Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or is my MIL??

114 replies

ElfinsMum · 06/04/2022 15:48

We live in Australia. Planning our first trip back to the UK in three years for this (UK) summer. SIL also lives abroad and has booked to bring her kids across to the UK at the same time as our visit. My PIL will have their grandchildren (aged 11 down to 2) altogether for the second time ever and after a long spell when Covid made it impossible for them to see any of us. They are v excited obviously.

This is how my bossy, controlling, emotionally tone deaf MIL wants it to go:

  • All the kids, who do not remember each other and speak a couple of times a year on Skype, are going to get on perfectly 24/7 for seven days solid
  • All eleven of us are going to sleep in their quite small house for a full week, including all 6 children sleeping on the floor in one room. The kids are going to love this too and be perfectly well rested and well behaved.
  • As their living room is really small and even MIL acknowledges that there won't be space for everyone, we are going to go on a big outing every day. She gave us some examples, "then we could go to, FOR EXAMPLE, [theme park], then the next day, FOR EXAMPLE, [local national trust]". (She has form for going completely ott on planned activities when we visit... she hears about her friends going to places with their GCs all year and then tries to go to all of them with us when we visit. I nearly asked if she had booked the tickets.)
  • If any of the kids don't want to do any of the above or don't love every second of it, they will be told they are wrong and made to do it anyway. The refrains of DH's childhood were "Don't be silly" and "You'll like it when you get there".

Clearly DH and I think this is all going to end in tears. AIBU to keep the joint visit (with us and SIL) to a max of 4 nights and stay (all 5 of us) at the local premier Inn?

(We would stay with them in their own home on our own for another spell during the trip. We are in the UK for a few weeks in all)

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 06/04/2022 23:08

[quote ElfinsMum]@yikesanotherbooboo Genuinely, I am wondering how you would express to your kids that they must make the most of it? One or other of my kids generally lose the plot with MIL after a few days because she just expects to tell them exactly what to do and say all day every day. SIL was fairly similar when we last met up: lots of use of boundaries, consequences, reward charts and the naughty step. We are just the opposite end of the spectrum, barefoot hippies the lot of us Grin[/quote]
My DGC would hate it.

Age range from 15 -3 and the 5 year old is pretty bossy.

And my kids would tell me quite firmly what to do with such a lunatic idea.

You're supposed to be looking forward to this, not dreading it

And I can't stand grown women who cry when they don't get their own way

saraclara · 06/04/2022 22:58

Don't see it from her POV. See it from your kids' POV and stick up for them or else you'll be the granny nobody visits when it's your turn.

FFS. These GPs haven't seen their own kids or their grandkids for three years. Covid has been shit for people whose kids and GC are on the other side of the world. Surely all the older kids can have it explained to them that their GPs (and specifically FIL who is apparently wonderful) are bursting with excitement to see them, and that it would be kind to go wit the flow for a few days. After all it will probably be years before the GCs have to do it again.

Wilburisagirl · 06/04/2022 21:48

This more or less describes our cousin holidays. We would get together once a year or once every two years and stay at my Grandma's house. The parents got the bedrooms and the kids slept on air mattresses in the lounge room. We LOVED it. It was an adventure and meant we got to spend every minute catching up and playing. We became super close even though we saw each other infrequently.

I'd say give it a chance, but maybe take 2-3 days at the end to stay in a hotel in case you're finding it too much.

MotherofTerriers · 06/04/2022 21:23

I had this with my ex mil, and the large holiday house worked well. I explained it as we were all so looking forward to seeing her and would like to treat her and for her to be able to spend the time enjoying her grandchildren not worrying about hoovering and tidying. Have a look for somewhere suitable and close to where she lives and ask her to plan the excursions and activities

ChateauMargaux · 06/04/2022 21:04

Good luck. I understand and I have no answers. My sister and I have spent our entire lives as parents trying to navigate visits home so that we are all OK. We both live abroad and there are probably good reasons for that. While we struggle to manage our kids food, mood and sleep around the craziness that are other people's routines, rules and expectations, the kids all have a great time and have great memories. My eldest nephew is 19 and my youngest is 9. We have 8 kids between three of us.

