Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder who funds a teacher's school trip

482 replies

iwasjustwonderingreally · 06/04/2022 10:41

My daughter went skiing with her school in February half term.

Four teachers accompanied them.

Do teachers pay for themselves, or a contribution, (I appreciate they are working though), or is the cost to the pupil inflated to cover the cost of the teachers?

OP posts:
WalltoWallBtards · 06/04/2022 13:32

You’ll have to ask your school how it was funded, won’t you? Before you start complaining about the teachers who spent 24/7 with a bunch of teenagers on a school trip.

Silverclocks · 06/04/2022 13:31

The travel companies often offer the staff places free. I.e x number of free places per y children. Schools aren't allowed to inflate the cost of the trip to cover children who can't/don't pay, but they can cover expenses, which staff costs would be.

Personally I don't understand why schools are so keen to offer these trips or what the real benefit to (a few) children is, but I wouldn't expect staff to pay for themselves. IME it won't be all expenses paid like most other business trips though. They won't be claiming for food and drink etc and they won't be paid for the week's work (skiing is usually in the holidays?)

budgiegirl · 06/04/2022 13:30

@Responsiveroo

If your teenager came back And said she’d been I’ll But “all” the teachers had been tipsy and one especially drunk

And you trusted your teen, she they weren’t prone to exaggerating (no idea about this one!)
Would you not pursue a complaint? Or at least approach the school and ask for a pretty frank disuxssion?

I agree - yes, I would at least want to make an enquiry as to what had happened. But I would proceed with caution, as it can be very difficult to judge the difference between 'tipsy', 'drunk', and just 'high sprits'.

I'm a cub leader, and take the cubs on camps/residentials at least three times a year. The Scout Association rules state that leaders who are responsible for young people may not drink (at all), and a minimum of two leaders must be responsible at any time, depending on the number on kids on camp. This should be risk assessed.

Other leaders can have a drink, but away from the young people, and should consider how it may affect their ability to carry out their duties later.

As a result, we rarely have a drink on camp (as much as we might need one!). We may share a bottle of wine in the late evening, but it's rare, and at least two people will remain alcohol free!

I fully appreciate how hard it is to take children away on holiday, it's exhausting. And I understand that some teachers may want to have a drink, that's fair enough. But I certainly wouldn't think it's ok for all to be drinking, and no-one should be drunk. Of course, we don't really know what happened here, but it seems fair to investigate.

MsTSwift · 06/04/2022 13:30

Look at all the posters remembering their school trip teen experiences of what 20/30/40 years ago! They are precious things so any teacher facilitating that would have to be pretty bloody awful for me to complain as long as my kid came back in one piece.

Shinyandnew1 · 06/04/2022 13:29

@mam0918

Our school holds fundraisers to send teachers on holiday... not even school trips just mid-term holidays (to exotic locations).

They say the teachers 'learn' things on these 'excursions' and then share that wisdom with the class... I frankly find it cheeky fuckery.

That’s certainly never happened in any state school I’ve worked in, or even heard of! Grin
KnowingMeKnowingYouAhaaaa · 06/04/2022 13:29

Do you really think a teacher who is giving up their holidays and time with their own family to work a school trip is going to pay for themselves??? They can't do whatever they like, no relaxing, no drinking, supervising 30+ teens 24/7, yet you would contemplate they pay for the privilege 🤣🤣. It's the equivalent of someone paying for a work business trip.

MsTSwift · 06/04/2022 13:28

Absolutely Goldbar. They are entirely separate issues. So if the teachers were self funding it would be ok for them not to supervise the teens would it?

Also it’s so thick to compare the cost of a school trip to that of a family holiday you have to pay staff costs on a trip either of the attending teachers or the staff at the activity centre.

I would be so grateful if my child could get on a trip! I collect with bottles of wine for staff but both parents are teachers so know they hell of it. No money would be enough for me to be responsible for other peoples teens.

HollaHolla · 06/04/2022 13:28

Also, I went on a school trip to Italy in the early 90s. It was great, because my three best friends and I all went together, and were in a big hotel room. Turned out one was SO messy, it drove us all to distraction; someone else hooked up with a local boy, and climbed out the window of the hotel to meet him; and we were all rounded up in a divey nightclub one night by a furious PE teacher, when we'd gone somewhere we shouldn't have. We were 16, it was a rite of passage!

