessment appointment, the surgeon inspected my eyes and I said, "What do you reckon? Can you do anything for me?"

He said, somewhat wryly, "Put it this way - you're not a challenge."

Which is great. If someone's going to burn a bit of your eyeball, what you want is for that person to think you represent a very mundane day at the office.

It doesn't hurt much, and the pain is not only bearable but brief. For me the problem was suppressing the understandable instinct to escape. Although I knew that this was something I'd signed up for, paid for and walked into of my own free will, when the bloke leaned over me with the machine, there was a very fundamental and animalistic part of my brain screaming, "He's after your eyes! Punch the fucker and run!" My fists were clenched throughout.

My eyes felt irritated and light-sensitive that evening, but all that was completely gone by the morning.

When I first talked to the surgeon about it, he said, "This is a very wonderful procedure with outstanding results, but it's not a miracle - it won't stop you aging. So you're not going to be free of glasses forever. Your eyes will still deteriorate."

He also said, "I can give you whatever kind of sight you want, perfectly, but not for all distances. For instance, if you're an archer, you might want great long-distance sight, but in a few years time you'll need glasses for reading. Or, if you work on computers a lot, I can give you the best sight for that, but in a few years time you'll need glasses to drive. So what do you want?"

Lastly, some people report that they get more glare at night, which I do. I'm not crazy about driving after dark.

Lonecatwithkitten · 08/04/2022 23:43

I had lens replacement surgery last October as I was nearly 50 so laser is not suitable. I was long sighted, short sighted, poor middle vision and astigmatisms, plus both my parents have had cataract surgery.
I had tried contacts, but developed dry eye so could no longer wear them. Had tried regular varifocals - no good for doing my job, indoor varifocals made my nauseaous if I looked outside. I was spending large amounts of my days searching for my glasses as I had taken them off.
Lens replacement has been life changing even though I had posterior capsule thickened that had to be treated with yag laser. Now 6 months on it is so much better. Plus I will not develop cataracts in later life which would have required the identical surgery.
I do have haloing, but my astigmatism caused me to suffer horrible night glare and haloing is a million times better than that - not painful just there and improves the closer you get to the light.

Phoenix76 · 08/04/2022 23:10

I think it’s like any surgery as pp’s have said, for some it will feel miraculous for others it will be a disaster. I’m fortunate in that I fell into the miraculous category along with my sister. I had it done well over 10 years ago, probably closer to 15. A couple of years ago on a routine eye test, my optician said he was extremely impressed with the results (worth mentioning was not the same company who performed the surgery) and said if everyone had it done and it turned out as well as mine they’d be out of a job.

I remember clearly opening my eyes (after extremely unpleasant feelings, like hot sand in my eyes) when it had settled down and seeing clearly for the first time, it was a bird in a tree a long way off, everything had a crisp outline. Knowing I didn’t have to faff about with glasses and contact lenses again. Even now, my eyes are great and very often I’m thankful for it.

It’s absolutely essential though that you go to an expert in the field, anything cheap run as fast as you can. Research the clinic thoroughly and read up on the procedure. I certainly didn’t enjoy it, you’re fully awake and you can smell the burning and afterwards it was painful but my life since has been transformed in the most positive way. Good luck whatever you decide.

violetbunny · 08/04/2022 22:09

I had it done 10 years ago and wish I hadn't. I still have 20/20 vision but my eyes are extremely dry now, I have to put drops in literally every couple of hours. When I wake up in the morning my eyes feel like the Sahara desert. In hindsight the company knew I had underlying issues with dryness, but encouraged me to use eye drops every 30 mins in the days ahead of the surgery so that I would still qualify for it.

Setthescenes · 08/04/2022 21:02

I had LASIK and I've been left with permanent damage and my eyesight will now always be affected (ghosting, glare, halos) I can't go to the cinema or drive at night, and need lots of lights on in the house after sunset.

It's great when it goes well but a small % are unlucky like me; I wish I hadn't risked it. Sad

littlemisslozza · 08/04/2022 20:42

I had it done 20 years ago, along with DH, my dad and my brother. All problem free and highly recommend. I have hay fever and could never wear contact lenses in the summer and my eyes were too irritated. Game changer.

Poshishchap · 08/04/2022 20:32

Had mine done 15 years ago. Still perfect vision. Had LASIK and was driving the next day. If you live far from the surgery I would recommend a hotel nearby as you'll probably need to go in the next day for a check up. Also, it starts to get uncomfortable after an hour, room service and a glass of wine is brilliant for post op

Luckyelephant1 · 08/04/2022 20:20

I had LASIK in one eye and the older LASEK in the other eye as I had some issues with that eye that meant it wasn't suitable for LASIK. Recovery is more painful with LASEK but it only lasts a few days and it's still the best thing I've ever done.

