Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder who funds a teacher's school trip

482 replies

iwasjustwonderingreally · 06/04/2022 10:41

My daughter went skiing with her school in February half term.

Four teachers accompanied them.

Do teachers pay for themselves, or a contribution, (I appreciate they are working though), or is the cost to the pupil inflated to cover the cost of the teachers?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
marcopront · 08/04/2022 13:59

@whattodo2019

I'm sure their costs are absorbed by the children. Teachers definitely don't pay at the school I work at.
And you thought in two days and 481 posts no one would have said that, so you needed to say it.
whattodo2019 · 08/04/2022 09:51

I'm sure their costs are absorbed by the children. Teachers definitely don't pay at the school I work at.

00100001 · 08/04/2022 09:44

[quote Lavenderlid]@Silverclocks
I had to stop reading when you wrote "lived experience"[/quote]
So you read the majority of her post then ...

ldontWanna · 08/04/2022 09:33

@FrippEnos

ldontWanna

Why are you so insistent that the teachers must be in the wrong?

I have organised/ lead and been on many trips in my years of teaching and I have only ever know of one teacher get completely hammered.

That teacher was investigated and suspended and was never allowed out of a trip again (even to local theme parks).

And there is no insistence that teachers can never be wrong, just that it is investigated fairly and proof brought forward.

I'm not . I'm just accepting that it is a possibility, unlike many posters.
Sartre · 08/04/2022 09:18

I’ve always assumed parents pay for teacher’s places too. Guess it’s like paying for childcare.

TeaPacks · 08/04/2022 09:12

You should have asked the question differently.

AIBU to expect teachers responsible for children not to be drunk? Of course YANBU (and even they had paid for themselves, it's irrelevant, the point is that they were in a position of responsibility and care)

Very different to AIBU to ask if teachers' expenses should be paid for - which is a different question and clearly YABU to that one (even to ask it - obviously teachers are paid for)

Musmerian · 08/04/2022 09:05

@Silverclocks

Going on a school trip is hard work, I don't think anyone doubts that, but that doesn't also mean no teacher enjoys it and chooses to go.

The really depressing thing about these threads is how many teachers seem to despise their work, the children and the families they serve which, which isn't my experience IRL at all.

Honestly, no one's indispensable, if it's that awful do yourself and the children a favour and go and do something else.

I do wonder if, in part, the recruitment crisis is self fulfilling. (Some) teachers seem determined to paint the blackest picture possible, whilst continuing to take the salary, they're not helping anyone.

My lived experience is that teaching is hard work, but the vast majority of teachers enjoy their work (most of the time, the same as in any other industry) but a handful of these determined to be miserable can really drag a school down.

Not quite sure where you got that from on this thread? I love my job and the trips are satisfying but from a professional point of view - not from a free jolly perspective. Teachers on this thread have merely pointed out that it’s work and that they are giving up their holiday time - no one has said they don’t like their jobs.
65honeybee · 08/04/2022 08:45

@Lavenderlid yes!

Lavenderlid · 08/04/2022 08:33

@Silverclocks
I had to stop reading when you wrote "lived experience"

Sherrystrull · 08/04/2022 08:00

@Silverclocks

Going on a school trip is hard work, I don't think anyone doubts that, but that doesn't also mean no teacher enjoys it and chooses to go.

The really depressing thing about these threads is how many teachers seem to despise their work, the children and the families they serve which, which isn't my experience IRL at all.

Honestly, no one's indispensable, if it's that awful do yourself and the children a favour and go and do something else.

I do wonder if, in part, the recruitment crisis is self fulfilling. (Some) teachers seem determined to paint the blackest picture possible, whilst continuing to take the salary, they're not helping anyone.

My lived experience is that teaching is hard work, but the vast majority of teachers enjoy their work (most of the time, the same as in any other industry) but a handful of these determined to be miserable can really drag a school down.

I haven't got from this thread that any teachers despise their work or the families they work with.

School staff explaining their lived experiences and the reality of trips in light of an op asking a daft question is what I see.

Trips are incredibly hard work, tons of work but also incredibly rewarding.
However, complaints from parents are probably the worst part.

Silverclocks · 08/04/2022 07:54

Going on a school trip is hard work, I don't think anyone doubts that, but that doesn't also mean no teacher enjoys it and chooses to go.

The really depressing thing about these threads is how many teachers seem to despise their work, the children and the families they serve which, which isn't my experience IRL at all.

Honestly, no one's indispensable, if it's that awful do yourself and the children a favour and go and do something else.

I do wonder if, in part, the recruitment crisis is self fulfilling. (Some) teachers seem determined to paint the blackest picture possible, whilst continuing to take the salary, they're not helping anyone.

My lived experience is that teaching is hard work, but the vast majority of teachers enjoy their work (most of the time, the same as in any other industry) but a handful of these determined to be miserable can really drag a school down.

echt · 08/04/2022 07:42

However I don't think that this insistence that teachers can never be in the wrong,all children lie and we should all be eternally grateful for their work is doing anyone any good

No-one has said this. Ever.

FrippEnos · 08/04/2022 06:48

ldontWanna

Why are you so insistent that the teachers must be in the wrong?

I have organised/ lead and been on many trips in my years of teaching and I have only ever know of one teacher get completely hammered.

That teacher was investigated and suspended and was never allowed out of a trip again (even to local theme parks).

