Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Both houses we have tried to buy have been downvalued

60 replies

spuddy56 · 06/04/2022 16:59

We are attempting to be first time buyers. Both the houses we have had offers accepted on have been downvalued by the mortgage company by 15k and 10k. The market is mental here. There's so little coming on and anything affordable for a first time buyer gets snapped up and goes over asking. The sellers won't reduce.

We've managed to save a 15% deposit for a 300k house/flat completely on our own while renting so there is no leeway or extra money from family to make up the extra in cash.

What can we do? Do we just give up and keep renting? We are so scared about buying at the peak and then not being able to remortgage or something. I'm so upset that after years of saving we are finally able to buy but still can't.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheLadyDIdGood · 13/04/2022 09:37

I'm seeing a lot more price reductions now so hold tight and don't offer anything above the asking price. Lots of mortgage companies are wise to the over valuation scams. So they're refusing to fund the excessive asking prices.

A probate house I saw before the 1st lockdown was remarketed for £200k more in Feb. Obviously, it didn't sell and has now been reduced by £50k but it is still overpriced. It needs a total renovation so adding the costs of that to the asking price still makes it £££.

spuddy56 · 13/04/2022 09:32

@Ohwellnevermindthen

I think that's a sign that it is really a bad time to buy. You have been reassured that the houses you look at are overvalued, so it is possible in the near future prices will drop when people get a reality check. I would keep saving so you have a bigger deposit (the issue is getting a mortgage on a smaller deposit if it does drop dramatically as banks may not lend).

You could also be paying much higher interest on an overvalued property if you buy now, as things are very unstable with inflation at its highest point for 30 years. You will be paying very little equity off in the first couple of years.

The press love to put stories out there about house prices going up as it creates a lot of class division and home owners lap it up. Look at the final sale price. Look at Harrison's property cycle too.

This is what worries me. It seems like a mental time to buy but we are paying 800 in rent and could be kicked out or have it raised at any time.

What counts as a bigger deposit? We have 15% of a 300k house at the moment. That would be a starter home where we are now but probably not somewhere we could really have school age children so couldn't be looking to stay long term in case of negative equity.

OP posts:
WellBeyondFedUp · 13/04/2022 08:42

Explained situation to parents who own 3 houses and 2 swimming pools but still no help offered.

Solidarity! At the last open day we went to (over 20 viewers), my mum suggested that if I offered the ‘offers over’ price that they would take the house off the market as we are FTBers.

It was sweet in its naïveté but also frustrating because they have no idea of the reality. They can’t understand why we “just can’t find a nice house.” After all, they did!

(The house eventually went for 35,000 over ‘offers over’ price.)

Ohwellnevermindthen · 13/04/2022 08:36

I think that's a sign that it is really a bad time to buy. You have been reassured that the houses you look at are overvalued, so it is possible in the near future prices will drop when people get a reality check. I would keep saving so you have a bigger deposit (the issue is getting a mortgage on a smaller deposit if it does drop dramatically as banks may not lend).

You could also be paying much higher interest on an overvalued property if you buy now, as things are very unstable with inflation at its highest point for 30 years. You will be paying very little equity off in the first couple of years.

The press love to put stories out there about house prices going up as it creates a lot of class division and home owners lap it up. Look at the final sale price. Look at Harrison's property cycle too.

TheLadyDIdGood · 13/04/2022 08:16

Ours hasn't sold yet but I've requested a viewing to see a house this weekend. It's not in our preferred area but it's still commutable from to work & school. It's chain free and has been on the market for a while. Hoping to speak to the agent later to get background information on the house.

Will need to appoint our solicitor soon and get our mortgage in principle ASAP.

Soontobe60 · 13/04/2022 07:36

@spuddy56

Thanks. Do you think we should reduce our deposit when they get downvalued or stick with what the bank says?
The mortgage you can get will be very much dependent on the valuation. If it’s been downvalued by 15K, you’ll be offered a lower mortgage and be expected to make up the shortfall from cash. My DD was in this position last year. After being outbid several times, they started looking at cheaper properties that needed work doing on them and managed to buy one with a bigger % deposit. The end result was that they’ve got a smaller mortgage on a lower interest rate because they put down an 18% deposit. They then got a loan to pay for the renovations. It’s been hard work, but they’ve got the house of their dreams now.
spuddy56 · 13/04/2022 07:27

@WellBeyondFedUp

How are you getting on *@spuddy56*? We are in exactly the same situation and it is heartbreaking.
Same miserable state! Have seen a house we love come on the market but there's so much interest the viewings have turned to an open day so not getting hopes up. Explained situation to parents who own 3 houses and 2 swimming pools but still no help offered.
OP posts:
WellBeyondFedUp · 12/04/2022 21:31

How are you getting on @spuddy56? We are in exactly the same situation and it is heartbreaking.

whoatealltheeggs · 08/04/2022 10:31

If your job is portable then moving to a new cheaper area is a good idea.

spuddy56 · 08/04/2022 10:23

Really don't know what to do for the best. Keep sending partner links to jobs in much cheaper areas as I can be more flexible with location. But in the meantime we are wasting so much money on rent. We spoke last night and decided we really couldn't fill any of the gap with cash, it would mean we have zero emergency money for repairs, car breakdowns etc. So either try new lender or give up.

