Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or is my MIL??

114 replies

ElfinsMum · 06/04/2022 15:48

We live in Australia. Planning our first trip back to the UK in three years for this (UK) summer. SIL also lives abroad and has booked to bring her kids across to the UK at the same time as our visit. My PIL will have their grandchildren (aged 11 down to 2) altogether for the second time ever and after a long spell when Covid made it impossible for them to see any of us. They are v excited obviously.

This is how my bossy, controlling, emotionally tone deaf MIL wants it to go:

  • All the kids, who do not remember each other and speak a couple of times a year on Skype, are going to get on perfectly 24/7 for seven days solid
  • All eleven of us are going to sleep in their quite small house for a full week, including all 6 children sleeping on the floor in one room. The kids are going to love this too and be perfectly well rested and well behaved.
  • As their living room is really small and even MIL acknowledges that there won't be space for everyone, we are going to go on a big outing every day. She gave us some examples, "then we could go to, FOR EXAMPLE, [theme park], then the next day, FOR EXAMPLE, [local national trust]". (She has form for going completely ott on planned activities when we visit... she hears about her friends going to places with their GCs all year and then tries to go to all of them with us when we visit. I nearly asked if she had booked the tickets.)
  • If any of the kids don't want to do any of the above or don't love every second of it, they will be told they are wrong and made to do it anyway. The refrains of DH's childhood were "Don't be silly" and "You'll like it when you get there".

Clearly DH and I think this is all going to end in tears. AIBU to keep the joint visit (with us and SIL) to a max of 4 nights and stay (all 5 of us) at the local premier Inn?

(We would stay with them in their own home on our own for another spell during the trip. We are in the UK for a few weeks in all)

OP posts:
ElfinsMum · 06/04/2022 16:37

@maddy68 Yeah I was a shy kid. That shit terrified me. I only learnt to enjoy parties once there was alcohol!

(At least two of my kids are like me. I think the toddler isn't so much)

OP posts:
Merrymouse · 06/04/2022 16:35

You also know your own children OP. Some children (and adults) would thrive in this situation, others wouldn’t.

If at the end of a long day all the children still want to camp out together, you can always change your mind, however by booking the hotel you can make that a choice, not an ordeal.

mbosnz · 06/04/2022 16:35

While it's one thing to expect adults to suck it up, I think it's unrealistic to expect children to be able to do so to the same degree. If the children have some down time in a quiet space of their own, and know that they're going to have that if they need it, I think it's most probably going to be a lot easier for the children to behave and enjoy their visit, which of course is going to make it easier for all the adults to do so as well!

ElfinsMum · 06/04/2022 16:31

@blossomtoes I appreciate they may get on well and then it will seem like we made the wrong choice.

How would you play it by ear exactly? Both families are flying long haul to meet up.

OP posts:
maddy68 · 06/04/2022 16:30

I think that sounds bloody lovely
That's what family occasions are like? Did you never have big Christmases etc?
The kids will bicker and fall out.and make up. That's what makes them bond and they will have this fab memory forever

Merrymouse · 06/04/2022 16:30

I agree you need to ‘suck it up’ to an extent, but by allowing the children to retreat and regroup you are increasing the chances that the days will go well.

You have said that you are also happy to stay with them as a smaller family group, so she will still get to spend time with her gc then.

It sounds as though you are just sensibly managing expectations.

ElfinsMum · 06/04/2022 16:27

@FinnRussell We will have our own car. Like the idea of taking some scenic routes to catch naps etc.

(Love the user name btw, he's a joy to watch even on catch up from down here!)

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 06/04/2022 16:23

[quote ElfinsMum]@Blossomtoes Why restrict to 4 days? Because the kids don't know each other at all. What if some of them don't get on?? I can tolerate coaching my kids through a couple more awkward days without upsetting grandma but not more than that. It isn't fair on them.[/quote]
But what if they do get on and absolutely love being together? Just play it by ear a bit.

ElfinsMum · 06/04/2022 16:21

@Blossomtoes Why restrict to 4 days? Because the kids don't know each other at all. What if some of them don't get on?? I can tolerate coaching my kids through a couple more awkward days without upsetting grandma but not more than that. It isn't fair on them.

OP posts:
FinnRussell · 06/04/2022 16:21

The sleeping arrangements aren't workable. Get your SIL on board and present a united front to your MIL. Premier Inn sounds much better. The day trips you need to suck up I think. Hire your own car and use it to carve out down time. Good luck.

mbosnz · 06/04/2022 16:20

Has MIL factored in jet lag and disrupted sleep patterns?

chisanunian · 06/04/2022 16:17

You can't have six children with that age range sharing one room. They will have completely different bedtimes for one thing, and where on earth is all their stuff going to go?

