Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rishi's wife does not pay tax (millions!!) on dividends!

870 replies

FlowerArranger · 07/04/2022 06:16

From today's Guardian :

Rishi Sunak’s multi-millionaire wife claims non-domicile status, it has emerged, which allows her to save millions of pounds in tax on dividends collected from her family’s IT business empire.

Akshata Murthy, who receives about £11.5m in annual dividends from her stake in the Indian IT services company Infosys, declares non-dom status, a scheme that allows people to avoid tax on foreign earnings.

www.theguardian.com/politics/2022/apr/06/rishi-sunaks-wife-claims-non-domicile-status?CMP=Share_AndroidApp_Other

Anyone as outraged by this as I am? I mean what the actual fuck?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 08/04/2022 12:20

@LauraNicolaides Crikey! That's what I meant. I don't use much SM and coudn't think how to phrase it. Thanks!

mrshoho · 08/04/2022 12:19

I would describe it more as transparency. Why shouldn't we all be more aware of the financial circumstances of the people elected to serve this country?

LauraNicolaides · 08/04/2022 12:16

[quote SamphirethePogoingStickerist]@Dahliasrule I don't get all the 'optics' stuff. It (any kind of 'it') makes little difference to me in any part of my life. If it works it works, if it does not work then it doesn't matter what it looks like.[/quote]
I agree.

It's politics for the Instagram generation!

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 08/04/2022 12:11

@Teael

It's just an outright lie, though. Her home is clearly here, her husband is in one of our highest offices of state, for fucks sake!

People voted for this.

The majority of people who voted didn't vote Tory.

Labour policy for the 2019 election was abolish the tax treatment Rishi's wife and other wealthy people use.

www.reuters.com/article/uk-britain-politics-labour-nondom-idUKKBN1W60FZ

At least she doesn't make any pretence to have any interest in staying the UK a moment longer than she has to, unlike many others.

mrshoho · 08/04/2022 12:00

It will be interesting to read more about their green card situation. The knives are really out for him. He's been an MP since 2015 but all that time he possibly held a green card? Is it not a requirement of a green card to have an intention to make the US your permanent residence? We're these green cards bought due to being investors in US business? I can't think they would have been student visas but maybe they were?

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 08/04/2022 11:59

@Dahliasrule I don't get all the 'optics' stuff. It (any kind of 'it') makes little difference to me in any part of my life. If it works it works, if it does not work then it doesn't matter what it looks like.

Dahliasrule · 08/04/2022 11:57

SamphirethePogoingStickerist, it may not be against the rules but it is not a good look.

luckylavender · 08/04/2022 11:48

@OutingHobby

This person is married to the chancellor whose job is to redistribute the taxes paid in the UK fairly

It isn't her job though.

But she lives in Downing Street. Come on, she's done nothing wrong but it doesn't pass the sniff test.
TurquoiseDress · 08/04/2022 11:42

Since this story emerged yesterday, reading the details, it's outrageous but I'm really not surprised!

How can Rishi Sunak have the first fucking clue about the financial struggles many people are going through currently?

He lives in a mega privileged world completely awash with money and utterly removed from the daily life of those his decisions will impact greatly,

Shit show

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 08/04/2022 11:42

@Dahliasrule

Sky are now reporting that both Sunak and his wife held American Green cards during his first year in the chancellorship. I.e that he was a permanent resident of the US despite holding one of the very top jobs in UK government.
And that's not against the rules either!

here is no residency qualification at all - an MP could even live outside the UK

www.parliament.uk/about/faqs/house-of-commons-faqs/members-faq-page2/#jump14

Dahliasrule · 08/04/2022 11:37

Sky are now reporting that both Sunak and his wife held American Green cards during his first year in the chancellorship. I.e that he was a permanent resident of the US despite holding one of the very top jobs in UK government.

