Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if anyone is friends / related to someone who has committed domestic violence?

59 replies

Oogabooga123 · 06/04/2022 19:39

I have always wondered how the friends / family of these people feel about it?

EXDP was massively controlling, and abusive in most ways, mostly emotionally and a few times physically. His mum knows, his siblings know, at least some of his friends know.

They all seem to carry on as usual, it just seems so strange, I feel like if it was my brother I wouldn’t want anything to do with him.

Just musing out loud really, he was spotted out locally having dinner with his family and new girlfriend, poor girl… how can they not tell her?

Is this just his or is there families everywhere that are apparently ok with this.

OP posts:
littlesnowdropfairy · 06/04/2022 22:20

I stopped my father from strangling my mother when I was 16.

MaChienEstUnDick · 06/04/2022 22:16

I believe my cousin was violent to a girlfriend, I trust the source who told me anyway. I've cut him out of my life completely, however did speak to him at my mother's funeral because that was easier for me than ignoring him.

HoryDunky · 06/04/2022 22:12

I'm not sure that this is relevant but it feels cathartic to talk about. My EX Husband wasn't physically abusive but he was emotionally and financially. I got on very well with his family until I decided enough was enough which resulted in physical threats to my elderly parents and myself. I also lost a lot of mutual friends due to his behaviour during our marriage but from what I have heard they are all friends again now, and I am the one cast out. It hurts but at the same time, I ask myself if I want people like that in my life

Alicenwonderland · 06/04/2022 21:59

In my case my ex MIL blames herself so is happy to listen to her DS's lies. She was in abusive relationships herself and my ex was abused by these men. When he attacked his sister (they were adults, this was a celebration with alcohol involved) she literally looked the other way, afterwards she said she didn't see anything. Half his family disowned him, the other half support him. It caused a massive rift.

Harridan1981 · 06/04/2022 21:51

@DamnShesaSexyChick

They probably don’t think about it because it’s a private matter and no one really knows what goes on behind closed doors.
This makes me very uncomfortable. Abuse of any sort is not a 'private matter'.

And the words "really knows" implies some sort of double edged sword. So I'm not really sure what point you're trying to make on this particular thread?

VelvetChairGirl · 06/04/2022 21:47

my ex's family have cognitive dissonance, makes it easier for them to just bury their heads in the sand and carry on pretending nothing happened.

his mother blamed me.
his older bother said its nothing to do with him and he's staying out of it.
his younger brother said the same, but his girlfriend was lovely and very supportive of me.

I am sure thats how it goes, bury their heads in the sand and carry on as if nothing happened, no skin of their nose, they dont know the full story, takes 2 to tango etc.

Crimeismymiddlename · 06/04/2022 21:39

My Uncle and his son, my cousin.
Only one out of three of my uncles children talk to him, as he is a nasty bitter man. My cousins wife life with the children, he has gone all fathers for justice, we all know the truth about why his DC won’t see him.

Mangogogogo · 06/04/2022 21:23

I think sometimes they don’t want to admit it tbh.
At work I work with offenders. A lot have been charged with assault on their partners and as shite as it is, I can’t just not do my job and working with them I do end up liking some of them. Not minimising what they’ve done but I’m trying to support them with not doing it again. Maybe I’m just kidding myself but I can see why people who love these people wouldn’t just walk away from them.
When the victim’s family are still on their side is something else though, very difficult to deal with

SkirridHill · 06/04/2022 21:14

My ex's family are the same. They minimise his behaviour, because to acknowledge it means they have to acknowledge that they raised him in a household full of violence, screaming and shouting: and left him as a child in situations that were far beyond his capacity to emotionally process them.

Consequently he treated the women in his life in the same way; emotionally abusing and controlling them, resorting to physical violence when frequently drunk or on drugs, and threatening suicide when it suited him.

When I finally kicked him out one of his family members told me we'd "both been as bad as each other". Err, I think not.

oliviastwisted · 06/04/2022 21:10

Trigger warning

Sexually abused by brother a number of times as a young child as was my sister for decades apparently.

Father told me he was never mentioning it to my brother again and he was continuing his relationship with him and I had to just accept that. Mother went along with that, sister, also abused, goes along with that shite as do other brothers and extended family members. They are all emotionally and psychologically abusive as far as I’m concerned.

FIL abused MIL emotionally and physically. Swept under the rug for years until the shit eventually hit the fan with his kids who no longer speak to him, long story. MIL has stayed all these years.

LakieLady · 06/04/2022 21:10

I was very good friends with a couple who met each other through me.

I knew their relationship was volatile, and that she was a heavy drinker, but I saw a fresh scar on his head when they came to stay for the weekend. She'd hit him with a bread board, cut the artery in his temple, and he'd had to have stitches. I was gobsmacked that she could be violent like that, I'd only ever known her to get mouthy and stroppy. And she laughed as she told me what she'd done.

I was beyond horrified.

Over the next couple of years, we stayed friends but I tried to arrange things that didn't involve vast amounts of alcohol. They split up when their son was 16, her partner had been afraid to leave her with his son while the son was still young and his son would never have left his mum.

After they split, I stayed friends with them both for a while, and saw them separately, but bit by bit, it all came out. He had scars where she'd attacked him with a broken glass and on his shin where she'd kicked him so hard he had a 4" gash on his leg. She'd been emotionally and financially abusive as well.