Blossomtoes · 06/04/2022 16:15

@Ozanj

You need to see it from her point of view. All her gc live abroad & for only the second time ever she gets to see them all together. Of course she’s excited and of course she wants to book trips. In your position I would go along with everything she wants - it’s such a short time in the grand scheme of things.
I partly agree with this but not all. A house heaving with kids will be tough on everyone so the Premier Inn idea is a good one. Why restrict all the kids being together to four days though? That feels really mean.
SatinHeart · 06/04/2022 16:14

@Ozanj

You need to see it from her point of view. All her gc live abroad & for only the second time ever she gets to see them all together. Of course she’s excited and of course she wants to book trips. In your position I would go along with everything she wants - it’s such a short time in the grand scheme of things.
Yep I'm afraid I think I'd suck it up for a week.

Although we live in the same country as MIL, she has 4 other grandchildren who live abroad (long haul) and I've watched how heartbreaking that has been for her over the years, even before COVID.

girlmom21 · 06/04/2022 16:13

[quote ElfinsMum]@girlmom21 That's what I would like to happen. But MIL makes it very hard to disagree with her. She interprets even alternative suggestions as opposition. If DH tells her we want to do something different to what she wants she tells y
him he's wrong. If he insists, she cries.[/quote]
I think he needs to make it very clear beforehand then that you want this to be a nice experience for everyone and it won't be a nice experience if the kids are miserable or exhausted so you'll need to let them lead and she needs to trust yours and DH's judgment.

If she agrees, he can remind her of that if she becomes overbearing.

If she cries, don't pander to her (him not you!)

Sparkletastic · 06/04/2022 16:12

You are going to have to be very firm but kind.

Thatsplentyjack · 06/04/2022 16:12

I think I would try and get self catering accommodation though.

Thatsplentyjack · 06/04/2022 16:12

Not a chance I would be staying in a house with 11 other people for 2 nights, never mind a week. I would go on the days out she's landing though.

ElfinsMum · 06/04/2022 16:11

@girlmom21 That's what I would like to happen. But MIL makes it very hard to disagree with her. She interprets even alternative suggestions as opposition. If DH tells her we want to do something different to what she wants she tells y
him he's wrong. If he insists, she cries.

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 06/04/2022 16:09

@ElfinsMum

I absolutely can see it from her point of view and, obviously, we feel horribly guilty that they have been left alone (especially poor FIL, who is lovely).

However, if we just go along with all her plans, how would you get three kids ranging from 11-2 to play along?? Particularly as they got progressively more and more tired and more and more sick of being bossed around as the week wore on?

Well you know your kids best so you leave venues when they've had enough and don't let her boss them around
girlmom21 · 06/04/2022 16:07

I have 8 kids in a room most weekends so I don’t see how this is a problem. We just remove the bed and put them all in sleeping bags.

It's very different if it's a regular set up and they know each other well

EverNapping · 06/04/2022 16:07

If my family get together had been like this I don't think I'd be in speaking terms with any of them by adulthood. I cannot cope with most of my relatives for anything more than single afternoons. My inner teenage self is having a freak out at the very thought.

Sleep at the local hotel.

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 06/04/2022 16:06

Can you out-enthuse her? Book the premier inn, plan for the kids to do one sleepover night and make it a camp in or something like that so she'll have loads of bragging rights to her friends. And arrange an activity for each day but a small one like a pizza night in her house where the kids make the pizzas. Or if dh's family used to do big frys, or tea or have some sort of family memory organise that- remember you'd make a massive fry in the mornings mom let's do that, or a bbq or whatever. Loads of "making memories". Get dh and SIL on board. One theme park and 4 night overlap max with separate accommodation.

ElfinsMum · 06/04/2022 16:06

I absolutely can see it from her point of view and, obviously, we feel horribly guilty that they have been left alone (especially poor FIL, who is lovely).

However, if we just go along with all her plans, how would you get three kids ranging from 11-2 to play along?? Particularly as they got progressively more and more tired and more and more sick of being bossed around as the week wore on?

OP posts:
Ozanj · 06/04/2022 16:05

@iklboo

Can’t see the problem with this.. my dc’s would prefer to sit on their phones all day. But when we do go they enjoy it

Even sleeping six to one room on the floor?

I have 8 kids in a room most weekends so I don’t see how this is a problem. We just remove the bed and put them all in sleeping bags.
Swipe left for the next trending thread