The only cons are dry eyes (which I already had but it's now worse) and night driving is hard because I feel like the glare of headlights really affects me now.

thing47 · 08/04/2022 20:15

@bubble2000 No surgery is risk-free and tabloid newspapers don't typically run stories about successful operations…

DS had this procedure earlier this year and definitely falls in to the 'best thing I've ever done' camp. It's worked brilliantly even though there was an added concern in that he has had Type I diabetes for almost 20 years. He had it done primarily for professional purposes so was extremely motivated to follow all the rules for after-care in terms of applying drops and gels and so on, and not over-stretching his eyes for a few days.

He had it done at Moorfields (so it was expensive). I can also put to rest the idea that surgeons performing the procedure wouldn't have it themselves, that just is not true. DS's eye surgeon at Moorfields had had it done, and so had several of his colleagues.

chocolatecheesecake · 08/04/2022 19:51

I had mine done 15 years ago. I was approx -6 in both eyes and had got to the point where I got headaches wearing glasses (in spite of thinned lenses) and had blurred vision and sore eyes by the end of the day wearing contact lenses. It's been life changing. Getting up in the night with babies, beach/swimming and being able to see where the kids are... and just being able to live my life without headaches, blurred vision and hassle.

I'm now early 40s and know I will need reading glasses soon, but these years of perfect vision have been completely worth it.

However, I worked for surgeons (different specialty) at the time, and their advice was to have it done by surgeons who did far more complex things in their NHS practice. And to run a mile from anywhere/anyone where this was the most advanced thing they did. And who do not have a NHS practice. I had mine done by a Guy's and St Thomas' consultant who fixed botched procedures (amongst other things far more cutting edge) done by the high street clinics.

latetothefisting · 08/04/2022 19:38

@catblanket

Always wondered about this. How do they do it? Are you awake? Doesn’t it hurt?
Have you seen the clockwork orange? Grin and no, it doesn't hurt because they numb it beforehand, but you can smell your eye burning.

I fully understand why you're nervous OP but can only echo like most of the other posters that it was the best thing I've spent money on. Personally didn't have any side effects at all - one of my eyes was apparently mildly infected but they gave me stronger drops and it cleared up easily. It didn't hurt or anything.

DivorcedAndDelighted · 08/04/2022 19:14

@WalkingOnTheCracks

I met my future wife in the waiting room for Lazik.

So what was supposed to be a couple of grand has cost me an absolute fortune.

Brilliant - I did not expect to end up snorting with laughter on this thread Grin
WalkingOnTheCracks · 08/04/2022 14:11

I met my future wife in the waiting room for Lazik.

So what was supposed to be a couple of grand has cost me an absolute fortune.

SherbetDips · 08/04/2022 13:56

Had it 3 years ago, best thing I’ve ever done. I was a -6 - 7 with a stigmatism and now I’ve 20/20 vision and I’m free from spending 400 quid a lense for both sunglasses and regular glasses on top of the cost of frames etc

Money worth spent.

Stretchandsnap · 08/04/2022 13:54

Forgot to say I had mine at London vision clinic on Harley street and I chose them because their results with my prescription were impressive (-7 & -7 astigmatism and big pupils) . You pay for your first meeting (I think it was £500) but it is taken off the cost of surgery if you go ahead. I would recommend them completely, they were very honest about what my results could be best/worst case scenario. Hope that helps

Roominmyhouse · 08/04/2022 13:32

I had in done in 2013. I was back in glasses/contacts by 2020 sadly so it was £3k wasted for me. I was short sighted and am back to being short sighted.

Mayhemmumma · 08/04/2022 13:27

Best decision ever! Swimming, showers, exercise, driving at night, no monthly cost, so many things have made life better without contacts I love it.

It was however extremely painful for 24hrs. I'm glad they did both eyes at the same time or id not have gone back!

DivorcedAndDelighted · 08/04/2022 10:20

Forgot to say, my prescription was -5 and the vision I've achieved after LASIK is better than I ever had with glasses or contacts. One eye is super - sharp and the other is 20:20. Glasses and contacts were not trouble - free for me; I'm very outdoorsy and practical, and my nose and ear shape mean that glasses were never very secure and constantly annoyed me. I used to get various problems with contact lenses eg sensitivity to some solutions, and had corneal abrasions on a few occasions due to things getting stuck under lenses. Also used to get this issue with dry patches on my eyes. I just don't get any trouble now. The surgery aftercare of eyedrops and artificial tears did get me into the habit of using good, preservative-free eye drops whenever I feel the slightest dryness, so that has probably helped. I doubt that surgery has "cured" my intermittent dry eyes, but it has helped me to manage it.
My surgery was 16 years ago last month Grin

DivorcedAndDelighted · 08/04/2022 10:10

@bubble2000

Yes it's so telling the eye surgeon all wear glasses - they don't trust their own treatment - when asked they say " oh sadly myveyes aren't suitable'

Apologies for the daily mail link 🙈🙈🙈- was just wanting to put something up quickly!!!