And there is no insistence that teachers can never be wrong, just that it is investigated fairly and proof brought forward.

pollyglot · 07/04/2022 23:08

I've organised many school trips, abroad, residential within the country and full-day. They are SO much work. Months of preparations, then 24/7 on duty on the actual trip. Dealing with severe diabetics, allergy-sufferers, somnambulists, home-sickness, hysteria. Matron tasked with preparing meds for various kids, and then forgetting one...too late, we were already on the road - and guess who got the blame...I was supposed to check the meds that the medically-trained matron had sorted. But the parents were beyond lovely and supportive. We (DH and I) took some 10-12 year old boys to Rome for the day, accompanied by some parents. It was just magic, and the parents gave us some absolutely beautiful gifts as a thank-you. Wonderful experiences, but to pay for myself to go, after all those preps and with all those responsibilities? Are you serious?

mamaduckbone · 07/04/2022 18:47

When we go on school trips (U.K. not overseas though) there are free places for accompanying teachers.

theemperorhasnoclothes · 07/04/2022 18:45

No one's saying that teachers can never be in the wrong - just that jumping to conclusions that they are on very shaky evidence at best from the OPs comments - is not proportionate. I said before I probably would sign a letter asking for an investigation, but I wouldn't sign a letter complaining that teachers were inappropriately drunk given I wasn't there without having a bit more evidence.

And that who pays for teachers' places is totally irrelevant.

Frankly the original question - about who pays - makes me doubt the other stuff. Why on earth would you bring that into something like this unless you were on a general mud slinging campaign?

Musmerian · 07/04/2022 13:47

It’s not quite like that. I am currently in the throes of organising a trip - unlike ski trips it’s not done by a company so I’ve been booking all sorts of things individually, making sure invoices are paid, chasing kids to reply , sorting complicated risk assessments. I’m doing it because it’s important for the department profile and the subject and because I know how much students get from that. It’s exhausting and you have to be on the ball the whole time if you’re in charge . Ski trips , although staff do get the opportunity to ski, are still stressful. One year my husband spent three days at the hospital with different students. If we just wanted a jolly we would go on our own.

C8H10N4O2 · 07/04/2022 11:27

However I don't think that this insistence that teachers can never be in the wrong,all children lie and we should all be eternally grateful for their work is doing anyone any good

It is however an entirely normal reaction to people assuming that Not My Nigel is never wrong and that the teacher is always at fault.

The head was entirely correct to tell them to delete pictures taken without consent - that would be true even if it depicted people silently reading. It doesn't follow that any complaint has been dismissed or is being covered up, its basic privacy.

ldontWanna · 07/04/2022 11:23

@Mistressiggi

I wonder what replies like this would be if instead of an ill child not being appropriately attended to, the thread was about a child coming to serious harm due to lack of supervision/drinking. Well they'd be the same really wouldn't they, investigate the claims of drunkenness and have some proof before damming the supervising staff on the basis of hearsay.
And what would that proof be? Because children's accounts are being dismissed, video/photo proof as well.

So unless a member of staff actually comes forward (and even then I suspect there would be doubt) then there is no proof.

I work in a school, I know how hard it is,how bonkers some parents and complaints can be and how a child's interpretation of what happened is very different from what actually happened.

However I don't think that this insistence that teachers can never be in the wrong,all children lie and we should all be eternally grateful for their work is doing anyone any good.

Some posters completely refuse to accept the possibility that this could happen and some think that if did it's not that bad or a big deal because teachers work hard and trips are exhausting (which I find even worse).

justfiveminutes · 07/04/2022 11:16

Oh please come back and update op.

Was it an inebriated, incompetent teacher who left a seriously ill pupil to fend for themselves?

Or a teacher who had a single beer but didn't offer enough tlc to a dramatic teenager with a bit of a sniffle?

I'd be interested to know what the photographic evidence showed too.

Pissed teachers on trips are suspended and usually make the news but I haven't seen anything yet.

dephlogisticated · 07/04/2022 10:39

I'm surprised you need to ask this, would you expect to pay to go somewhere where you are working? It is very very hard work to be a teacher on a trip- not to mention all the admin beforehand, and a huge amount of responsibility.

theemperorhasnoclothes · 07/04/2022 10:06

Yes it wasn't a skiing injury but my point was really that they were accepting a level of risk in sending their kids on this holiday and then getting up in arms about teachers having a few drinks? It doesn't really make sense, unless you're holding teachers to impossible standards.

65honeybee · 07/04/2022 10:06

Why so much dissing of teachers?

Standard on MN, especially coming up to school holidays.

Boredom? Resentment? Plain old fashioned pot stirring? Take your pick!

Clymene · 07/04/2022 09:52

I don't even think it was a skiing injury was it? The OP says the kid was unwell. Probably had too much to drink Grin

theemperorhasnoclothes · 07/04/2022 09:48

This thread is heartening I suppose in that so many people are saying the payment point is irrelevant and also to be sure of facts before you decide what really happened.

But on a further point, I just don't understand why parents who feel like this send their kids on school trips. It's skiing FFS - one of the most high risk activities you can do. Obviously there is a risk your child will be injured. Teachers (or ski instructors) aren't magicians they can't prevent things from happening.

It's really unclear from the OP whether there was any harm that occurred to a child or whether they were just outraged that the teachers had been drinking. Children will get sick on holiday, there will be accidents, just as there would be if you took your own kids. Accepting this is part of signing up to the trip and in fact part of travelling - particularly if you're doing something like skiing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread