Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Christian MIL taking DC to Christian toddler group - I was unaware

507 replies

AtheistMama · 06/04/2022 15:12

Name change for this one.

My MIL does childcare once a week for DS aged 3, for which I am grateful for - they have a great relationship, and obviously it saves us money on nursery fees.

My MIL is a lovely women, not a bad bone in her body. She is also devoutly Christian, belonging to an evangelical church. DH was brought up as an evangelical Christian, but is an atheist and slowly detached himself from their church in his young adulthood. There is no animosity from his mother and the wider family about this (who are mostly also evangelical Christians).

DH and I have been together for 10 years, married for 5, but I have never really talked to MIL about my religious beliefs because she is quite sensitive/easily upset and I didn't want to offend her. The status quo has just been that it is obvious to all that DH and I are not Christian and it's been left at that.

My understanding of DH's families beliefs is that they think everyone who is not baptised is going to Hell; they also do not approve of homosexuality or gay marriage, sex before marriage, etc. I am an atheist and do not subscribe to these beliefs. In particular, the idea that they believe that I am going to Hell bothers me when I think about it. In general, I am anti-organised religion and was never going to bring DS up in any religious way.

MIL takes DS to a toddler's group at her church every week, but I was under the impression that it was open to the whole community and therefore not Christian (I think this came from DH not my MIL). I looked up the group today (was wondering about the timings for a seperate reason), and clocked that they have a Bible story every week.

I'm feeling a bit annoyed because if I had known about the Bible story bit when it was first suggested that she take him (years ago), I would have gently asked her to pick another activity. But now he's been going for a few years, he loves it and it's part of their routine. She would probably be upset by being asked to stop going (and probably it didn't occur to her that I wouldn't be happy about it).

However, I feel really uncomfortable about the Bible story, and annoyed that she didn't say anything at the start. Needless to say, DS has never mentioned it, so it's possible that he's running around the hall and not even listening to it.

DH tends to skirt around issues with his DM that might be upsetting because he thinks she's quite delicate and feels protective about her.

AIBU to bring it up with her now?

OP posts:
ifyouturnonthelight · 07/04/2022 15:47

All these people whinging about Christian play groups and I bet you all took advantage of the £1 entry fee and the nice toys though

TheKeatingFive · 07/04/2022 15:47

It should not be pushed on children

It's going to be very hard to keep children away from the most popular bible stories. They are everywhere.

stimpyyouidiot · 07/04/2022 15:45

It should not be pushed on children, especially if the parents don't want it. All the 'I took mine and it did no harm' - you made that decision yourself. Op hasn't chosen that for her child and I would be furious if someone tried to indoctrinate my child from a young age. You can all say 'it's just a story!' But children have no critical thinking skills and take things literally. Unless you're saying 'some people believe' (which in a church, they won't be) they are going to believe it.

Pumpfive · 07/04/2022 15:42

I don't think you are naive tbh! As a nanny, I take the children to a Christian led playgroup and there's no religion imposed on the children. It's different for different churches!

Lillith111 · 07/04/2022 15:35

@TwuntyFriend if you don’t believe in God you go to hell according to Christianity. Personally I think that no one deserves to be tortured (except perhaps people like Hitler) and anyone who supports and worships an entity who thinks it’s ok to torture isn’t someone I want to associate with. It’s a cruel belief

TwuntyFriend · 07/04/2022 15:20

[quote Lillith111]@TwuntyFriend why is it ok to hold the belief that your friends deserve to be tortured? I’d be uncomfortable if one of my friends worshipped something she thinks is going to torture me even if I don’t believe in it because she’s condoning that torture[/quote]
Nowhere did the OP state her MIL thinks they 'deserve' to be tortured. But as Christian you believe in Heaven and Hell. Every person has the opportunity to go to Heaven should they wish to choose it.

Lillith111 · 07/04/2022 15:04

@TwuntyFriend why is it ok to hold the belief that your friends deserve to be tortured? I’d be uncomfortable if one of my friends worshipped something she thinks is going to torture me even if I don’t believe in it because she’s condoning that torture

WalkingOnTheCracks · 07/04/2022 14:53

One of the benefits of Sunday School and being brought up in the church, is that it makes doorstep conversations with Jehovah's Witnesses a lot of fun.