As I said important to do own research and question do I need this unnecessary surgery when clearly the risks are there and if I am uuckyvthe impact is horrific

That's one we can quickly lay to rest. There was a peer-reviewed study of Ophthalmologists who performed laser vision correction , asking if they had or would have the procedure themselves:

62.5 percent of refractive surgeons with refractive error amenable to treatment have already had laser vision correction, and 95 percent are completely, or at least mostly, satisfied with their outcomes.
This level of acceptance is around five times the prevalence of refractive surgery in the general population, far surpassing any other profession with the possible exception of the military.
We also found that the vast majority (over 90 percent) of the refractive surgeons we surveyed have performed or recommended LVC to one or more of their parents, spouses, siblings, and/or children.

ForFiveMinutes · 08/04/2022 09:13

I had it done over 25 years ago when it only cost about £250 per eye, I was hugely shortsighted. Best £500 I ever spent.
I have the normal age deterioration now in my early 50’s so I do wear reading glasses, but the benefits from the last 25 years massively outweigh that. Nothing worse than falling asleep in contacts and having to prise them off your eyeballs!

MumofCandR · 08/04/2022 09:02

Thank you all for the insights and personal experiences - I will definitely go to several good clinics and have a free consultation and then decide what to do. Thank you!

OP posts:
TheComptonEffect · 08/04/2022 08:46

I had it done 9 years ago. Was over -6.5 with bad astigmatism in both eyes. It didn't work brilliantly for me, the most difficult being at night was offered to redo again but decided against it. Lasted without glasses for 5/6 years (I do think having kids made it worse) until a new neighbour was at an event and came to speak to me but I had no idea who she was as I only waved at her in passing and out of context I just couldn't see her! Went back to glasses again. It cost me 4k.
Pros- freedom of not wearing glasses and having my eyemakeup seen.
Cons- even at '20/20 ' vision my eyesight was never as good as it had been with glasses which was quite difficult. Recovery took a while. Night vision was just awful, now improved with glasses but will never be better than it is now. I actually missed my glasses, they were really part of my identity! (My husband prefers me with them too)
However, overall I would do it again for a few reasons. My prescription is now -3.5, means I can get the whole range of glasses(couldn't before to support the lenses), glasses are cheaper and if I hadn't tried I always would have wondered. I can still see okish without glasses (enough to drive apparently but absolutely no way I would).

bubble2000 · 08/04/2022 06:55

Yes it's so telling the eye surgeon all wear glasses - they don't trust their own treatment - when asked they say " oh sadly myveyes aren't suitable'

Apologies for the daily mail link 🙈🙈🙈- was just wanting to put something up quickly!!!

As I said important to do own research and question do I need this unnecessary surgery when clearly the risks are there and if I am uuckyvthe impact is horrific

Roselilly36 · 08/04/2022 06:19

I had lasik in 2008, without doubt the best money I have ever spent. No regrets at all. The only thing I would say, is given your age, you will need reading glasses in a few years time, as the lasik will treat the myopia only. But totally worth doing. Good luck.

Newhorizon21 · 08/04/2022 06:15

@DivorcedAndDelighted

I had LASIK 16 years ago, got some minor complications including dry eyes for about a year and, at one point, a dislodged corneal flap when my toddler hit me i in the eye. Had a reaction to some of the drops. Had some halo-ing at night but tbh I used to get that with contacts and it didn't bother me at all - I don't get it any more. The eye surgery was still one of the best decisions of my life. For years I used to give silent thanks to the surgeon every morning. I still often think of him, and actually contacted his office last year to say thanks. I'm a health researcher now, though I wasn't then. I have kept an 'eye' on safety research and it's impressive. I know that many eye surgeons have had their own eyes fixed, as have many other healthcare professionals. I'd suggest:
  • Go for a consultation with a specialist clinic or two, to get their realistic assessment of likely results for you as an individual. They know what they're talking about. You can't expect a general optician to be an expert in this.
  • Look at experience and outcome stats for eyes in your prescription range. Clinics should publish stats by category. The surgeon's experience won't necessarily correlate with how impressive his job title is. Someone who is a consultant at an eye hospital specialising in eg trauma, cataracts, rare forms of blindness, may be brilliant in those areas but less experienced at laser vision correction than a surgeon who is not yet a consultant, but specialises in this. My surgeon had done over 10,000 LASIK procedures when he did mine. Last time I checked he was at 80,000 plus!!
  • Once you're on the mailing list for a private clinic you may get offers when they have spare capacity. I got this from Optimax.

Age - I had mine done in my mid 30s & was told repeatedly that I would need reading glasses in my 40s. Well, I'm just turning 50 and I don't yet.
You may be advised to consider implantable contacts. A friend had these recently & was advised that anyone 50+ should go for them routinely.

  • Don't wait forever "to see what the long term results are" - this has been around for years and there's plenty of data. A friend of mine had vision correction surgery in the 1980s. I was looking into it for about 5 years and my optician kept saying "oh, wait a few years, see what happens", and after 5 years I realised those goalposts were always moving. By the way, when I went to that optician for an independent check up 2 years after my surgery, she said she couldn't see any scarring or any sign that I'd had surgery, even on her highest magnification examination.
Thank you, this is helpful