Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why people are so keen to defend their profession

119 replies

Siepie · 06/04/2022 12:04

It's something I see quite a lot on Mumsnet. I'm including my own job here: I'm a lecturer. I work hard and I think I do a good job. Several times on Mumsnet I've seen threads about problems DC are having at university, and lecturers posting along the lines of "that could never happen" / "a lecturer would never do that!" Meanwhile I'm thinking I've definitely worked with people I could imagine doing that!

It seems to be the same with a lot of public facing roles on here, e.g. teachers, doctors, receptionists, call handlers. I'd understand if a poster was complaining about all of your profession, but if someone's posting about a specific incident, why do posters automatically disbelieve them? Do you really think everyone with the same job as you is good at that job? If so you must have been very lucky with your colleagues!

OP posts:
balalake · 09/04/2022 13:07

spivs!

balalake · 09/04/2022 13:07

@namechangetheworld hope you find some inner peace outing yourself. Though part of the dislike of estate agents is that they are allowed to work with little regulation, the system that allows the seemingly too many chancers and spies.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 09/04/2022 12:34

Just to balance the criticism that teachers get…

Sherrystrull · 09/04/2022 11:40

@JoyLurking9to5

So true *@Selkiesarereal* I had several really astonishingly nasty teachers. One who set out to shame me and humiliate me with an audience.

A relative of mine is a teacher and she is/has (?) given me and just me the silent treatment while fawning over all the rest of our relatives. It's so weird, but I think, this blatant emotional dysfunction is from a teacher. wow. Some teachers are good but they are only teachers and unfortunately you can't teach emotional health. They're not asked how they deal with their own dislike of pupils who may be triggering something in them. They're not taught how to avoid projecting on to students. They're not aware they're not aware. (The bad teachers I mean)

This is the type of post that I would normally respond to. Even though it isn't directed at me as a teacher it still upsets me to read and makes me realise how lots and lots of people feel about the teaching profession.
Iwonder08 · 09/04/2022 11:09

In my experience.. Re midwives.. Big well respected hospital with great stats.. I met about 20 midwives, out of which 1 was decent. The rest showed either one or all of these qualitites: incompetence, rudeness, disregard for health of their patients (not comfort, I mean health). I've never seen a thread here about ALL midwives being shit, but people rightly complain about fundamental issues within the industry.
Being overworked doesn't justify any of the issues above.

Fairislefandango · 09/04/2022 11:01

The problem with teaching is that all of us at one time went to school and most likely had a shit teacher so know that they still exist.

Yes but there are rubbish or unpleasant people in every job in the world, because a proportion of human beings are incompetent and/or unpleasant. Plus a lot of that is very subjective. There are so many teachers which some students and parents hate but other students and parents think are great!

namechangetheworld · 09/04/2022 10:47

Try being an estate agent Hmm

JoyLurking9to5 · 09/04/2022 10:21

But is it the midwives and nurses fault they're understaffed? @Lineofconcepcion

I deal with unsatisfied customers and they're so angry as well but if it were my decision, I WOULD hire more staff. It's not my decision.

Lineofconcepcion · 09/04/2022 10:14

@IDontDrinkTea

I’ll preface this by saying I’m a midwife, as this will give context to what I’m saying.

I think there’s a lot of bits about the profession that people don’t realise unless they’re in it. There’s currently a national shortage of midwives; I’d go as far as to describe it as a crisis. I don’t remember the last shift I worked where we had a full complement of staff. This means the staff are probably doing their very best in difficult circumstances. I often see posts saying my midwife left me etc, but realistically yes, I am going to prioritise the bits of my job that keep people safe rather than the bits that keep people comfortable. It’s shit, but it’s true.

Secondly, I read a lot of posts about how the midwives were just sat at their desk doing paperwork and chatting. I’d rather not do this, but there is an entire office of people who audit everything I write and tell me off if I’ve missed something. For example, I once received a written warning for not performing a blood pressure check during a woman’s labour - it didn’t take into account that the baby arrived so quickly I delivered it in the footwell of their car.

