Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder who funds a teacher's school trip

482 replies

iwasjustwonderingreally · 06/04/2022 10:41

My daughter went skiing with her school in February half term.

Four teachers accompanied them.

Do teachers pay for themselves, or a contribution, (I appreciate they are working though), or is the cost to the pupil inflated to cover the cost of the teachers?

OP posts:
flumposie · 06/04/2022 11:52

has depletedGrin

flumposie · 06/04/2022 11:52

I've done trips during holidays that involved over 24 hours on a coach abroad. I used to run a lunchtime club, extra revision at lunchtime and during holidays. I will do no more. Threads like this and the hatred shown towards teachers over the last few years as depleted all goodwill.

Gardeninspring · 06/04/2022 11:51

*cruise around the Med

Wardrobes123 · 06/04/2022 11:51

As a parent I’d happily pay extra to give the teachers a little extra thanks! I often bought wine or chocs as an additional thank you anyway.

Teachers organise the trips, send letters, chase payment and then agree to supervise our children on these trips which mean so much to the kids.

I wouldn’t care if they weren’t supervising them 24/7 or had a couple of drinks in the evening.

Without teachers these trips wouldn’t happen at all. Just think about that.

How any parent can question or moan about this is beyond me.

Gardeninspring · 06/04/2022 11:50

Back in the 90s when I was at school we went on a cruise around for a week. Can't remember how much my parents paid for it but it was around £800 (this was 26 years ago). The teachers had a tough job keeping us all safe and in line so my parents were perfectly happy to have paid towards their trip too as it was in no way leisurely or relaxing for them. Lots of early starts, different excursions, hassle with teenagers etc. I remember our flight out to Athens was delayed at Gatwick and we were all tired and moody at the airport all night. The teachers had a right game trying to sort everything out whilst being shattered themselves.

Shinyandnew1 · 06/04/2022 11:50

This has nothing at all to do with who pays for teacher trips really has it, OP?

There are a lot of posts about teachers on here this morning…

Blanketpolicy · 06/04/2022 11:50

It has been raised as a complaint and, before I decide whether or not I want to put my name to any complaint, I want to find out if it's been paid for by parents or not!

So it is a teacher pile on?

Do you have a complaint of your own without being incited to get involved in a group one?

If you expect the/a teacher(s) to be stone cold sober do you think your expectations are too high? I get tipsy in charge of my teen, is that a problem? As long as there was one or two not too "tipsy" to deal with it then what is actual the problem?

How will you prove that there was no teacher capable of dealing with the problem?

If the concern is safety, then who pays for it is completely irrelevant and will make your complaint look petty and embarrassing.

echt · 06/04/2022 11:50

@iwasjustwonderingreally

The complaint is that their child was ill and they'd have expected there to be at least one teacher who wasn't drunk and who could take responsibility.

I would imagine we'd all hope that when sending our kids away with the school.

There is video/photographic evidence of drunken teachers. The Head Mistress has actually contacted some pupils asking them to delete the photos.

What load of drip-feeding bollocks.

If you're that bothereded , and welcome to MN, asking MN won't help. You may find that the teachers were paid for by a beneficent fairy.

But that's not your point, is it. You're just stirring the shit.

Oh and I absolutely guarantee you will NOT return with the results of your "concern" about this matter.

Abraxan · 06/04/2022 11:49

Most companies who run school visits offer x number of staff places depending on how many children are paid for. This applies to residential and day trips usually.

Teachers definitely don't pay for themselves. It's part of the job in many schools - not really a perk, as supervising a trip is extremely stressful generally and residential are hard work, even if the main activity is run by instructors.

Teachers also aren't paid for the extra hours they work on trips either, so they are usually working additional several hours unpaid including being 'available' 24 hours a day whilst in residential.

mudgetastic · 06/04/2022 11:49

The funding is a red herring
Even if the teachers flights abs accommodations were paid , the teachers would probably be below minimum wage if considered that they should all be avail24*7

The teachers were formally responsible , trusted by the parents and failed

They didn't all need to be sober but they should have ensured someone was ?

PurpleFlower1983 · 06/04/2022 11:49

There won’t be anymore school trips going from that school moving forward! This is why so many schools don’t bother anymore.

CulturePigeon · 06/04/2022 11:48

This question has sent my blood pressure up! I will respond with 2 examples I've experienced myself as a teacher:

On a choir tour to Italy, I have never been so tired and stressed, and I was with a group of well-behaved teenage boys who were truly a delight to accompany. But the 6.00 am starts, the not getting to bed until the small hours (late concerts far away), the constant, constant head counting and checking EVERYTHING is just relentless. In addition, 3 boys needed hospital treatment and that involved getting taxis to distant hospitals (with my rudimentary Italian - thank goodness so many of them spoke English) to make decisions about injuries and illnesses which you just hoped would be right. It was exhausting, and that was with no behaviour issues to deal with.

Second case: Year 6 Journey - a teacher couldn't go and my fantastic TA volunteered, even though she'd had something booked for the half-term with her family. After a shattering week, she was counting the kids off the coach while their families waitied, only to hear (on of the least supportive) parents turn to another and say 'It's just a bloody free holiday for the teachers, isn't it?' She had to restrain herself not to whack this horrible, unimaginative person, who was often reluctant to take responsibilty for their own offspring, never mind 30 of other people's.

Grrrrr. Try it and see if it's a free holiday. Remember Land's End.