Natty13 · 06/04/2022 21:02

@ElfinsMum

I absolutely can see it from her point of view and, obviously, we feel horribly guilty that they have been left alone (especially poor FIL, who is lovely).

However, if we just go along with all her plans, how would you get three kids ranging from 11-2 to play along?? Particularly as they got progressively more and more tired and more and more sick of being bossed around as the week wore on?

Don't see it from her POV. See it from your kids' POV and stick up for them or else you'll be the granny nobody visits when it's your turn.
mbosnz · 06/04/2022 20:56

I had cousins I loved to see, and I had cousins I'd rather kill than say hullo to. The feelings were entirely mutual. With 35 first cousins, there's plenty to choose from. Just because you're of an age, and share some DNA, it's a tad unreasonable to assume you're just gagging to spend time together - especially if you barely know each other!

DeliaOwens · 06/04/2022 20:52

OP. Get the hotel room or AirB&B.

I was your children and when I tell you I hated every do his minute of 'holidays home' that is not an exaggeration. The forced familiarity with my cousins was horrible. I don't see or hear from any of them outside of funerals now.

I loved being with my grandparents 1:1. Preferred when they came to us as I was able to sleep in my own bed.

SnackSizeRaisin · 06/04/2022 20:42

I think either bigger shared accommodation with separate bedrooms, or nearby hotel would be best. The kids may all get on great and if they do you can leave the older ones to sleep over with their cousins for one or more nights but a whole week of them all in one room may be a disaster. The shared activities may be great but may also need some flexibility in case you need a day doing something on your own in the middle.
Different parenting styles are only a problem if they apply the same rules to your children. You may have to intervene with "we don't have that rule in our family" a few times. We have this with my brother who is constantly lecturing his rude children who basically ignore him. I don't want him lecturing mine as they actually listen and find it all a bit much. But it's not a big deal at all and the cousins love each other

Merrymouse · 06/04/2022 20:22

I think the problem is not kids getting on with cousins who they don’t see very often, but unrealistic expectations of the adults who don’t see them very often.

It’s one thing throwing a load of kids together in a familiar environment with familiar adults and another doing the same thing in an unfamiliar environment with adults who don’t spend time with them the rest of the year.

To make things more difficult, the fact that the gps don’t know all their gcs foibles is likely to be a bit painful for all involved. In those circumstances I think it’s wise to make plans so that everyone can retreat to their own space. That doesn’t mean there can’t be any sleepovers at all, but better to leave a hotel room empty than to feel you need to move to one half way through the visit.

insanemumof3 · 06/04/2022 20:22

I think it will end up in tears if you follow only her plans. Children need there space as well even if its only an hour, just to decompress from such alot everyday. Also just a note, what if you or your partner or kids see something happening on a day out and decided yous would love to try that at some point on your trip? Would MIL allow that change to her schedule? Sometimes the spare of the moment unplanned days happen to be the best!

Easterisoffeggstooexpensive · 06/04/2022 20:13

Not sure I would want my dc around a grown woman who cries when she doesn't get her own way...

Wondergirl100 · 06/04/2022 20:08

Be firm aboyt your boundaries in order to keep your kids happy - and you know best how to do this - but also do think sympathetically of MIL

I can't imagine how I would feel in her position - and actually I think it is really sweet for cousins to all hang out together a lot. This is what we would have done as children - been put all in a room with cousins we saw once a year.

It is also possible to over worry about stuff like kids getting on with cousins - it will be a laugh even if its tiring. We share rooms with lots of cousins when we go overseas - yes the children are tired/ shy/ get ratty and overwhelmed

But try not to go into this totally defensively. Im sure your MIL knows very well that kids get tired on holiday - she was a parent herself of small children once.

Just keep saying - they will be jet lagged so we need our own space for naps etc

KosherDill · 06/04/2022 19:59

I wouldn't do this in a million years. Book the Inn posthaste.

A sleepover of all the cousins for one or two nights, maybe. But I think the reality of that would not be what she envisions.

How about a group activity that would leave her with something when you're all gone? "Let's all build granny a rose arbor!" or something like that?

whumpthereitis · 06/04/2022 19:51

And don’t be held to ransom by tears. Your needs matter too.