Our teachers were also compassionate, caring, supportive, and fun. I was 16, but had never been away from my family for 10 days - and was horribly homesick. We got our exam results when we were away, and there was a lot of crying/celebration.
I remember even being able to bring a bottle of wine home for my parents - the teachers got them duty free, and put in the lockers under the bus. It was great fun, and I remember my mum picking me up from the school when we got home about 2am, with chocolate for all of the teachers to say thanks!

Doggirl · 06/04/2022 13:26

Have also been on a school trip myself where some teachers were staggering around the corridors in the evenings. Was in the ‘90’s though, and our teachers used to pop out for a pint at lunchtime, so was probably seen as more acceptable back then.

I suspect lots of things that went on then wouldn't fly nowadays.
My only trip abroad with school was skiing in the early '90s. Once we were in ski classes for the day, the teachers certainly didn't stick around with ustypically that was 6 hours+ (barring any problems that needed them, of course), as we took packed lunches each day. One teacher was a regular on these trips: he didn't do anything else with the school outside teaching, and in fact didn't seem to warm to his pupils much. Oh, and he got me and a couple of other Year 12s to buy duty free for him on the ferryI was 17, some would have been 16--like I say, this wouldn't fly nowadays!

Maireas · 06/04/2022 13:25

@mam0918

Our school holds fundraisers to send teachers on holiday... not even school trips just mid-term holidays (to exotic locations).

They say the teachers 'learn' things on these 'excursions' and then share that wisdom with the class... I frankly find it cheeky fuckery.

Well I've never heard of that in my life and I've been teaching for 38 years.

Goldbar · 06/04/2022 13:24

Potential teacher misconduct is an entirely separate issue to who pays for the teachers on a school trip.

I would NEVER want to take a bunch of someone else's kids away on a residential trip and be responsible for them. There actually isn't enough you could pay me to do that as I have some...err...interesting memories of what people used to get up to on the school trips I went on as a teenager. Happily, I work in adult education so that won't be asked of me.

The idea that teachers should pay for the privilege of taking other people's kids away is really very funny Grin. They don't earn megabucks, you know. What would you choose if you couldn't afford both...a holiday with your own family or a school trip shepherding other people's kids?

mam0918 · 06/04/2022 13:23

Our school holds fundraisers to send teachers on holiday... not even school trips just mid-term holidays (to exotic locations).

They say the teachers 'learn' things on these 'excursions' and then share that wisdom with the class... I frankly find it cheeky fuckery.

RealBecca · 06/04/2022 13:22

I dont understand why you are signing a mass letter Bout a particular student instead of writing your own about your own concerns.

You can then ask who funds it from the school who will know. I'm not sure how it's relevant, presumably it wouldn't matter of there hadn't been unacceptable behaviour by the teachers and their duty of care.

It sounds like someone wants to write "all while WE we paying for the teachers!"

Its irrelevant who paid. The duty of care is the issue, stick with it.

DreamingofGinoclock · 06/04/2022 13:21

@iwasjustwonderingreally

The complaint is that their child was ill and they'd have expected there to be at least one teacher who wasn't drunk and who could take responsibility.

I would imagine we'd all hope that when sending our kids away with the school.

There is video/photographic evidence of drunken teachers. The Head Mistress has actually contacted some pupils asking them to delete the photos.

I wouldn't begrudge the teachers having a drink ...but like you you would expect one each night to stay sober for safety ....it reminds me of a school trip we went on to Germany ...we went to a beer hall to see the atmosphere (we obviously all had soft drinks etc as think we were in year 9) ...all the teachers bar one had one of the stines of beer and while they weren't drunk / still capable one of the teachers didn't drink ( I remember because we asked her why and she said because she had to keep an eye on us!)
UnsuitableHat · 06/04/2022 13:21

Teacher places are free. The cost is soaked up by the rest.

Mulhollandmagoo · 06/04/2022 13:17

@iwasjustwonderingreally

Jeez, it was just a simple question to clarify a situation as a parent is complaining that the teachers were drunk when their child was ill.

I'm not saying teachers should pay!!!!

I remember going on school trips at comp, there were always wild rumours about the teachers, which were all completely made up! We thought it was hilarious, looking back now I realise based on your posts that we could have got one in serious trouble.