"As scripture tells us in John14:6..."

"Well, yeah, but given the necessarily judgemental nature of every religion, I think that Matthew6:14-15 muddies the waters a bit."

"Erm...hang on..."

"...Take your time."

I keep Jehovah's Witnesses at the door for hours. I consider it a service to the neighbourhood.

SirChenjins · 07/04/2022 14:51

Your son growing up to be aware of faith is a good thing

Faiths - plural. And non-faiths of course. Unfortunately this particular church playgroup is doing neither - it’s teaching one particular belief system above all others through the medium of storytelling. It’s how we introduce children to all manner of things we want them to believe in.

Thehop · 07/04/2022 14:29

My husband is atheist and our children go to chirch of England schools where they study the bible.

We teach them that the bible is “beliefs” and that all religions have beliefs and ours are that science answered a lot of those questions, but we respect all religions.

I’m quite spiritual but my husband isn’t. We use schools teachings to just show them how wide spanning beliefs are.

Ponderingwindow · 07/04/2022 14:25

An introduction to the mythologies of various religions is distinctly different than the presentation of any one of those mythologies as having any basis in reality.

When we read children a story like Hansel and Gretel, we are teaching children not to wander off and not to trust strangers. There is a lesson in the story hidden among the gingerbread. At the same time, we assure the child the witches aren’t real and no one is going to eat them.

I have never heard the same assurances offered to children about a god who killed almost everyone by flooding the earth. There is no reminder at the end not to worry because it’s just a story. There are no assurances that it’s not possible to have brought two of every animal on a boat and there aren’t really capricious gods who murder people.

TwuntyFriend · 07/04/2022 14:13

@Nicholethejewellery

I don't see a big deal with what she's doing. If you don't believe the Bible is an accurate history of the world then it would do your child no more harm hearing one than him hearing any other fictional children. I mean there's some violent material in the Bible but I doubt that's what they're teaching young children, anyway most fairy stories have some kind of violence or other serious criminality in them (Hansel & Gretel, the Pied Piper, The Three Bears etc).

I find these sentences interesting:
I am an atheist and do not subscribe to these beliefs. In particular, the idea that they believe that I am going to Hell bothers me when I think about it.

If you believe they are wrong, what does it matter to you? If they're not trying to convert you, aren't calling you a sinner all the time, why does it matter if they believe something that millions of others do. It sounds like they're showing more tolerance to you than you are to them.

100% this.

Not every Christian wants to indoctrinate others at a playgroup. You may not believe, but your MIL does - and you need to be respectful of that. Your son growing up to be aware of faith is a good thing.

twentythreehundred · 07/04/2022 14:04

Oopps. Posted too soon - was going to also reply that I can further understand your concerns about my posts because of my theological ignorance- however, I do not undertake any type of exit counselling or engage directly in theological discussions with people leaving Christian fundamentalism.

And I don't know the particulars of the religions (such as the names of the groups or specific churches) because anonymity is important because many leavers fear retaliation/ harassment - even if that fear isn't based in reality, they often feel it.

twentythreehundred · 07/04/2022 13:56

The conflation particularly bothers me because it tends to lead to negative consequences, where people assume views I do not possess. I could never run as a politician (not that I'd want to...), I'd just get interrogated on my views on gay sex, Trump and creationism. I feel similarly locked out of teaching, EDI work, ecetera.The US evangelicals have stolen the media attention, and rarely does anyone bother to differentiate between stereotype and reality.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 07/04/2022 13:47

@TheKeatingFive

Noah's ark taught as a fairy tale is very different from being taught that God will fully killed all the people on the earth due to their sinful nature and literally saved a handful of people in an ark.

The child is three. For the love of god.

...or someone else.
redbigbananafeet · 07/04/2022 13:44

If it helps OP, think about the Bible stories they are likely to be discussing. All I can think of have a human/moral element to them ands that's likely to be what the discussion/point of the story centers around

Chouetted · 07/04/2022 13:41

@twentythreehundred

Thank you *@Chouetted* for your explanation, what you write is exactly my understanding. My apologies for the conflation of evangelism with fundamentalism- my views are heavily biased by my experiences. Accuracy is always a good thing.