MrsWinters · 08/04/2022 11:36

It’s appalling. Whilst it might be legal, it is really not ethical-she is claiming non-dom status whilst residing here.
If you want to live in our society then you should pay your share. Unfortunately one rule for the rich, another for the rest of us.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 08/04/2022 11:31

@Cornettoninja don't do that. It's a fucked up situation and we all have our own takes on it. That mine's based on decades of such shite bothering me doesn't mean I don't think this is wrong. It's just a small part of a much bigger issue. An issue that all parties suffer from.

Having said that I am now off ot have a look and see how rich the Greens are!!

littledrummergirl · 08/04/2022 11:27

Recently my mil became very unwell and needed palliative care.
Dsil moved in with her for four months while dh and I alternated weekends to give dsil time off.
Does this mean that none of would class our main homes up until this point as still being our main homes despite all moving back into them full time when mil passed away?
Just because someone has chosen to live in another country to their parents they shouldn't be allowed to use this to reset the clock on their tax status.
As a family they are saying that they are not committed to the UK. This should disqualify either of them for being in any positions of power within the country.
Why would you want to shape policies in a country your family is not committed to? It is unlikely to be for the benefit of those who are committed to the country.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 08/04/2022 11:25

@mrshoho

Grin at Sean Connery. Poor guy not even allowed to rest in peace!
Aye imagine dying just to dodge tax, the bastard.
Cornettoninja · 08/04/2022 11:19

@SamphirethePogoingStickerist then I apologise, I may have mixed you up with another poster - I’m blaming covid doing a number on my memory!

@saku is the concept of fairness worthy of derision?

Saku · 08/04/2022 11:14

Why not Sunak paid furlough out of her wife's inherited money, which she inherited in other country? How dare he is asking to pay furlough for UK people from UK people?
His wife pays tax only on UK earned money.... when she and he have so much extra money. How dare she can have 400m inherited money. So unfair Envy .
Why cant Sunak force his wife and show some patriarchy, to distribute her inherited/earned money among UK people. Why they are buying houses from inherited money for themselves.
MORALLY he should donate his money along with his wife's money for roads, ambulance etc. etc. as he holds THE exchequer post. Why he is making furlough schemes in lockdown and charging tax afterwards for same people when business are open? Why cant he give away his money instead when he eats 3 breads at the same time. Grin
When they distribute their money in public then only he can be considered PM material ... ohh wait ..still may be nahhh Hmm Grin

HardyBuckette · 08/04/2022 11:09

Riiiight.

Anyway, if there's one thing that should be abundantly clear, it's that this is not a non-issue. As you were.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 08/04/2022 11:07

@HardyBuckette

I'm not sure which and how many posters have used the 'non-story' term samphire and cba to look back over the thread. If you haven't, then I'm not referring to you, and if you have then the argument that this the wrong story rather than a non-story is not the only one you've been making.
That's a tad convoluted... I've now got the pellet with the poison's in the vessel with the pestle, the chalice from the palace has the brew that is true. goig through my head Smile
Teael · 08/04/2022 11:06

It's just an outright lie, though. Her home is clearly here, her husband is in one of our highest offices of state, for fucks sake!

People voted for this.

HardyBuckette · 08/04/2022 11:04

I'm not sure which and how many posters have used the 'non-story' term samphire and cba to look back over the thread. If you haven't, then I'm not referring to you, and if you have then the argument that this the wrong story rather than a non-story is not the only one you've been making.

LauraNicolaides · 08/04/2022 11:03

[quote Chessie678]@Skyellaskerry
Generally speaking, if a non-dom earns dividends overseas and then buys UK property with them they will be charged to UK tax on the amount used to purchase the UK property. There are a lot of complicated rules aimed at preventing tax avoidance here. Even if you take out a loan to buy UK property but pay off the loan using foreign income, that foreign income can become subject to UK tax, for example. HMRC really think a lot about how to counter tax avoidance and that is a large part of the reason that our tax system is complicated.

