Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rishi's wife does not pay tax (millions!!) on dividends!

870 replies

FlowerArranger · 07/04/2022 06:16

From today's Guardian :

Rishi Sunak’s multi-millionaire wife claims non-domicile status, it has emerged, which allows her to save millions of pounds in tax on dividends collected from her family’s IT business empire.

Akshata Murthy, who receives about £11.5m in annual dividends from her stake in the Indian IT services company Infosys, declares non-dom status, a scheme that allows people to avoid tax on foreign earnings.

www.theguardian.com/politics/2022/apr/06/rishi-sunaks-wife-claims-non-domicile-status?CMP=Share_AndroidApp_Other

Anyone as outraged by this as I am? I mean what the actual fuck?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Zilla1 · 07/04/2022 10:39

We're all in it together and a millionaire Chancellor with a billionaire wife will be able to empathise with those who don't have the money for food or heating just as much as someone who grew up on benefits, if not more. It's discrimination to suggest otherwise. It's also why MPs must be paid more as there are some jobs where if you pay peanuts then you get moneys. Like MPs. And the City. Not the NHS and care workers.
they get claps.

And just look at the 5p cut in fuel duty and the 2024 tax cut before the election to see how the Chancellor is moving heaven and earth to satisfy his electorate.

cyclamenqueen · 07/04/2022 10:36

@EstelleCostanza

It’s a long time since I looked at the English law of domicile but I’m pretty sure your current domicile - which is what’s relevant here - isn’t determined by your fathers. Think that’s a red herring
That’s true , you can change your domicile but the assumption prims facie is that unless you apply to change it your domicile is related to your parents ( usually fathers ) domicile. The fact that she was born in India, the bulk of her assets are in India, her nationality is Indian, she holds an Indian passport means that frankly her domicile is India, the fact that she is married to an Englishman should not change that .

Two of my siblings are married to non U.K. citizens, both of whom have retained their domicile of origin. I gave neices and nephews who have the U.K. as their domicile of origin and who are non U.K. domicile .

Cornettoninja · 07/04/2022 10:35

@Electrox

I also find the assumption that we should get the tax take rather than India pretty repellent.

Agreed. It's all quite Colonial.

I don’t necessarily think the tax should be paid here, what I do think is that someone benefitting from what, is for all practical purposes a complicated tax set up, to the tune of millions of pounds annually shouldn’t be entangled with a senior member of the cabinet. Certainly not one that is in control of millions of peoples financial security and tax laws.

It might be legal, it’s not morally right though. It’s also either fucking stupidity or complacency rooted in arrogance to think that this wouldn’t be an issue. Gary Barlow and Jimmy Carr didn’t escape scrutiny for taking advantage of perfectly legal tax directives, why would the Sunak’s not think their set up would be any different?

Zilla1 · 07/04/2022 10:30

'must be paying tax somewhere' I admire your optimism though to be clear, I have in mind the generic billionaire with scope to manage the geographic and temporal dimensions of revenue and taxation rather than any individual

missmoon · 07/04/2022 10:30

@MarshaBradyo

But in this case a multi millionaire woman is using the get out.

Tax is being paid. Does it help that India is receiving large chunks of this wealth in tax?

Do you know how much tax she is paying in India? We don't even know if she is domiciled in India for tax purposes, let alone whether she is actually paying tax there, and if so, how much.

There are lots of tax avoidance schemes in India too. The very rich rarely pay a lot of tax.

Rosehugger · 07/04/2022 10:27

She must be paying tax somewhere. If someone is clearly resident in the UK though and using our public services they should be paying tax here.

tigger1001 · 07/04/2022 10:25

[quote Lockheart]@ancientgran it's not a get-out, it's something that was set in stone when she was born.

She can't change her domicile of origin any more than you or I can.

Your domicile of origin depends on your parents and not where you were physically born. If your parents are married, your domicile of origin is your father's domicile. If your parents are unmarried, it is your mother's.[/quote]
This!

Electrox · 07/04/2022 10:22

I also find the assumption that we should get the tax take rather than India pretty repellent.

