Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Christian MIL taking DC to Christian toddler group - I was unaware

507 replies

AtheistMama · 06/04/2022 15:12

Name change for this one.

My MIL does childcare once a week for DS aged 3, for which I am grateful for - they have a great relationship, and obviously it saves us money on nursery fees.

My MIL is a lovely women, not a bad bone in her body. She is also devoutly Christian, belonging to an evangelical church. DH was brought up as an evangelical Christian, but is an atheist and slowly detached himself from their church in his young adulthood. There is no animosity from his mother and the wider family about this (who are mostly also evangelical Christians).

DH and I have been together for 10 years, married for 5, but I have never really talked to MIL about my religious beliefs because she is quite sensitive/easily upset and I didn't want to offend her. The status quo has just been that it is obvious to all that DH and I are not Christian and it's been left at that.

My understanding of DH's families beliefs is that they think everyone who is not baptised is going to Hell; they also do not approve of homosexuality or gay marriage, sex before marriage, etc. I am an atheist and do not subscribe to these beliefs. In particular, the idea that they believe that I am going to Hell bothers me when I think about it. In general, I am anti-organised religion and was never going to bring DS up in any religious way.

MIL takes DS to a toddler's group at her church every week, but I was under the impression that it was open to the whole community and therefore not Christian (I think this came from DH not my MIL). I looked up the group today (was wondering about the timings for a seperate reason), and clocked that they have a Bible story every week.

I'm feeling a bit annoyed because if I had known about the Bible story bit when it was first suggested that she take him (years ago), I would have gently asked her to pick another activity. But now he's been going for a few years, he loves it and it's part of their routine. She would probably be upset by being asked to stop going (and probably it didn't occur to her that I wouldn't be happy about it).

However, I feel really uncomfortable about the Bible story, and annoyed that she didn't say anything at the start. Needless to say, DS has never mentioned it, so it's possible that he's running around the hall and not even listening to it.

DH tends to skirt around issues with his DM that might be upsetting because he thinks she's quite delicate and feels protective about her.

AIBU to bring it up with her now?

OP posts:
rogueone · 06/04/2022 20:55

Well i am assuming your not in an area where 'aethiests' have to play the game and take their DC to sunday school every sunday to access the local good school? The sheer numbers of non believers reappear to get their DC into the sought after school is shocking.

As someone who was brought up to believe and went to sunday school etc it has allowed me to have a balanced opinion around religion. I remember with fondnest my sunday school sessions

twentythreehundred · 06/04/2022 20:53

put on by kindly people for the community's benefit,

Put on by religious fundamentalists who further hate thinking in the community

venusmay · 06/04/2022 20:53

I wouldn't worry, all they will remember is the toys and a snack. At 5 it would be different! A lot of schools are faith in our area so I think you will either be lucky to avoid this in the future or gave to work round it.

Tanith · 06/04/2022 20:50

Don't be so utterly ridiculous! If your DH grew up in this devoutly religious family and became an atheist, how on earth do you imagine one Bible story a week is going to indoctrinate your 3 year old??

Your lovely MIL is saving you childcare fees and taking your child to an activity he enjoys, put on by kindly people for the community's benefit, and you object to them reading a Bible story!

If it really is such an issue that you feel you need to raise it with her, you should make other arrangements for your childcare. After all, she's a Christian woman: your DS is being exposed to Christianity for a whole day not just at the toddler group!

MardyMandy · 06/04/2022 20:48

He's 3. He won't remember. He's not being indoctrinated.
They are just stories like any other stories that you read to him.
None of them are true. They are just entertaining stories.

My in-laws are staunch Catholics. My husband was born to Catholic parents, was practising Catholic and altar boy in childhood, now atheist. I'm Church of England, should anybody ask, but atheist with agnostic leanings.
In infant school, I remember a day when I was really scared because my teacher told me that God could see everything I did. When you're a very little kid, that sort of thing can scare you. I imagined some sort of big guy in the sky, watching me.
When I got home my older brother (older by 10 years) could see I was
withdrawn and scared (pretty spooked to be honest) and asked me what was wrong so I told him.

He told me that was rubbish and my teacher was daft and a bit weird.
Nobody was watching me, and if she said it again he would go and talk to her. He was 14 at the time. He actually does have a belief in God, but obvs didn't want his little sister scared shitless by an over zealous RE teachers claims that 'God Is Watching You'

Forty years later he still believes there is a God. I don't, but we get on OK despite that. As much as he always believed in God, he was angry and protective when I was a child, that a belief in a big man in the sky, watching you, was used to scare kids. That's not the God he has in mind.

SirChenjins · 06/04/2022 20:40

Yes, RE is about understanding different religions, but assemblies can actually teach a religion, unless the law has changed recently. I went to a normal state school, not a faith school and there were prayers every day and religious assembly with hymns and readings

My DCs schools didn’t/don’t have this. They teach RMPS which includes both religious belief systems and secular systems - certainly no prayers, hymns or readings at assemblies.

Sirzy · 06/04/2022 20:32

The key thing to remember if your religious beliefs are yours and in the long run your part of what will guide your son but you can’t decide for him. Learning about other religions and the beliefs of others is much more likely to lead to a rounded individual who can respect others views while still holding onto their own.

Ds was raised as Christian as I am but now at the age of 12 he has been atheist for many years and that is perfectly fine, because his views are his.

winterchills · 06/04/2022 20:31

I think your being unreasonable tbh. It's a bible story? So when your child goes to school he/she can not take part in the nativity etc? Celebrate Easter? It will be open to everyone is just a kids group

Gwenhwyfar · 06/04/2022 20:27

"Well the RE curriculum shouldn't be taught like that."