There is a concept of "clean capital" which is money which the non-dom earned before they became UK resident. The idea is that the UK should not have the right to tax something which was earned before a person had a connection to the UK. This clean capital can be brought to the UK or used to purchase UK property without incurring UK tax provided it is not mixed with foreign income earned while the non-dom is UK resident. So most remittance basis users will try to buy UK property from clean capital if they can.[/quote]
Thanks for your really helpful explanations @Chessie678 - definitely the best part of this thread!

This discussion reminds me the the populism of brexit.

Just like with EU membership, we have a long-standing, rational, well-thought-through, tedious, dull and complex system which is beyond the comprehension of most people. Some devious people (in this case the Tory competitors of Sunak) take advantage of the complexity, play people like fiddles, and whip up a lot of hysteria to achieve their aims.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 08/04/2022 11:00

[quote Cornettoninja]@SamphirethePogoingStickerist it’s interesting that you seem to think there hasn’t been interest and awareness generally in this previously, one of the reasons I say they’ve been daft from a PR pov is this is a known contentious issue. Pretty easily avoided by declaring it scrupulously which I believe he failed to do, or not taking advantage of it for the duration of his parliamentary career.

I agree that the current interest is likely a tool for smearing although I wouldn’t point the finger at Starmer, BJ still has party gate rumbling in the background along with consequences of Brexit coming to the foreground, financial entanglement with Russian oligarchs, etc. Sunak is the strongest candidate to replace him… it was an easy punch considering that it’s already a point of contention. Media attention is just providing a lot of people with forum to hold discussions they have been trying to have for a some time. Imho it’s a risky move since some people will just add this to growing list of other grievances with this current cabinet but I can see the advantage of making a direct threat to a competitors chance of taking BJ’s position within the party may tip the balance that makes it worth the risk.

I’m also unsure why you’d hold up other tax rules as evidence of why this is all fine. We’re all focussed on one element yes, but more widely there are clearly legal, but immoral or unfair, issues that would benefit from the same public scrutiny. We do not have a ‘fair’ system and we are also not Monaco. I question exactly how much money these policies actually benefit the average tax payer by topping up the treasury. We’re sold the line that these rules create wealth for the UK, but then we were told Brexit would be a wealth creator… I presume that it’d be shouted from the rooftops if it was a success from the electorates perspective but it’s not. Why’s that?[/quote]
I'm not sure I've said any of that, have I?

I've just focussd more on him, and other politicians rather than their spouses.

And I haven't held up other tax rules as evidence of why this is all fine. It isn't fine, none of it is fine. It is all the basis of indifference at bets, corruption at worst. I am decrying a wider issues, based in the personal wealth of those who run the country.

Akshata Murthy is neither here nor there, in the grand scheme of things. The ever increasing disparity in economic equality is the issue.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 08/04/2022 10:53

@HardyBuckette

It's not precisely a non story. But it is the wrong story.

Which is a different argument.

And the only one I have been making.

What Murty as an individual, the daughter of the Indian "father of IT", billionaire, with family monies to protect does to protect her money is her business, as long as it remains legal. Which, as far as we know today, it is (HMRC might disagree at some future date). I saulte her. She has the money her parent's earned, are still earning, her potential inheritance as well as her current stake (which is a tiny % apparently) separated from her marriage. Good for her!

That she is also truly bloody wealthy here in the UK, with her UK business is also good for her. And separate from her husband over and above it having been part of his legal requirement for disclosure.

What the many uber rich career politicians in the UK do is my longstanding bugbear. More that they are careerists than rich, but that only adds to the disconnect.

Individuals being as rich as Croesus is one thing. But when all of our politicians are, or all those in the Cabinet and Shadow Cabinet, then we have a major problem, one we have long lived with, unfortunately.

HardyBuckette · 08/04/2022 10:51

Yes, I don't think Starmer is the most obvious candidate here. It's possible, but looking at the people with the most to gain from this blowing up now, it's the other potential leadership candidates if Johnson goes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread