Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if anyone is friends / related to someone who has committed domestic violence?

59 replies

Oogabooga123 · 06/04/2022 19:39

I have always wondered how the friends / family of these people feel about it?

EXDP was massively controlling, and abusive in most ways, mostly emotionally and a few times physically. His mum knows, his siblings know, at least some of his friends know.

They all seem to carry on as usual, it just seems so strange, I feel like if it was my brother I wouldn’t want anything to do with him.

Just musing out loud really, he was spotted out locally having dinner with his family and new girlfriend, poor girl… how can they not tell her?

Is this just his or is there families everywhere that are apparently ok with this.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Fluffyunicorn1 · 07/04/2022 18:39

My ex MIL is a strange woman. She knows what he did and acknowledged it but then there’s been various excuses for it.

When I left him she said he was taking drugs because he couldn’t see his kids. He was taking drugs when he lived with them so that doesn’t make any sense. Then he got together with someone else and strangled her but that wasn’t his fault because she was just as bad apparently.

She also sent him to prison twice herself for abuse on her. But then let him move back in with her each time he came out because he’d “changed”. Needless to say he’s still an abusive drug addict who puts the fear of god into her so she gives him money.

But at first I was told I’d ruined his life etc everything was my fault.

I don’t have much to do with her now. She video calls my older dd now and again that’s about it.

I agree with the respect comment someone made though. He never had any respect for her and she never taught him to either. Funnily enough her other 2 kids don’t have any respect for other people either. No discipline and just let them carry on for an easy life what’s happened is one of her sons abuses every woman he comes into contact with

StationaryMagpie · 07/04/2022 18:33

our mutual friend used to call Ex out on his behaviour.. but he wasn't just controlling/abusive with me, he did it to friends/family too.

they have all, one by one, walked away from him.. he spends a lot of his time moaning he is lonely now, and seems to really struggle to understand why no-one wants anything to do with him.

TCMolly · 07/04/2022 18:24

My ex kicked our front door in and I asked FIL to fix it because he was a very handy.

He duly fixed it and he and MIL never mentioned it again.

They knew he was abusive but they just brushed it under the carpet.

incognitoforthisone · 07/04/2022 18:18

no one really knows what goes on behind closed doors

So when my ex's friends saw me stagger from 'behind closed doors' of a hotel room, covered in blood, barefoot, with a split lip and my nose smashed across my face, you think they didn't know what was going on, then? Really? Right.

Od130990 · 07/04/2022 16:42

For 18 years I suffered physical, mental, sexual, financial and emotional abuse. I was stabbed, ear sliced off, kicked so hard in the vagina that i required an operation. When I finally left he stalked me for a further 2 year. Yet his family think he's fantastic, his friends & ex mutual friends think he's great. 2 of our 3 kids think he's amazing and some of my own family still speak & associate with him. In his last violent attack at our family home not even the police would enter & waited for armed response to arrive they left me & my 3 kids inside the whole time that bastard had a knife to my throat 49 mins to be precise but not even the police helped. Yes he's well know to our local police & considered extremely dangerous but surely it's their duty to protect. Another time we were sat in a beer garden on a match day ( beer garden full of big burly meat head men ) out of nowhere the bastard jumped up & repeatedly kicked & kneed me in my face & head; not one of the Men ( I use that word loosely) tried to intervene or help me but as soon as it was over & he left the beer garden they then gathered around to ask was I alright and had he really just assaulted me in such a brutal manner in public! I told them they were a bunch of bitches & to f**k off. I couldn't/wouldn't stand by while anyone was being attacked.

ThreeLocusts · 07/04/2022 00:10

My dad was abusive. His mum told off my mum for failing to give him the space that he needed, being a genius. My cousin, who got a different bucket of crap from her grandmother and dad, was always keen to insist that 'our family isn't that bad, quite normal'.

Aged 18 my mother was sexually assaulted by a colleague of her dad's ( both vicars). She tried to confide in her stepmother, who asserted that 1. this hadn't happened and 2. it was my mum's fault.

20 years later she tried to tell a family therapist about my dad's attempt to rape her. Therapist ignored it and somehow concluded she, not he, was the problem.

Ppl are damn good at finding excuses. Oh, and damn the patriarchy. Damn it.

TeaOnTheMountain · 07/04/2022 00:00

This is a cathartic thread.

I left an abusive relationship last year. My friends reactions have varied, some have been supportive, some have claimed they’re “impartial”, some have continued to be friends with him despite knowing I left with a non-mol. I find it unbearable that people would continue to be friends with him despite that.
It seems to be out of some aim to be mature about the divorce- “we can still be friends with both of you”. It mostly makes me never want to speak to them again.