Finally, perception of what’s happening whilst you’re in labour is definitely skewed and Im not judging as I have children myself. What feels like ages waiting for pain relief is actually 15 minutes, which is the time it takes to find a second midwife free to check a controlled drug out of the controlled drug cupboard, mix it with an antiemetic, sign a drug chart, possibly even get it prescribed if required.

So it’s not that I’m saying stuff never happens. But what I’m saying is there’s often very valid reasons for what happened, and perhaps their perception is different from the perception of the staff

Here we go again. It isn't that patients are waiting 15minutes for drugs ffs, it's that they're dying.
JoyLurking9to5 · 09/04/2022 09:57

So true @Selkiesarereal I had several really astonishingly nasty teachers. One who set out to shame me and humiliate me with an audience.

A relative of mine is a teacher and she is/has (?) given me and just me the silent treatment while fawning over all the rest of our relatives. It's so weird, but I think, this blatant emotional dysfunction is from a teacher. wow. Some teachers are good but they are only teachers and unfortunately you can't teach emotional health. They're not asked how they deal with their own dislike of pupils who may be triggering something in them. They're not taught how to avoid projecting on to students. They're not aware they're not aware. (The bad teachers I mean)

Selkiesarereal · 09/04/2022 09:42

The problem with teaching is that all of us at one time went to school and most likely had a shit teacher so know that they still exist.

Another problem is perception . A few years ago I was chatting with a friend who has a child in the same class as mine and they were quite disappointed in parents night as the teacher told them all was good no problems, etc and they felt that the teacher really wasn’t engaged with the class as there wasn’t really anything of substance said.

Yet I knew differently as my child was going through an asd diagnosis at the time and they were very actively involved in helping us with this. So sometimes it can be all about perception as for many parents they will not have had to deal with the school when there are very real problems going on.

That said I do know someone in a similar position at a different school and their teacher was shit.

IDontDrinkTea · 09/04/2022 09:28

I’ll preface this by saying I’m a midwife, as this will give context to what I’m saying.

I think there’s a lot of bits about the profession that people don’t realise unless they’re in it. There’s currently a national shortage of midwives; I’d go as far as to describe it as a crisis. I don’t remember the last shift I worked where we had a full complement of staff. This means the staff are probably doing their very best in difficult circumstances. I often see posts saying my midwife left me etc, but realistically yes, I am going to prioritise the bits of my job that keep people safe rather than the bits that keep people comfortable. It’s shit, but it’s true.

Secondly, I read a lot of posts about how the midwives were just sat at their desk doing paperwork and chatting. I’d rather not do this, but there is an entire office of people who audit everything I write and tell me off if I’ve missed something. For example, I once received a written warning for not performing a blood pressure check during a woman’s labour - it didn’t take into account that the baby arrived so quickly I delivered it in the footwell of their car.

Finally, perception of what’s happening whilst you’re in labour is definitely skewed and Im not judging as I have children myself. What feels like ages waiting for pain relief is actually 15 minutes, which is the time it takes to find a second midwife free to check a controlled drug out of the controlled drug cupboard, mix it with an antiemetic, sign a drug chart, possibly even get it prescribed if required.

So it’s not that I’m saying stuff never happens. But what I’m saying is there’s often very valid reasons for what happened, and perhaps their perception is different from the perception of the staff

Isobelslider · 09/04/2022 09:25

@user1497207191

The other issue is that most people have no control over choice of teacher, nurse, GP, etc - they're basically given who they get and have to like it or lump it.

With other professions, such as solicitors, accountants, IFAs, etc., and trades such as plumbers, electricians, builders, etc., you have free choice. If you get someone who you don't like, does a crap job, etc., then you simply move on and choose someone else.

I agree with this.

And also as someone who works in the public sector, people have a sense of expectation that the public sector is there to do what they want, rather than what is best for the public as a whole.

But yes, I also know plenty of people in my line of work who are incompetent and live up to every stereotype people have of the job.

