Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rishi's wife does not pay tax (millions!!) on dividends!

870 replies

FlowerArranger · 07/04/2022 06:16

From today's Guardian :

Rishi Sunak’s multi-millionaire wife claims non-domicile status, it has emerged, which allows her to save millions of pounds in tax on dividends collected from her family’s IT business empire.

Akshata Murthy, who receives about £11.5m in annual dividends from her stake in the Indian IT services company Infosys, declares non-dom status, a scheme that allows people to avoid tax on foreign earnings.

www.theguardian.com/politics/2022/apr/06/rishi-sunaks-wife-claims-non-domicile-status?CMP=Share_AndroidApp_Other

Anyone as outraged by this as I am? I mean what the actual fuck?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Lockheart · 10/04/2022 11:34

@Nennypops

Non-dom is a legal status which is not governed by you but by your parents domicile and the length of time you spend in the UK.

Non-domiciled tax status is governed by the individual.

No it is not. The remittance basis is governed by the individual. They choose whether or not to use it every year in their self-assessment tax return.

Non-dom status is determined by law. You're either non-dom or you're not.

mrshoho · 10/04/2022 11:25

Believe me if I had that much money I'd gladly pay. What the fuck would an individual need 500 million in dividends alone for?

Folicky · 10/04/2022 11:23

@Hollyhead

To me it’s a non story - unless we expect politicians and their families to follow different tax laws than the rest of us? She’s not breaking any laws. It just highlights the gap between the rich and poor.

The maths of the article also doesn’t add up - I wouldn’t expect a dividend of 11.5m from a company only worth 690m, of which I had a 1% stake. You can only take dividend from profits so that would suggest a 1.15bn profit for the year which would make the company worth more.

You go Marty Byrde
rwalker · 10/04/2022 11:20

Love to know how many of us would pay tax that we didn't have to

mrshoho · 10/04/2022 11:16

[quote Lockheart]@Nennypops no it is not. You are confusing non-domiciled with the remittance basis.

Non-dom is a legal status which is not governed by you but by your parents domicile and the length of time you spend in the UK.

The remittance basis is a method of taxation, only open to non-doms, which you have to decide to claim year on year in your tax return. That is a choice, your non-dom status is not.[/quote]
You seem to be missing the point. She has chosen to be non domiciled. The reason for this is to make use of the remittance basis open only to non dom indivuals. She could have chosen to be domiciled in the UK. She is married to the Chancellor, her kids go to school here, her family home is here etc etc. You are normally domiciled in the country you intend to permanently reside in. By carefully saying she intends to return to India one day she can choose to be non domiciled.

This from uk gov guidelines
When might HMRC challenge your domicile status?
5.22 We do not normally challenge any person who says they have a UK domicile. If you say you’ve a non-UK domicile, we might want to check whether or not that is correct, particularly if you were born in the UK.

5.23 By its very nature, a check aimed at establishing your domicile will be an in-depth examination of:

your background
lifestyle
your intentions over the course of your lifetime.
Any check of this sort will extend to areas of your life, and that of your family, that you might not normally think are relevant to your UK tax affairs. We will need to ask these questions and sometimes ask you to provide us with evidence about these areas of your life, as part of our check. This may involve meeting with you in person.

Nennypops · 10/04/2022 10:52

Non-dom is a legal status which is not governed by you but by your parents domicile and the length of time you spend in the UK.

Non-domiciled tax status is governed by the individual.

Cornettoninja · 10/04/2022 10:36

But to suggest that she's made a moral choice to pay in India is nonsense

As is the narrative that the UK wants to take the money out of philanthropic (billionaire) Indians and their employees mouths.

The sums of money being talked about are not going to bankrupt any of the companies involved, they’re barely a dent in their profits. Which is one of the reason, morally, it’s shady to go to so much effort (i.e any effort) to avoid tax liability. It’s even shadier when one of the beneficiaries of all this hoarding is in charge of our treasury and has denied national insurance relief for months in a time of cost of living sky rocketing.

Legality means very little when those making the laws are not beyond reproach themselves.

Lockheart · 10/04/2022 10:36

And yes, the remittance basis is the one which comes with a charge after 7 years. No-one pays anything to be non-dom, in the same way I pay nothing to be UK-dom.

Zilla1 · 10/04/2022 10:36

It's practically like she's a charity, Giving her hard earned money in tax to help the poor.

Are there poor in Cayman? There are some in Mauritius.

FWIW, I suspect the green card revelations and the implications of the expectations of what holding a Green Card means will cause more problems for the Chancellor. That and the competence in how the furlough money was distributed, both to the fraudulent and the millions of the self employed who were left high and dry.

Lockheart · 10/04/2022 10:34

@Nennypops no it is not. You are confusing non-domiciled with the remittance basis.

Non-dom is a legal status which is not governed by you but by your parents domicile and the length of time you spend in the UK.

The remittance basis is a method of taxation, only open to non-doms, which you have to decide to claim year on year in your tax return. That is a choice, your non-dom status is not.

Nennypops · 10/04/2022 10:29

[quote Watchamocauli]@ancientgran

Prove it where she lied. She is paying taxes to the country where she is earning it.

You want to fill UK Coffers with Indian earned company? Shame on you

Infosys has 229K employees worldwide. My family and friends work there so no their hard earned dividends are not for UK TAX coffers[/quote]
The employees have no choice about what happens to the dividends that shareholders are paid off the back of their work. In this case, they don't even go into Indian tax coffers given the use of tax shelters.