His family have never spoken to me since. I assume they think I have ruined his life and that a I’m an insane liar. But I so much hope that there is a small part of them that doubts that, and that knows there is truth in what I’ve claimed. As a young teen he held a small child out of an upstairs window by the ankles, wrestled his father to the floor and pinned him against the wall, had to be physically restrained by both parents because they thought he would kill his brother after an argument.. how can they not see there’s a problem?

TooBigForMyBoots · 06/04/2022 23:33

Yes, my uncle. My grandmother punished him.

Meadmaiden · 06/04/2022 23:32

No, of course not.

I had a neighbour who I later learnt had committed DV. I disliked him from the first moment I met him, he was a deeply unpleasant person. I didn't know about the DV then, but I wasn't surprised when I found out.

Fortunately his partner kicked him out and he's no longer my neighbour. She is a lovely person.

RoseMartha · 06/04/2022 23:26

My exh was and still is abusive.

His family shunned me when I decided to divorce him. To this day my exh doesn't think he did anything wrong, nor does his family.

I never got to speak to them about what was happening.

On the odd occasion I have seen them in the street they look the other way but will acknowledge the dc's if they are with me and stop to chat to them. Leaving me standing there as if I am invisible.

coldandverytired · 06/04/2022 23:15

My ex mil once told me that I should cook exh more meals (he worked shifts snd preferred vodka on his return… even at 6am) and then he wouldn’t be a raging alcoholic violent narcissist 🤷🏼‍♀️
I got the last laugh in some ways, he lives in their spare room and they’ve lost their retirement years trying to cope with him… karma. Needless to say, she now ‘gets it’ and rings to have a chat because she’s struggling to cope.

Whydothat · 06/04/2022 23:13

ExMIL told him he needed to sort me out properly. She told him I was emotionally abusive for trying to leave the violent relationship and if he did it properly I wouldn't go anywhere.
She physically and emotionally abused ExH and his siblings from a very early age.

Swimmum78 · 06/04/2022 23:06

My dad was an abusive alcoholic. Mainly to my mum. And occasionally us. I hated him growing up. I did forgive him when I got older. He had a terrible terrible childhood and despite being abusive when drunk he really did do a lot to support us and give us the life chances he didn't get. People are complicated.

Punkaintdeadman · 06/04/2022 23:04

I haven't RTFT but I believe EXs family genuinely believe his lies and bullpoo. I don't know if that's because it makes it easier for me to live with or if it's the truth. It must be hard to believe someone who you only see the good side of is so awful. And when I think of everything I put up with and forgave I can see how others would buy into it. I'm more hurt by the mutual friends who still give him the time of day. That makes me so angry and upset.

Brightrainbow · 06/04/2022 23:03

My ex used to control everything in my life-from what I ate to who I spoke to
He even controlled the amount of sanpro I was allowed to use when I was on my period
He battered me 87 times in two years
His mum,to this day,believes I had him arrested ‘for fun’ and once told me ‘to put up and shut up-he’s just copying his dad’
He got arrested once for breaking my cheek and collar bones-I’ll always be grateful to that policeman-she rang me to demand I pay his £80 fine as ‘he’s on the dole!he can’t afford to pay it!’

My own mother has the same attitude-‘what did you do to set him off again?’ was a favourite and she once stood there while he battered the hell out of me and did nothing but laugh and point

I’m nc with the pair of them

Weekendtobegin · 06/04/2022 22:59

I think a lot of people speak as though they're against DV but when it's their own family member or friend they either won't accept the truth, they blame the woman or they say that their situation is different because x, y, z

Like he's not a proper abuser but more of a lovable misunderstood rogue.

Haggisfish3 · 06/04/2022 22:58

My brother was abusive to my sil. I didn’t support him at all/I encouraged her to go to police, supported her in leaving and am now no contact with him but am still very much a part of my sil and niece’s and nephews lives. I loathe his behaviour.

Weekendtobegin · 06/04/2022 22:56

I have a relative (not a close relative) and I know he has been very violent to ex partners. Although there is no excuse for violence the ex partner (victim) had drug and alcohol dependency, they both cheated on each other and she eventually even left their child to be brought up by him and his new girlfriend 🤷‍♀️

They stayed on friendly terms even though he'd beaten her up in the past. They're both very damaged and dysfunctional.it's almost as though she accepted it as their normal so everyone else did.