You want to foster a good relationship with the grandparents. If your kids are jetlagged, overwhelmed, overcrowded and upset they’re unlikely to enjoy themselves, they’re unlikely to have good memories of the trip, and they’re unlikely to want to repeat the experience.

whumpthereitis · 06/04/2022 19:46

Well that sounds like hell on earth. As if the long haul flights on either end of the trip aren’t going to be bad enough Confused

I would book the hotel. You’ll appreciate the breathing space, especially after said long haul flights.

Morred · 06/04/2022 19:31

Can you lean in to the thought behind some of the day trips and redirect them a bit. Sort of “oh the kids will be so excited to see you and be all together that they don’t need big thrills from trips every day too. They’d would absolutely love #makingmemories by cooking with you? And a sleepover would be so much for fun if it’s a special one off? Maybe all the kids could help you set up camp in the spare room and turn the lounge into a fearsome jungle/wildwood! Much more special to our family than going to Attraction Centre like all the other sheeple.”

She’s excited, but also sounds like she’s awful. Try to do excited with her rather than anything that sounds too much like squashing her plans. The good thing with you going to visit her is she can’t actually make you stay in her house.

Tohaveandtohold · 06/04/2022 19:30

You are not being unreasonable with the accommodation thing, it’ll be a night mare for all of you to stay together in that house for week. The premier inn advice sounds good or if you and sil want to stay together, maybe get a self catering air bnb .
However I’ll personally be happy with her planning trips, it’s like she’s trying to make all the memories at once because she sees you all once in a couple of years and the children will get to be with their cousins as well in a fun place

Unsure33 · 06/04/2022 19:29

You could hire some pop up tents for the garden ? I think all ages would love that or a teepee ?

Days out … bit more difficult but if you go and it does not work out can you leave early if using own transport ?

ElfinsMum · 06/04/2022 19:19

@Lunificent Nailed it.

Except you've missed the part where my kids have already lost it but I coach them through just holding it together for a day or two longer so that by the time we leave it feels like letting off the pressure cooker.

(Poor woman, I actually don't think she has any inkling that she has this affect on those around her. But she isn't close to any of her large family so I don't think it's just us.)

OP posts:
Creameggs223 · 06/04/2022 19:15

@OutingHobby

What does DH want to do. It's his family you're visiting so I'd go with that. If everyone ends up miserable at least it won't be blamed on you.
So you would be miserable squashed and force to do things you don't want to because dh says ok.
ElfinsMum · 06/04/2022 19:05

@tobedtoMN I think it's pretty common for grandparents not to make this shift successfully though, eh? And I can make decisions for my kids, of course, but I can't change how my MIL feels about them.

OP posts:
luxxlisbon · 06/04/2022 19:02

YANBU to want to stay in a hotel for part of the trip but I think you’re being a bit unreasonable with regards to your MIL. She barely sees her son or GC so of course she would want to squeeze in all the things she misses out on into the visit, or at least as much as possible.
It’s only once every coupon of years so I would just suck it up to be honest. Different if she was over planning but you seen her all the time imo.

givethatbabyaname · 06/04/2022 19:01

Genuinely, I am wondering how you would express to your kids that they must make the most of it? One or other of my kids generally lose the plot with MIL after a few days because she just expects to tell them exactly what to do and say all day every day.

Your kids are humans, not robots. You can't make them do anything. Tell them what the plan is, tell them that they have to behave themselves. If they don't, well that's that. Your MIL will just have to deal with it. If she thinks she can go about telling young children what to do, when, and how, for an entire week, and actually be listened to - well, more fool her. I'm sure your kids will speak their minds. Anyway, she's the one who wants them under her roof for a week!

As long as your children aren't rude to her and don't break her house, the rest is just what it is. Kids are boisterous, loud, unruly. Children who have traveled a long way, and are far from home, and excitable because they're around other kids ON HOLIDAY, cannot be expected to be perfect. Only an idiot would expect that.

Lunificent · 06/04/2022 18:59

When things go wrong, people like this always blame other people. Your poor frazzled children will be struggling and she’ll be calling them spoilt. It will be an absolute nightmare. Don’t do it.