HardyBuckette · 10/04/2022 10:29

@Notonthestairs

I'm pretty certain that they'd have specified Indian tax if that is where she is paying it. Otherwise it's very sloppy wording.

I don't doubt it's legal and she's certainly not the only wealthy person to do it. I've read articles about how much Indian money is put through Mauritius to limit tax at home. Millions lost to their exchequer.

But to suggest that she's made a moral choice to pay in India is nonsense.

Yes, if she is in fact paying full tax in India, her PR people need sacking. Because if she actually were doing that, shouting it from the rooftops would be her best line of defence. You can tell that because the bots and defenders are all trying to say that's what's happening.
Nennypops · 10/04/2022 10:27

@Watchamocauli

She did not lie anywhere about her non Dom status. Proof it don’t just forth crap from twitter
Her spokesman said she had no choice but to be non dom. That is absolute rubbish. It's a status you can only gain if you apply for it, and if you keep it up by making the required payments.
Notonthestairs · 10/04/2022 10:21

I'm pretty certain that they'd have specified Indian tax if that is where she is paying it. Otherwise it's very sloppy wording.

I don't doubt it's legal and she's certainly not the only wealthy person to do it. I've read articles about how much Indian money is put through Mauritius to limit tax at home. Millions lost to their exchequer.

But to suggest that she's made a moral choice to pay in India is nonsense.

ancientgran · 10/04/2022 10:13

@Notonthestairs

"All Ms Murthy's monies are rightfully earned and properly taxed in the country where it's earned."

People keep writing this. All I've read is that she pays international tax - not Indian tax. The implication is that it's funnelled to a tax haven like Mauritius where tax can be minimal.

Smoke and mirrors isn't it. They say something that can be interpreted how you like and the Sunak fans interpret it to say something it doesn't say.
ancientgran · 10/04/2022 10:11

[quote Watchamocauli]@ancientgran

Prove it where she lied. She is paying taxes to the country where she is earning it.

You want to fill UK Coffers with Indian earned company? Shame on you

Infosys has 229K employees worldwide. My family and friends work there so no their hard earned dividends are not for UK TAX coffers[/quote]
The first statement was that it was just one of those things, she's Indian so she is non dom. It wasn't true, she applied for non dom status it didn't just automatically happen.

From The Independent A spokesperson for Ms Murthy said: “India does not allow its citizens to hold the citizenship of another country simultaneously. So, according to British law, Ms Murty is treated as non-domiciled for UK tax purposes. She has always and will continue to pay UK taxes on all her UK income.

So unless you think her spokesperson said that without her permission she lied as tax liability is nothing to do with her not having British citizenship.

Sunak continued that with the she loves her country, she won't cut ties with it. No one asked her to plenty of Indian people make their permanent home in the UK and don't claim non dom status and they probably still love India.

I wonder how she arranged her Indian taxes, did she pay them, did she pay a reduced rate as a non resident? It will be interesting to see what else comes out and also how the US views the green card situation.

C8H10N4O2 · 10/04/2022 10:07

Her father started his life in poverty and by dint of hard work has raised himself up

Guff.

He was born into a comfortably off middle class Brahmin family who could afford to educate him privately and send him to university.

Nennypops · 10/04/2022 10:01

Akshata pays taxes towards the country that helped her parents build Infosys. As she should.

Apparently not, given her use of a Mauritius tax haven.

Notonthestairs · 10/04/2022 09:58

"All Ms Murthy's monies are rightfully earned and properly taxed in the country where it's earned."

People keep writing this. All I've read is that she pays international tax - not Indian tax. The implication is that it's funnelled to a tax haven like Mauritius where tax can be minimal.

Rosehugger · 10/04/2022 09:54

The whole thing is looking extremely fishy

From dishy to fishy.

C8H10N4O2 · 10/04/2022 09:53

Please do some reading about Infosys and how it was started by a pretty poor couple who came from nothing in a country with no social security system, and how it has greatly helped reduce income disparity in India. They are not the usual run of billionaires. Akshata pays taxes towards the country that helped her parents build Infosys. As she should

Oh come on, both Murty's parents came from comfortably off middle class backgrounds and were university educated at a time when only the very privileged went to university.

The building of a giant company is sufficient achievement that it doesn't need mythologising by pretending the founders came from poverty.

vickyc90 · 10/04/2022 09:48

@LoisLane66

She CANNOT bring those earnings or the interest earned, into the UK unless she pays tax on whatever the amount is. She pays correct tax here on earnings here. It's all above board. Her husband went into more detail than was requested when he explained her status. The only reason she is offering to pay tax on money earned abroad but not brought into the UK, is the hue and cry the general public have made over her status. Her father started his life in poverty and by dint of hard work has raised himself up. All Ms Murthy's monies are rightfully earned and properly taxed in the country where it's earned. Why do people have a problem with individuals who better their born position. I wish she hadn't caved in.

One of my family works in Dubai where they pay no tax but those earnings can't be brought or sent here without attracting tax.

Got it in one, tax in this country is insane. I'm all for a safety net but we also need to get everyone out working to support themselves.
Zilla1 · 10/04/2022 09:43

We now have two people in arguably the most important roles in British society held by people who need to resign

Only the two?

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 10/04/2022 09:42

It's definitely bye bye Rishi now, after the review, he might have been able to salvage his career before, but he'll be gone now.

SundaeSunday100 · 10/04/2022 09:40

The whole thing is looking extremely fishy. The fact that they are now apparently moving out of No.11 looks to me like they have a lot more to hide and are desperately trying to close the lid on things. I think there is way more to this than has been reported. The greed is just staggering.