Shgytfgtf111 · 06/04/2022 11:48

@IceVolcanoes

Some kid took a photo of the teacher holding a beer presumably. Then spread it around on social media claiming the teachers were all wasted. That’s my guess at what’s really happened.

Meanwhile, little Johnny didn’t get personalised nursing care like he would from mummy, when he had a bit of a headache.

So the teachers should all be hung. Clearly.

And the HT is trying to cover it up too. 🙄

This
JudgeJ · 06/04/2022 11:48

@iwasjustwonderingreally

For those surprised that I ask ...

The teachers aren't with the children during the day as they are off skiing on their own (as the children are in ski school).

They are all also drinking at night and one got particularly drunk.

It has been raised as a complaint and, before I decide whether or not I want to put my name to any complaint, I want to find out if it's been paid for by parents or not!

Surely you're not claiming that parents never have a drink and occasionally too many?
Sarahcoggles · 06/04/2022 11:48

@MySecretHistory I think my experience is highly relevant.
I had to be accompanied to hospital by a teacher, which obviously left the teachers back at the hotel short-staffed. The kids who'd witnessed my seizure why quite upset. We were all about 13 I think, so quite young really. The whole episode was quite a challenge for the staff, and had any of them been even slightly drunk, it would have made the situation a lot worse.

School trips are incredibly hard work for teachers, and I'm hugely grateful to all of the ones who have accompanied me and my kids over the years. But the fact remains that they have a responsibility to stay fully coherent at all times, in the same way that anyone does when they're working.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 06/04/2022 11:47

Inflated cost? No, but the price represents the cost of the trip including the adults that need to go.
I'm frankly amazed that teachers are willing to spend half term on a coach to Italy with 40 teenagers and deal with all of that. Good on them

IceVolcanoes · 06/04/2022 11:46

@AndAsIfByMagic

I do hope the children who videoed teachers without consent get expelled at the very least.
They probably shouldn’t even have had their phone with them either. No electronics has been a rule on every residential my kids have been to. For good reason.
RaleighDurham · 06/04/2022 11:45

Might be worth pointing out to all the parents queueing to sign up to this complaint (on the word of a few teenagers) that this will almost certainly put the kibosh on any future residential trips going ahead.
It's hard enough to get staff to go as it is, even for skiing.

phishy · 06/04/2022 11:45

This is probably one of the worst drip feeds I’ve seen.

Take your own sodding kids skiing next time.

JudgeJ · 06/04/2022 11:44

@bigTillyMint

There are usually a number of free adult spaces included in the cost. I guess that ultimately the parents are paying for the teacher, but the teachers are in locoparentis obvs
As a teacher on a school trip you're expected to be far more careful than a parent. As a parent you would probably be happy to sit and have a coffee while your child of around 13 plays on the beach within your sight, if said child falls and breaks an arm it's an accident. Do exactly the same as a teacher and it's possibly a career destroying event. A friend once took a ski trip, he called the Head and said 'Do you want the good news or the bad?' 'The bad' 'A girl's broken her arm' 'So what's the good news then?' 'It was your daughter so there'll be no trouble from the parents!' Remember school trips abroad are often in holiday time so a teacher is not only giving up some holiday time but possibly missing time with their own children
afuckinggoat · 06/04/2022 11:43

I missed the fact that the trip was in half term.

A completely unpaid week of 24/7 responsibility only to come back to a bunch of dickhead parents spreading rumours about teachers having a drink in the evenings of their unpaid work trip. The children were filming the teachers too?

There's another thread live that is discussing declining literacy of teachers: ostensibly the literacy and numeracy tests for trainee teachers are being scrapped due to recruitment issues. OP, why do you think there is a recruitment crisis in education...?

robocracker · 06/04/2022 11:42

I'm not paying to go in the guide camp I've planned in May either. Selfish bitch that I am!

AndAsIfByMagic · 06/04/2022 11:42

I do hope the children who videoed teachers without consent get expelled at the very least.

robocracker · 06/04/2022 11:42

The pupils pay for the teachers or the teacher places are "free" with an education company. If they go in term time parents also pay for cover for the lessons they're missing.

Of course we could always not go on any trips, or go on trips and leave the rest of the students with nothing to do.

I once walked out if a restaurant in Iceland crying due to students behaviour. I'd have been mightily pissed off if id paid for the privilege.

In fact I have been on field trips completely unpaid as I work part time and as I do geography and field trips are essential to the curriculum I have volunteered to go on my days off.

I'm such an awful person.

theemperorhasnoclothes · 06/04/2022 11:42

Who pays is totally irrelevant to the issue at hand, and if you include it you will dilute your complaint OP.

The company makes the decision to include 'free' teacher spaces or they wouldn't get any bookings. So technically no-one is 'paying' for the teachers as these are complementary places given by the ski company. Of course how they do it is by increasing the per pupil cost but legally, in contract, those teacher places will be free. It's a total distraction from your complaint and you'll get nowhere with it.

If one teacher was very drunk then if they were 'on duty' that's gross misconduct. If they weren't 'on duty' (i.e. not working - do you expect that teachers work 24/7 on these trips?) but still on a school trip it's not a good example, and they probably will get a ticking off from the HT.

When teachers aren't working they can drink alcohol. But doing it to excess isn't ok because it isn't a good example and it could affect their performance when they are next on duty.

However, are there any adults e.g. other teachers or ideally staff at the place they're staying who can verify this because it's not like kids totally exaggerating when they feel hard done by isn't a thing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread