Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder who funds a teacher's school trip

482 replies

iwasjustwonderingreally · 06/04/2022 10:41

My daughter went skiing with her school in February half term.

Four teachers accompanied them.

Do teachers pay for themselves, or a contribution, (I appreciate they are working though), or is the cost to the pupil inflated to cover the cost of the teachers?

OP posts:
sillysmiles · 06/04/2022 13:03

@iwasjustwonderingreally

Jeez, it was just a simple question to clarify a situation as a parent is complaining that the teachers were drunk when their child was ill.

I'm not saying teachers should pay!!!!

Was it your child? Are you on the board of management?

How are you involved?

Scottishnewmum · 06/04/2022 13:03

I'm a secondary school teacher and I can tell you right now that no teacher in their right mind would pay to go on a school trip. You're delusional if you think a few hours of skiing makes up for the sleep deprivation that comes with teenage coach trips, or the unpleasantness of policing teenagers who want nothing more than to sneak out of their rooms at night to drink/meet up with boyfriends/girlfriends etc. Or the sheer rage that comes with CONSTANTLY having to police them keeping seatbelts on in buses/taxis etc. or dealing with the inevitable student who has motion sickness (and cleaning up his/her vomit), or having to try (usually in vain) to prevent them from leaving the coach a sticky disaster of squashed sweets. Or the weight of responsibility that comes with trying to ensure their safety/ensure nobody gets lost (or "lost" - teenagers inevitably want to disappear). And, remember, this is half term! This should be a holiday for the teacher as well, who, by the way, still needs to mark a pile of work that was handed in before the holidays and plan lessons for the week after the holidays, i.e. making powerpoints, researching, reading ahead, making up worksheets etc.

IceVolcanoes · 06/04/2022 13:00

@Lavenderlid

I love how it's gone from "tipsy" to "drunk" to "pissed" in a few stages Grin
And yet, apparently the same kind of inflation could never happen to teenagers recounting events.
Lavenderlid · 06/04/2022 12:57

I love how it's gone from "tipsy" to "drunk" to "pissed" in a few stages Grin

TheTurn0fTheScrew · 06/04/2022 12:56

there's a big gap between unfit to drive, and drunk
I won't drive after a single drink.
I am perfectly competent to look after my children and deal with emergencies after three drinks.

I would expect school trips to have a nightly designated driver (on DC2's residential a kid needed driving to A&E), and a spare to step up if that person got called out, but I wouldn't be fussed about the rest of them having a couple of beers.

I cannot think of anything I'd rather do less than take a school trip away overnight - away from my own family, extra hours for no money, no guaranteed time off/breaks, constant nagging feeling that if something goes wrong I'd cop for it. I am very grateful to staff that run these things. The idea that staff should pay is ridiculous.

jamdonut · 06/04/2022 12:55

I had to pay £50 to go on a primary school residential to London, to help keep the cost down for pupils! An amazing time was had but I didn’t get paid any extra for being on duty for 3 days! All the teachers and TAs did this!

Heartofglass12345 · 06/04/2022 12:55

The teachers were all most definitely drunk when we went to France but this was over 20 years ago, I'm surprised at teachers doing this nowadays!

DockOTheBay · 06/04/2022 12:54

I always assumed the high cost was due to the teachers' costs being covered by parents. there are probably about 1 teacher for every 8 or so kids, so it would add about 12.5% on to the cost of each student. But then this would probably be negated by group booking discounts which you wouldn't get as a family. School trips are expensive because they have to cover EVERYTHING - all the food, insurance, travel, activities all day every day - in the price.

Changingtides1234 · 06/04/2022 12:52

Probably already been answered
But for trips the company offers a free adult spot for so many students

Shinyandnew1 · 06/04/2022 12:51

I very much doubt that ‘all’ the teachers were pissed.

I can’t see that it matters who paid for the teachers’ ‘holiday’-what has got to do with anything?

DockOTheBay · 06/04/2022 12:51

Teachers are unpaid for a school trip outside of term time. They are only paid for term time, its just split over the full year so they don't have a paycheck of 0 in August. So they are giving up their own free time and don't have to pay. The cost will either be paid by the students going, or will be free as some trips have a certain number of "free" spaces per number of children booked on.

Pregnagainagain · 06/04/2022 12:51

Hahaha

Hyenaormeercat · 06/04/2022 12:51

How times have changed, my trip to Austria in 1984, we older kids were drinking with the teachers in the evenings...pupils were 14-18 (I was the eldest kid, very early in year Birthday). Teachers weren't fall over drunk but definitely merry.

Although they did confiscate some booze from younger kids.
Kids drinking was seen as a bigger issue for parents to complain about than adults drinking then.
Cracking trip! I remember it well, and found photos recently in a box.

Themintwiththehole · 06/04/2022 12:50

Twenty something years ago when I was a young teacher I went on a residential trip with 3 other teachers and about 20 sixth formers. One evening two of the teachers, without telling me and the other teacher, took the school minibus and drove about half a dozen of the students to a pub a few miles away. The teacher who had driven them there got so drunk the other teacher had to drive them back to where we were staying. She wasn't insured to drive the minibus, and all the students (Y12) were underage. So very irresponsible all round. But sod all to do with whether any of the four teachers had paid to go.

Robin843 · 06/04/2022 12:49

My DC went to an independent school. The costs of the organised school trips abroad were eye-watering, so our DC never went on any. For the same price all 4 of us had a holiday. I always assumed the high cost was due to the teachers' costs being covered by parents.

IceVolcanoes · 06/04/2022 12:49

@Responsiveroo

If your teenager came back And said she’d been I’ll But “all” the teachers had been tipsy and one especially drunk

And you trusted your teen, she they weren’t prone to exaggerating (no idea about this one!)
Would you not pursue a complaint? Or at least approach the school and ask for a pretty frank disuxssion?

I trust my teen.

But I also know that his (and his friends’) perception of what’s actually happening is often inaccurate.

I certainly would not jump straight to how dreadful the teachers were and how the ‘failed in their duty of care’ etc.

Thehop · 06/04/2022 12:48

There should be a Rota. A group can have a drink tonight. B group can take over for emergencies.

I would hate it if my child was I’ll and the teachers were all pissed.

Mxflamingnoravera · 06/04/2022 12:48

Many schools now have a "no drinking on school trips" policy, it has meant even fewer teachers are willing to give up their annual leave to take students on a trip abroad. Not even a single glass of wine is permissable if the staff go by the policy. I have taken kids away and if I was not allowed a glass of wine with my dinner I simply would not volunteer to go.
The students also had a no drinking policy and of course they managed to get hold of it and most of the illnesses were associated with drunken students being sick, starting fights, breaking furniture and covering smoke detectors with plastic bags so they could conceal that they were smoking weed.
I take my hat off to any teacher willing to take kids away anywhere.

Responsiveroo · 06/04/2022 12:46

What have i have said so inflammatory

Only that based on the op
Which is all we have
The teachers failed in their duty of care

Responsiveroo · 06/04/2022 12:45

If your teenager came back
And said she’d been I’ll
But “all” the teachers had been tipsy and one especially drunk

And you trusted your teen, she they weren’t prone to exaggerating (no idea about this one!)
Would you not pursue a complaint? Or at least approach the school and ask for a pretty frank disuxssion?

IceVolcanoes · 06/04/2022 12:44

@Responsiveroo

No one “knows” anything

We can only go from the op

And she is talking definitively in terms of “all”

None of us know whether the op is telling he truth

But that’s the risk you take with mumsnet surely

Actually, the problem do many of us have is that it’s a ‘punish the awful teachers’ thread where (as is often the case) the OP doesn’t know for certain because she wasn’t there.

So it’s (at best) a third hand account of what is teenager has told his mum who has told the tale to other parents. Possibly with some out of context videos that shouldn’t have been recorded in the first place.

Not exactly reliable stuff.

The context that the question on the OP’s mind was ‘did I pay for the teachers?’ influences things too. It doesn’t suggest the most reasonable attitude from the start.

WinniesHunny · 06/04/2022 12:44

@PAFMO

Are you enjoying MN, *@responsiveroo*? I see you joined yesterday and have been quite opinionated helping those of us unable to understand what OPs have written by speaking on their behalf on many threads already. Above and beyond I'd say.
Arseholes gonna arsehole!
Responsiveroo · 06/04/2022 12:43

@PAFMO

Are you enjoying MN, *@responsiveroo*? I see you joined yesterday and have been quite opinionated helping those of us unable to understand what OPs have written by speaking on their behalf on many threads already. Above and beyond I'd say.
Very much so thanks for asking
alltheteeshirts · 06/04/2022 12:43

You know none of them want to be there, right? So they shouldn't pay.

As for the teacher who got drunk, it's fair enough to complain. Regardless of who paid for what, that teacher was there to look after the pupils (you can't respond in an emergency if you're off your face when there's an accident out of hours) and it's unprofessional.

Teachers are humans. But they shouldn't let their pupils see just how flawed they are... There's supposed to be an attempt at covering up the imperfect behaviours we all exhibit.

PAFMO · 06/04/2022 12:40

Are you enjoying MN, @responsiveroo?
I see you joined yesterday and have been quite opinionated helping those of us unable to understand what OPs have written by speaking on their behalf on many threads already.
Above and beyond I'd say.