Agreed. It's all quite Colonial.

Edmontosaurus · 07/04/2022 10:22

My take away from this story is:

Labour believe husbands should control their wives finances.

Labour have no idea how tax and the economy work.

Labour are trying to stir up class hatred because they have no properly thought out positive policies.

If they do not get their act together they will, once again, leave the field completely open for Boris and his British Nationalist party to walk away with the next election.

Zilla1 · 07/04/2022 10:20

For those asserting the appropriate amount of tax will be paid in India, are you certain that there is no double Dutch or more recent tax optimising structure to the ownership and dividends payment so the 'appropriate' amount of tax does not approximate to zero some time in the future?

Imagine the stress this will cause Priti, Michael, Liz and everyone queueing up to defend the Chancellor today. Well, stress when they are not trying to meet donors and power brokers to compensate for one of the runners having a billionaire in their camp with all their corporate friends. Why did Teresa and Priti have a falling out, back in the day?

Electrox · 07/04/2022 10:19

Akshata Murthy is not a politician and stays away from the limelight. Why should she be singled out? It just reads like a witch hunt.

EstelleCostanza · 07/04/2022 10:19

It’s a long time since I looked at the English law of domicile but I’m pretty sure your current domicile - which is what’s relevant here - isn’t determined by your fathers. Think that’s a red herring

MarshaBradyo · 07/04/2022 10:18

But in this case a multi millionaire woman is using the get out.

Tax is being paid. Does it help that India is receiving large chunks of this wealth in tax?

EstelleCostanza · 07/04/2022 10:17

Yes I think that is why Boris disclaimed his US citizenship which he had by virtue of being born there. But obviously not lived there since childhood.

Lockheart · 07/04/2022 10:17

@ancientgran it's not a get-out, it's something that was set in stone when she was born.

She can't change her domicile of origin any more than you or I can.

Your domicile of origin depends on your parents and not where you were physically born. If your parents are married, your domicile of origin is your father's domicile. If your parents are unmarried, it is your mother's.

Toomanyradishes · 07/04/2022 10:16

*ancientgran

tigger1001

"The BBC are saying she can do this as her father was born in India, is she his chattel instead of her husband's?"

Domicile follows your fathers domicile generally. It doesn't change on marriage any more. Think it was the 1970's that changed.

So much for independent women. Claim to be daddy's little girl if it saves you money.*

Shes not claiming to be her fathers daughter, she is her fathers daughter. And the law currently states that your country of domicile is determined by your fathers country of domicile, in the same way as your country of citizenship is determined by your parents country of citizenship.

Now by all means complain that the law is sexist because it only takens into account your fathers country of domicile not your mothers.

But following this law doesnt make her any less of an independant woman just because the law is sexist.

Many women are given their fathers surname as their surname. Does that automatically make them less independant?

tigger1001 · 07/04/2022 10:14

"But in this case a multi millionaire woman is using the get out."

Not sure it's a get out. She will still be paying tax on the income, just not in the uk. Which the law allows her to do. She can legally claim non domiciled status. She certainly won't be the only one.

Do you think her domicile should change on marriage?

lljkk · 07/04/2022 10:14

Oh, and in theory we Yanks abroad have to pay $10 or more to efile, although I keep getting efile for free (no idea why). Or pay $12+ to photocopy & post our tax documents.

The individual states also want us expat Americans to file for any income that can be placed in that state, such as that $12 ... but again we won't owe, we're just obliged to do a lot of paperwork.

Costs $800+/year to get our taxes done professionally as expats.

I'm not minted so take chances of doing IRS forms myself

Chessie678 · 07/04/2022 10:13

@daimbarsatemydogsbone
The US is quite aggressive in taxing non-resident citizens. The starting position is that they are charged to US tax on worldwide income from all sources. However that is subject to various exemptions e.g for foreign income and the application of double tax treaties with other countries. The reality is that as a US non- resident citizen who earns all their income outside the US you are unlikely to be liable for US tax. That’s a different issue though as it’s about how non- residents are taxed.

