Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rishi's wife does not pay tax (millions!!) on dividends!

870 replies

FlowerArranger · 07/04/2022 06:16

From today's Guardian :

Rishi Sunak’s multi-millionaire wife claims non-domicile status, it has emerged, which allows her to save millions of pounds in tax on dividends collected from her family’s IT business empire.

Akshata Murthy, who receives about £11.5m in annual dividends from her stake in the Indian IT services company Infosys, declares non-dom status, a scheme that allows people to avoid tax on foreign earnings.

www.theguardian.com/politics/2022/apr/06/rishi-sunaks-wife-claims-non-domicile-status?CMP=Share_AndroidApp_Other

Anyone as outraged by this as I am? I mean what the actual fuck?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Notonthestairs · 08/04/2022 09:42

@mrshoho

Grin at Sean Connery. Poor guy not even allowed to rest in peace!
Shock ShockShockShockShockShock oh my. Apologies. 😳
mrshoho · 08/04/2022 09:40

Grin at Sean Connery. Poor guy not even allowed to rest in peace!

Karwomannghia · 08/04/2022 09:39

I’ve just read on Apple news that they both were registered as permanent residents of the US whilst he was chancellor! Yes it maybe within rules but it’s still immoral, greedy and means poor people have to basically shoulder HIS tax burden which he can easily afford and continue to live a life of luxury with. It’s absolutely disgusting. People running the country should care about the people in it, not just themselves. Vile. The next government needs to get taxation sorted properly.

tigger1001 · 08/04/2022 09:38

"That's not true, though, is it? She isn't someone residing in the UK whose PERMANENT HOME, or domicile, is abroad. She is married to a UK secretary of a state and her permanent home is here."

Do you know that? Is she planning to live in the uk forever? Is she planning to return to India when her husbands political career is over?

If her domicile of origin hasn't changed, then she is entirely following the tax rules.

tigger1001 · 08/04/2022 09:35

@Notonthestairs

"I'm waiting for the media to now name all the entertainers, football players and other multi-millionaires who are non-dom as well. Bet that's not going to happen as: A - it's not part of their current narrative B - what they're doing is not illegal."

Off the top of my head Jensen Button, Lewis Hamilton, Michael Caine, Phil Collins, Phillip Green, Sean Connery & Mick Jagger. In fairness they do seem to primarily live outside the UK - unlike Murty.

Well Sean Connery is definitely outside the uk tax system considering he passed away a few years ago.

The others? I don't know their domicile and whether they have changed it to the country they reside in. If they don't live here they will not be uk resident, but could still be domiciled.

knowinglesseveryday · 08/04/2022 09:34

It's all bullshit and scams, and fuck the rest of us. In fact, squeeze the rest of us. They all stink.

knowinglesseveryday · 08/04/2022 09:33

@tigger1001

"She is married to the chancellor, for one thing. And she LIVES here, which the rules say mean she should pay here. And if she doesn't, that's interesting too."

The rules say she can elect to pay tax on her overseas earnings on the remittance basis as a non domiciled individual. She has chosen to do so. All within the tax rules.

That's not true, though, is it? She isn't someone residing in the UK whose PERMANENT HOME, or domicile, is abroad. She is married to a UK secretary of a state and her permanent home is here.
mrshoho · 08/04/2022 09:28

@SamphirethePogoingStickerist

But you don't need non dom status unless you live here?!
But the idea is that an individual is temporarily resident here Her residency looks pretty permanent don't you think. HMRC looks at where you buy your Residential property. Where your kids go to school etc. It seems she is using the excuse that she intends to return to India at some point to care for her billionaire parents god bless them as they reason for electing to be non dom.
Notonthestairs · 08/04/2022 09:26

@tigger1001 - sorry, I don't follow. Are you saying that HMRC (or relevant body) can't review & change her status if they think circumstances have changed? Not being goady - I'm interested.

As far as I can see she's chosen to apply for this and can equally choose to have it removed.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 08/04/2022 09:21

But you don't need non dom status unless you live here?!

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 08/04/2022 09:21

@Cheekymaw

We get the Government we deserved . The public get what the public want as Mr Weller said.
Later on in that song it's "the public wants what the public gets" which seems more apt - all those non-millionaire aspirational Tory voters chanting "shaft us some more, we're scum, we deserve it!"
Zonder · 08/04/2022 09:19

What do you mean @tigger1001 ? She doesn't have to be non Dom, especially since UK is where she lived most of the time. That's the bit that makes it immoral for me.

tigger1001 · 08/04/2022 09:17

[quote Notonthestairs]@Eleganz - agree with your post.

Non dom status isn't static. She may well have been non dom in the past but not now.

[/quote]
Even if she elected to pay on the arising basis, she would still be non-domiciled.

mrshoho · 08/04/2022 09:16

And although her non dom status is technically legal HMRC can and do investigate this loophole. The statement from her representative 'explaining' the reasons has been pulled apart as factually untrue. Yet again this is another rule that the mega rich are allowed to interpret to suit their own greed. If the laws were changed so there was a definite right or wrong like the rest of us have to live by then it would be far simpler. But our ruling leaders past and present have managed to keep these tax rules very complex. And don't people just hate it when we dare to question. They all make me sick.

Notonthestairs · 08/04/2022 09:16

"I'm waiting for the media to now name all the entertainers, football players and other multi-millionaires who are non-dom as well. Bet that's not going to happen as:
A - it's not part of their current narrative
B - what they're doing is not illegal."

Off the top of my head Jensen Button, Lewis Hamilton, Michael Caine, Phil Collins, Phillip Green, Sean Connery & Mick Jagger. In fairness they do seem to primarily live outside the UK - unlike Murty.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 08/04/2022 09:16

@Cheekymaw

We get the Government we deserved . The public get what the public want as Mr Weller said.
Yeah, er not really. As always even amongst those who can be arsed to vote, quite a lot more people didn't vote for this current shower of cunts than did. On the other hand, I suppose our apparent unwillingness to change our antediluvian voting systems means we doomed to repeat this.
SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 08/04/2022 09:11

It’s a loophole which she is exploiting.

It isn't a loophole though. It is how the legal exemption was set up. This is how it works, how it was always meant to work. Not what it says on the tin, but exactly what it was designed for. That's why there is a slidign scale of payments to be made. So, whilst the dividends themselves are not taxed here in the UK, there is payment made every year for her having received them, and any other earnings out of the country.

Those who have been living in the UK for at least seven of the previous nine tax years must pay £30,000 a year to the government. Those who have lived in the UK for 12 of the previous 14 tax years must pay £60,000 a year. UK residents must pay tax on their worldwide earnings once they have been in the country for 15 of the previous 20 years.

The thing that would be heinous would be is she went home to India for a while and then came back, resetting her non dom clock. Which might happen if/when her parents require help, nursng. Who kows. It hasn't happened, may never happen. But the conjecture is being made to fan the flames.

Seek the person with the fan...

HardyBuckette · 08/04/2022 09:07

I'm waiting for the media to now name all the entertainers, football players and other multi-millionaires who are non-dom as well. Bet that's not going to happen as:
A - it's not part of their current narrative
B - what they're doing is not illegal.

You forgot C, they're not married to the Chancellor of the Exchequer.

It really is quite abundantly clear that who AM is married to is the reason for this being of such significant interest. That's why it's so important. One could think she's done nothing wrong at all whilst also acknowledging that incredibly blatant point. With that in mind, your post is very disingenuous.

Notonthestairs · 08/04/2022 09:07

@Eleganz - agree with your post.

Non dom status isn't static. She may well have been non dom in the past but not now.

tigger1001 · 08/04/2022 09:07

"It’s a loophole which she is exploiting. "

To me it's no a loophole. It's Hmrc rules. She can apply for remittance basis if she meets the conditions. Just like anyone else who meets the conditions. That's not a loophole that a clever tax accountant has discovered. That's available to any non domiciled individual with more than £2k foreign income.

People might not like the rules and there is a discussion there, but it's not a loophole.

tigger1001 · 08/04/2022 09:03

"She is married to the chancellor, for one thing. And she LIVES here, which the rules say mean she should pay here. And if she doesn't, that's interesting too."

The rules say she can elect to pay tax on her overseas earnings on the remittance basis as a non domiciled individual. She has chosen to do so. All within the tax rules.

Iggly · 08/04/2022 09:00

[quote Wheniruletheworld]@iggly The chancellor of the exchequer does not 'make tax laws'. Do you know how laws are made in this country. Certainly not by a single person. try this:
www.parliament.uk/about/how/laws/

and this re non-dom status
www.theguardian.com/politics/2022/apr/07/what-is-non-domicile-status-and-who-qualifies-hmrc[/quote]
You know exactly what I mean. He oversees HMRC who, funnily enough, will draft the tax laws which are then put before Parliament. Better?

I know how Parliament works but thank you.

I also know that non Dom status is a choice based on the principle that you are not putting down permanent roots in the UK.

It’s a loophole which she is exploiting.

It’s high profile because of who her husband is.

Made worse by the fact he’s overseeing the biggest cost of living crisis we’ve ever known in living memory.

C8H10N4O2 · 08/04/2022 08:59

None of us know where Murty pays tax, people are assuming its paid in India but we don't know how her wealth is held. All we know is that she has used her Indian citizenship to claim non dom status despite being clearly established in the UK, children at UK schools etc. HMRC normally require evidence of non doms being longer term temporary residents.

It matters in two ways. Her husband is responsible for decision making on the non dom rules and HMRC senior staff have said they were not aware of this in discussions on non dom rules.

It also matters that the people we may be electing to high office have a long term commitment to the country which is questionable if they or their spouse have declared to HMRC they plan to leave.

Iggly · 08/04/2022 08:58

@Eleganz

It is like we've had collective amnesia about this "non-dom" business. I distinctly remember that there was a huge furore previously about it, particularly around people with "non-dom" status sitting in the house of lords. Lists of non-dom people were published and there was a lot of public anger. Small changes were made around the house of lords but that was it and it all died down eventually.

Now we find that the wife of the chancellor, the man who has just raised our taxes, is also benefitting from this carefully protected loophole. The idea that this is racial motivated is nonsense, it is the fact that non-dom status is not acceptable to most of the British public as it allows very wealthy people who live here and benefit from doing so to avoid paying tax here for what is, for them, a nominal fee.

The issue is that our tax laws specifically allow rich people to reduce their tax burdens way beyond what normal people can do and this now goes straight to the top as even the Chancellor's wife is doing it by using a loop hole that some how asks us not to believe the evidence in front of our eyes that despite being married to a senior British politician, having 3 homes here, having children and educating them here, making large donations to top UK private schools, she is actually domiciled in India and all this is just a temporary arrangement. Just like all the other tax Dodgers who are insisting that Monaco or other tax havens are their true homes, not their massive piles in London. It stinks.

Many of us pay over a third of our incomes in taxation (either from direct deductions or through VAT), yet we have super rich people paying only tiny fractions of that.

^this

You have to pay £30k for her non Dom status I understand - so it is only for very fucking rich.

Zilla1 · 08/04/2022 08:54

Although I can imagine the Chancellor looking around the Cabinet table and considering how loyal his friends have been, if anyone does have prejudices about Indians and tax, you might not want to have a look at what a Churchillian approach to tax involved.

Swipe left for the next trending thread