OP posts:
PicaK · 07/04/2022 14:12

The point is they don't have the money to make up the shortfall

Alarae · 07/04/2022 12:23

In the grand scheme of things throughout a lifetime of ownership £10k isn't massive. If that's what it costs to secure your home, and you can afford it, I would go for it.

If your deposit is 45k on a purchase of £300k that banks have downvalued to 290k, that gives you a LTV of ~88%. I imagine the banks will still lend to you at 90% LTV, so you could consider a 2 year fix to pay down the mortgage and then hopefully at the end of that period you would tip into a lower LTV bracket.

Unfortunately with the way the housing market, unless the house has been on the market a long time, it's likely that someone else will just come in and buy the house at the same price.

It is doubtful house prices will truly crash, although they could stagnate. If you are intending to live there for a decent amount of time, paying the extra now probably won't really matter.

hypaingea · 07/04/2022 12:17

Yeah i'm not sure about a crash, just stagnation.The impact of rate rises, cost of living won't be felt for a few years as most buyers fix.

Kabalagala · 07/04/2022 12:03

Waiting for a crash is risky in my opinion. It may happen, may not. Might be this year, might be in 5 years. House prices are currently still rising.
More regulations are coming in for landlords and renting is going to get harder.

TheLadyDIdGood · 07/04/2022 10:37

If you put this in the mnet property & DIY forum, you'll get lots more replies from people going through the same thing.

MyCommentWasDeleted · 07/04/2022 10:29

Sit tight, the market looks like it is topping out and should correct. Article in todays independent reporting the same - www.independent.co.uk/voices/housing-market-recession-inflation-b2052204.html

Don’t be in a position where you’ve overpaid 15k on a house that has dropped in value.

hypaingea · 07/04/2022 09:55

It's definitely a weird time, prices are crazy but all other economic signs are saying the opposite. The BOE believe inflation is temporary because salaries won't go up yet they initially thought it was a blip & there is huge demand for staff in certain industries so who knows what to think

user1471538283 · 07/04/2022 09:44

This is happening more and more. I dont think it's your bank being cautious.

You can only afford what you can afford and what the bank can loan.

I know its disappointing but something will give soon.

MatildaTheCat · 07/04/2022 09:27

We are looking for DS and the market is scaring me. Interest rates are very probably about to rise sharply which will make some of this excess borrowing unaffordable.

We bid on a property that was on at 600 and it went for 650. Nice house but not suddenly worth 650.

I’d recommend trying to find properties that have been sitting on the market for a while or have been recently returned to the market. Or waiting which is what we are inclined to do.

LGY1 · 07/04/2022 09:20

We have just had our house valued.
One of the estate agents said to me that at the moment some houses are being valued at less than the offer price, but people moving from their first to second home (our market) have made that much equity in their first that they are making up the difference in cash so it doesn’t matter

hypaingea · 07/04/2022 09:18

I fully appreciate the rental market is shite & would favour European reforms.
I think as long as you are mindful re the future & future proof as much as possible it will help.

nodogz · 07/04/2022 09:07

@spuddy56 It's such a tricky situation. I don't think many people (who bought easily) realise how unstable and expensive the rental market is and that this should factor in to your decision making criteria as the security of your own home might be worth the extra couple of thousand.

Just keep plugging away, the right house is out there. Explore all the areas in your 1.5 hr travel time and leaflet preferred areas and houses? Expand the search from minimum to maximum value. Be the best buyers, if it's a probate offer to take it as it comes (no need for vendors to clear). If someone has a fancy pond, tell them you love fish and you'd definitely keep it!

Is there anything you can do for extra cash? Freelance? Upcycle furniture? Grow plants for Facebook marketplace? A couple of extra grand, a different lenders valuation and a good seller could be the right combination!

spuddy56 · 07/04/2022 07:20

Yep we have to consider that our landlady could raise the rent or kick us out at a moments notice and we would be faced with higher rent somewhere too. I really don't know what is best.

OP posts:
hypaingea · 06/04/2022 21:57

Yes for those stuck with high rents buying is obviously more attractive & if you can future proof by buying bigger that's something.

I'm in London in an expensive area & prices have stagnated really since Brexit, once you factor in stamp duty.

Kabalagala · 06/04/2022 21:53

@hypaingea

Try a different mortgage company and just keep trying. We've just (literally a few hours ago) got our mortgage offer for a 90% mortgage where we offered £20k over asking.

Personally I think it's crazy to stretch with high LTVs in the current climate.

The alternative is keep paying rent £500 more a month than our mortgage will be, if our landlord raises rent or sells, we can't afford anything else locally. Or we can wait, and risk seeing prices continue to soar. We're in the south east, and I highly doubt there will anything more than a temporary stagnation in prices unfortunately. Luckily we've been able to buy somewhere big enough that we won't need to move any time soon. It's well worth the risk for us