Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder who funds a teacher's school trip

482 replies

iwasjustwonderingreally · 06/04/2022 10:41

My daughter went skiing with her school in February half term.

Four teachers accompanied them.

Do teachers pay for themselves, or a contribution, (I appreciate they are working though), or is the cost to the pupil inflated to cover the cost of the teachers?

OP posts:
BigSandyBalls2015 · 06/04/2022 12:21

Any of the complainers who have younger kids in that school will not be on future trips.

Everyone goes on about how it's a fair system, names out of the hat etc, if over subscribed.

That's not true IME ..... my DDs went on a fab long haul trip and the kids that went were miraculously in friendship groups already, making it far easier to share rooms and all get along as well as possible.

This was a very over subscribed trip with a long waiting list.

Christ the teachers deserve several drinks after a day sorting out teens - this group were were 15 year olds .... shudder.

Responsiveroo · 06/04/2022 12:20

@MsTSwift

What utter idiots are complaining! WY to go your child never having a school trip to go on. Not enough eye rolls possible.
Read the updates

The “idiot” is complaint because her daughter was Ill and all the teachers were pissed

Responsiveroo · 06/04/2022 12:18

The question about financing muddies the waters
Irrelevant

MsTSwift · 06/04/2022 12:18

What utter idiots are complaining! WY to go your child never having a school trip to go on. Not enough eye rolls possible.

Maray1967 · 06/04/2022 12:18

Uni lecturer here who has taken plenty of field trips to European cities - not skiing though.
We are not in loco parentis but are representing the university abroad as are the students. We would have a couple of drinks but would never be drunk. I can tell you that a field trip ends up costing us a fair bit of money over and above the basic cost being covered and a meal allowance at night. We have had to take students to police stations when phones/passports have been lost/stolen, been to the British embassy to help student get new passport, gone to hospitals to deal with sprained ankles, suspected cellulitis, infections etc, dealt with the occasional falling out, complaints over snoring etc while being with the students all day in sites, museums etc. I enjoy it - mostly- but I work very hard before and during the trip. I then get back and catch up on marking and admin not done while away. Our students almost always show appreciation - loads of thanks from them plus family collecting them at the airport.
When DC1 went on a school trip which ran partly into the Easter holidays I made sure we both thanked the staff because it is definitely not teachers’/lecturers’ idea of a holiday.

It would be a serious disciplinary offence I’m sure if a teacher is drunk on a school trip. Does the video footage actually show that?

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 06/04/2022 12:18

@iwasjustwonderingreally

For those surprised that I ask ...

The teachers aren't with the children during the day as they are off skiing on their own (as the children are in ski school).

They are all also drinking at night and one got particularly drunk.

It has been raised as a complaint and, before I decide whether or not I want to put my name to any complaint, I want to find out if it's been paid for by parents or not!

Then, if you have proof of drunken conduct, complain about that.

But don't throw the kitchen sink at it!

HollaHolla · 06/04/2022 12:18

Actually, my Dad went on one too - as there was only one male teacher in the school, who was due to go, and then a family situation meant he couldn't. They needed a male teacher in the party. There was a sudden scramble, my Dad is appropriately criminal record/child safeguarding cleared (in his job too), and could get the time off. He also gave up his Annual Leave, and went to help Mum and the other teacher.
His trip was paid for too. (But he probably did drink some of the comedy beer stein.)

Responsiveroo · 06/04/2022 12:18

Who pays what is utterly irrelevant

The teachers has a duty of care

They have failed in that duty

Mosschopz · 06/04/2022 12:17

OP, if the headteacher has asked students to delete images from their phones, it will have been because they were taken without consent, and may be shared without permission. They’d do this whatever the issue.

OP your post infers the school is somehow trying to avoid liability or cover up some kind of indiscretion by insisting on the deleting of images. This won’t be the case, they’ll be held to account for their safeguarding by the governing body, which will always investigate if there is a complaint. All I’d add is two points; if photos or videos have been to humiliate or ridicule the teachers this will never go down well and they won’t be feeding anything back to you as a parent. They won’t be supplying you with any rocks to throw either…

Sarahcoggles · 06/04/2022 12:14

[quote MichelleScarn]@Sarahcoggles are they 'working' they're not getting paid.

Am assuming your own parents never drank and you never drink to remain always 'fully coherent'?

Constant Vigilance of course...[/quote]
My Mum was a single parent and she never drank.
I'm also a single parent and have never been drunk when in charge of my kids.
Not that that is any of your business, because we're not talking about families. We're talking about school trips.

I collapsed and had a seizure in a foreign country where I didn't speak the language, and I woke up in a hospital. It was bloody scary and I was very grateful one of the teachers was with me and in control.

I think if none of the teachers can stay sober for a week when in a position of such responsibility, I'm not sure the school should be offering residential trips at all.

BananaPlants · 06/04/2022 12:14

Have also been on a school trip myself where some teachers were staggering around the corridors in the evenings. Was in the ‘90’s though, and our teachers used to pop out for a pint at lunchtime, so was probably seen as more acceptable back then.