If I'm honest, I'd steer clear of this whole thing and let the parent complain, your child was looked after and cared for correctly so you personally have no reason to complain, and the parent in question will most likely end up with egg on their face once this is investigated.

viques · 06/04/2022 13:17

I don’t think anyone who has never taken other peoples children away on overnight or longer trips can understand how stressful they are. Lots of kids, you think you know but never know how they will respond to being away from home, you are on duty 24 hours a day, you sleep with your ears open ( it is like having large new borns, ) . You are constantly counting, checking, being vigilant, while simultaneously comforting anxious children , encouraging nervous ones, calming the boisterous, you check on what they are eating, how they are dressed, how much they are sleeping, you try to keep track of the belongings they discard, lose and damage! You stay positive when it rains, slap on sunscreen when it is hot, make sure they have pictures of their achievements and you glow as you watch them blossom and show sides of their personalities you never knew about.

The very thought that some people seem to resent the fact that teachers aren’t paying for the privilege of caring for other peoples children for free during their own free time is astonishing, but not totally unexpected, on all the school journeys I arranged, supervised and accompanied I can count on the fingers of one hand the parents who said “Thankyou for taking them, I appreciate how hard it must be.”

I have never taken kids abroad, or done an activity as potentially dangerous as skiing, so hats off to those teachers brave enough and resilient enough to do so.

Scottishnewmum · 06/04/2022 13:14

@IceVolcanoes

Some kid took a photo of the teacher holding a beer presumably. Then spread it around on social media claiming the teachers were all wasted. That’s my guess at what’s really happened.

Meanwhile, little Johnny didn’t get personalised nursing care like he would from mummy, when he had a bit of a headache.

So the teachers should all be hung. Clearly.

And the HT is trying to cover it up too. 🙄

This is exactly what I suspect is the way this panned out in reality. It never ceases to amaze me how gullible some parents are when it comes to being totally lied to by their own children. Teachers see the real side to people's kids, but some parents are just blind.
Obelisk · 06/04/2022 13:14

Obviously the cost of the children’s ski trip is increased to cover the teachers. As if any teacher would pay for themselves to go. Honestly, sometimes mumsnet is ridiculous.

This reminds me of the occasional posts on here where people complain that they've asked the nanny to take their children to the zoo and now she wants them to pay for her ticket Grin

Pregnagainagain · 06/04/2022 13:14

I feel sorry for the teachers, I doubt all of them were drunk. What a shame, I’m sure there will be zero school trips like this going forward as none will be willing to go, I imagine it would be difficult to remain in full work mode 24 hours a day.
When I was at school we went to the theatre (sixth form) my teacher only had debit card, no cash and he asked to borrow £10 for some refreshments until Monday, I had no issue with this, however the accompanying English teacher reported him and I was called in to the head, he had to apologise to me! I said it was unnecessary and he knew it was nothing I had said, I saw him a few years ago and we laughed about it, teacher who reported it left not long after. This reminds me of that

SW1amp · 06/04/2022 13:11

@Responsiveroo

Fgs they don’t “deserve” to have a few drinks at the end of the day that renders them not able to drive for example

There should have been a rota ie two can drink but the other refrain completely

There were ALL drinking

What vehicle are they supposed be able to drive..?

The coach?
Or should they just hotwire a random car in the ski resort?

WilsonMilson · 06/04/2022 13:11

Obviously the cost of the children’s ski trip is increased to cover the teachers. As if any teacher would pay for themselves to go. Honestly, sometimes mumsnet is ridiculous.

Wormwoodgal · 06/04/2022 13:08

The companies offering ski trips and long haul trips to schools operate on at least a 50% net profit margin, often more. So if you pay £2,000 for your child's trip, £1,000 (or more) of that is profit for the company. Out of the other £1,000 (or less) come all the expenses for the trip, including free places for accompanying staff. For these more expensive trips the companies do a lot of the organisation for the trip.
If pupils are encouraged to fundraise for their trip, at least half of what they raise goes to the company running the trip.
In the schools I worked in, there was always the same group of teachers who went on the attractive non-curricular trips (skiing, Africa, China) - usually this group consisted of the organisers of other attractive trips, on a quid pro quo basis. I went on a week's residential in Brittany and a couple of day trips to Cleethorpes!

DietrichandDiMaggio · 06/04/2022 13:07

[quote ReadyToMoveIt]@rosesarebluey you’re offended by ‘FFS’?![/quote]
Just about to say the exact same thing!

dworky · 06/04/2022 13:07

Would you fork out to look after & keep safe numerous over-excited children, 24-7?

Swipe left for the next trending thread