I cut all ties with her after that. And I was ashamed of myself for not picking up on what was going on.

sweetbellyhigh · 06/04/2022 21:07

@Oogabooga123

Honestly the worst is that he honestly made me feel like my own family was shit and his cared about me more. So when he actually was physically violent I left the house with just my phone and car keys and phoned his mum, instead of my own. Who the next morning told me I should go and sort things out with him.

By the time I worked up the courage to tell my own family who convinced me to report it to the police the bruises had faded and his mum swore blind to the police she had no idea what I was talking about. .. this woman was at the birth of 2 /3 of my children.

Like I want to know how she sleeps at night knowing she did that to me and to her grandchildren who she professes to love more than life.

They raised him, they know what he's like. And they probably taught him violence. They are not suddenly going to turn into people who advocate for victims.

MrsTerryPratchett · 06/04/2022 21:05

@sweetbellyhigh

Thank be of my closest friends is married to a man who has been v violent or attempted strangulation, pushing downstairs. They are still together and I still talk to them both. So many people have abandoned her and I just feel she needs someone who will be there no matter what. But deep down I fear he will kill her and the children one day.
And yes, I've pretended to tolerate them while my friend was with them.

Making sure she knew there was always a sofa at mine, day or night.

LaMagdalena · 06/04/2022 21:01

My ex was violent to me, he was an angry drunk. I had bruises (including on my face), he smashed my phone, I had to go to a women's refuge, etc etc.

His sister told me that I was the abusive one, that I was a fantasist, and that people like me 'are the reason real victims of abuse aren't believed.' In the face of evidence to the contrary, she said her brother didn't have any problems with anger or alcohol.

Now, I can kind of understand still loving someone when they've done something wrong, but what I don't understand is this kind of victim-blaming, enabling BS. It seems pretty standard though, from what I gather.

sweetbellyhigh · 06/04/2022 21:00

Thank be of my closest friends is married to a man who has been v violent or attempted strangulation, pushing downstairs.
They are still together and I still talk to them both.
So many people have abandoned her and I just feel she needs someone who will be there no matter what. But deep down I fear he will kill her and the children one day.

MrsTerryPratchett · 06/04/2022 20:59

I was friends with one.

When his wife told me, I wasn't.

I'm so sorry OP.

PakkaMakka · 06/04/2022 20:58

I'm pretty sure my cousin has been, he's a nice guy when sober but he has a serious drink problem and issues with violence when drunk (to others, eg street fights).
If I knew it was happening in a relationship I wouldn't defend him at all.
In terms of staying around - he's messed up from an abusive childhood. I have firm boundaries with him about what I can and can't do for him. If I didn't support him he'd try and get support from other family members who want to keep their distance (eg young kids) so it's better that i stick around for him.
He's been single for a while. I'm pretty sure if the whole family cut him off he'd be more likely to find another partner so he'd have company and someone to cook him a meal every now and then.

My stepdad was violent, after he died I found out his sister never actually wanted to stick by him but was scared of him because of how he'd treated her as kids and that's why she never challenged him.

Oogabooga123 · 06/04/2022 20:54

Honestly the worst is that he honestly made me feel like my own family was shit and his cared about me more. So when he actually was physically violent I left the house with just my phone and car keys and phoned his mum, instead of my own. Who the next morning told me I should go and sort things out with him.

By the time I worked up the courage to tell my own family who convinced me to report it to the police the bruises had faded and his mum swore blind to the police she had no idea what I was talking about. .. this woman was at the birth of 2 /3 of my children.

Like I want to know how she sleeps at night knowing she did that to me and to her grandchildren who she professes to love more than life.

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 06/04/2022 20:43

It's difficult. If you launch into them, there's a chance that the victim will stay with them and have lost another potential source of help when they're ready to leave. Some might not ever leave, anyhow. And if you cut them off or get turned into the bad guy interfering, the victim loses an ally.

That's why abusers are always having arguments and problems with other people - they've identified a potential threat that must be eliminated.

Chonfox · 06/04/2022 20:33

YANBU I've always wondered this too. My dad was abusive towards my mum and us too. I completely cut him out once I was an adult. I can't wrap my head around people who forgive/ignore this behavior. I assume in the case of parents ignoring it is because the abuser usually comes from a fucked up family to begin with? So it's either happened to them and they think its "normal" or they're somewhat to blame.

Glad you escaped Flowers

Newrumpus · 06/04/2022 20:32

Sorry - to elaborate just a little. I find it extremely difficult and painful to think about. My dad was hurt a few times (children much less). Related to serious MH problems.

A580Hojas · 06/04/2022 20:30

When our children were young (20ish years ago) I was friends with a woman in an abusive relationship. Her husband caused her physical injury (once requiring hospital admission) on at least two occasions in the the 3 or 4 years I was friends with her. She eventually left him (hooray) but maintains a relationship with him to this day and his kids are allowed to see him. Do not understand.

DamnShesaSexyChick · 06/04/2022 20:30

They probably don’t think about it because it’s a private matter and no one really knows what goes on behind closed doors.

DeadSouth · 06/04/2022 20:29

My brother manipulated and gaslit his ex for years, I called him out on it constantly and actively encouraged her to leave, she deserves so much better and I was so proud when she did. The only reason I’m even still in minimal contact is due to his mental health I fear he’d kill himself. Due to my own flaws if I know somethings a massive possibility and I do nothing to try prevent it I’ll blame myself even if I’m blameless.

Newrumpus · 06/04/2022 20:28

My mum