HollaHolla · 06/04/2022 12:12

My Mum was a primary school teacher, and she and a couple of colleagues used to take groups of 11 & 12 year olds on language school trips each year.
She gave up her 1/2 term holiday (with us three kids at home - teenagers/older by then.) Took them on the coach all the way to the Black Forest, and spent all day in school/activities with them. As she was the senior teacher, and fluent in German, she did all of the planning, communications, etc., and then spent pretty much 24 hours a day with the kids.
She loved it, but needed a holiday when she came back! It's hard work. I know that she paid something out of her own pocket - even if it was just, as others say, drinks or sticking plasters, or something for kids who didn't have anything.

There is also a picture of her holding a comedy giant stein of beer, in a café one day. She is pretty much tee-total (loves a kaffee & kuchen instead!), so it was ironic that this snap exists. I'm fairly sure she drank none of it! So, would that picture mean she was hammered, in the eyes of anyone who saw it?!

AxolotlEars · 06/04/2022 12:11

The costs are covered by the children who go. They aren't really free

Abraxan · 06/04/2022 12:11

@iwasjustwonderingreally

For those surprised that I ask ...

The teachers aren't with the children during the day as they are off skiing on their own (as the children are in ski school).

They are all also drinking at night and one got particularly drunk.

It has been raised as a complaint and, before I decide whether or not I want to put my name to any complaint, I want to find out if it's been paid for by parents or not!

Why do you need to add your name to the parent's letter of complaint?

Was your child directly involved?
Does your child have direct evidence of the event?

If not, then leave it to those who are.
If so, write your own letter indicating the facts as you/your child know them.

A pile on letter signed by lots of hanger in parents will not strengthen that parent's complaint, infact it's likely to do the opposite.

Much better approach is for that parent to be very factual and professional about their dealings with the school over this as it is potentially very serious, with potentially incredibly serious consequences for the teacher(s) involved.

BananaPlants · 06/04/2022 12:11

(Trip paid as a helper)

BananaPlants · 06/04/2022 12:11

I knew a teacher who used to take her partner on ski trips, paid as a helper. He definitely attended very hungover on journeys there and not sure quite how much use he would have been as a “responsible adult” on the trip overall

Or teachers who decided on more exotic locations, one meeting her family over there and saying on afterwards for a family holiday (no idea how that worked for funding, or for being a teacher short on the way back though!)

sgiasm · 06/04/2022 12:10

Does the school start with a b? If so i know the trip you are talking about. Everyone on this thread would be the same if it was there child.

Soul11Soul · 06/04/2022 12:10

@PAFMO

And the parent will look very foolish complaining on the hearsay of the kid that the teachers were drunk. How ill was the child?
Yes because we all know that all young people are rampant liars and no teacher has ever behaved inappropriately. This is a narrative that has fuelled child abuse and neglect for years.
Abraxan · 06/04/2022 12:08

@Ilovedthe70s

Did I miss the announcement that it’s pile on teacher day? How many teacher threads is it so far today?
Easter holidays for many. It's always the same.
tinytemper66 · 06/04/2022 12:08

We agreed to pay extra so we had more staff ration. No one was forced to pay. I was happy to pay and so were the others. I always asked different teachers to go on the trips.

NoddyMcdoddy · 06/04/2022 12:07

DD went skiing with school a couple of years ago. Apparently a teacher got drunk and got off with another teacher from another school which was a source of great amusement to the teenagers. Same teacher also accompanied one of the students to hospital with a broken leg, had to go on a late night search party for 4 students who left the hotel, bought all the students pizzas and ice creams on the last day as a treat.

On balance, so what if he had a few drinks / got drunk on what was his night off, bearing in mind it’s a teenagers perception of what being drunk is.

In fact had I appreciated how much teachers do on this trip I’d have contacted the hotel and bought the teachers a round of drinks.

All teachers getting drunk and thus leaving the students without at least 1 person with duty of care is not great and would be the only grounds that would merit a complaint to the school in my book. It’s not likely that’s what happened.

Those that took videos of teachers and shared them need a stern word from school and parents about privacy, of course the head requested the videos be deleted. Disgraceful to be sharing such footage.

Also, by what means the teachers were funded has absolutely nothing to do with the teacher being supposedly drunk.

Sally872 · 06/04/2022 12:05

Doesn't matter who paid. If the teacher was too drunk, this left your child at risk and you feel this needs highlighted then complain. If you trust the other teachers will report/deal with it leave it at that.

Bringing up who pays for teachers is not helpful. Their cost should be covered by the children it is generous they give up their time. They should not be too drunk to supervise. I expect other teachers will have spoken to them and taken action to make sure this does not happen again (if the children's account is accurate and not exaggerated)

godmum56 · 06/04/2022 12:03

@comealongponds

Some places offer free adult places with youth group bookings. Otherwise the cost is split between pupils. Absolutely no way teachers should pay, and if they had to, trips just wouldn’t run.
while I agree that teachers shouldn't pay as it work of an extreme kind, of course the parents will ALWAYS pay somehow. Either the company will charge more for the places to cover the costs of the teachers or the school will pay for the teachers places and split the cost around. No such thing as a free lunch or a free holiday.
echt · 06/04/2022 12:03

@OfstedOffred

Also it's not "hearsay evidence" if i feed back that my sibling (teacher!) whom I lived with at the time was happy to get a slot on a two week school trip abroad and really enjoyed it.
Er, yes it is. Look it up.
Ilovedthe70s · 06/04/2022 12:02

Did I miss the announcement that it’s pile on teacher day?
How many teacher threads is it so far today?