Yes, RE is about understanding different religions, but assemblies can actually teach a religion, unless the law has changed recently. I went to a normal state school, not a faith school and there were prayers every day and religious assembly with hymns and readings.

TheWelshposter · 06/04/2022 20:25

I'm against the whole idea of teaching religion to kids (ie in school) but if this is just a toddler groups he's likely to interpret it as a fairytale.
When my kids come home from school and tell me about the things they heard in RE class ie heaven and hell, they clearly see it as a fairytale too.

Gwenhwyfar · 06/04/2022 20:23

I hope you realise that state schools in the UK are not secular. They have religious assemblies and can have Bible stories too.

Benjispruce4 · 06/04/2022 20:21

@ChuckBerrysBoots snap!

ChuckBerrysBoots · 06/04/2022 20:20

Both kids go to Catholic school and all it’s served to do is put them off religion altogether - both committed atheists! I tend to describe us as “cultural catholics” more than anything

Creameggs223 · 06/04/2022 20:18

You do realise once he is at school regardless of religion they still learn about the bible, my dds school isn't Catholic but they had a priest in at Christmas doing a little mass my dd enjoyed it and asked can she go to father Tom's church. Its a story and once dc is old enough he will decide if he believes or not no harm is being done.

Mewski · 06/04/2022 20:08

@PerfectPrepPrincess

I think you're being unreasonable. Listening to a bible story isn't going to make him a believer, if anything it's just a different way of explaining morals and ethics. It'll all stop when he goes to school anyway so I wouldn't fret unessacarily. It'd be mean to stop something so harmless that he enjoys.
I agree with this. I went to a Christian primary school which was all hymns and church trips across the road for Easter etc. My parents weren't religious, and I naturally was an atheist also. Better to maintain a good relationship with Mil Your DS won't really pick up on the religious stuff
Frankola · 06/04/2022 20:08

Some friends and I used to take our toddlers to a church playgroup once a week because it was a lovely space to play in. We're all atheist.

Everyone at the group was lovely and they also used to read a story from the Bible but it's simply an acknowledgement that the session is run by the church. There was no pressure to confirm to any organised religion and the people who ran the group knew that about 80% of mums were not part of the church

tearinghairout · 06/04/2022 20:07

OP, re your concerns about the going to hell, no sex outside marriage etc etc, you are your dch's main carer and I think your dch will grow up in a UK where those beliefs are more and more seen as abnormal. My own DM was pretty full-on with some of those beliefs to my dch and it has been a way of me and their dad discussing our own beliefs about gay marriage etc with them. So I wouldn't worry about it.

SleepingStandingUp · 06/04/2022 20:02

As someone who's agnostic and takes her kids to a church group every week, yes yabu. The stories are basically about being nice to people. We do a prayer before snack which is basically be thankful for your food. The art activity is linked to the religious story but the kids just see they're painting a fish or making a boat etc. It's playgroup, not indoctrination.

mycatisannoying · 06/04/2022 19:57

YABU and can't be serious?!

twentythreehundred · 06/04/2022 19:56

Thank you for the clarification Idontwanna

I have some thinking to do about my own biases (prejudices). I take your point on board.

And as for my friend, our relationship is strong enough for me to question her beliefs and for us to disagree and continue to discuss the topics over time. I wrote "shit" more in surprise than disappointment. I may have been naïve in my assumptions because I have known her for many years and know her to be a very liberal person.

But now we have some long and interesting conversations ahead of us.

seastargirl · 06/04/2022 19:55

I've just read barry the fish with fingers,I don't think that's going to have any long lasting impact on my child just like I dont think bible stories will. If you feel you've been duped you could raise it. But think of the happiness it's bought your son and his grandma rather than thinking of yourself.

tearinghairout · 06/04/2022 19:54

@WalkingOnTheCracks

I was about twenty-five before I worked out why, during my childhood, my mum and dad had insisted on me taking my ever-increasing number of younger siblings to Sunday School every week.
I wonder if that was the same reason we sent ours? All the dch in the cul-de-sac used to go - someone from the church would collect them and bring them.home - and it was a very quiet cul-de-dac for two hours every Sunday morning Wink
Cait33 · 06/04/2022 19:53

I'm an atheist and my mum took DD to a church toddler group when she was little (also as part of a free childcare set up). DD loved it and it definitely didn't affect her religious beliefs. She's as atheist as the day is long now as a 23 YO. She actually asked me to withdraw her from RE at school when she about 9 and I refused. How can she decide she doesn't believe in something if she doesn't learn about it? I now have a DS with my DH who comes from a fairly religious background. Their minister approached me when DS was a baby to ask if I would agree to him being baptized. I told him I don't believe and don't support organised religion but would be content to allow the baptism (to me a meaningless and harmless ceremony) as long as he understood I wouldn't be making any promises to bring DS up in the church etc etc. To my amazement, he agreed so we went ahead. It kept PIL and the extended family happy and we had a lovely day out. DS received about £500 in gifts too so all in all not a bad day! I honestly wouldn't worry OP.

cansu · 06/04/2022 19:53

Listening to a bible story will not harm him. Even when he goes to school, he will learn 'about' religions. Knowing about the bible is a good reference point for literature in the future. It is not in any way worth causing any upset.

Hertsgirl10 · 06/04/2022 19:49

What’s the difference to your child hearing a bible story to any other story? I don’t believe in religion either so won’t make any difference to me what stories are being read in a baby group.

I don’t know why you’re so bothered about it when your son doesn’t mention it and you don’t mind her taking him, you knew it was a religious group before, why the shock about the stories?
They’re stories same as any other to me, I know people believe it but people believe in witches or Harry Potter and other strange stuff, don’t stress about it he will be at school soon enough.

Swipe left for the next trending thread