WlNDMlLL · 09/04/2022 09:19

[quote giggly]@cornflakedreams how fucking dare you make such sweeping statements about me. Just how ducking dare you. I have saved more lives than you’ve had hot dinners. You can ram your anger about me right up your own arse[/quote]
You are right to be angry. The response to your post was completely over the top and frankly one of the most horrible accusations I've ever read on MN. You can disagree with someone's view of the state of the NHS without accusing them of being the reason countless people have died.

DragonOverTheMoon · 09/04/2022 09:12

It's to do with identity. Some people identify themselves as their job more than others.

Disneyblueeyes · 09/04/2022 09:07

Problem with teachers is that parents often only learn about the competence of their child's teacher through the words of their 6 year old.

lljkk · 09/04/2022 09:04

A lot of jobs, either company specific or industry wide and sometimes legally mandated, there is lots of regulation. So for me, these "never do that!" comments are usually about the expected regulatory framework, nothing to do with character of individuals. Sometimes there are other practical reasons to find the story difficult to believe.

Of course anyone can be a bastard or negligent... but chances that someone would
A) do things at work to risk physically damaging themselves
B) where that physical damage would risk them being forced to take time off work
C) spout opinions or do actions that would easily get them reported for misconduct through easily accessible reporting systems (whistle blowing)
D) be continued presence in one's workplace in a workplace where people in OP's role move departments frequently, just 'yesterday" in fact

It just stretches credibility. there are fantasists that come on fora like MN, they are about. So yeah, people get questioned, of course they do.

yes I'm thinking of claims on a specific recent thread

ps: and that wasn't my profession by any means being accused of so much misconduct

pps: I've worked with plenty scientists, lecturers, who virtually never answer emails, and that's when they are paid to liaise with my employer (!). Big companies are no better.

Seemssounfair · 09/04/2022 09:00

I always read any posts complaining about or defending a profession assuming the poster means IME, but just hasn't been specific because it is an informal forum.

There are some professionals on MN that need to do the same and get over themselves.

Most posters don't deserve the boring, repeatitive pile ons and derailing of their thread they get for a mistake in wording. Says much more about the professional than the op.

Onionpatch · 09/04/2022 08:58

I think a lot of threads start with a reasonable complaint about a specific event. I agree any profession has some mediocre or poor practicioners. I also think even amazing professionals have bad days or make mistakes.

I do think a lot of threads then move onto very general swiping though- poor gp receptionists!

I think insiders know how hard people in their job work and in what difficult circumstances so feel they need to defend it. Individuals do their best in crappy situations and didnt make the crappy situation - but it sometimes comes across that the crappy situation is just how is has to be and noone ever makes a mistake.

JoyLurking9to5 · 09/04/2022 08:55

@cornflakedreams are you for real, all of those statements ''people like you'' and comparing giggly to a child killer. Wow.

Panda161 · 09/04/2022 08:48

Because for some people their profession is a core part of their identity, so they interpret any criticism as an attack on them

JoyLurking9to5 · 09/04/2022 08:44

I used to work in insurance and the amount of people who said jokily oh I'm not looking to buy insurance, as though the only roles are sales roles. I used to say well unless you own a fleet of oil rigs or a south american insurance company, I couldn't take your business.

JoyLurking9to5 · 09/04/2022 08:43

human nature ?

I feel like I want to challenge the perception (in Ireland anyway) that civil servants have an easy life. My dept/organisation is understaffed deliberately and the volume of work heaped upon us is unbelievable. And yet I've to read in the Waterford Whisperers that Civil Servants do 30 minutes of work a day and will get a fantastic pension for their efforts.

superdupertruper · 09/04/2022 08:41

I'm a police officer so I've had my tin hat on under several user names for quite some time now.

Stompythedinosaur · 09/04/2022 08:40

I'm a nurse, and can get very tired of the nurse bashing threads. I never see threads about a reasonable issue. I very often see threads where people have misunderstood what nursing is and posters want to buy in to the misogynistic notion that nurses should be "perfect, servant-like, self-sacrificing angels". I challenge it, because it is misogyny.

Swipe left for the next trending thread