Anyway he's not someone I'd want to have anything to do with myself but his past doesn't seem to have stopped him from having lots of friends, close family relationships and friends.

I had a violent boyfriend many years ago and his family knew but didn't care. They were a strange and dysfunctional bunch too.

Namechangenumber23 · 06/04/2022 22:53

I despair OP, I really do.
I've had two close friends go through abusive relationships. Both have had to estrange themselves from people they thought were good friends and/or family because at "best" they acted like nothing had happened and worst, were incredibly insistent it wasn't that bad and should forgive and forget etc.../it was her fault/she must have provoked him etc, etc.
I have another friend whose family member was convicted of serious SA and grooming of a minor. When he was released their family assisted him to change his name, funded setting him up in another part of the world and get work. They will not entertain any talk about his conviction/past. Their family have frozen out members who have dared to (rightfully) express their opinion/outrage about it. Their parents even refused to go to their wedding because they would not invite the offender.

I don't get the mindset of people like this.

wellstopdoingitthen · 06/04/2022 22:50

My ex partner was violent & controlling towards me. I had been with him since I was 16. My whole family (&his) knew about it. Some years after I finally left(when I was 27) I found out that my brother was still meeting up with him & his new girlfriend. I found it so distressing. I am happily married (30 years) now but I still find it upsetting. When I challenged my brother he said 'well he does a manual job so that's how he expresses himself '. He said that I was too weak. My whole family knew they would meet up for dinner etc.

Xpologog · 06/04/2022 22:35

My exh was more emotionally abusive than physical but he did start threatening violence ( my cue to leave) One particularly bad day I was holed up in the bedroom, he was downstairs doing as much as he could to distress me ( flicking electricity off and on, lighting multiple cigarettes to stink the place out, playing loud music) I phoned his parents to ask his dad to call him, thought that might kick him out of it. FIL told me he was sure I could look after myself, he wasn’t interested in my problems and their only concern was seeing their grandchildren ( step children) We were told a day to visit them ( usually without kids) and as long as he was sober when he arrived and left (3 hour visit ) they were happy. The fact that he had booze in the car, was knocking it back before we left their road and was screaming abuse at me ( driving) within the hour was no concern of theirs. Out of sight, out of mind.

Sweetpeasaremadeofcheese · 06/04/2022 22:35

My dad is an abusive arsehole and as a result very few people speak to him, myself included.
If my husband was abusive (he isn't) I know his mum would have his back 100%. It would be denial that he would do that, then excuses if it was undeniable. Same with my brother, my mum would back him up, even though she has been a victim.

UsernameNotAvailableHmm · 06/04/2022 22:29

Yes OP, I know of a couple of families who witnessed a family member being abusive, physically, financially and mentally, and yet nobody addressed it.

Sad
MagnoliaXYZ · 06/04/2022 22:23

I was friends with a man when I was younger who ended up in a relationship with one of my closest friends, they met through me. They rented a house together and had kids. After they separated, he was physically violent to the children when he had them one weekend, the police were involved. I'd distanced myself from him when they split up (closer friend to her than him) but would still see him occasionally in bigger groups. After that incident, I completely cut all ties with him, have seen him at work a few times and have had to be polite and say hello when he's said it first, but when I've seen him in the street, I've completely ignored him.

I was disgusted by it. By that point, I'd probably known him about 15 years and he was definitely the quietest in the group. He would not have been someone I'd have thought would be abusive so I was very surprised. I assume his family know about the incident as he was only allowed supervised contact with the children afterwards and it was done at his parent's house (which is where I think he was living).

Bettyboop3 · 06/04/2022 22:22

@DressingPafe

Usually the mothers of these men have their own issues. People might not like me saying this but I have never known an abusive man who had a good relationship with their mother. In fact, it’s the first thing I’d be on the lookout for were I to date again.

I’ve had 2 relationships with abusive men. With the first his mum was an alcoholic whose husband had left her (I don’t know if she drank before or as a result of that) and she apparently took a lot of her frustrations out on my ex when he was a kid (his sister told me). His sister was disappointed in him but felt it was out of her control, which I guess it was.

The second had just a really f.ed up relationship with his mum. One minute she’d be screaming at him. The next he was the greatest guy in the world! I genuinely think she had some kind of serious MH issue.

If a man has no respect for his mother then he’s going to find it difficult to respect any woman. Not saying it can’t be done. Some men can rise above it all and be decent human beings. Others can’t though.

That is a very rude generalisation based on all of 2 men. Very offensive - blame the mother!!