I don't find it boring as it is important to have a clear understanding when working with and/or supporting (mostly) women and children fleeing high demand religious groups.

Thanks, I'm glad we were able to find agreement.

The conflation particularly bothers me because it tends to lead to negative consequences, where people assume views I do not possess. I could never run as a politician (not that I'd want to...), I'd just get interrogated on my views on gay sex, Trump and creationism. I feel similarly locked out of teaching, EDI work, ecetera.The US evangelicals have stolen the media attention, and rarely does anyone bother to differentiate between stereotype and reality.

Aspiringmatriarch · 07/04/2022 13:39

Can I just point out again that we're talking about a toddler group? I could be wrong but I'm pretty sure the kinds of groups you're discussing aren't the ones running local toddler groups. Confused

twentythreehundred · 07/04/2022 13:33

Thank you @Chouetted for your explanation, what you write is exactly my understanding. My apologies for the conflation of evangelism with fundamentalism- my views are heavily biased by my experiences. Accuracy is always a good thing.

I don't find it boring as it is important to have a clear understanding when working with and/or supporting (mostly) women and children fleeing high demand religious groups.

twentythreehundred · 07/04/2022 13:26

@Aspiringmatriarch

Shunning? For goodness sake. Talk about projection Confused. I imagine PP meant that with such extreme and militant views it would be very unlikely they would enjoy a pleasant relationship.
Yes, I think shunning (although it does happen in the U.K.) was too strong a word for what the poster was referring to. Some high demand religious groups don't practice shunning because the groups are small and need the converts/members, so they espouse the view that leavers are always welcome back into the fold.
Chouetted · 07/04/2022 13:23

@twentythreehundred

I'm surprised that you don't know the difference between evangelical and fundamentalism, and a bit concerned.

Concerned about what?

If you think I am lacking in understanding, I welcome your elucidation.

I don't want to bore you to death with theological minutae, but evagelicalism is a theological position that centralises the bible, a personal relationship with God, and social activism. It's poorly defined, but the Bebbington quadrilateral is usually quoted - biblicentrism, crucicentrism, conversionism and activism. In general, it's part of the reaction against the excesses of the Catholic church, that generally formed the Reformation.

There are widespread evangelical contingents in many mainstream denominations. The Methodist Church, for example, is evangelical. There are even evangelical Catholics, although I've never quite understood how they managed that. You'll find a wide range of theological positions amongst them, but in the UK, they are usually politically liberal, even when theologically conservative.

Fundamentalism is religion that tends towards extremism or biblical literalism, regardless of the theological position. These include the groups you mention, but also other, non-evangelical groups.

newbiename · 07/04/2022 13:19

I heard bible stories at school. I'm an atheist. They are just stories like Christmas and Easter.

rurallibralady87 · 07/04/2022 13:14

@Brainwave89

I would ask to see more of what the Toddler group is doing. Some basic David and Goliath, Noah's Ark bible study will do little harm, but as soon as anyone starts saying same sex couples are wrong, only people who are married should have babies etc then it would be time to call a halt. I also grew up in quite a religious household and it can be potentially dangerous. One of the boys at my Church was clearly gay and the pressure placed on him was so significant he finished up sectioned. Even now his mental health is poor, and the same risks apply to other groups who may not agree with Christians see as the one version of the truth. Your MIL may be lovely but I would be careful.
You really think they will be discussing same sex couples at a toddler group?
rurallibralady87 · 07/04/2022 13:14

@Brainwave89

I would ask to see more of what the Toddler group is doing. Some basic David and Goliath, Noah's Ark bible study will do little harm, but as soon as anyone starts saying same sex couples are wrong, only people who are married should have babies etc then it would be time to call a halt. I also grew up in quite a religious household and it can be potentially dangerous. One of the boys at my Church was clearly gay and the pressure placed on him was so significant he finished up sectioned. Even now his mental health is poor, and the same risks apply to other groups who may not agree with Christians see as the one version of the truth. Your MIL may be lovely but I would be careful.
You really think they will be discussing same sex couples at a toddler group?
Aspiringmatriarch · 07/04/2022 13:12

Shunning? For goodness sake. Talk about projection Confused.
I imagine PP meant that with such extreme and militant views it would be very unlikely they would enjoy a pleasant relationship.

Swipe left for the next trending thread