Citizenship is rarely relevant to the UK tax system. The starting position in the UK is that “UK residents” which can include non- doms are charged to tax on worldwide income and gains but again there are lots of exceptions to that including the application of our double tax treaties with other countries and the non- dom rules. Even UK domiciled residents tend to get tax relief in the UK if they have already paid foreign tax on the same amount.

Arguably the non- dom rules make the UK a relatively attractive jurisdiction for foreigners and there are arguments for reforming them e.g the effect is to attract foreigners to the UK but dissuade them from bringing their money here. But they are in place for economic reasons as a deliberate choice by parliament and non- doms still tend to pay a lot of UK tax overall.

ancientgran · 07/04/2022 10:12

@EstelleCostanza

The English law of domicile is quite complicated. There is no single test. So I’m not quite sure where the thing about the father comes from. It is true the US will tax it’s citizens even if domiciled elsewhere. Hence people disclaiming their us citizenship when they don’t fancy paying taxes in a country they gave no intention of returning to
Is that why Johnson gave up his US citizenship?

I knew young men back in the 60s who did it as they didn't want to be called up for Vietnam. At least that was what they said, I suppose it could have been tax and it sounded cooler to be anti a war.

lljkk · 07/04/2022 10:10

USA insists that we file, but the tax exempt earnings allowance is pretty generous, maybe $80k now. so yes we have to document our earnings, but most Americans abroad don't end up owing any taxes. Plus we have our usual tax-free-income allowance, maybe $3k now?

Still a hassle to file (!)

UK doesn't seem to apply exemptions on earnings abroad ,from what I can work out. So yes, I was liable to file & pay tax to HMRC for $12.00 earned in interest.

ancientgran · 07/04/2022 10:10

@tigger1001

"So much for independent women. Claim to be daddy's little girl if it saves you money"

Applies to men too. It's a basic principle - domicile generally follows your fathers domicile.

But in this case a multi millionaire woman is using the get out.
ancientgran · 07/04/2022 10:09

[quote daimbarsatemydogsbone]@ancientgran

Didn't some people do that a few years back and then the taxman caught up with them, clarified the rules and they had to repay the money? I can't remember the details, must have a google.

Yes - the loan charge. HMRC applied the law retrospectively. People lost their houses, there have been at least 8 suicides. The difference being that the people involved weren't millionaires and were in many cases tricked or at least misled. As usual HMRC didn't go after Sir Bufton Tufton and his rich mates who peddled the schemes - they came after all the little guys and took all their money because they were an easy target.

This will happen again soon as HMRC is launching a new retrospective attack on contractors, but they only go after the small fry easy targets and never the providers.

Funny how a lot of the work formerly done by contractors is now being exported to be done in India by firms like Infosys - the source of Rishi's wife's wealth.[/quote]
Yes that is the one I vaguely remembered. So as for "if you boss offered you a scheme where you paid 5% rather than 20%" be wary of this sort of offering.

Yes they should go after the big boys but everyone should pay their taxes and if people didn't pay the correct amount then I think they should pay up, obviously they should be offered a way to do it that is workable for them but I honestly don't see why their lifestyle should be sacrosanct when others pay the going rate.

I don't know if people had to pay penalties and if they did I think they should be able to fight that if they were misled.

tigger1001 · 07/04/2022 10:08

"So much for independent women. Claim to be daddy's little girl if it saves you money"

Applies to men too. It's a basic principle - domicile generally follows your fathers domicile.

MarshaBradyo · 07/04/2022 10:06

@Toomanyradishes

She pays indian tax on her indian income. If she brings that money into the uk she pays uk tax on it. Any money she earns in the uk she pays uk tax on. Is that correct?

And what people are annoyed about is the tax on the income generated in india is paid in india, and benefits india. You are saying the UK should get that money. Honestly i think she would lose in the press either way. This way you get the press frothing about her taking money out of the mouths of starving british babies. If the situation were reversed no doubt they would be frothing about her taking the money out of the mouths of starving indian babies.

Im not a tory fan, but I am pretty sure the main issue here in the press is that she is an Indian woman who is successful in her own right.

Pretty much. It either goes to India or here.